Guden v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Guden v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 980

Citation: Guden v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 980
Appeal from: Application for extension of time: Guden v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] AATA 380
Parties: BURAK GUDEN v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File number: VID 930 of 2013
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 27 September 2013
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – applicant sought an extension of time under rule 33.13 of the Federal Court Rules to appeal under s 44(2A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“AAT Act”) – application futile as Court lacks jurisdiction to hear an appeal from the Tribunal’s decision under s 500 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“Migration Act”) under s 44 of the AAT Act – Tribunal’s decision is a privative clause decision or purported privative clause decision – As Federal Court has jurisdiction under s 476A of the Migration Act application for extension treated as made under s 477A.

MIGRATION – Tribunal did not fail to comply with Direction no 55 – Visa Refusal and Cancelation under s 501 and/or take into account irrelevant considerations – misdescription of applicant’s earlier offending not material – Tribunal did not fail to undertake balancing exercise required by paragraph 7(1)(b) of Direction no 55

Legislation: Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 44(1) and (2A)
Direction no 55 – Visa Refusal and Cancelation under s 501 (direction given pursuant to s 499 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth)) paragraphs 6.3, 7 and 11
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 33.13
Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 5, 5E, 474, 476A(1) and (2), 477(3)(d), 477A, 483, 499, 500(1), 501(1), (6) and (7)
Cases cited: Fischer v Commonwealth of Australia (1997) 54 ALD 673
FTZK v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCAFC 44
Metera v Administrative Appeals Tribunal and Anor (2008) 105 ALD 18; [2008] FCA 1627
Rinka v Minister for Immigration & Citizenship [2009] FCA 886
Date of hearing: 20 September 2013
Date of last submissions: 20 September 2013
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 90
Counsel for the Applicant: The applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the Respondents: David Brown of Australian Government Solicitor

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 930 of 2013

BETWEEN:

BURAK GUDEN
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 SEPTEMBER 2013

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs fixed at $2,000.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 930 of 2013

BETWEEN:

BURAK GUDEN
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE:

27 SEPTEMBER 2013

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Guden v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 980
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Guden v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, the applicant, who arrived in Australia as a child and had a criminal history, sought a Special Eligibility (Residence) (Class AO) visa, which was refused. He appealed the decision to the Migration Review Tribunal, which affirmed the refusal. The applicant then sought to appeal the Tribunal's decision to the Federal Court, but the Court dismissed his application for an extension of time to appeal and found that the appeal was futile due to the privative clause in the Migration Act. The Court also found that the Tribunal did not fail to comply with Direction no 55 or take into account irrelevant considerations, and that the misdescription of the applicant’s earlier offending was not material.

The primary legal issues in the case were whether the Court had jurisdiction to hear the applicant’s appeal from the Tribunal’s decision, and whether the Tribunal had failed to comply with Direction no 55 or had taken into account irrelevant considerations in making its decision. The Court found that it did not have jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the Tribunal’s decision because the decision was a privative clause decision or a purported privative clause decision, and that the application for an extension of time to appeal should be treated as made under s 477A of the Migration Act. The Court also found that the Tribunal had not failed to comply with Direction no 55 or take into account irrelevant considerations in making its decision, and that the misdescription of the applicant’s earlier offending was not material to the outcome of the case.

The Court's reasoning in the case was based on its interpretation of the relevant legislation and the principles of administrative law. The Court found that the privative clause in the Migration Act meant that the Court did not have jurisdiction to hear the applicant’s appeal from the Tribunal’s decision. The Court also found that the Tribunal had correctly applied Direction no 55 in making its decision, and that the misdescription of the applicant’s earlier offending was not material to the outcome of the case. The Court ordered that the application be dismissed and that the applicant pay the Minister’s costs.

