Grannall v Marrickville Margarine Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read
93 CLR 55

MARRICKVILLE MARGARINE PROPRIE-

TARY LIMITED Constitutional Law (Cth.) -Freedom of inter-State trade and commerce-Table

margarine-Manufacture-Sale-Licence-State legislation-Validity-Severa- 1954-1955. bility-The Constitution (63 &64 Vict. c. 12), S. 92-Judiciary Act 1903-1950, 8. 18-Dairy Industry Act 1915-1951 (N.S.W.), S. 2 (2), 22A (1) (b).

Section 22A (1) (b) of the Dairy Industry Act 1915-1951 (N.S.W.) provides that no person shall manufacture or prepare table margarine unless he obtains a table margarine licence. Under S. 22A (2) and (3) the Minister of Agriculture is given authority to grant or refuse a licence at his discretion. If a licence is granted it must contain a condition limiting the quantity which may be manufactured during the currency of the licence and the aggregate quantity of table margarine respectively specified in the various licences must not exceed 2,500 tons in a period of twelve months S. 22A (6) (c). The Act contains a severability clause. Although not stated by the Act it was not contested that the motive for limiting the production of table margarine is lest the Australian market for butter should be prejudiced by the competition of margarine.

In answer to an information laid against the company in the Court of Petty Sessions for not holding a licence from the Minister of Agriculture the company set up S. 92 of the Constitution saying that S. 22A (1) (b) forms an inseparable part of a statutory attempt to restrict the freedom of inter-State commerce in margarine. Under S. 40 of the Judiciary Act 1903-1950 the cause was removed into the High Court.

Held that S. 22A of the Dairy Industry Act 1915-1951 (N.S.W.) is a wholly valid enactment not affected in any way by S. 92 of the Constitution. Legis- lative restrictions or prohibitions upon the production or manufacture of goods, do not, in themselves, constitute an infringement of S. 92.

Merely because the primary motive of the legislation is that margarine shall not be sold to consumers who might otherwise buy butter, although

93 CLR 56

they might buy in inter-State trade, or from or through those who do buy margarine in inter-State trade, it does not necessarily follow that there is a direct interference with inter-State trade. It does not matter whether the purpose or motive is inferred from circumstances or from the statute or, indeed,

The distinction between S. 51 (i.) and S. 92 of the Constitution discussed. Section 21 forbids the exportation of margarine from New South Wales unless certain conditions are complied with and therefore there may be some doubt as to its validity but it is clearly severable. Section 22B which, inter alia, makes it unlawful to sell cooking margarine to persons not therein pre- scribed may well be ineffective in the face of S. 92 but this could not bear on the validity of S. 22A (1) (b). Section 22c is an overriding provision enabling the Minister to grant a special permit for the manufacture of table margarine for export from Australia with a condition…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grannall v Marrickville Margarine Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1955] HCA 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Grannall v Marrickville Margarine Pty Ltd* concerned a prosecution against Marrickville Margarine Pty Ltd for manufacturing table margarine without a licence, contrary to section 22A(1)(b) of the *Dairy Industry Act 1915-1951* (NSW). The company argued that this provision, which required a licence and imposed quantity limitations on table margarine manufacture, infringed section 92 of the Australian Constitution, which guarantees freedom of inter-State trade, commerce, and intercourse. The matter was removed to the High Court of Australia.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether section 22A(1)(b) of the New South Wales Act, by regulating the manufacture of table margarine, constituted an impermissible burden on inter-State trade and commerce, thereby contravening section 92 of the Constitution. The court was required to determine if the legislative restrictions on production, even if primarily aimed at protecting the dairy industry from competition, directly interfered with the freedom of inter-State commerce, or if such restrictions were merely antecedent to, and distinct from, inter-State trade itself.

The High Court held that section 22A of the *Dairy Industry Act* was a valid enactment and not affected by section 92 of the Constitution. The court reasoned that legislative restrictions or prohibitions on the production or manufacture of goods, in themselves, do not infringe section 92. While the court acknowledged that the motive for limiting margarine production was to protect the butter market, it found that this did not necessarily equate to a direct interference with inter-State trade. The court distinguished between the act of manufacture and the act of inter-State trade, stating that while manufacture is a necessary precursor to trade, it does not, in itself, constitute trade or commerce among the States. The court emphasised that section 92 protects inter-State dealing and movement, not the activities that precede them.

The court found that the provisions of section 22A(1)(b) were valid and did not contravene section 92 of the Constitution. The company's defence failed, and the charge against it was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.