FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| GRATTAN & GRATTAN AND ANOR (NO. 6) | [2014] FamCA 1118 |
| FAMILY LAW – INJUNCTIONS - Injunction sought by wife to enable joint control of large number of corporate entities in circumstances where there were allegations of improper use of funds, breach of an injunction and irregularities in company accounts – Discussion about ordinary course of business and whether where there is a large sum of money involved in assets, the balance of convenience favours a refusal of such an injunction – Consideration of the approach of the Court to the granting of the injunction where there are significant corporate entities involved – Injunction granted. |
| Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) |
| ASIC v Triton Underwriting Insurance Agency [2003] NSWSC 1145 Jackson v Sterling Industries [1987] HCA 23; (1987) 71 ALR 457 Yunghanns v Candoora No 19 Pty Ltd (No 2) [2000] VSC 300 |
| APPLICANT: | Mr Grattan |
| RESPONDENT: | Ms Grattan |
| INTERVENER: | B Pty Ltd |
| FILE NUMBER: | MLC | 4259 | of | 2013 |
| DATE DELIVERED: | 11 December 2014 |
| PLACE DELIVERED: | Melbourne |
| PLACE HEARD: | Melbourne |
| JUDGMENT OF: | Cronin J |
| HEARING DATE: | 4, 5, 8 & 10 December 2014 |
REPRESENTATION
| COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: | Mr Ackman QC with Mr Werner |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: | Taussig Cherrie Fildes |
| COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: | Mr Glick QC with Mr Strum |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: | Lander & Rogers |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE INTERVENOR: | Mr C, C Law Firm |
Orders
That on or before 4.00pm on Friday 12 December 2014, the husband and the wife sign all documents and do all acts and things necessary to open a cheque account with Westpac Banking Corporation in their joint names.
That the husband cause or direct all monies hereafter payable or paid to, and/or receivable or received by him, and any of the Grattan Entities as defined in Annexure A to these orders (whether in the form of cash, cheque, bank transfer, credit card payment or howsoever otherwise) to be forthwith deposited into the joint Westpac account without deduction howsoever.
That the husband be prohibited, whether by himself, his servants or agents from:
(a)Causing, authorising, permitting or abiding or howsoever otherwise preventing any monies receivable or received by or payable or paid to him and any of the Grattan Entities (whether in the form of cash, cheque, bank transfer, credit card payment or howsoever otherwise) to be dealt with other than by immediate payment into the Joint Westpac Account; and
(b)Drawing upon or in any manner dealing with or causing, authorising, permitting or abiding by any other person drawing upon or dealing with any accounts in his name or in the name of any of the Grattan Entities or in any other accounts to which he is a signatory other than in the ordinary course of business PROVIDED ALWAYS THAT the written consent of the wife is first obtained in relation to any such business drawings or dealings.
That the husband and the wife, by themselves, their servants and agents, be prohibited from drawing upon or in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Grattan and Grattan and Anor (No. 6) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FamCA 1118
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine the terms of interim orders to govern the financial affairs of the parties and the Grattan Entities pending final resolution of the proceedings. Specifically, the court had to consider how monies payable or receivable by the husband and the Grattan Entities should be handled, the restrictions to be placed on drawing from or dealing with accounts held by the husband or the Grattan Entities, and the payment of liabilities incurred by credit card use. The court also had to address the immediate release of funds from a NAB facility to the husband and wife.
Cronin J reasoned that it was necessary to implement stringent measures to preserve assets and ensure financial transparency. The court ordered the establishment of a joint Westpac account into which all monies payable or receivable by the husband and the Grattan Entities were to be deposited forthwith and without deduction. The husband was prohibited from dealing with these monies other than by depositing them into the joint account, and from drawing upon any accounts in his name or the Grattan Entities' names without the wife's written consent, except in the ordinary course of business. The court also ordered that liabilities incurred by credit card use by the husband or Grattan Entities were to be paid solely from a sum of $150,000 to be paid to the husband, and that existing accounts were not to be used for such payments.
The court further ordered that $150,000 each be drawn down from a NAB facility in the name of the second respondent and paid to the husband and wife respectively, to be treated as part-property settlements. Additionally, the court restrained National Australia Bank Limited, ANZ Banking Corporation Limited, and Westpac Banking Corporation Limited from permitting any drawings or dealings with accounts in the names of the husband and Grattan Entities, save for amounts properly owing to those banks. The wife's application for interim orders was otherwise dismissed, and outstanding applications for final hearing were adjourned.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
That on or before 4.00pm on Friday 12 December 2014, the husband and the wife sign all documents and do all acts and things necessary to open a cheque account with Westpac Banking Corporation in their joint names.
2.
That the husband cause or direct all monies hereafter payable or paid to, and/or receivable or received by him, and any of the Grattan Entities as defined in Annexure A to these orders (whether in the form of cash, cheque, bank transfer, credit card payment or howsoever otherwise) to be forthwith deposited into the joint Westpac account without deduction howsoever.
