Goff v Permenant Trustee Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[2010] QDC 438

DISTRICT COURT

CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE ROBIN QC

No 4144 of 2004

ANGELA GEORGINA GOFF Plaintiff

and

PERMANENT TRUSTEE AUSTRALIA LIMITED Defendant

BRISBANE

..DATE 29/10/2010

ORDER

Catchwords

Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002, s 9(2)(b), s 16(2), s 18(1)(c)(ii), s 43, s 59(2)(b) Transport Operations (Marine Safety) Act 1994, s 9(2)(1), s 43 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, r 69(1)(b), r 171, r 293, r 376, r 377, r
389(2)

Plaintiff (a tourist from overseas) injured in collision between a catamaran on which she was a passenger and a ferry - official inquiry held ferry primarily responsible - Part 1 notice of claim sent to ferry operator - claim (stayed) commenced by leave of court against owner of ferry with its consent - defendant never given Part 1 notice, but requested Part 2 notice - plaintiff authorised to proceed further against it, despite non-compliance - plaintiff given leave to proceed against ferry operator, added as a defendant - it and owner now have common representation - prejudice to respondents asserted from apparent changes in plaintiff's medical and economic circumstances as delay unfolded and the respondents' being out of time to proceed against the catarmaran

HIS HONOUR:  The court is asked by the plaintiff for orders
under the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA) to regularise a situation which at present is untidy. The first relief is sought under section 18(1)(c)(ii) in terms that the plaintiff be authorised to proceed further with the claim against the defendant despite her failure to give a complying notice of claim. The secondary relief sought is pursuant to section 59(2)(b) seeking that she be granted leave to commence a proceeding against Mulpha Hotel Pty Ltd trading as Hayman
Island Resort.

Further relief is sought which seems to me essentially to
follow the relief already identified.  Thus it's sought
pursuant to rule 69(1)(b)(i) and (ii) of the UCPR that Mulpha be joined as a party in this proceeding which was commenced as
long ago as 2004 on the eve of expiration of the limitation
period pursuant to arrangements under section 43 of PIPA.  It's understandable that the view is taken that it's better to have Mulpha in this proceeding than as a defendant in its own separate claim.

Next, leave is sought pursuant to rules 376 and 377 to amend
the claimant's statement of claim to include Mulpha.  Other
arrangements are envisaged in the application which would
coordinate what happens in the proceeding with out-of-court
steps which would ordinarily be pursued under the PIPA.

Mr O'Sullivan for the plaintiff has indicated that, although
not sought in the application, authorisation of the court to
proceed under rule 389(2) is required given the dimensions of
delay, no step having been taken in the last two years.

The plaintiff was in Australia as a tourist and injured in a
collision in the Whitsundays between a catamaran called the
“Pride of Airlie" on which she was taking a cruise and the “Sun Paradise”, which was a ferry whose chief use…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goff v Permenant Trustee Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QDC 438
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Goff v Permenant Trustee Australia Ltd involved the plaintiff, a tourist from overseas, who was injured in a collision between a catamaran and a ferry. An official inquiry held the ferry primarily responsible for the incident. The plaintiff initially sent a Part 1 notice of claim to the ferry operator, and subsequently commenced a claim against the owner of the ferry with its consent. However, the defendant, who was the registered owner of the ferry, was never given a Part 1 notice, but requested a Part 2 notice. The plaintiff was granted leave to proceed against the ferry operator, who was added as a defendant. The ferry operator and the owner now have common representation. The respondents argued that there was prejudice from apparent changes in the plaintiff's medical and economic circumstances due to the delay in the proceedings and that they were out of time to proceed against the catamaran.

The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff should be authorised to proceed further with the claim against the defendant despite her failure to give a complying notice of claim, and whether the plaintiff should be granted leave to commence a proceeding against the ferry operator. The court also considered whether the plaintiff should be granted leave to amend the statement of claim to include the ferry operator as a defendant, and whether the plaintiff should be authorised to proceed under rule 389(2) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules.

The court found that the plaintiff should be authorised to proceed further with the claim against the defendant despite her failure to give a complying notice of claim. The court also found that the plaintiff should be granted leave to commence a proceeding against the ferry operator. The court considered that the plaintiff's medical and economic circumstances had changed due to the delay in the proceedings, but found that the prejudice to the respondents was not sufficient to outweigh the benefits of regularising the situation. The court also found that the respondents' being out of time to proceed against the catamaran did not affect the plaintiff's ability to recover damages from the defendant or the ferry operator. The court granted the relief sought by the plaintiff and made an appropriate draft order. The court reserved costs and adjourned the matter for further directions.

