[2011] QPEC 29
PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT
JUDGE ROBIN QC
P & E Appeal No 1477 of 2010
| GOLD COAST CITY COUNCIL | Appellant |
| and | |
| GMA CERTIFICATION GROUP PTY LTD and DAPHNE CUTHBERT, | Respondent Co-Respondents |
BRISBANE
..DATE 22/02/2011
JUDGMENT
Sustainable Planning Act 2009 s 245(2), s 464(2)(e) s 479 Building Act 1975
Building and Development Resolution Committee lacked jurisdiction to order a private certifier to decide a development application as if there were no concurrence agency requirements of the Council - Council had approved a reconfiguration according to a plan of development requiring its consent to any retaining structure exceeding 1.2 metres - Committee erred in determining that the condition did not survive the reconfiguration - private certifiers approving developments contrary to the condition would commit an offence
HIS HONOUR: Mr Lyons, representing the appellant Gold Coast City Council, was the only person standing at the hearing of this appeal which is against a building and development resolution committee's decision in Appeal Number 4 of 2010 dated 19 April 2010. It proceeded “ex parte”.
The appeal is brought under section 479 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (SPA). Such appeals are limited to the ground of an error or mistake of law on the part of the committee or that the committee had no jurisdiction to make its decision or exceeded its jurisdiction in making the decision.
The committee's decision pursuant to section 464(2)(e) of the SPA was to set aside the decision of the respondent private certifier and to direct the private certifier, as assessment manager, to decide a development application for building works as if there had been no concurrence agency requirements of the council.
Five conditions were stipulated in respect of the retaining wall which was the subject of the development application, and those ultimately found their way into the building works approval which the respondent company issued pursuant to the committee's order.
The co-respondents had applied for approval to construct a retaining wall on Lot 400 SP206391 at 137 Wunburra Circle, Pacific Pines. That is one of more than 1,000 residential allotments created pursuant to the council's approval of a reconfiguration application in 2006.
The large subdivision was located in problematic terrain in consequence of which the council's approval for reconfiguration of a lot contained, in condition 6, a requirement that retaining structures, such as a retaining wall, not exceed 1.2 metres in height without the approval of the chief executive officer.
The structure which the co-respondents were desirous of establishing ranged in height to two metres. It may be accepted that the purpose of that structure was to enhance the stability of the residence that had been erected on Lot 400 and presumably pursuant to proper authorisation. There also may be a factor of protecting neighbouring properties.
Although the council has gone to considerable trouble by prosecuting this appeal to establish that the committee lacked jurisdiction or power to make the decision it did, it has been persuaded in an independent…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gold Coast City Council v GMA Certification Group Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] QPEC 29
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the committee lacked the jurisdiction to order the private certifier to decide the development application without considering the concurrence agency requirements of the Council. The court held that the Building and Development Resolution Committee erred in determining that the condition set out in the council's approval for the reconfiguration of the lot did not survive the reconfiguration. The court held that the private certifier approving developments contrary to the condition would commit an offence under the Building Act 1975. The court noted that the Building Act 1975, as amended, constrained a private certifier in issuing development approvals. The court also held that it was not within the committee's power to make a decision that the private certifier could not have made.
The court allowed the council's appeal and ordered that the co-respondent's development application for building works on Lot 400 SP206391 be refused. The court held that the committee's decision amounted to the commission of an offence under section 84 of the Building Act 1975. The court held that it was a jurisdictional error for the Committee to have made a decision which amounts to the commission of an offence under section 84. The court held that the principle set out in section 245 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 applies even if later development, including reconfiguring a lot, is approved for the land or the land as reconfigured. The court held that the condition 6 is one which attaches to the land to which the approval containing it relates, and binds the owner, the owner's successors in title and any occupier of the land.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi