Catchwords – migration – protection visa – refugee – whether the Applicant committed war crimes – whether the Applicant was a member of the LTTE – whether witness is credible – whether witness is reliable - misleading government officials – international law - Sri Lanka – Refugee Convention – Rome Statute – decision affirmed
Legislation
Migration Act 1958 Migration and Maritime Powers Legislation Amendment (Resolving the Asylum Legacy Caseload) Act 2014 (Cth)
Elements of Crimes Explanatory Memorandum, Migration and Maritime Powers Legislation Amendment (Resolving the Asylum Legacy Caseload) Bill 2014 Human Rights Council, “Report of the OHCHR Investigations on Sri Lanka” (A/HRC/30/CRP.2), 16 September 2015 [223]-[224] R Ramasubramanian, ‘Suicide Terrorism in Sri Lanka’ (2004) 1(5) IPCS Research Papers 1, 9, 21 Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court UNHCR Background Note on the Application of the Exclusions Clauses: Article 1F of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees, 4 September 2003 UNHCR Eligibility Guidelines for Assessing the International Protection Needs of Asylum-Seekers from Sri Lanka 21 December 2012 UNHCR’s Handbook on Procedures and criteria for determining Refugee Status under the 1951 Convention and the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees, 1 January 1992 UNHCR Lisbon Expert Roundtable, Global Consultations on International Protection held on 3-4 May 2001, Summary Conclusions – Exclusion from Refugee Status, EC/GC/01/2Track/1, 30 May 2001 UNHCR Statement on Article 1F of the 1951 Convention, Issued in the context of the preliminary ruling references to the Court of Justice of the European Communities from the German Federal Administrative Court regarding the interpretation of Articles 12(2)(b) and (c) of the Qualification Directive United Nations Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees
ViennaConventionontheLawof Treaties
REASONS FOR DECISION
Mr A Maryniak QC, Member
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read GZCK and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:
This matter concerned an application for a protection visa by an individual identified as GZCK, who sought to resist a decision by the Minister for Home Affairs. The applicant, born in Sri Lanka in 1973, claimed to have been forcibly recruited into the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) in the late 1980s. He alleged that his roles within the organisation evolved from assisting a relative in a shop that sold items to the LTTE, to intelligence work, including facilitating travel arrangements for LTTE operatives and gathering information on rival political parties. The applicant's credibility and reliability as a witness were central to the proceedings before Mr A Maryniak QC, Member.
The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicant had committed war crimes, and whether he was a member of the LTTE. These questions were intrinsically linked to the applicant's credibility, particularly in light of significant discrepancies and inconsistencies in his statements to various government agencies, including ASIO and the Immigration Review Tribunal (IMR). The Tribunal was required to assess whether there were serious reasons for considering that the applicant had committed war crimes, a determination that necessitated a thorough examination of his knowledge and actions as an alleged intelligence officer within the LTTE.
The Tribunal found that the applicant was not a credible or reliable witness. This conclusion was based on the scale of discrepancies and variations in the multiple versions of events he provided over time, and the Tribunal found his explanations for these inconsistencies unconvincing. The Tribunal noted that the applicant's role in facilitating travel arrangements for LTTE operatives, including those involved in "Black Tiger" operations, and his admitted responsibility for sending individuals who later died in attacks such as the bombing of the Temple of the Tooth in Kandy, provided serious reasons for considering that he had committed war crimes. The Tribunal determined that the applicant's claims of not knowing the civilian nature of targets were implausible, given his involvement in intelligence and the known activities of the LTTE.
The Tribunal affirmed the decision, finding that the applicant had not established that he met the criteria for a protection visa, primarily due to his lack of credibility and the serious reasons for considering that he had committed war crimes.
