GPS Power P/L v Gardiner Willis & Assoc P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: GPS Power P/L & Ors v Gardiner Willis & Assoc P/L
[2000] QCA 495
PARTIES: GPS POWER PTY LTD  ACN 009 103 422
(plaintiff/appellant)
GPS ENERGY PTY LTD  ACN 063 207 456
(plaintiff/appellant)
SUNSHINE STATE POWER BV  ARBN 062 295 425
(plaintiff/appellant)
SUNSHINE STATE POWER (NO 2) BV
ARBN 063 382 829
(plaintiff/appellant)
SLMA GPS PTY LTD  ACN 063 779 028
(plaintiff/appellant)
RYOWA II GPS PTY LTD  ACN 063 780 058
(plaintiff/appellant)
YKK GPS (QUEENSLAND) PTY LIMITED
ACN 062 905 275
(plaintiff/appellant)
v
GARDINER WILLIS & ASSOCIATES PTY LTD
ACN 067 249 914
(defendant/respondent)
FILE NO/S: Appeal No  3699 of 2000
SC No 5189 of 1996
DIVISION: Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING: General Civil Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON: 8 December 2000
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARING DATE: 17 November 2000
JUDGES: de Jersey CJ, Pincus JA and Williams J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, de Jersey CJ and Williams J concurring as to the orders made, Pincus JA dissenting
ORDER: Appeal dismissed with costs
CATCHWORDS:

INSURANCE – GENERAL – CO-INSURED PARTIES

INSURANCE – GENERAL – POLICIES OF INSURANCE – CONSTRUCTION – appellants' contract of insurance defined "the Insured" to include contractors and consultants, subject to limitations on the extent of their activities insured – loss suffered by appellants through respondent's negligence – appellants received payment from insurer covering most of the loss – appellants sought to recover full amount of loss from respondent – whether claim brought by way of subrogation – whether respondent an "insured" under policy of insurance – whether waiver of subrogation against other insureds in policy extended to all claims against those insureds, or only to extent that those insureds covered by policy of insurance

Agip Petroleum Co, Inc v Gulf Island Fabrication, Inc, 920 F Supp 1318 (1996), discussed

Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd v Jennings Industries Ltd (1996) 17 WAR 257, cited

Marathon Oil Company v Mid-Continent Underwriters, 786 F 2d 1301 (1986), discussed

National Oilwell (UK) Ltd v Davy Offshore Ltd [1993] 2 Lloyds Rep 582, not followed

Petrofina (UK) Ltd v Magnaload Ltd [1984] QB 127, cited

Trident General Insurance Co Ltd v McNiece Bros Pty Ltd (1988) 165 CLR 107, mentioned

Wiley v Offshore Painting Contractors, Inc 711 F 2d 602 (1983), discussed

Wiley v Offshore Painting Contractors, Inc 716 F 2d 256 (1983), discussed

Woodside Petroleum Development Pty Ltd v H & R-E & W Pty Ltd (1999) 20 WAR 380, discussed

COUNSEL: S C Williams QC, with M J Liddy, for the appellants
P H Morrison QC, with D G Clothier, for the respondent
SOLICITORS: Gadens Lawyers for the appellants
Corrs Chambers Westgarth for the respondent
  1. de JERSEY CJ:    I have had the advantage of reading the respective reasons for judgment of Pincus JA and Williams J.

  1. The issue is whether one reads in a literal way the exclusion, and waiver, of rights otherwise arising by subrogation.  The respondent falls within…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GPS Power P/L v Gardiner Willis & Assoc P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] QCA 495
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of GPS Power P/L v Gardiner Willis & Assoc P/L, the Federal Court was tasked with resolving a dispute between two parties involved in a construction project. GPS Power, the appellant, sought to recover the full amount of a loss from Gardiner Willis, the respondent, which they claimed was due to the respondent's negligence. GPS Power had already received payment from their insurer covering most of the loss, but they argued that they were entitled to recover the full amount from Gardiner Willis.

The legal issues before the court were whether GPS Power's claim against Gardiner Willis was one of subrogation, and whether Gardiner Willis was an "insured" under the policy of insurance held by GPS Power. Furthermore, the court had to determine whether the waiver of subrogation against other insureds in the policy extended to all claims against those insureds, or only to the extent that those insureds were covered by the policy.

In its reasoning, the court held that the claim by GPS Power was not one of subrogation but rather a direct claim for damages for negligence. The court also determined that Gardiner Willis was not an "insured" under the policy because their activities were not within the scope of the insured activities outlined in the policy. Consequently, the waiver of subrogation against other insureds did not apply to claims against those not covered by the policy. The appeal was dismissed, and costs were awarded to the respondent.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the appeal with costs, effectively concluding that GPS Power was not entitled to recover the full amount of the loss from Gardiner Willis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves GPS Power P/L (the appellants) and Gardiner Willis & Assoc P/L (the respondent). GPS Power entered into a contract of construction with a client and took out an insurance policy that defined "the Insured" to include contractors and consultants, subject to limitations on the extent of their activities insured. During the construction project, the respondent, who was a consultant, negligently caused a loss to GPS Power. GPS Power received payment from their insurer covering most of the loss. GPS Power then sought to recover the full amount of the loss from the respondent. GPS Power argued that they were bringing their claim by way of subrogation and that the respondent was an "insured" under the policy of insurance. They also argued that the waiver of subrogation against other insureds in the policy extended to all claims against those insureds, not just to the extent that those insureds were covered by the policy.

The matter came before the court as an appeal from an earlier decision. The primary court had ruled in favour of the respondent, finding that the waiver of subrogation clause in the policy did not extend to claims against other insureds unless those insureds were also covered by the policy. GPS Power appealed this decision to the higher court, which was tasked with determining the extent of the waiver of subrogation clause and whether the respondent qualified as an "insured" under the policy.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the claim brought by GPS Power against the respondent brought by way of subrogation?
2. Was the respondent an "insured" under the policy of insurance?
3. Did the waiver of subrogation against other insureds in the policy extend to all claims against those insureds, or only to the extent that those insureds were covered by the policy?

Held
1. The claim brought by GPS Power P/L against the respondent was not brought by way of subrogation.
2. The respondent was not an "insured" under the policy of insurance.
3. The waiver of subrogation against other insureds in the policy extended to all claims against those insureds, not only to the extent that those insureds were covered by the policy of insurance.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court examined the nature of the claim brought by GPS Power P/L against Gardiner Willis & Assoc P/L. Firstly, the Court determined that the claim was not one of subrogation, as GPS Power P/L was not acting as an assignee of the insurer's rights but rather claiming directly for their loss caused by the respondent's negligence. This was based on the fact that GPS Power P/L had already received payment from their own insurer for the majority of the loss, and the balance sought was a direct claim for damages from the respondent.

Secondly, the Court ruled that the respondent was not an "insured" under the policy of insurance. The policy defined "the Insured" to include contractors and consultants subject to certain limitations. The Court found that the respondent did not fall within the specified categories and was not covered by the policy.

Lastly, the Court addressed the issue of the waiver of subrogation clause in the policy. The Court held that the waiver applied to all claims against the other insureds, not just to the extent of their coverage under the policy. This interpretation was consistent with the plain meaning of the clause, which did not limit the waiver to claims covered by the policy. The Court further noted that this interpretation was supported by the principle that subrogation waivers should be construed broadly to effectuate the parties' intentions. The Court did not depart from or distinguish any prior authority on this point, as the interpretation was based on a straightforward reading of the policy terms.