Grahn v The Valuer-General

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
 
  LAND APPEAL COURT,

BRISBANE.

13th December, 1990.

Re:Appeals against determinations of the Land Court -

Valuation of Land Act 1944 - 1987
  AV89-246 and 247.

Dr Hans and Else Grahn

-v-

The Valuer-General

J U D G M E N T

Dr Hans and Else Grahn have appealed against the determination of unimproved value of two (2) parcels of residential land situated in Whytecliffe Parade, Woody Point.  The relevant date for the determinations of the respective unimproved values is 31st March, 1988.  The Land Court determinations are:-

AV89-246 -An unimproved value of $75,500 for Subdivision 1 of Resubdivisions 83 and 84 of Subdivision 2 of Portion 111, Parish of Redcliffe (Valuer-General's assessment affirmed) - 18 Whytecliffe Parade.

AV89-247 -An unimproved value of $79,000 for Lot 2 on RP 141248, Parish of Redcliffe (Appeal allowed - Valuer-General's determination of $84,000 set aside) - 56 Whytecliffe Parade.

Dr and Mrs Grahn come before this Court maintaining that the unimproved value of each parcel at the relevant date is $40,000.
  The conduct of the appellants' case was in the hands of Dr Grahn, who elected to present submissions in statement form.  This material is substantially identical to the evidence he furnished to the Land Court and no useful purpose would be served in incorporating much of it in this judgment - suffice it to say that it is accurately recorded in the decision of the learned Member below and that decision should be read in conjunction with this judgment.
  One of the principle concerns of the appellants is the problem with continual repairs to their dwelling house at 18 Whytecliffe Parade caused by land slips along an escarpment upon which the dwelling is erected.  The main sliding line is under the balcony of the dwelling.  After heavy downpours new slips become visible and Dr Grahn says the house is moving and sinking in the direction of the beach.  The repair of structural damage involves costly outlays and additional maintenance to the dwelling house.  Dr Grahn says that the land at 56 Whytecliffe Parade contains a dangerous sliding line.
Dr Grahn is somewhat aggrieved that, to his knowledge, no internal inspection of either of the subject sites was made by any of the respondent's valuers. We might comment that this is surprising since Ground 1 in the respective Notices of Appeal to the Land Court contain a reference to the problem with surface movement. The valuer, Mr G.P. Crowley, walked the beach and the frontage and he interviewed the purchaser of the sale land at 48 Whytecliffe Parade in addition to inspecting the improvements on the sale lots, but there is no evidence that he physically examined the subject lots on this particular issue. Be that as it may, we are confined in this judgment to the evidence which does not convince us that there would be insufficient room on either subject lot for the erection of a dwelling house away from the problem slip line. For valuation purposes,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Grahn v The Valuer-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1990] QLAC 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dr Hans and Else Grahn have appealed against the determination of unimproved value of two parcels of residential land located at Whytecliffe Parade, Woody Point. The determinations were made by the Land Court and pertain to the date of 31st March, 1988. The respective values determined were $75,500 for Subdivision 1 of Resubdivisions 83 and 84 of Subdivision 2 of Portion 111, Parish of Redcliffe (Valuer-General's assessment affirmed) and $79,000 for Lot 2 on RP 141248, Parish of Redcliffe (Appeal allowed - Valuer-General's determination of $84,000 set aside). The Grahns argued that the unimproved value of each parcel should be $40,000, citing issues such as land slips and the need for continual repairs to their dwelling at 18 Whytecliffe Parade.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the unimproved value determinations were appropriate and whether the valuer's methods and evidence were sufficient to support the valuations. The Grahns argued that the valuer did not inspect the sites and that the valuations did not adequately consider the problems caused by land slips. The court needed to determine if the valuer's approach, which included site-to-site comparisons and consideration of factors like lot size, situation, shape, and topography, was legally sound.

The court concluded that the valuer's approach was appropriate and that the evidence supported the determinations. The court noted that the Grahns' arguments were based on personal perceptions and did not account for established valuation principles. The court emphasised that for residential sites, site-to-site comparisons were preferable to unit area value comparisons. The court dismissed the Grahns' appeal, affirming the Land Court's determinations. The appeals were dismissed, and the Land Court's determinations dated 6th April, 1990 were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established