Background

Background to the litigation

Angela Georgina Goff, a tourist from the United Kingdom, was involved in a maritime collision in the Whitsundays, Australia, between the catamaran "Pride of Airlie" and the ferry "Sun Paradise". Goff was a passenger on the "Pride of Airlie" at the time of the collision. The Maritime Safety Queensland Board of Inquiry held that the "Sun Paradise" was primarily responsible for the collision, though it noted that the master of the "Pride of Airlie" should have considered taking additional steps to avoid the collision. Angela Goff was injured in the incident and commenced legal proceedings against the registered owner of the "Sun Paradise", Permanent Trustee Australia Limited, seeking damages for her injuries.

The proceedings were initiated on the eve of the expiration of the limitation period under the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA). Goff did not provide a compliant Part 1 notice of claim to the owner of the "Sun Paradise", instead, it was sent to the ferry operator, Mulpha Hotel Pty Ltd trading as Hayman Island Resort. The owner consented to the commencement of proceedings under section 43 of the PIPA despite the procedural missteps. Following the change in legal representation, the plaintiff sought authorisation to proceed with the claim against the owner despite the procedural error and to add the operator, Mulpha, as a defendant. The defendants claimed prejudice due to the delay in proceedings, arguing that it affected the plaintiff's medical and economic circumstances and precluded them from taking action against the operator of the "Pride of Airlie".

The plaintiff's solicitors indicated that the delay had escalated the damages claimed by the plaintiff, which were initially estimated in Pounds Sterling, and that the delay had likely extinguished any possibility of bringing the "Pride of Airlie" operator into the proceedings as a defendant or as a third party. The defendants argued that the delay had prejudiced them, making it impossible to pursue contribution from the "Pride of Airlie" operator under the PIPA and the general law. The case was set for a later hearing to determine whether the application for relief from the stay and the potential strike-out or summary judgment motion would proceed.

The matter before the Court is an application by the plaintiff, Angela Georgina Goff, seeking various orders under the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (Qld) and the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) to regularise the procedural history of the case. Goff, an overseas tourist, was injured in a collision between a catamaran and a ferry in the Whitsundays. The defendant in the case is the registered owner of the ferry, Permanent Trustee Australia Limited, while the operator of the ferry is Mulpha Hotel Pty Ltd trading as Hayman Island Resort. The plaintiff initially commenced proceedings against the defendant but sought to add Mulpha as a defendant and amend her statement of claim accordingly. The primary issue before the Court was whether the plaintiff should be granted leave to proceed with the amended claim despite the procedural delays and the potential prejudice to the defendants arising from the changes in the plaintiff's medical and economic circumstances.

The case originated from the plaintiff's injury in a collision between a catamaran on which she was a passenger and a ferry in November 2003. A Maritime Safety Queensland Board of Inquiry held the ferry primarily responsible for the incident. The plaintiff sent a Part 1 notice of claim to the ferry operator, which was Mulpha, but commenced the claim against the defendant, the registered owner of the ferry, with its consent. The plaintiff did not give the defendant a complying notice of claim, but the defendant requested a Part 2 notice. The plaintiff was granted leave to proceed against the ferry operator, added as a defendant, and both defendants now have common representation. The plaintiff seeks orders to regularise the situation, including authorisation to proceed with the claim against the defendant despite the non-compliance, leave to commence a proceeding against Mulpha, and permission to amend the statement of claim to include Mulpha.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Should the plaintiff be authorised to proceed with her claim against the defendant despite failing to provide a complying notice of claim under section 18(1)(c)(ii) of the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA)?
2. Should the plaintiff be granted leave to commence a proceeding against Mulpha Hotel Pty Ltd trading as Hayman Island Resort under section 59(2)(b) of the PIPA?
3. Should Mulpha be joined as a party in the proceeding under rule 69(1)(b) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR)?
4. Should the plaintiff's statement of claim be amended to include Mulpha under rules 376 and 377 of the UCPR?
5. Should the court authorise the plaintiff to proceed with her claim under rule 389(2) of the UCPR, given the significant delay in the proceedings?
6. Has the delay in proceedings caused prejudice to the respondents, and if so, to what extent?
7. Should the plaintiff's claim against the operator of the Pride of Airlie be dismissed due to the limitation period under the PIPA and common law?

