Griffin Energy Pty Ltd v Western Power Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Griffin Energy Pty Ltd v Western Power Corporation [2006] FCA 1241

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – preliminary discovery – whether there was compliance with O 15A r 6(a) of the Federal Court Rules – information in documents confidential – whether discretion should be exercised to refuse preliminary discovery order

Electricity Corporation Act 1994 (Cth)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 82, 87

Federal Court Rules O 15A r 6

Hughes Aircraft Systems International v Civil Aviation Authority (1995) 217 ALR 303
St George Bank Limited v Rabo Australia Limited (2004) 211 ALR 147
Viskase Corp v Cryovac Inc [2000] FCA 1695

GRIFFIN ENERGY PTY LTD (ABN 38 002 105 545) and GRIFFIN ELECTRICITY PTY LTD (ACN 113 898 678) and GRIFFIN POWER PTY LTD (ACN 106 034 879) v WESTERN POWER CORPORATION (ABN 38 362 983 875)
WAD 348 OF 2005

SIOPIS J
15 SEPTEMBER 2006
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 348 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

GRIFFIN ENERGY PTY LTD (ABN 38 002 105 545)
First Applicant

GRIFFIN ELECTRICITY PTY LTD (ACN 113 898 678)
Second Applicant

GRIFFIN POWER PTY LTD (ACN 106 034 879)
Third Applicant

AND:

WESTERN POWER CORPORATION (ABN 38 362 983 875)
Respondent

JUDGE:

SIOPIS J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 SEPTEMBER 2006

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1The parties are to confer with a view to producing a minute of orders reflecting this judgment.

2The application is otherwise adjourned sine die.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 348 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

GRIFFIN ENERGY PTY LTD (ABN 38 002 105 545)
First Applicant

GRIFFIN ELECTRICITY PTY LTD (ACN 113 898 678)
Second Applicant

GRIFFIN POWER PTY LTD (ACN 106 034 879)
Third Applicant

AND:

WESTERN POWER CORPORATION (ABN 38 362 983 875)
Respondent

JUDGE:

SIOPIS J

DATE:

15 SEPTEMBER 2006

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The respondent is responsible for the generation, transmission and distribution of electricity throughout Western Australia.  The main transition network is in the south‑west of the State centred on Perth.  It is known as the South West Interconnected System (‘the SWIS’).  In 2002 the respondent embarked upon a tender process for the purpose of procuring additional generating capacity for the SWIS.  This tender process was conducted pursuant to the Electricity Corporation Act 1994 (WA), which requires the respondent to procure substantial new generating capacity through a non discriminatory and open public procurement process (‘PPP’).

  2. There were two stages to the PPP for the SWIS.  This case is concerned with the second stage of the PPP.

  3. Under the first stage the respondent sought a procurement of approximately 240MW of generating capacity for the SWIS by late 2005.

  4. In December 2002, the respondent launched Stage 2 of the PPP which was for the procurement for 300MW to 330MW of new generating capacity for the SWIS.  The applicants submitted a tender to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Griffin Energy Pty Ltd v Western Power Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1241
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Griffin Energy Pty Ltd, represented by Mr Wayne Richard Trumble, sought to obtain certain documents from Western Power Corporation, the respondent. The documents in question pertained to a tender process for the procurement of a power station. The applicants sought production of all bid proposals, submissions, presentations, and any other documents which recorded or evidenced the content of any proposal submitted by Wambo to the respondent. The Federal Court was required to determine whether the applicants were entitled to the discovery of certain documents from the respondent in relation to the tender process.

The court examined the nature of the documents sought, which included confidential information and potentially proprietary technical designs. The respondent argued that the documents contained sensitive information, which, if disclosed, could harm their business interests and potentially compromise their competitive position against the applicants. The court considered the arguments from both parties, particularly the discretionary factors that should be considered in granting such an order. The court noted the potential for commercial harm and the proprietary nature of the information sought.

The court concluded that the applicants were not entitled to the discovery of the documents in question. The court held that the potential for commercial harm to the respondent, coupled with the proprietary nature of the information, outweighed the applicants' interest in obtaining the documents. The court exercised its discretion to decline relief, noting that the applicants had not demonstrated a compelling need for the documents that would justify overriding the respondent's legitimate concerns.

The court made no further orders for the production of the documents and adjourned the application sine die.