Background
Background to the litigation
Due to the nature of the relevant visa in this matter and by reason of section 501K of the Act, the Applicant is not identified in this Decision and various aspects of these reasons have been edited accordingly. Further, identifying information in Annexure A has been redacted to comply with section 501K of the Act. THE APPLICANT’S BACKGROUND A summary of the Applicant’s background, as provided in his Closing Submissions, is set out in paragraphs 5 to 18 below. Such background facts were essentially not challenged by the Respondent. The Applicant was born in Sri Lanka in 1973. He identifies as Hindu and of Tamil ethnicity. In the late 1980s when the Applicant was around 15 or 16 years old, he would assist a relative in their shop, which included selling items to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE). At this time a man named “Ramanan” was in charge of the LTTE. The Applicant knew of Ramanan from personal experience.[1][1] Statement of GZCK dated 29 April 2015, paragraph 8. Around 1989 the Applicant was forcibly recruited into the LTTE. This was initiated by Ramanan who tricked the Applicant into believing he was delivering items to the LTTE but he was in fact left in an LTTE camp and forced to join the organisation.[2][2] Ibid, paragraphs 16 to 25. The Applicant was unable to carry through on his orders to kill in battle and around 1992 he was punished by the LTTE by being placed in the kitchen and ordered to cook for the LTTE soldiers. He then negotiated his return to his village where he was tasked with selling goods to the LTTE under the control of Ramanan.[3][3] Ibid, paragraphs 33 to 40. The Applicant then worked under his relative to avoid going into battle. However, around 1993 he was moved to another village and it was around this time he was sent for training in Intelligence work. After his training he attended interviews conducted by the LTTE and operated the recording equipment and labelled cassettes. He would listen to the recordings and write down the story of the person being interviewed and write a report.[4][4] Ibid, paragraphs 48 to 67. Around 1996 he negotiated his return to the area he grew up in. His tasks included selling goods and some Intelligence work for his superior at the time.[5][5] Ibid, paragraphs 68 to 73. The Applicant continued doing Intelligence work from 1997 to 2001; and it was in this period that the Applicant was tasked with making arrangements for boys to travel to Colombo.[6][6] Ibid, paragraphs 74 to 87. He then returned to the area where he grew up, where he was tasked with gathering information about other political parties such as the Eelan People’s Democratic Party and the People’s Organisation of Tamil Eelam. He also continued to help with the arrangements for the boys travelling to Colombo.[7][7] Ibid, paragraphs 88 to 96. In 2003 the Applicant had a motorcycle accident and injured his leg.[8][8] Ibid, paragraph 97. Around 2003 or 2004 there was a split in the LTTE and the Karuna Group was formed. The Applicant escaped from a camp and was instructed by his supervisor to go to the area the Applicant grew up in. It was around this time that the Applicant made another attempt to leave the LTTE. He went into hiding from July to December 2004. Prior to this, he spent a few months in jail having been caught by the police. Again he was attempting to make plans to leave the LTTE and go overseas.[9][9] Ibid, paragraphs 130 to 151.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
It is apparent from Annexure A and the evidence before the Tribunal generally that the Applicant has variously resiled from, downplayed, or claimed that he cannot recall, statements that he made to ASIO.[50][50] Annexure A is identical to the aide-memoire tendered at final hearing, save for the addition of a column in relation to the Applicant’s oral evidence, and associated formatting changes.Oral Evidence In relation to the IMR process:(a)When asked about why he decided to tell the IMR about his LTTE membership, the Applicant said: “I realised I have to tell the truth that I was in the movement”.[51] However, when the details were put to him, he conceded that he had not told the truth in relation to his period in detention or his intelligence role. The Applicant said that he feared that he would be detained for longer if he told the whole truth; also, that ASIO had told him that he did not have to tell the whole truth.[52] He said that he was scared that if he admitted to being an intelligence officer, “they may assume that I am an important person and detain me”.[53] When asked whether this was because of the sorts of things that happened in the intelligence wing of the LTTE, he initially claimed: “I do not know about attacking the normal civilians and the movement never told to target civilians”.[54] When asked about the LTTE bombings of the Colombo Central Bank (1996), the Dehiwala train (1996), the World Trade Centre Building in Colombo (1997), the Temple of the Tooth Relic in Kandy (1998) and the Colombo International Airport (2001), the Applicant admitted to knowing of these events but said that he did not know whether the targets were “civilian”.