3.
That the husband be prohibited, whether by himself, his servants or agents from:
(a) Causing, authorising, permitting or abiding or howsoever otherwise preventing any monies receivable or received by or payable or paid to him and any of the Grattan Entities (whether in the form of cash, cheque, bank transfer, credit card payment or howsoever otherwise) to be dealt with other than by immediate payment into the Joint Westpac Account; and
(b) Drawing upon or in any manner dealing with or causing, authorising, permitting or abiding by any other person drawing upon or dealing with any accounts in his name or in the name of any of the Grattan Entities or in any other accounts to which he is a signatory other than in the ordinary course of business PROVIDED ALWAYS THAT the written consent of the wife is first obtained in relation to any such business drawings or dealings.
4.
That the husband and the wife, by themselves, their servants and agents, be prohibited from drawing upon or in any manner dealing with or causing, authorising, permitting or abiding by any other person drawing upon or dealing with the Joint Westpac Account other than upon the joint signature of the Husband and the Wife.
5.
That any and all liabilities incurred by the Husband or any of the Grattan Entities by reason of the use of any credit cards (whether in his name or that of any of the Grattan Entities) only be paid by the husband from the sum of $150,000 paid to him pursuant to the next paragraph hereof AND for the avoidance of doubt, the husband not use or abide the use of any existing accounts in his name or that of any of the Grattan Entities to pay such credit card liabilities.
6.
That notwithstanding any other provisions of these orders, the husband and the second respondent forthwith execute all documents and do all acts and things necessary to cause two sums of $150,000 each (a total of $300,000) to be drawn down in favour of and paid to each of the husband and the wife from the NAB facility in the name of the second respondent and secured over Business F, such sums to be specifically acknowledged by the parties and treated at trial as part-property settlements in respect of each of their ultimate entitlements and to be specifically adjusted against their respective entitlements.
7.
That:
(a) National Australia Bank Limited;
(b) ANZ Banking Corporation Limited; and
(c) Westpac Banking Corporation Limited,
each be restrained from permitting or abiding any drawing upon or dealing with, any accounts in the names of the husband and of any of the Grattan Entities save as may be properly owing from time to time to each of those banks.
8.
That the wife’s application for interim orders is otherwise dismissed.
9.
That all outstanding applications for final hearing are adjourned to 10.00am on 18 February 2015.
ANNEXURE “A”
CORPORATE ENTITIES COMPRISING THE GRATTAN GROUP
1.
AA Street Partnership / AA Street, Suburb BB Joint Venture
2.
AA Street Pty Limited
3.
CC Unit Trust
4.
DD Pty Limited
5.
DD Trust
6.
EE Unit Trust
7.
FF Pty Limited
8.
GG Pty Limited
9.
HH Unit Trust
10.
JJ Pty Limited
11.
JJ Unit Trust
12.
KK Australasia Pty Limited
13.
KK Australasia Trust
14.
KK Pty Limited
15.
LL Pty Limited
16.
MM Pty Limited
17.
MM Unit Trust
18.
Grattan I Street Pty Limited
19.
Grattan I Street Trust
20.
Grattan Equity Holdings Pty Limited
21.
Grattan Equity Unit Trust
22.
Grattan Family Extended Trust
23.
Grattan Family Trust
24.
Grattan Finance Pty Limited
25.
Grattan Finance Trust
26.
Grattan Group Investments Pty Limited
27.
Grattan Group Nominees Pty Limited
28.
Grattan Holdings Pty Limited
29.
Grattan Holdings Trust
30.
Grattan Investment Trust
31.
Grattan Nominees Pty Limited
32.
Grattan Nominees Pty Limited and NN Nominees Pty Limited Partnership
33.
Grattan Technologies Pty Limited
34.
OO Distribution Trust
35.
PP Finance Pty Limited
36.
PP Finance Trust
37.
QQ Pty Limited
38.
QQ Trust
39.
RR Family Trust
40.
SS Trading Trust
41.
TT Unit Trust
42.
UU Pty Limited
43.
UU Pty Limited and VV Pty Limited Partnership
44.
WW Grattan Family Trust
45.
XX Unit Trust
46.
YY Management Pty Limited
47.
YY Management Unit Trust
48.
YY Pty Limited
49.
YY Unit Trust
50.
ZZ Pty Limited
51.
ZZ Unit Trust
52.
AB Pty Limited
53.
BC Pty Limited
54.
CD Unit Trust
55.
B Pty Limited
56.
DE (Int) Limited
57.
EF Pty Limited
58.
FG Pty Limited
59.
GH Pty Limited (previously HI Pty Limited)
60.
GH Trust
61.
IJ Pty Limited
62.
JK Pty Limited
63.
KL Pty Limited
64.
KL Unit Trust
65.
LM Trust
66.
MN Pty Limited
67.
MN Unit Trust
68.
Business F Unit Trust
69.
NO Pty Limited
70.
OP Pty Limited
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi