Granitgard Pty Ltd v Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Granitgard Pty Ltd ACN 007 427 590 v Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd ACN 093 837 337 [2008] FCA 865

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – amended notice of motion – application to vacate trial dates – leave to file further amended statement of claim – whether vacation of trial will prejudice respondent

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to inspect property of third party premises pursuant to O 17 of the Federal Court Rules – offer of undertaking to the court as to confidentiality

COSTS – whether respondent entitled to costs thrown away as a result of the vacation of trial dates – whether on an indemnity or standard basis – whether applicant entitled to costs of notice of motion if successful

Held: upon applicant providing undertaking regarding contact with third parties, leave to file further amended statement of claim granted and trial dates vacated – any prejudice to respondent compensable by costs and undertaking – inspection of property of third party ordered in light of further amendments to pleadings – confidentiality requires inspection be conducted by expert independent of applicant – applicant to pay respondent’s costs thrown away as result of vacation of trial dates and further amendment to pleadings – circumstances of case not such as to warrant indemnity costs – costs of amended notice of motion reserved

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 51A, 52, 53
Federal Court Rules O 13 r 2, O 17

Abela v Giew (1964) 81 WN (Pt 1) NSW 344 cited
Australian Broadcasting Commission v Parish (1980) 29 ALR 228 cited
Caruso Australia Pty Ltd v Portec Australia Pty Ltd [1986] FCA 40 cited
Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Limited (1993) 46 FCR 225 cited
David Charles Robinson v Aware Industries Ltd (unreported, Weinberg J, 1 October 1998) cited
Dresna Pty Ltd v Misu Nominees Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 1537 cited
Ex parte Fielder Gillespie Ltd [1984] 2 QdR 339 cited
Ketteman v Hansel Properties Ltd [1987] AC 189 cited
Londish v Gulf Pacific Pty Ltd (1993) 45 FCR 128 cited
Menzies v CRCI Pty Ltd [2007] NSWCA 118 cited
Smith v Gannawarra Shire Council (2002) 4 VR 344 cited
SPI Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd v Diageo Australia Ltd (No 4) [2007] FCA 1035 applied
State of Queensland v JL Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146 cited
The Commonwealth v Verwayen (1990) 170 CLR 394 cited

GRANITGARD PTY LIMITED ACN 007 427 590 v TERMICIDE PEST CONTROL PTY LTD ACN 093 837 337

QUD 312 OF 2007

COLLIER J
10 JUNE 2008
BRISBANE

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD 312 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

GRANITGARD PTY LIMITED ACN 007 427 590
Applicant

AND:

TERMICIDE PEST CONTROL PTY LTD ACN 093 837 337
Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 JUNE 2008

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

UPON THE APPLICANT THROUGH ITS COUNSEL UNDERTAKING UNTIL JUDGMENT IS GIVEN IN THESE PROCEEDINGS OR EARLIER ORDER OF THE COURT NOT TO REPRESENT BY ITSELF , ITS OFFICERS, SERVANTS OR AGENTS, TO…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Granitgard Pty Ltd v Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 865
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Granitgard Pty Ltd v Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd concerns a dispute between two companies operating in the pest control industry. Granitgard Pty Ltd, the applicant, filed proceedings against Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd, the respondent, alleging breaches of sections 52 and 53 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The applicant challenges specific representations made by the respondent about its product, Termiglass, which is a termite barrier system comprising glass particles. Granitgard claims that Termiglass does not meet certain standards and is not as effective as the respondent advertises. The case involves complex technical details about the composition and effectiveness of the products, with both parties employing termite experts to support their positions.

The legal issues before the Court centered on whether the respondent’s representations about Termiglass were misleading or deceptive, and if they breached the provisions of the Trade Practices Act. The Court had to consider the evidence provided by both parties, including expert reports, particle size analysis of Termiglass samples, and compliance with relevant standards and appraisals. The Court was also required to determine the appropriate procedural steps moving forward, particularly in light of the applicant’s request for further amendments to its statement of claim and the need for additional discovery and expert inspections.