[55] He did, however, admit that another LTTE operative was organising these sorts of attacks.[56] Eventually, he admitted that it was to avoid being associated with this sort of thing that he had concealed his intelligence role from the IMR, adding that he was scared because it was “a big thing” to be in the intelligence wing.[57](b)The Applicant later denied that he had misled the IMR by not admitting his intelligence role. When it was put to him again that this was misleading, he said that others had done the same.[58][51] Transcript, p 28.[52] Transcript, p 39.[53] Transcript, p 40.[54] Transcript, p 41.[55] Transcript, p 41-42.[56] Transcript, p 42.[57] Transcript, p 42.[58] Transcript, p 47. In relation to ASIO:(a)The Applicant claimed to have told ASIO the whole truth.[59](b)Later, the Applicant confirmed this.[60] When asked why he had told the truth to ASIO, he said first that it was because he knew that ASIO was an intelligence organisation and if he lied, they might wonder what else he was hiding. When pressed to explain this, the Applicant claimed that he was motivated by his conscience.[61] When asked why his conscience did not motivate him to tell the truth to the IMR, he claimed that ASIO had told him that he only had to tell the truth to them.[62](c)The Applicant was taken to that part of his April 2015 statutory declaration in which he claimed to have misled ASIO in relation to one matter, but to otherwise have told the truth. When asked again whether there were other instances where he had not told the truth to ASIO, the Applicant said that he could no longer recall.[63](d)The Applicant was taken to many parts of the summary of what he told ASIO. He generally agreed that it was accurate and that it sounded like information that he had provided to ASIO. The only significant points of disagreement related to the Applicant having attended interrogations during his intelligence training and his later incarceration at a jail base, including his having attended the interrogation of a formerly high ranking LTTE member at an LTTE operative’s request, and then producing the interrogation report. Otherwise, the Applicant agreed with what was put to him save where he said that he could not remember. He said that he could not recall being given an additional role reporting suspected spies upon returning from overseas (a matter which is referred to in his witness statement, at [47.f]).(e)Towards the end of his evidence, when he was taken to inconsistencies in his statements regarding being overseas, the Applicant, as he had done at his delegate interview, again relied on the fact that he had told the truth to ASIO.[64][59] Transcript, p 39.[60] Transcript, p 48.[61] Transcript, p 48.[62] Transcript, p 51.[63] Transcript, p 51.[64] Transcript, p 96.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The Applicant has been truthful about the reasons why he has not been forthcoming whenever asked about not being forthcoming. His reasons accord with him being a person seeking asylum and fearful of being returned to a place which may cause him harm.CONCLUSIONS After consideration of all the material before it (including the Applicant’s oral evidence), the Tribunal finds, on balance, by reason of the scale of the discrepancies and variations in the various versions of ‘the truth’ the Applicant has given over the years (even taking into account the matters raised by the Applicant in addressing such versions) that the Applicant is not a credible or reliable witness. The body of evidence from the Applicant incorporating all the inconsistencies, when analysed, is not credible or reliable. The Tribunal finds that the purported explanations for the inconsistencies and discrepancies are not convincing. The role of the Tribunal is not to unravel the various versions and make positive findings of fact. The Tribunal is to consider, in light of all the material before it, whether they are ‘serious reasons for considering’ that the Applicant “has committed … a war crime.” The Tribunal is to investigate what the Applicant knew about the LTTE and its intelligence wing, and what the Applicant did as an intelligence officer.Travel Arrangements On the evidence as discussed above, the Applicant has had a role in making travel arrangements to assist covert Black Tiger operations behind enemy lines. The relevant various versions of the Applicant pertaining to travel arrangements are at rows 51, 54, 56 and 90 of Annexure A. The Respondent submitted that these versions from the Applicant are foundations for the following:(a)It was well known that an LTTE operative was in charge of intelligence/Black Tiger operations that included bombings behind enemy lines, of what were obviously civilian targets.[74] The Applicant himself knew this. His claim not to know whether certain targets were “civilian” is implausible.[75](b)When an LTTE operative was posted to the area where the Applicant grew up as an intelligence leader, the Applicant travelled with him as his assistant. His tasks included helping LTTE operatives by facilitating the travel into enemy controlled areas, such as Colombo. He did this from 1996-1998 and again, upon an LTTE operative’s return to the area the Applicant grew up in 1998, from then until after the ceasefire in February 2002.