|
BRISBANE
27 JUNE 1997
Re: Appeal against Minister’s Decision on the purchase
price of land for conversion purposes
Land Act 1994
Special Lease No.: 200631
Lessee: William Alex Lago
(Hearing at Innisfail)
D E C I S I O N
Mr WA Lago is the lessee of Special Lease No. 200631. Under the provisions of s.165 of the Land Act 1994 (“the Act”), Mr Lago applied to convert the Special Lease to a Deed of Grant. In granting the application, the Minister for Natural Resources decided that the purchase price for conversion purposes was $85,000.
Mr Lago appealed against the Minister’s decision on the purchase price under s.170(1) of the Act. Following the internal review process provided for in s.422 to s.425 of the Act, Mr Lago’s solicitors were advised by letter dated 8 November 1996, that the delegate for the Minister had reviewed the amount of the purchase price and confirmed the original decision of $85,000. By Notice of Appeal dated 5 December 1996, Mr Lago appealed to the Land Court against that decision, advising that his estimate of the unimproved value was $36,000.
Section 170 of the Act provides as follows:
“(1)Unless a price or formula has already been stated in the lease to be converted, the Minister decides the purchase price for the conversion of a lease to a deed of grant.
(2)The lessee may appeal against the Minister’s decision on the purchase price.
(3)The purchase price is an amount equal to the total of -
(a)the unimproved value of the land being offered, as if it were fee simple; and
(b)the market value of any commercial timber that is the property of the State on the land.
(4)The unimproved value of the land is calculated at the day the Minister receives the conversion application.”
In this case the value of commercial timber was not a consideration. The parties agreed that the relevant date for the determination of unimproved value is 22 September 1995.
“Unimproved value” is defined in s.434:
“(1)In this Act, the ‘unimproved value’ of land is the amount an estate in fee simple in the land in an unimproved state would be worth if there were an exchange between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm’s-length transaction after proper marketing, if the parties had acted knowledgeably, prudently and without compulsion.”
At the hearing of the appeal, the appellant was represented by Mr D Morzone, of Counsel, while the respondent was represented by Senior Valuer, Mr PF Goodman-Jones. Valuation evidence for the appellant was given by Mr R Dickson, a registered valuer in private practice, and for the respondent by Mr EM Migliorini, a registered valuer employed by the Department of Natural Resources.
Special Lease No. 200631 is in respect of the land contained in Lot 26 on Crown Plan T9482, Parish of Rockingham, County of Cardwell, which has an area of 680 m². It is situated at 6 Taylor Street, Tully Heads, a township immediately to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Lago and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1997] QLC 96
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was determining the unimproved value of the land for conversion purposes under s.170 of the Act. The definition of "unimproved value" in s.434 of the Act guided the Court, emphasizing the worth of an estate in fee simple in an unimproved state if exchanged between willing parties in an arm's-length transaction. The Court had to decide which sales and valuation evidence best reflected this unimproved value.
The Court considered the evidence from both parties. Lago's valuer, Mr. Dickson, focused on the immediate vicinity and argued that the subject land's unimproved value was $36,000, citing declining values due to erosion threats. In contrast, the respondent's valuer, Mr. Migliorini, relied on sales further afield, suggesting the unimproved value was $85,000. The Court found that while Mr. Dickson's evidence highlighted local market conditions, it lacked comparative sales of vacant land. Mr. Migliorini's evidence, though geographically broader, better reflected the value of similar beachfront properties. After weighing all the evidence, the Court concluded that the unimproved value of the subject land was $75,000.
The Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the Minister's determination and determining the unimproved value of Special Lease No. 200631 at $75,000.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi