Chernikeeff and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

Chernikeeff and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2020] AATA 25 (13 January 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2018/5954

Re:PAUL CHERNIKEEFF

APPLICANT

AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:R CAMERON SENIOR MEMBER.

Date:13 January 2020

Place:Melbourne

Accordingly, the Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision and substitutes a decision in the following terms:

  1. The Applicant’s Private Pilot Licence Aeroplane Category (PPL) is suspended until 12 July 2020;

    (a)Prior to reinstatement of the Applicant’s PPL:

    (i)The Applicant must undertake a minimum of 15 hours of remedial flying training at a flight training school acceptable to Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). CASA must receive a written report from the flight training school on the standard of the Applicant’s conduct as a pilot during the training period.

    (ii)The Applicant must undertake and pass a PPL flight test under the supervision of a CASA officer, or an examiner approved by CASA.

    (iii)Undertake a psychological evaluation by a psychologist acceptable to CASA and provide a psychological evaluation report addressing the Applicant’s insight into the conduct which led to the making of the reviewable decision and the likelihood of there being a repeat of such conduct.

    (b)That every six months until 30 June 2022 the Applicant must furnish to CASA copies of his Pilot Logbook and all relevant pages of the Maintenance Release for Aircraft VH-BQZ.

    (c)That the Applicant is precluded from flying with any passengers from the reinstatement of the Applicant’s PPL until 30 June 2021.

    ....[sgd]....................................................................

    R CAMERON SENIOR MEMBER.

    CATCHWORDS

    CIVIL AVIATION – cancellation of Private Pilot Licence Aeroplane Category – whether applicant fit and proper person – whether applicant failed in duty as a pilot – need to maintain proper documentation – where applicant had prior suspension of licence – decision under review set aside and substituted

    LEGISLATION

    Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth)
    Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth)

    Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

    CASES

    Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321
    Ekinci v CASA [2014] AATA 424 at [10].
    Grima v CASA[2018] AATA 3737.
    Hughes and Vale Pty Ltd v NSW (No 2) (1955) 93 CLR 127

    Re: Broadbent v CASA [1999] AATA 972.

    SECONDARY MATERIALS

    Civil Aviation Advisory Publication 42ZC-1 (2)

    REASONS FOR DECISION

    R CAMERON SENIOR MEMBER.

    THE REVIEWABLE DECISION.

  2. The Applicant seeks a review of a decision made by the Respondent (“CASA”) made on 12 July 2018 cancelling the Applicant’s Private Pilot Licence Aeroplane Category (“PPL”) (“the reviewable decision”).

    THE APPLICABLE LEGISLATION.

  3. CASA is the regulator of civil aviation in Australia, established under the relevant provisions of the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) (“the Act”).

  4. Section 3A of the Act specifies its objects as the establishment of a regulatory framework for maintaining, enhancing and promoting the safety of civil aviation, with particular emphasis on preventing aviation accidents and incidents.

  5. As was readily acknowledged by counsel for both the Applicant and the Respondent section 9A of the Act requires CASA—and the Tribunal stepping into its shoes as a decision maker—to have regard for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chernikeeff and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the applicant against a decision by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to cancel his Private Pilot Licence (Aeroplane Category). The dispute arose from allegations that the applicant was not a fit and proper person to hold the licence, and that he had failed in his duties as a pilot, necessitating the cancellation under Civil Aviation Regulation 269(1)(d).

The court was required to determine whether the applicant had failed in his duty with respect to matters affecting the safe navigation or operation of an aircraft, as contemplated by CAR 269(1)(c), and whether he was consequently not a fit and proper person to hold a Private Pilot Licence under CAR 269(1)(d). These two limbs were considered to be intrinsically linked, requiring the application of the same facts and circumstances to both.

The court found that the applicant had indeed failed in his duties in several respects. These included flying without a current Maintenance Release, which was described as grossly irresponsible and a fundamental breach of aviation safety requirements. The applicant also failed to ensure he had a current medical certificate, a basic obligation for any pilot. Furthermore, the court found that the applicant's decision to fly from Temora to Latrobe Valley after his application for a Special Flight Permit had been refused was indefensible and a conscious decision to break the law. His landing on runway 04 at Tooradin contrary to the prevailing circuit direction was also identified as unsafe conduct and a manifest breach of duty.