The Court granted the applicant leave to further amend its statement of claim, allowing it to include new details about the variability and composition of Termiglass. The Court also permitted the applicant to inspect the manufacturing process at Vision Glass Recycling, the supplier of Termiglass, subject to strict confidentiality and usage conditions. The Court further ordered that the previously scheduled trial dates be vacated and set new directions for further proceedings, including additional discovery and the next hearing date. The Court emphasized the importance of maintaining confidentiality regarding the inspection and imposed costs on the applicant for the additional amendments and the vacation of trial dates.

The Court’s orders included allowing the applicant to file a further amended statement of claim by a specific date, granting the respondent permission to file a further amended defence, and scheduling a new directions hearing. The Court also permitted the applicant to inspect the manufacturing process of Termiglass under controlled conditions, with strict confidentiality clauses. These orders reflect the Court’s intention to manage the proceedings efficiently while ensuring that both parties have adequate opportunity to present their cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant have leave to file and serve a Further Amended Statement of Claim in the form exhibited to the affidavit of Tracy Lynn O’Neill filed on 30 May 2008, by 4.00 pm on 11 June 2008.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs occasioned by, and thrown away in consequence of, further amendments to the amended Statement of Claim as contemplated by paragraph 1 hereof.

3. The respondent have leave to file and serve a Further Amended Defence by 4.00 pm on 13 June 2008.

4. The trial set down to commence on 23 June 2008 be vacated.

5. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs occasioned by, and thrown away in consequence of, vacation of the trial dates.

6. Pursuant to O 17 of the Federal Court Rules, that the applicant (through its legal representatives and experts) be permitted to attend at the premises of Vision Glass Recycling at 39 Colebard St, West Archerfield Qld 4110 to observe and record the manufacturing process for, to inspect the equipment used in that process and to take samples of, the crushed glass it provides to Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd as Termiglass (“the inspection”), such inspection to be:

(a) undertaken by arrangement with Vision Glass Recycling;

(b) carried out between the hours of 9.00 am and 4.00 pm on or before 20 June 2008;

(c) carried out by:

(i) the parties’ legal representatives; and

(ii) an expert chosen by the applicant and notified to the respondent on or before 4.00 pm 12 June 2008 who is independent of the applicant and any related entity thereto;

(d) carried out in the presence of such other persons as the respondent so wishes, being no more than four persons.

7. Except by leave of the Court or with the written consent of the respondent or its solicitors, information or knowledge gained during the inspection be not:

(a) divulged to any person, firm or company other than the solicitors and Counsel for the applicant and the Court;

(b) used for any purpose other than the purposes of these proceedings.

8. Prior to carrying out the inspection, the applicant’s legal representatives and the independent expert give to the respondent and to this Court an undertaking in writing to abide by the requirements of paragraph 7 hereof.

