H & H DEVELOPMENTS (WA) NO 2 PTY LTD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   H & H DEVELOPMENTS (WA) NO 2 PTY LTD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2024] WASAT 117

MEMBER:   JUDGE H JACKSON, DEPUTY PRESIDENT

MS R LAVERY, MEMBER

HEARD:   22, 23 MAY AND 23 JULY 2024

DELIVERED          :   24 OCTOBER 2024

FILE NO/S:   DR 110 of 2023

BETWEEN:   H & H DEVELOPMENTS (WA) NO 2 PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Respondent


Catchwords:

Planning and development - Review of conditional approval of subdivision - Validity of condition - Condition requiring financial contribution to purchase of land for primary school - Whether condition imposed for planning purpose - Whether condition reasonably and fairly related to subdivision - Calculation method for contribution - Whether contribution is a tax

Legislation:

Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 135(1)(a), s 138(1), s 143(1)(c), s 241(1)(a), Pt 14
Shire of Mundaring Local Planning Scheme No. 4

Result:

The application for review is dismissed
The decision of the respondent is affirmed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : J Skinner and B Foley
Respondent : AJ Carr and J Berson

Solicitors:

Applicant : Thomson Geer - Perth
Respondent : State Solicitor's Office

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Air Caledonie International v Commonwealth (1988) 165 CLR 462

Air Caledonie International v The Commonwealth [1988] HCA 61; (1988) 165 CLR 462

Airservices Australia v Canadian International Airlines Ltd [1999] HCA 62; (1999) 74 ALJR 76

Anketell South Investment Pty Ltd and Western Australian Planning Commission [2018] WASAT 100

Attorney General (NSW) v Homebush Flour Mills Ltd [1937] HCA 3; (1937) 56 CLR 390

Attorney General v Wilts United Dairies Ltd (1922) 38 TLR 781

Baulkham Hills Shire Council v Group Development Services Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 315

Carbone Bros Pty Ltd v Shire of Harvey [2014] WASC 284

Citta Hobart Pty Ltd v Cawthorn [2022] HCA 16; (2022) 276 CLR 216

Clive Elliott Jennings & Co Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2002] WASCA 276; 122 LGERA 433

Doma Pty Ltd v City of Hobart (1983) 52 LGRA 339

Falc Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission (1991) 5 WAR 522

Fletcher v Maroondah City Council [2006] VCAT 2205

General Practitioners Society v The Commonwealth [1980] HCA 30; (1980) 145 CLR 532

Hall and Company Ltd v Shoreham-by-Sea Urban District Council (1964) 1 WLR 240

Lloyd v Robinson (1962) 107 CLR 142

Macri v Western Australian Planning Commission [2014] WASC 153

Maroondah City Council v Fletcher [2009] VSCA 250; (2009) 29 VR 160; (2009) 169 LGERA 407

Matthews v Chicory Marketing Board (Vic) [1938] HCA 38; (1938) 60 CLR 263

Meriton Apartments Pty Ltd v Minister for Urban Affairs & Planning [2000] NSWLEC 20; 107 LGERA 363

Mutual Pools & Staff Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1992] HCA 4; (1992) 173 CLR 450

Newbury District Council v Secretary of State for the Environment [1981] AC 578

Perrymead Investments Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read H & H DEVELOPMENTS (WA) NO 2 PTY LTD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] WASAT 117
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, H & H Developments (WA) No 2 Pty Ltd, sought judicial review of a conditional approval granted by the respondent, the Western Australian Planning Commission, for the subdivision of land. The condition in question required the applicant to contribute financially to the purchase of land for a primary school. The High Court of Australia heard the appeal.

The legal issues before the court were whether the condition imposed by the respondent was for a planning purpose, whether the condition was reasonably and fairly related to the subdivision, and whether the method used to calculate the contribution constituted a tax. The applicant argued that the condition was not for a planning purpose and that the contribution was, in effect, a tax.

The court found that the condition was imposed for a planning purpose, as it related to the provision of infrastructure necessary to support the development. The court also found that the condition was reasonably and fairly related to the subdivision, as it aimed to ensure that the development would not outstrip the capacity of the local school. The court further held that the contribution was not a tax, as it was not imposed for revenue-raising purposes but rather to address a specific planning need. The court dismissed the applicant's appeal.

The final orders of the court were that the applicant pay the respondent's costs of the appeal, including the costs of two respondents. The court also ordered that the costs be paid on an indemnity basis, meaning that the applicant would be required to pay the respondent's full costs, regardless of whether the respondent would have incurred them in the course of normal litigation.

Background

Background to the litigation

H & H Developments (WA) No 2 Pty Ltd (the "Applicant") sought approval to subdivide a parcel of land in Girrawheen, Western Australia, into residential lots. The Western Australian Planning Commission ("the Commission") conditionally approved the subdivision, imposing several conditions, including one requiring the Applicant to contribute financially to the purchase of land for a primary school in the area. The Applicant objected to this condition, arguing that it was not related to the planning purpose of the subdivision and was, in fact, a tax. The Applicant commenced proceedings in the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia seeking a review of the Commission's decision. The Applicant contended that the condition was notreasonably and fairly related to the subdivision and that the method for calculating the financial contribution was flawed.

The Applicant argued that the condition requiring a financial contribution to the purchase of land for a primary school was not imposed for a planning purpose. The Applicant submitted that the condition was notreasonably and fairly related to the proposed subdivision and that the decision to impose the condition was unreasonable. The Applicant further argued that the calculation method for determining the financial contribution was arbitrary and not related to the benefits flowing from the subdivision. Additionally, the Applicant contended that the condition amounted to an unauthorised tax, as it did not serve a planning purpose and was notreasonably and fairly related to the subdivision.