(c)The Applicant’s claim that he was not told specific details of particular Black Tiger operations is plausible, given the obvious need for operational security. His claim that such operations were not discussed even after the fact is less plausible and inconsistent with his evidence that his section had received a request to send boys to Colombo for the airport attack, as well as his evidence that he later travelled to join other members of the intelligence wing in celebrating that attack (which was ultimately carried out by Black Tigers from another section).[76](d)In any event, given what he knew of a specific LTTE operative’s role, it must have been obvious to the Applicant from the very beginning that the Black Tiger operations were likely to include attacks upon civilian targets.[77](e)Furthermore, the Applicant himself told ASIO that he was responsible for sending one of the boys who died in the bombing of the Temple of the Tooth in Kandy. Thereafter, he must have realised that such attacks were a possible consequence of his actions. This is so whether the Applicant was told of the boy’s role, or whether, as he has subsequently claimed, he surmised it from the timing of the bombing in relation to the travel and the fact that he never saw that boy again. The attack in Kandy occurred in 1998. The Applicant told ASIO that he sent nine or ten boys to Colombo between 1998 and 2001.[74] Human Rights Council, “Report of the OHCHR Investigations on Sri Lanka” (A/HRC/30/CRP.2), 16 September 2015 [223]-[224], Attachment B to the Minister’s Statement of Facts and Contentions and R Ramasubramanian, ‘Suicide Terrorism in Sri Lanka’ (2004) 1(5) IPCS Research Papers 1, 9, 21, Attachment C to the Minister’s Statement of Facts and Contentions.[75] See 103(a) above.[76] See Appendix A, row 59. One of the Black Tigers who carried out the attack was Muthappa, whom the Applicant had earlier sent to Colombo.[77] See [45.1] above
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The primary issue before the Tribunal was whether the Applicant, a Sri Lankan national, had committed war crimes as a member of the LTTE, particularly as an intelligence officer. The Tribunal found the Applicant not to be a credible or reliable witness, due to the significant discrepancies and variations in the various versions of the truth provided over the years. The Applicant's explanations for these inconsistencies were not convincing. The Tribunal's role was to determine whether there were serious reasons for considering that the Applicant had committed a war crime, based on the evidence regarding his knowledge of the LTTE and its intelligence wing, and his role as an intelligence officer.
The Applicant had admitted to being forcibly recruited into the LTTE, and had held a position within the intelligence wing. He had facilitated travel arrangements for covert operations behind enemy lines, including the bombing of civilian targets. The Applicant claimed he was unaware of certain targets being civilian, but the Tribunal found this claim implausible, given his knowledge of an LTTE operative in charge of intelligence/Black Tiger operations. The Applicant's assertion that he was not told specific details of particular Black Tiger operations was deemed plausible, given the need for operational security. However, his claim that such operations were not discussed even after the fact was less plausible, as the Applicant had evidence that his section had received a request to send boys to Colombo for the airport attack, and he later travelled to join other members of the intelligence wing in celebrating that attack.
The Tribunal found it obvious to the Applicant from the very beginning that the Black Tiger operations were likely to include attacks upon civilian targets. Furthermore, the Applicant had told ASIO that he was responsible for sending one of the boys who died in the bombing of the Temple of the Tooth in Kandy, which led him to realise that such attacks were a possible consequence of his actions. The Applicant's claims regarding his knowledge of certain aspects of the LTTE and his role within the organisation were deemed not credible, as they were inconsistent with the evidence before the Tribunal.
In conclusion, the Tribunal found that the Applicant was not a credible or reliable witness due to the discrepancies and variations in his accounts over the years. The body of evidence from the Applicant, incorporating all the inconsistencies, was not credible or reliable. The Tribunal found serious reasons for considering that the Applicant had committed war crimes as a member of the LTTE, particularly as an intelligence officer, based on his involvement in making travel arrangements to assist covert Black Tiger operations behind enemy lines. The Tribunal found that the Applicant had knowledge of the likely civilian targets of such operations and the possible consequences of his actions.