In summary, the Court found that it did not have jurisdiction to hear the applicant’s appeal from the Tribunal’s decision because the decision was a privative clause decision, and that the application for an extension of time to appeal should be treated as made under s 477A of the Migration Act. The Court also found that the Tribunal had not failed to comply with Direction no 55 or taken into account irrelevant considerations in making its decision, and that the misdescription of the applicant’s earlier offending was not material. The Court ordered that the application be dismissed and that the applicant pay the Minister’s costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs fixed at $2,000.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing of the application, the applicant, who was not legally qualified, represented himself.BACKGROUND The applicant arrived in Australia with his parents in 1997 when he was 10 years old. He has resided continuously in Australia on various visas since that date. On 19 March 2004, the applicant pleaded guilty to two charges of recklessly causing serious injury before the Dandenong Children’s Court. He was not convicted of those offences but was placed on a bond to be of good behaviour until 5 November 2004. The charges related to a fight between two groups of students at High School during which the applicant, who was then in year 10, stabbed another student with a knife. On 29 June 2005, the applicant applied for a Special Eligibility (Residence) (Class AO), which was refused on 27 October 2006. The applicant subsequently sought a review by the Migration Review Tribunal. On 9 June 2007, the applicant, in company with one Labinot Musa, attacked and seriously wounded two brothers, John Doukis and Peter Doukis. On 7 April 2008, the Migration Review Tribunal remitted the applicant’s matter to the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. During that time, the applicant remained on a Bridging E (Class WE) visa. On 20 June 2008, the applicant (then 21 years old) was convicted of several offences in relation to the attack on the Messrs Doukis, including two counts of intentionally causing serious injury when attacking and seriously wounding them. His Honour, Judge Barnett of the County Court of Victoria, sentenced the applicant to eight years imprisonment with a non‑parole period of six years. Barnett J made a number of sentencing remarks, which the Tribunal set out at paragraphs 11 and 13 of its reasons as follows: 14.Guden, when you were interviewed you indicated to the police that you had blacked out. Apparently that night you injected testosterone into your shoulders with the view of building up bulk in the muscles of your shoulders but had significantly overdosed. You were also taking Panadeine Forte and cold and flu tablets as you were suffering from a cold and you consumed alcohol.…19.At about Poath Road and in Dandenong Road the lights turned red and all cars stopped. John Doukis and Raman tried to turn in their seats to see what was happening with the Celica. John Doukis could not see clearly and opened his door to put one foot out. At that time you, Guden, came increasingly angry and yelled: “Let me out, let me out,” pushing against Hanna’s seat. Hanna opened the driver’s door and her seat released. That allowed you, Guden, to exit the Celica, carrying with you a black handled machete.20.You crossed in front of the Celica and ran to the left towards the open driver’s door window of Peter Doukis’s Camry. You yelled: “I’m going to cut your throat” and then swung the machete, using both hands through the open window towards Peter Doukis. Peter Doukis raised his arm and received a machete cut to the right forearm causing a deep incision. He screamed in pain.21.During this John Doukis left the Civic and ran across to where his brother’s Camry was. As he neared the Camry, you, Musa, had left the Celica by that stage and ran to John Doukis. You kicked John Doukis from behind and sent him colliding against the boot of the Camry. Doukis then fell to the ground. As he hit the ground you, Musa, began to punch and kick him. About this time Peter Doukis drove his Camry forward to escape Guden.22.Guden, you then turned your attention to John Doukis, swinging the machete down at him. John Doukis raised his arm to protect himself and received a severe cut to the left forearm which cut through to the bone. As this was happening you, Musa, continually kicked John Doukis. John Doukis grabbed hold of his injured forearm and you Guden raised the machete and swung it down towards his head. John Doukis ducked his head to try and avoid the blow. He then stood up and ran in a zigzag fashion, trying to escape from both you Musa and Guden. As he did so he screamed: “You’ve broken my arm, what are you trying to do, kill me? Stop it, stop it. If you keep going you’ll kill me.23.As he ran he was continually punched and kicked from behind by both of you. In fact you endeavoured to kick his legs to try and make him trip over again. As he neared the grass median strip between the inbound and outbound lanes