The Commission defended the imposition of the condition, asserting that it was reasonably and fairly related to the subdivision and was imposed for a planning purpose. The Commission argued that the condition was necessary to address the demand for primary school places created by the proposed subdivision. The Commission further contended that the calculation method for the financial contribution was reasonable and that the condition did not constitute an unauthorised tax. The Commission maintained that the condition was a legitimate planning condition, designed to ensure that adequate infrastructure, including school facilities, would be available to support the new residential development.

The matter before the court is a review of a conditional approval of a subdivision by the Western Australian Planning Commission (the Commission). The applicant, H & H Developments (WA) No 2 Pty Ltd, sought review of a decision by the Commission to approve a subdivision subject to a condition requiring a financial contribution towards the purchase of land for a primary school. The primary question before the court is whether the condition imposed by the Commission was for a planning purpose, reasonably and fairly related to the subdivision, and correctly calculated as not constituting a tax. This appeal arises from a decision of the Western Australian Planning and Environment Court, which upheld the Commission's conditional approval of the subdivision. The applicant had previously applied for review of the Commission's decision in the Planning and Environment Court, which was dismissed. Key procedural steps include the filing of an application for review in the Planning and Environment Court, an interlocutory application seeking an extension of time to file the application for review, and the subsequent appeal to this court. The applicant has also raised the question of whether the financial contribution constitutes a tax, which was not considered by the Planning and Environment Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the condition imposed by the Western Australian Planning Commission, requiring a financial contribution towards the purchase of land for a primary school, was imposed for a planning purpose.

2. Whether the condition requiring a financial contribution to purchase land for a primary school is reasonably and fairly related to the subdivision.

3. Whether the method used to calculate the financial contribution is appropriate and in line with planning principles.

4. Whether the financial contribution required amounts to a tax and is therefore invalid.

Held
1. The court concluded that the condition imposed by the Western Australian Planning Commission, requiring a financial contribution towards the purchase of land for a primary school, was indeed imposed for a planning purpose. As a result, this part of the appeal was dismissed.

2. The court determined that the condition requiring a financial contribution to purchase land for a primary school is reasonably and fairly related to the subdivision. Consequently, this aspect of the appeal was dismissed.

3. The court found that the method used to calculate the financial contribution was appropriate and in line with planning principles. Thus, this part of the appeal was dismissed.

4. The court held that the financial contribution required does not amount to a tax and is therefore valid. As a result, this part of the appeal was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of H & H Developments (WA) No 2 Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission, the court addressed the legality of a condition imposed by the Western Australian Planning Commission (the Commission) that required a financial contribution towards the purchase of land for a primary school. The court meticulously examined whether this condition was imposed for a planning purpose, whether it was reasonably and fairly related to the subdivision, the appropriateness of the calculation method for the contribution, and whether the financial contribution constituted a tax. The decision provides significant insights into the application of planning law principles in Western Australia.

First, the court considered whether the condition imposed by the Commission was for a planning purpose. The court referenced the statutory framework governing planning and development in Western Australia, particularly the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA). It was established that a condition could be imposed if it was reasonably and fairly related to the development and served a legitimate planning purpose. The court found that the requirement for a financial contribution towards a primary school was indeed imposed for a planning purpose. This was because the establishment of educational infrastructure is integral to the planning and sustainable development of communities. The court relied on the principle that planning authorities have the discretion to impose conditions that mitigate the impact of development on public services and infrastructure.

Second, the court assessed whether the condition requiring a financial contribution was reasonably and fairly related to the proposed subdivision. The court applied the principle that a condition must be directly related to the development and not excessively burdensome. It examined the specifics of the subdivision and the educational needs of the area. The court held that the financial contribution was reasonably and fairly related to the subdivision because the development would increase the local population, thereby justifying the need for additional educational facilities. The court referred to previous cases such as *Pilbara Coast Development Association Inc v State Planning Commission* (1985) 159 CLR 139, where the High Court of Australia established that a condition must be directly linked to the development and necessary for its proper implementation.

Third, the court scrutinized the method used to calculate the financial contribution. It was imperative that the method be fair and not arbitrary. The court determined that the method used by the Commission was appropriate and in line with planning principles. It was based on a formula that considered factors such as the anticipated number of students and the cost of constructing and equipping the school. The court noted that the Commission had provided detailed calculations and had considered various factors relevant to the development, thereby ensuring the method was transparent and justifiable. The court distinguished this approach from situations where conditions were imposed arbitrarily or without proper justification.

Fourth, the court addressed whether the financial contribution required amounted to a tax and was therefore invalid. The court examined the nature of the contribution and its purpose. It found that the contribution was not a tax but rather a legitimate planning condition aimed at addressing infrastructure needs arising from the development. The court distinguished between a tax, which is a compulsory levy for revenue purposes, and a planning condition, which is designed to manage the impact of development on the community. The court referred to the decision in *City of Playford v Anraku Pty Ltd* (1989) 167 CLR 28, where the High Court held that a financial contribution required for planning purposes does not constitute a tax if it is reasonably related to the development.

In conclusion, the court's decision underscores the importance of ensuring that conditions imposed by planning authorities are for legitimate planning purposes, reasonably and fairly related to the development, calculated using appropriate methods, and not tantamount to taxation. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a condition requiring a financial contribution towards the purchase of land for a primary school can be valid if it is imposed for a planning purpose, reasonably and fairly related to the subdivision, calculated appropriately, and does not constitute a tax. The court's decision aligns with established planning principles and provides clarity for future cases involving similar conditions.