Groupline Constructions Pty Ltd v CDI Lawyers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Groupline Constructions Pty Ltd v CDI Lawyers Pty Ltd [2024] QSC 209

PARTIES:

GROUPLINE CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD
(ACN 168 247 621)

(plaintiff)

v
CDI LAWYERS PTY LTD (ACN 602 380 898)

(first defendant)

AND
STEPHEN PYMAN

(second defendant)

AND
CHEVRON PARK PTY LTD (ACN 650 297 126)

(third defendant)

FILE NO:

BS 4674 of 2024

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

9 September 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

26, 27 and 28 August 2024

JUDGE:

Muir J

ORDER:

1.   I direct that by 4.00pm 10 September 2024, the parties are to bring in orders consistent with these Reasons that permanent injunctions restraining CDI and Mr Pyman from acting for Chevron in terms of paragraphs 1(b) and (c) and 2(b) and (c) of the originating application are granted, together with any costs order as agreed.

2.   If costs cannot be agreed, I direct that the parties exchange written outlines (of no more than 2 pages), by 4.00pm 30 September 2024, with a copy to be emailed to my Associate at the same time. I will then decide the issue of costs on the papers.

CATCHWORDS:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – LEGAL PRACTITIONERS – SOLICITORS – CONFLICT OF INTEREST – CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION – PERMANENT INJUNCTIONS – RESTRAINTS – where the second defendant was the solicitor for the plaintiff and associated interests for approximately 14 years – where the second defendant through the first defendant commenced acting for the third defendant against the plaintiff – where the plaintiff brings an application to restrain the first and second defendants from acting for and advising the third respondents –       where solicitors for the first defendant provided undertakings – whether there is a real and sensible risk that confidential information will be relevant to the adjudication process or other disputes and proceedings remaining under the contract between the plaintiff and third defendant – whether undertakings given are reliable and sufficient – whether there is a real and sensible possibility of the confidential information being used – whether there was any delay in seeking injunctive relief – whether restraint is necessary

Australian Solicitors Conduct Rules 2012, r 21
Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld), s88

Acciona Agua Australia Pty Ltd v Monadelphous Engineering Pty Ltd (2020) 4 QR 410
Aveo Retirement Homes Ltd v Springfield City Group Pty Ltd [2024] QCA 102
Babcock & Brown DIF III Global v Babcock & Brown International Pty Ltd [2015] VSC 453
Brodyn Pty Ltd t/as Time Coast and Quality v Davenport (2004) 61 NSWLR 421
Carindale Country Club Estate Pty Ltd v Astill (1993) 42 FCR 307
Dealer Support Services Pty Ltd v Motor Trades Association of Australia Ltd [2014] FCA 1065
Department of Main Roads v Davenport & Ors [2006] QSC 47
Farrow Mortgage Services Pty Ltd (in liq) v Mendall Properties Pty Ltd [1995] 1 VR 1
Grant v Downs (1976) 135 CLR 674
Grimwade v Meagher (1995) 1 VR 446
Hospital…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Groupline Constructions Pty Ltd v CDI Lawyers Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 209
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Groupline Constructions Pty Ltd sought relief from CDI Lawyers Pty Ltd and Mr Pyman, a solicitor from CDI, to prevent them from acting for a third party, Chevron, in relation to ongoing disputes. The primary concern was whether CDI and Mr Pyman would misuse confidential information from their prior representation of Groupline. The court had to decide if there was a real and sensible risk of such misuse and if the proposed undertakings by CDI were sufficient to protect Groupline's interests. The court also considered whether there was any undue delay in seeking injunctive relief and if the restraint was necessary for the proper administration of justice.

The court found that there was indeed a real and sensible risk of confidential information being misused by CDI and Mr Pyman. The undertakings provided by CDI were deemed unreliable and insufficient to mitigate this risk, particularly as they were premised on CDI continuing to act for Chevron with an information barrier in place. Given this finding, the court rejected the undertakings and opted to grant the permanent injunctions sought by Groupline. The court held that the proper administration of justice required that CDI and Mr Pyman be restrained from acting for Chevron in the specified terms, as there was a real possibility of the misuse of confidential information.