The court noted that CASA had previously lifted a suspension of the applicant's licence, reminding him that past contraventions would be considered in the event of future breaches. However, subsequent events, including a flight on 21 January 2017, led to CASA's decision to cancel the licence. The court's final orders are not explicitly stated in the provided text, but the reasoning strongly suggests a confirmation of CASA's decision to cancel the licence.

Background

Background to the litigation

CAR 269 (1) (d) provides that CASA may, by notice in writing vary, or cancel a PPL if the licence holder is not a fit and proper person to have the responsibilities and exercise and perform the functions and duties of a holder of such an authorisation.BACKGROUND FACTS. Helpfully, counsel for the Applicant and the Respondent prepared an agreed statement of facts which was provided at the commencement of the hearing. The Applicant is the registered operator of an amateur built Helve Classic aircraft registration mark VH-BQZ (“Aircraft VH-BQZ”). Aircraft VH-BQZ was manufactured in the United States of America in 2004. In 2005 it was disassembled and shipped to Australia. Subsequently, it was reassembled in Australia in 2006. On 21 March 2006 a Special Certificate of Airworthiness (“SCOA”) was issued for Aircraft VH-BQZ. The SCOA specifies that, apart from the conditions contained in its annexure, all other maintenance and regulatory requirements are applicable. Part 1 of Aircraft VH-BQZ logbook records that it is fitted with a “Rotec” engine which is manufactured by “Rotec Aerosport” a business or company which is principally owned and controlled by the Applicant. The Applicant has been a proprietor of this business and manufactured several versions of the “Rotec” engine since approximately 2000. The engine manufacturing business conducted by the Applicant at all times material to this application has operated from Tyabb aerodrome. More will be said about this engine manufacturing business later in these reasons. The Applicant’s PPL Aviation Reference Number 755667 was issued to him on 2 June 2007. The Applicant has not at any time been issued with any form of authority permitting him to perform maintenance on Aircraft VH-BQZ.[2][2] This fact is admitted in the Agreed Statement of Facts at paragraph 7. Since obtaining his PPL in 2007 he has flown over 400 hours.SOME OBSERVATIONS ON THE WITNESSES. It is appropriate to make some initial observations about the veracity of the witnesses who gave evidence during the course of the hearing before the Tribunal. Specific observations will be made later in the reasons concerning various witnesses’ evidence on several discrete issues. The Applicant in several ways was a witness who was challenged by giving evidence. He had in many respects made a series of errors or omissions concerning several incidents and his subsequent dealings with CASA. He was obviously embarrassed by these events, and generally admitted his wrongdoing where appropriate. Much of it was very serious wrongdoing. However, sometimes in order to explain away his wrongdoing or embarrassment, he did not present as a particularly credible witness. There appeared to be at times a tendency to reconstruct, gloss over, or as some might describe it, “gild the lily”, to downplay the seriousness of his conduct. Where his evidence conflicts with that of other witnesses the Tribunal prefers the evidence of the other witnesses. However, despite some of the serious misconduct on the part of the Applicant the Tribunal does not view him as a fundamentally dishonest individual or a person with tendencies to engage in behaviour that might be seen to be morally reprehensible. The Applicant did, with hindsight, acknowledge his wrongdoing and conceded as he put it, that he had taken a wrong pathway and it was very regrettable. The Tribunal accepts this explanation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 24 December 2015, CASA lifted the suspension of the Applicant’s PPL. In CASA’s notice lifting the suspension, the Applicant was informed that the matters referred to in the Suspension Notice would be taken into account should the Applicant again come to CASA’s attention for contravening aviation legislation.[26][26] This fact is admitted in the Agreed Statement of Facts at paragraph 21. The "DECISION TO LIFT SUSPENSION OF PRIVATE PILOT LICENSE-AEROPLANE CATEGORY ARN 755667" ("the Decision to Lift the Suspension") is document T 83 of the T documents. It is also appropriate to repeat a paragraph of the Decision to Lift the Suspension in these reasons. The last paragraph states:“CASA considers that your successful completion of the required examination, along with the period of reflection resulting from the suspension of your license will improve your attitude to safety and has re-established your fitness to exercise the privileges of your PPL (A) in the wake of the matters referred to in my decision of 7 July 2015. However, you should be aware, that those matters will be taken into account should you again come to CASA’s attention for contravening the aviation legislation.” Once again the contents of this paragraph of the Decision to Lift the Suspension was a clear and unequivocal reminder to the Applicant, if not a warning, of the constant need for vigilance concerning aviation safety and compliance with the applicable aviation regulatory regime. He could have been in no doubt of the need not to incur any further breaches, but also that the matters referred to in the Suspension Notice could be taken into account again if there were any subsequent breaches.INCIDENT 21 JANUARY 2017 AND SUBSEQUENT EVENTS. On 21 January 2017, the Applicant flew Aircraft VH-BQZ with a female passenger from Tyabb to Tooradin, Victoria.