Orders

Orders of the court

1 The parties are to confer with a view to producing a minute of orders reflecting this judgment.

2 The application is otherwise adjourned sine die.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicants relied upon the affidavits of Wayne Richard Trumble affirmed on 22 November 2005, 8 March 2006 and 3 April 2006. The respondent relied upon the affidavits of Baden Furphy dated 7 April 2006 and Trevor Stanley Harvey sworn on 22 February 2006 and 30 March 2006. Mr Trumble was responsible for the preparation and submission of the tender on behalf of the applicants. Mr Harvey is an employee of the respondent and holds the position of Manager, Power Procurement. None of Mr Trumble, Mr Furphy or Mr Harvey was cross‑examined.Mr Trumble’s evidence In his affidavit of 22 November 2005, Mr Trumble identifies information from the respondent which led him to believe that the respondent required the proposed power station to have a baseload generating capacity of between 300MW to 330MW of power; or putting it another way, to be capable of generating 300MW to 330MW of power on a constantly sent‑out basis; and to meet prescribed environmental standards. Firstly, Mr Trumble identified a number of documents issued by the respondent entitled ‘Process Update’ dated 7 June 2002, 1 July 2002, 20 December 2002, 26 February 2003 and 31 March 2004 respectively. The author of each of these documents was Mr Trevor Harvey. Process Update No 2 is dated 7 June 2002 and reads:‘…[the respondent] has launched the public procurement process for approximately 240 MW peaking generation capacity for the South West Interconnected System (SWIS) by late 2005.The Minister for Energy Hon. Eric Ripper announced this first stage of power procurement on 2 June 2002, as part of a generation strategy including both the public procurement of additional capacity in two stages and the replacement of ageing units in [the respondent’s] existing portfolio.…A second stage of the power procurement process, which is to procure approximately 300 MW of baseload generation capacity by late 2007, is expected to commence in late 2002. No further information covering the second stage is yet available.’ Process Update No 5 is dated 1 July 2002 and reads:‘….EXPRESSION OF INTEREST UPDATE[The respondent] received 26 expressions of interest from companies with local, national and international operations to provide around 240 megawatts of new peaking capacity to meet the growing electricity demand in the South West Interconnected System.…The second stage of power procurement, to obtain additional baseload generating capacity, is expected to begin later in 2002 and to be in operation by 2007/08.’ Process Update No 12 is dated 20 December 2002 and reads:‘SWIS POWER PROCUREMENTSTAGE 2LAUNCH OF STAGE 2The Minister for Energy Hon. Eric Ripper announced in June 2002 two stages of public power procurement. The first stage is now in the Final Bid Phase.[The respondent] has today launched the second stage of the public procurement process, for the acquisition of 300 MW to 330 MW of baseload capacity for the South West Interconnected System (SWIS) to be in service from 2007.…Lodgement of expressions of interest close at 10:00 am WST on Wednesday, 26 February 2003.’

Decision

Reasons for decision

SIOPIS J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SIOPIS J

There is no need to deal with the question of whether there is a potential claim for relief in contract. Suffice to say that the exclusion clauses in the Bid Agreement appear, on the face of it, to comprise a substantial obstacle for the applicants.Discretionary considerations The next question is whether I should in the exercise of discretion decline relief. The respondent relied upon the affidavit of Mr Baden Furphy sworn 7 April 2006. Mr Furphy said that he was a partner of the law firm, Freehills, and that he had approximately 10 years experience acting on transactions in the energy industry having acted for various electricity companies and State governments. Mr Furphy said that Freehills acts for Wambo and was aware of Wambo’s participation in the PPP. Wambo is a joint venture between ERM Group and Babcock & Brown. Mr Furphy said that his role was to assist Wambo in the negotiation of the documentation for the project. He said that he is familiar with the documentation which was sent by Wambo to the respondent and received by Wambo from the respondent during the period 2002‑2005 in connection with Wambo’s tender. Mr Furphy said that the information contained in the Wambo documentation includes:‘(a)detailed information regarding the technical characteristics and design of the power stations;(b)financial information relating to the project, including pricing information; and(c)information relevant to the future operation of the power station.’ Mr Furphy said that the applicants seek production of all bid proposals, submissions, presentations and any other documents which record or evidence the content of any proposal submitted by Wambo to the respondent. This class of documents, he said, would include confidential information. Mr Furphy also said that he has been informed by Mr St Baker, Chairman of ERM Group, that the documentation in respect of which discovery is sought, also contains information regarding the technical characteristics and design of the power station which was the product of several years work in developing a power station that met the respondent’s specific requirements. There are, said Mr Furphy, aspects of Wambo’s project which were novel and elements of the information which Wambo regarded as proprietary. Mr Furphy went on to say that he was informed by Mr St Baker that the applicants, or a related company or companies of the applicants, are constructing the Bluewater Power Station in Western Australia and that once the Bluewater Power Station is constructed the applicants, or related companies, will be direct commercial competitors of Wambo into the future. Mr Furphy said that he was informed by Mr St Baker that there would be ways in which the applicants could use the information in the documents to the disadvantage of Wambo. Mr Furphy identified two specific ways. Firstly, when Wambo’s power station was not available for service, Wambo may need to procure energy from other sources, including possibly, the applicants. If the applicants were aware of Wambo’s contractual obligations with the respondent and the likely operational characteristics of the power station, this would give a commercial advantage to the applicants in any procurement negotiations with Wambo or an informational advantage in respect of selling energy into the market.