of Dandenong Road you, Guden, swung the machete down on the rear of Doukis’s head. The blow was delivered with such force it caused large lacerations to the rear of Doukis’s head and fractured his skull. The force was also sufficient enough for a small fragment of the machete to become embedded in his skull.24.Witnesses who observed the incident from the intersection of Chadstone Road and Dandenong Road described the attack as a frenzied attack and were highly disturbed by the objective features of what they saw. John Doukis was able to get to his feet again and kept running across the inbound lane towards the serve lane. He was bleeding heavily, leaving a blood trail on the road. He was again kicked and punched by you, Musa, and you, Guden, swung the machete at him again, causing a deep laceration across his back.25.At one stage it seems that you, Guden, swang the machete at Doukis as Musa or Doukis grabbed you, causing a cut to Musa’s right hand requiring stitches to be inserted at the Dandenong Hospital. Raman, believing the only way to stop Doukis from being killed was to run down both, that is you Guden and Musa, with the car he was driving. He drove through the traffic lights, made a u-turn, crossing inbound lanes so that he could drive the car into the vicinity of where you, Guden and Musa were standing.26.He then attempted to drive the car at both of you but overshot the point where you were standing and came to a stop. Peter Doukis tried to do the same thing. He slipped you, Guden, and then hit you Musa, causing you to roll across the Camry’s bonnet. The break allowed John Doukis to escape towards Raman’s Civic. Raman screamed for John Doukis to get into the car. You, Guden, still armed with the machete ran after John Doukis. You swung the machete at John Doukis but hit the car. Raman was able to drive away from the scene and leave with John Doukis and travel to the Monash Medical Centre.27.Peter Doukis at this stage was in severe pain and feeling the effects of blood loss. The passenger in the car took over driving and drove him also to the Monash Medical Centre where police were called. You, Musa and Guden then returned to Hanna’s pink Celica. She drove you towards Dandenong. Musa, you indicated that your hand was cut and you wanted to go to the Dandenong Hospital. Hanna, you pulled into a side street where you allowed Guden to get out of the car and put the machetes in a storm water drain. You then drove Musa to the Dandenong Hospital.…32.John Doukis received an eight centimetre horizontal wound over the octuple skull fracture, a deep wound to the middle forearm, severing muscles of the ulnar nerve and artery and a superficial wound to the right posterior chest wall. Peter Doukis suffered a six centimetre incise wound to the middle of the forearm. In addition to those injuries of course there are a number of superficial bruises and abrasions caused by the attack on both men.…56.Clearly you [Mr Guden] were the instigator of the offence, you were the one who was armed with the machete. You were the one who inflicted the severe wound to Peter Doukis’s arm and the multiple wounds to John Doukis. You were the principal assailant that has altered John Doukis’s life quite considerably as a result of the injuries that you inflicted upon him. As I have already said in relation to your co-accused Musa an appropriate sentence must strongly reflect the need of the community to denounce in no uncertain terms your conduct as totally unacceptable and of course to strongly reflect considerations of general and specific deterrence.57.In your case I do give weight to your youth. I suspect in many ways given more maturity and your ability to control your inclination to become intoxicated your chances of reoffending are perhaps limited. Nevertheless, even giving weight to those considerations there is a need in my mind to pass a significant sentence of imprisonment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal reviewed the Minister’s decision by reference to Direction no 55 – Visa Refusal and Cancelation under s 501 (“Direction no 55”), as required by s 499 of the Migration Act. On 6 June 2013, the Tribunal affirmed the Minister’s decision, made on 14 March 2013, to refuse the applicant a Special Eligibility (Residence) (Class AO) visa.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISIONFactual and legislative background The Tribunal set out the factual and legislative background stating, inter alia, at [19]:The power of the Tribunal to review the decision to refuse to grant a visa to Mr Guden is provided by Section 500. Under subsection 499(1) the Minister has given written directions (Direction [55] which commenced on 1 September 2012) as to the exercise of the power to review the decision. Subsection 499(2A) provides that these directions must be complied with. The Tribunal noted at [20]:As Mr Guden was sentenced to detention for eight years he has a “substantial criminal record” in accordance with subsection 501(7) of the Act. In accordance with subsection 501(6) he does not pass the character test and I must consider whether the Tribunal should exercise the discretion to grant him the visa he seeks. The Tribunal set out excerpts from Direction no 55, including paragraph 6.3 which specifies the principles that provide the framework within which a decision-maker should approach their task and the primary considerations in paragraph 11(1). The Tribunal stated at [23]:The Direction requires the decision-maker (in this case the Tribunal) to take into account the primary and other considerations relevant to the individual case. Primary considerations should generally be given greater weight than the other considerations.