[27][27] This fact is admitted in the Agreed Statement of Facts at paragraph 22. The Applicant had flown Aircraft VH-BQZ to Tooradin aerodrome no less than on 14 previous occasions between 2006 and 2016.[28][28] This evidence is contained in the pilots logbook, document T 191 of the T documents. In closing submissions Counsel for the Respondent identified each of the dates by reference to each relevant entry in the Applicant's Pilot Logbook. (See transcript pages 391-393 for details of the precise dates concerned. They need not be reproduced in these reasons.) A pilot in command before beginning a flight is required to study all available information appropriate to that flight, such as the Aeronautical Information Publication.[29] This document is published by Air Services Australia and includes, amongst other things, document known as “Enroute Supplement Australia” (“ERSA”). An ERSA contains information relevant to flight planning and to pilots in flight, particularly for those contemplating operations from a particular aerodrome.[30][29] CAR 239 (1).[30] The statement of Mr William Cox and the section headed "Pre-Flight Planning" is referred to concerning this matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Almost invariably, as is the case in this matter, it will be necessary to apply the same acts, facts and circumstances in determining both whether the Applicant:(a)Has failed in his duty with respect to any matter affecting the safe navigation or operation of an aircraft within the meaning of CAR 269 (1) (c); and(b)Is not a fit and proper person to have the responsibilities and exercise and perform the functions and duties of the holder of a PPL within the meaning of CAR 269 (1) (d).HAS THE APPLICANT FAILED IN HIS DUTY WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER AFFECTING THE SAFE NAVIGATION OR OPERATION OF AN AIRCRAFT WITHIN THE MEANING OF CAR 269 (1) (C)? Given the findings earlier in these reasons the Tribunal is satisfied that the Applicant failed in his duty with respect to several matters affecting the safe navigation, or operation of an aircraft, within the meaning of CAR 269 (1) (c). They will be summarised below. Flying without a current Maintenance Release. The Tribunal’s reasons in paragraph 37 above are referred to and repeated. Some further observations about the Applicant’s conduct are also warranted concerning this ground. The regulatory requirements for proper and up to date maintenance that is appropriately recorded is an essential feature of aviation safety. Every pilot knows this, or should know this. It is grossly irresponsible to fly without a current Maintenance Release. Sound aviation practice involves checking and crosschecking. Every competent pilot in the proper discharge of their duties should conduct diligent checks to ensure that a current Maintenance Release is in force before they fly. It is not that hard to do, and is not too difficult a demand; certainly not in the aviation setting, especially given the main objects of the Act being safety, which regulate the issue of a PPL, amongst other things. Flying without a current medical certificate. Once again the Tribunal’s reasons at paragraph 38 above are referred to and repeated. One has to question how the Applicant did not keep his medical certificate current. A pilot has a fundamental obligation to do so. It is also quite disturbing that the Applicant responded to the CASA officer Mr Scrimshaw in the way he did when questioned during the course of the ramp check on 17 April 2014. The Tribunal must conclude that he failed in his duty with respect to a matter affecting safe navigation or operation of an aircraft in flying without being certain that he had a current medical certificate. Flying from Temora to Tyabb and then the Latrobe Valley on 21 May 2014 knowing that the application for the SFP had been refused was indefensible. The observations made earlier in these reasons that it was a conscious decision to break the law, not to mention a stupid act on the part of the Applicant, are repeated. It was a blatant failure or breach of duty with respect to the safe navigation and operation of an aircraft, and something that a competent pilot in command simply would not do. Landing on runway 04 at Tooradin contrary to the prevailing circuit direction of the aerodrome, and therefore in contravention of CAR 166A (1) has been canvassed in these reasons at some length. It was unsafe conduct because it involved the Applicant landing in the opposite direction to prevailing circuit traffic at the aerodrome. It was a manifest breach of duty on the part of the Applicant as pilot in command.