Held
1. The plaintiff should be authorised to proceed with her claim against the defendant despite failing to provide a complying notice of claim under section 18(1)(c)(ii) of the PIPA. Result: Authorisation granted.
2. The plaintiff should be granted leave to commence a proceeding against Mulpha Hotel Pty Ltd trading as Hayman Island Resort under section 59(2)(b) of the PIPA. Result: Leave granted.
3. Mulpha should be joined as a party in the proceeding under rule 69(1)(b) of the UCPR. Result: Mulpha joined as party.
4. The plaintiff's statement of claim should be amended to include Mulpha under rules 376 and 377 of the UCPR. Result: Statement of claim amended.
5. The court should authorise the plaintiff to proceed with her claim under rule 389(2) of the UCPR, given the significant delay in the proceedings. Result: Authorisation granted.
6. The delay in proceedings has caused prejudice to the respondents, primarily due to the plaintiff's medical and economic circumstances changing over time. Result: Prejudice acknowledged.
7. The plaintiff's claim against the operator of the Pride of Airlie should be dismissed due to the limitation period under the PIPA and common law. Result: Claim dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Goff v Permanent Trustee Australia Ltd, the District Court of Queensland considered several critical issues concerning the plaintiff's ability to proceed with her claim against various defendants and the potential implications of delays in the proceedings. The first issue was whether the plaintiff should be authorised to proceed with her claim despite failing to provide a complying notice of claim under section 18(1)(c)(ii) of the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (PIPA). The court held that despite the procedural non-compliance, the plaintiff should be authorised to proceed further with her claim. This decision was influenced by the cooperative attitude between the plaintiff and the defendants, which allowed the matter to progress in a manner deemed appropriate for the purposes of the PIPA.

The second issue was whether the plaintiff should be granted leave to commence a proceeding against Mulpha Hotel Pty Ltd trading as Hayman Island Resort under section 59(2)(b) of the PIPA. The court granted this relief, recognising the need to streamline the litigation process by having all relevant parties in the same proceeding. The court relied on the principle that it is generally better to have all defendants in a single proceeding, thus avoiding the potential for conflicting outcomes.

The third issue was whether Mulpha should be joined as a party in the proceeding under rule 69(1)(b) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR). The court found that joining Mulpha as a party was appropriate given that it was the operator of the ferry involved in the collision and was more directly responsible for the incident. This decision was based on the recognition that Mulpha, as the operator, was the most appropriate party to the plaintiff's claim.

The fourth issue was whether the plaintiff's statement of claim should be amended to include Mulpha under rules 376 and 377 of the UCPR. The court allowed this amendment, facilitating the inclusion of Mulpha as a defendant in the proceeding and ensuring that all relevant parties were before the court.

The fifth issue was whether the court should authorise the plaintiff to proceed with her claim under rule 389(2) of the UCPR, considering the significant delay in the proceedings. The court authorised the plaintiff to proceed, emphasising the need for the matter to be resolved despite the delays. The court's decision was influenced by the principle that the expeditious resolution of personal injury claims is in the public interest.

The sixth issue was whether the delay in proceedings caused prejudice to the respondents and, if so, to what extent. The court acknowledged the prejudice caused by the delay, particularly in terms of the plaintiff's changing medical and economic circumstances. However, the court found that the benefits of resolving the matter outweighed the prejudice caused.

The final issue was whether the plaintiff's claim against the operator of the Pride of Airlie should be dismissed due to the limitation period under the PIPA and common law. The court held that it was now impossible for the Pride of Airlie to be brought into the proceedings, either as a defendant or in third-party proceedings, due to the passage of time. This decision was based on the principle that contribution notices under the PIPA and common law must be given within a specified timeframe.

In summary, the court's reasoning in this case was guided by a balance between procedural fairness and the expeditious resolution of personal injury claims. The court authorised the plaintiff to proceed with her claim despite procedural non-compliance, granted leave to add Mulpha as a party, allowed amendments to the statement of claim, and recognised the prejudice caused by delays while emphasising the need to resolve the matter. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court will exercise its discretion to allow a plaintiff to proceed with a claim despite procedural non-compliance if the public interest in resolving the matter outweighs the prejudice to the defendants.