[footnotes omitted] The Tribunal then considered, seriatim, the three primary considerations enumerated in paragraph 11(1). Primary consideration 11(1)(a) In relation to primary consideration 11(1)(a) (“[p]rotection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct”), the Tribunal set out the relevant matters specified in paragraph 11.1 to which it must have regard. The Tribunal discussed the relevant matters in detail. It concluded that the applicant’s conduct to date was extremely serious and the offences he committed in 2007 were within four years of, and more serious than, the first offences. The Tribunal noted that the applicant’s conduct formed the basis of a finding that he was not of good character under subsection 501(6)(c) apart from the finding under s 501(6)(a). The Tribunal had earlier described the circumstances of the offences in 2007 in some detail and set out at length the sentencing judge’s remarks, including about the continuing impact of the applicant’s conduct on several victims (including, the witnesses and the psychological and physical injuries of the Messrs Doukis, one of whom underwent ten hours of surgery and suffered permanent physical damage). The Tribunal discussed the risk to the Australian community should the applicant commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct, having regard to the matters set out in sub‑paragraph 11.1.2 of Direction no 55.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal then considered, seriatim, the three primary considerations enumerated in paragraph 11(1). Primary consideration 11(1)(a) In relation to primary consideration 11(1)(a) (“[p]rotection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct”), the Tribunal set out the relevant matters specified in paragraph 11.1 to which it must have regard. The Tribunal discussed the relevant matters in detail. It concluded that the applicant’s conduct to date was extremely serious and the offences he committed in 2007 were within four years of, and more serious than, the first offences. The Tribunal noted that the applicant’s conduct formed the basis of a finding that he was not of good character under subsection 501(6)(c) apart from the finding under s 501(6)(a). The Tribunal had earlier described the circumstances of the offences in 2007 in some detail and set out at length the sentencing judge’s remarks, including about the continuing impact of the applicant’s conduct on several victims (including, the witnesses and the psychological and physical injuries of the Messrs Doukis, one of whom underwent ten hours of surgery and suffered permanent physical damage). The Tribunal discussed the risk to the Australian community should the applicant commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct, having regard to the matters set out in sub‑paragraph 11.1.2 of Direction no 55. The Tribunal also set out sub‑paragraph 11.2.2 of Direction no 55. The Tribunal concluded (at [31]): Should Mr Guden commit further offences by way of physical attacks similar to those in which he has engaged in in the past, the harm to individuals and to the Australian community would be extreme. The victim or victims of such attacks would suffer severe injuries which could be fatal. Many members of the community would be affected by the trauma associated with such attacks and would feel less secure as a result. The Tribunal considered in detail the likelihood of the applicant reoffending, taking into account that the visa he sought would permit him to remain in Australia for an extended period. The Tribunal considered at length a number of reports. First, it considered the report of Ms Stevens (Provisional Psychologist at the Offender Development Department at the Fulham Correctional Centre). Ms Stevens prepared a Specialist Assessment and Management Plan in relation to the applicant, whom she interviewed on 27 April 2013. Ms Stevens opined that the risk he would engage in further violent conduct was low. The Tribunal placed less weight on the opinion of Ms Stevens than it would otherwise have done, as Ms Stevens did not have available totally accurate information, because the applicant gave her an untruthful and inaccurate account of the circumstances of his offending in 2007 which differed significantly from that put to the County Court and the evidence before the Tribunal. The Tribunal noted that this indicated the applicant’s failure to accept full responsibility for, and an endeavour to minimise the seriousness of, the conduct.