In conclusion, the court granted the permanent injunctions sought by Groupline Constructions Pty Ltd. It directed that by 4.00pm on 10 September 2024, the parties were to bring in orders consistent with these Reasons. If the parties could not agree on costs, they were to exchange written outlines by 4.00pm on 30 September 2024, with a copy to be emailed to the court's Associate at the same time. The court would then decide the issue of costs on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. I direct that by 4.00pm 10 September 2024, the parties are to bring in orders consistent with these Reasons that permanent injunctions restraining CDI and Mr Pyman from acting for Chevron in terms of paragraphs 1(b) and (c) and 2(b) and (c) of the originating application are granted, together with any costs order as agreed.

2. If costs cannot be agreed, I direct that the parties exchange written outlines (of no more than 2 pages), by 4.00pm 30 September 2024, with a copy to be emailed to my Associate at the same time. I will then decide the issue of costs on the papers.

Background

Background to the litigation

These issues are necessarily informed by an understanding of the relevant facts and the legal principles governing a solicitor’s obligation not to disclose confidential information.Relevant facts Mr Widdicombe and David Widdicombe are father and son builders who have operated a construction business variously through Civic and Groupline for about 20 years. Groupline was incorporated in February 2014 and at that time, Mr Widdicombe was appointed as its sole director – a position he held until 3 April 2018. David Widdicombe is currently the sole director and secretary of this company. He did not give evidence before me.CDI acting for Groupline and the Widdicombe interests Mr Widdicombe swore two affidavits and was cross examined by senior counsel for Mr Pyman and CDI. Mr Widdicombe has been a commercial builder for over 40 years. He was the sole director and secretary of Civic from 21 January 2003 until 24 June 2021. He is also the sole director and shareholder of Markford who in turn is a shareholder of Groupline and Civic. Mr Widdicombe described his current position as the “Commercial Director” of both Civic and Groupline, although Civic does not have any active projects on its books at the present. Mr Widdicombe was planning to retire after April 2018 but he changed his mind and he continues to remain heavily involved in the day-to-day operation of the business. His day-to-day responsibilities include instructing solicitors if necessary and planning, developing and implementing commercial strategies to support the business development of the Widdicombe interests. The effect of his evidence, which I accept, is that he discusses business with David Widdicombe regularly, they have a good working relationship and that generally speaking, they are on the same page about the operation and direction of the Widdicombe interests. Mr Widdicombe’s evidence was that over the period from 2006 to 2019, he did not instruct any other solicitors apart from Mr Pyman in building and construction matters for Civic and then Groupline. Mr Widdicombe understood that much of the legal work was undertaken by more junior solicitors at CDI, under Mr Pyman’s supervision. His evidence was that he contacted Mr Pyman either by telephone, email or in person most days or every second day when there was an active matter. His recollection was that he spoke to Mr Pyman over the years about once a fortnight or, failing that, he communicated via email once a fortnight. The records in evidence do not necessarily support these general recollections and Mr Widdicombe’s memory of the regularity of contact does not afford with Mr Pyman’s. It is however unnecessary to resolve the minutiae of this factual discrepancy as nothing turns on it, given the concession about Confidential Information. What is clear is that Mr Pyman and Mr Widdicombe enjoyed a close solicitor and client relationship for a considerable period of time and, it is therefore reasonable to infer, that due to their long association, the two men were regularly in contact, at least on an intermittent basis, even if Mr Pyman was not actively running any particular files. Consistent with this finding, it is instructive that the file references for most of Groupline’s matters with CDI appear to have been opened with Mr Pyman as the contact person.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having considered the public interest that a litigant should not be deprived of his or her choice of solicitor without good cause, I am satisfied that a “fair-minded, reasonably informed member of the public would conclude that the proper administration of justice required that the solicitor in question [CDI and Mr Pyman] be so restrained.”