Grima and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2018] AATA 3737 (8 October 2018)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s): 2017/0130
Re:Martin Grima
APPLICANT
AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Senior Member A Poljak
Date:8 October 2018
Place:Sydney
The decision under review is set aside, and in substitution a decision is made in the following terms:
1. The applicant’s multi-engine aeroplane class rating is cancelled pursuant to sub-regulations 269(1)(b) and (d) of the Civil Aviation Regulations 1998 (Cth).
2. The applicant’s private pilot licence - aeroplane category (PPL-A) is suspended until such time as:
a)The applicant undertakes 15 hours of remedial flying training at a Flight Training School acceptable to CASA including a minimum of:
i.cross-country navigation exercises planned at close to minimum reserves, requiring careful pre-flight planning and in-flight monitoring (including calculation of actual ground speed and fuel flow);
ii.unplanned diversions during cross-country navigation exercises given to the pilot whilst airborne, requiring flight to an unfamiliar destination;
iii.in-flight practice emergency sequences with emphasis not only on accurate flying, but also on sensible decision-making with regard to:
I.assessment of the emergency;
II.continuation/termination flight;
III.chosen flight path;
IV.type of approach;
V.preparedness for deterioration of the situation;
VI.distress calls and passenger handling consideration; and
b)CASA receives a written report from the Flight Training School on the standard of the applicant’s conduct as a pilot during the training period including whether his performance met the competency standards specified in the Part 61 Manual of Standards. The report must include all training records and competency standards achieved, and a final recommendation that the applicant is considered ready to undergo a flight test for a PPL-A; and
c)The applicant undertakes and passes the PPL-A flight test under the supervision of a CASA officer, or an examiner approved by CASA in writing; and
d)The applicant undertakes psychological evaluation by a psychologist acceptable to CASA and provides a psychological evaluation report addressing the applicant’s insight into the conduct which led to the making of the reviewable decision and the likelihood of their being a repeat of such conduct.
.......................[sgd].............................................
Senior Member A Poljak
CATCHWORDS
CIVIL AVIATION – cancellation of pilot licence – whether applicant fit and proper person – attempted solo flight in multi-engine aircraft – multi-engine aircraft endorsement – veracity of applicant’s records – whether adequate flight time – airworthiness of aircraft – whether appropriate level of planning – flight carrying persons later identified as wanted by police – whether applicant pilot in command – whether applicant’s involvement in the flight bears upon his fitness and propriety – meaning of ‘fit and proper person’ – need to take account of the responsibilities, functions and duties of the licence holder – Tribunal not able to be reasonably satisfied on a number of issues – applicant displayed lack of judgment and overconfidence in flying ability – consequences of decision considered – intention to pursue flying as a livelihood – decision under review set aside and substituted
LEGISLATION
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 43(1)
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Grima and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] AATA 3737
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal was required to determine whether Mr Grima possessed adequate flight time and training to be endorsed on a multi-engine aircraft, the veracity of his flight records, and whether his planning and judgment were appropriate for such an endorsement and for undertaking a flight carrying passengers later identified as wanted by police. Central to the Tribunal's consideration was the meaning of "fit and proper person" in the context of aviation safety, and whether Mr Grima's conduct demonstrated a lack of judgment and overconfidence.
The Tribunal found that Mr Grima's recorded flight time of 4.8 hours for his multi-engine endorsement was inadequate, especially given his limited total aeronautical experience and pilot-in-command time on single-engine aircraft. Expert evidence suggested a significantly higher level of experience, around 500 hours, was more appropriate for a flight of the nature undertaken. The Tribunal concluded that Mr Grima displayed a lack of judgment and overconfidence, and was not satisfied on a number of issues regarding his fitness and propriety to hold a licence. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside CASA's decision and substituted its own decision.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Mr Lawlor says in his witness statement dated 23 June 2017, that training on multi-engine aircraft is a ‘very serious matter’. In regards to the amount of flight time undertaken by the applicant to warrant his PA-60 endorsement, Mr Lawlor states at [41](d):“In my opinion, 4.8 hours of training for an inexperienced pilot (and not yet fully licensed) transitioning from a single to a twin-engine aircraft is not adequate to ensure full competency in the proper operation of a twin-engine aircraft which has significantly different performance and handling characteristics to a single engine aircraft. This is emphasised in the applicant’s case by the fact that, at the time of the issue of the PA-60 endorsement, the applicant had only recorded 6.4 hours as pilot in command time, all on single engine aircraft and only 80 hours of total aeronautical experience. I do not consider it appropriate or safe for any Flight Training Organisation (FTO) to sanction the issue of an initial twin-engine endorsement at all in those circumstances and I hold considerable doubts as to the applicant’s ability to safely operate the PA-60 aircraft type, or any other twin-engine aircraft.” [Emphasis added] At hearing, Mr Ekinci was questioned about the sufficiency of the applicant’s flight time of 4.8 hours to warrant his PA-60 endorsement. Mr Ekinci stated that he didn’t think it was exceptionally fast as he only needed 4.8 hours before he was satisfied that the applicant was proficient; this is despite the applicant taking 24.5 hours of solo flying to obtain his pilot’s licence. It was put to Mr Lawlor in cross examination that Mr Ekinci was the best person to comment on the applicant’s flying ability to which he responded, “I think when you factor in the experience of Mr Grima, his qualifications, lack of them in essential areas, I think Mr Ekinci’s faith in Mr Grima was not warranted”; “it was too early to take the training wheels off”. In Mr Lawlor’s view, the minimum period of time that someone ought to be flying before taking a flight such as the Norfolk Island Flight, is “something like 500 hours with a certain mix of experience on different types of aircraft, and on the particular type of aircraft concerned”. He did not believe that 10 hours of experience was sufficient to let a pilot go solo for the first time as “you can’t cover all the contingencies and the manoeuvres and competencies required, to safely send someone solo, in 10 hours”. Mr Lawlor explained that the minimum time required to be a commercial pilot was 150 hours in relation to one sort of course, or 200 hours in relation to another. When asked to reconcile this position with his view that you need at least 500 hours to undertake a flight of the kind that was proposed here (the Norfolk Island Flight), he stated, when someone comes out of a commercial license course, “they’re not really qualified to do much at all”. He described that a pilot who completes a commercial license course typically then undertakes simple activities such as joy flights and scenic flights to build up flying time or will get a job, all of which are very tightly controlled and the pilot does the same thing each day. In comparison, the applicant, according to his logbook, “has not done anything like that before, and then all of a sudden just launches off over the ocean”. Mr Lawlor states that “with 500 hours you’d have a little bit more of an opportunity to have experienced more of what aviation has to offer. It’s not a be-all and end-all, it’s just an approximate point, and other qualifications, I think, would adjust that amount up or down. But at 200 hours or 150 hours, you’re really not qualified to do much at all”.