9. The applicant file and serve any evidence in relation to the inspection within 14 days after the inspection.

10. The application for further and better discovery be adjourned to the date of the next directions hearing.

11. The matter be set down for further directions at a date to be fixed.

12. The parties have liberty to apply.

13. The costs associated with the amended notice of motion be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the conclusion of the hearing of 10 June 2008 I made appropriate orders and informed the parties that I would deliver reasons for my decision as soon as possible. I now deliver those reasons, attached to the orders I made on 10 June 2008.The facts Both the applicant and the respondent conduct businesses in the pest control and management industry, and part of that business is the installation of particle barriers into houses as protection against termites. The applicant installs a crushed granite product known as “Granitgard”. The respondent operates in south-east Queensland and supplies and installs a termite barrier system comprising glass particles known as “Termiglass”. The proceedings were commenced by application and statement of claim filed on 19 September 2007. The statement of claim was subsequently amended on 15 February 2008. In the pleading currently before the Court, the applicant claims that the respondent has engaged in conduct in breach of ss 52 and 53 Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). In particular, it challenges representations that the respondent’s product, inter alia, forms an impenetrable barrier, is “too hard to chew, too heavy to move and too small to crawl through”, satisfies the relevant Australian Standard and that it otherwise provides a suitable physical barrier against subterranean termite entry. On 15 February 2008 the proceedings were listed for hearing for five days commencing 23 June 2008, and directions were made in respect of discovery, the obtaining of samples of Termiglass from the respondent, the conduct of experiments and the filing of affidavit evidence by the applicant. Because of the applicant’s inability to meet the timetable ordered, further directions were made on 2 May 2008. Both applicant and respondent have retained the services of termite experts, and a number of reports have been produced and filed as evidence. The applicant has applied to the Court for leave to further amend its amended statement of claim by insertion of the following amendments:“6ATermiglass is a crushed glass product of variable quality, containing a range of glass sizes and types.Particulars(a)3 samples of termiglass have been produced by Termicide to Granitgard pursuant to orders in these proceedings. That sample contained crushed glass principally ranging in size of 1.71mm-2.36mm but with up to 1% being between 2.37mm and 3.35mm and up to 7% being between 1.19mm and 1.70mm. It contains a range of clear and coloured glass(b)3 samples of termiglass have also been produced by Mr Ken Thompson, a former employee of Termicide. Such samples was of product being installed by Termicide in or about December 2007 or January 2008. This sample contained crushed glass principally ranging in size from <1.18mm to 3.35mm and up to 6% being between 3.36mm and 4.75mm. The glass was also mostly coloured, and contained paper and traces of rubber(c)Mr Tim Prow, another former employee of Termicide, installed Termicide product during the period April to December 2007. The glass that was initially installed was clear in colour but later changed to include coloured glass which smelt of alcohol. The termiglass also contained paper and contained large particles of glass of up to 25mm in size(d)Further samples of Termiglass have been taken from a property at 38 Salvado Drive, Pacific Pines, Queensland 4211 that disclose 56% of the particles passed through a sieve of 1.18mm, 74% passed through a sieve of 74%, 88% passed through a sieve of 2.36mm and 100% passed through a sieve of 3.35mm.8.......(f) has a life expectancy of 50 years.Particulars...… Representation (f) is made following the installation of termiglass and is made in writing on a sticker placed on the property’s meter box by the installer of the termiglass.9AThe Representations relate to future matters within the meaning of s. 51A of the Trade Practices Act.10AThe CSIRO Appraisal dated December 2003 of termiglass requires the glass particles in termiglass to be between 1.2mm and 3mm in size. The conclusion made in the CSIRO Appraisal that termiglass satisfies the Australian Standard as a suitable physical termite barrier, relies on research of Ecospan Consulting Services of crushed glass particles of between 1.7 to 2.4mm in size.10BTermiglass is manufactured for Termicide by the business trading as Vision Glass Recycling.10CThe system and procedure used in the manufacture of Termicide is incapable of consistently producing large commercial quantities of termiglass of consistent quality and size to comply with the requirements of the Australian Standard, the CSIRO Appraisal or to be consistent with the crushed glass tested by Ecospan Consulting Services.Particulars(a1)Termiglass that is installed by Termicide contains or is likely to contain crushed glass that ranges in size from <1.18 to 25mm. Some of the product installed contains paper and particles of rubber.(a2)The system used in the manufacture of termiglass is incapable of consistently producing large commercial quantities of termiglass that satisfies the requirements of the Australian Standard, the CSIRO Appraisal or the samples tested by Ecospan Consulting Services.(b) …or does not consistently satisfy...(iii)it is not graded and shaped so that a sufficient proportion of the particles are of a size that cannot be transported by foraging termite species occurring in the region;(iv)it is not able to be placed in a manner so that the voids between particles do not permit the penetration of foraging termite species occurring in the region.(b1)Termiglass does not consistently satisfy the requirements of the CSIRO Appraisal that the crushed glass be between 1.2mm and 3mm in size nor does it consistently match the samples of crushed glass tested by Ecospan Consulting Services with a particle size of between 1.7mm and 2.4mm(c) …or does not consistently:...13....Particulars…or does not consistently:”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J

Full text does not contain this section.