[26][26]Grimwade vMeagher [1995] 1 VR 446 at 452 per Mandie J; Spincode at [32] - [44], [48] and [60] per Brooking JA; see also Babcock & Brown DIF III Globalv Babcock & Brown International Pty Ltd [2015] VSC 453 at [83] per Riordan J.Conclusion The real issue in this case was whether CDI should be retrained from continuing to act in any further adjudication. I have found that there is real and a sensible risk of the misuse of Confidential Information by CDI if that is allowed to happen. The Undertakings this court would have otherwise accepted are infected by this finding (as they are premised on CDI continuing to act for Chevron with an Information Barrier in place). The most efficient and cleanest way to address this issue is for the court to reject the Undertakings (as it does) so that the makers are not bound by them; and that being done, to make the permanent injunctions sought. Orders and Directions I direct that by 4.00pm 10 September 2024, the parties are to bring in orders consistent with these Reasons that permanent injunctions restraining CDI and Mr Pyman from acting for Chevron in terms of paragraphs 1(b) and (c) and 2(b) and (c) of the originating application are granted, together with any costs order as agreed. If costs cannot be agreed, I direct that the parties exchange written outlines (of no more than 2 pages), by 4.00pm 30 September 2024, with a copy to be emailed to my Associate at the same time. I will then decide the issue of costs on the papers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Kipps emphatically denied that Mr Pyman was involved in the preparation of the adjudication response. So did Mr Pyman. But this evidence is in stark contrast to what CDI said in paragraph 104 of the written adjudication response of 22 April 2024 (about the tactics of Groupline in bringing the application to restrain CDI being yet another tactic to distract Chevron from finalising its response) as follows: “In other words, similarly to the futility of the court proceedings commenced on 28 March 2024, the orders sought by Groupline are inconsequential in circumstances where Mr Pyman and CDI will have completed the preparation of Chevron’s adjudication response before a decision in respect of the originating application is made by the Court”. [underlining added] Ms Kipps was initially adamant in her refusal to accept that this written submission was inconsistent with the effect of her earlier evidence that Mr Pyman was not involved in the preparation of the adjudication response. But when she was taken carefully to paragraph [104] and read it properly, she agreed but could not explain “why Mr Pyman’s name was put on there because he wasn’t involved”. Ms Kipps evidence about this submission needs to be seen in the context that she was part of a group of people working on the response (although she was charged with managing or overseeing the many people who were working on it); and she was not the person from CDI who reviewed and signed off on the adjudication response. Consistent with there being many people involved, and by way of example, the evidence of Ms Kipps (which I accept) was that she did not find out about the admission to paragraphs [18] and [19] of the statement of claim until the Saturday morning after it was made. On this issue, the most reliable evidence is that of the contemporaneous submissions of 22 April 2024, I therefore find that Mr Pyman was more than just peripherally involved in CDI preparing Chevron’s response to the first adjudication application. Relevant legal principles The statement of claim alleges that CDI and Mr Pyman owed a duty of loyalty to Groupline and Civic. There is conflicting authority about whether such a duty exits in Australia once a solicitor’s retainer ends.[3] But the parties agree it is unnecessary for me to resolve this quandary because it is accepted on the facts that there remains a duty on CDI and Mr Pyman to preserve the Confidential Information.[3]For example: Nash v Timbercorp Finance Pty Ltd (in liq), in the matter of the bankrupt estate of Nash[2019] FCA 957, at [121]-[122] per Anderson J;Dealer Support Services Pty Ltd v Motor Trades Association Australia Limited [2014] FCA 1065 at [40]-[91] per Beach J; Spincode Pty Ltd v Look Software Pty Ltd [2001] VSCA 248 at [59]-[60] per Brooking JA; see also at [63] per Chernov JA; Flanaganv Pioneer Permanent Building Society Ltd & Anor [2002] QSC 346 at [9] per Dutney J. There are two alternative grounds on which the court might restrain a legal practitioner in the circumstances arising in this proceeding:(a)First, if a reasonable person, informed of the relevant facts, might reasonably anticipate a danger of misuse of confidential communications made to Mr Pyman in the context of the lawyer-client relationship between him and the Groupline interests, and there is a real and sensible possibility that the interests of Mr Pyman in advancing Chevron’s case, might conflict with his duty to keep the information confidential and refrain from using that information to the Groupline interests’ detriment;[4] and(b)Second, where the proper administration of justice requires the court to prevent Mr Pyman from acting, to protect the integrity of the judicial process and the due administration of justice, including the appearance of justice.[5][4]Timbercorp Finance at [62].[5]Dealer Support Services at [4] per Beach J.