GJT v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

GJT v Director of Public Prosecutions & Anor [2022] QSC 253

PARTIES:

GJT

(applicant)

v
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
(first respondent)
COMMISSIONER OF QUEENSLAND POLICE

(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Originating application filed by leave on 3 November 2022

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

18 November 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

3 November 2022

JUDGE:

Davis J

ORDER:

1.   The application is dismissed.

2.   The application, all material filed in the application, all written outlines of argument and the transcript of the proceedings be sealed in an envelope marked, “Not to be opened except by order of the Court” and placed on the file.

3.   The envelope is not to be opened except by order of the Court.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - DISCLOSURE OBLIGATIONS - where the applicant made statements of evidence in a criminal proceeding - where the applicant sought to rely on s 13A of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 - where the prosecutor has elected to call the applicant as a witness - where the prosecutor intends to make disclosure of the statements - whether the statements were disclosed so as to give rise to a duty of confidentiality - whether the prosecutor is obliged not to disclose the statements

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - where the applicant made statements of evidence in a criminal proceeding - where the applicant sought to rely on s 13A of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 - where the prosecutor has elected to call the applicant as a witness - where the applicant asserted that the statements should not be disclosed - whether ss 590AB and 590AH of the Criminal Code require disclosure - whether s 13A of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 obviates any disclosure obligation

Acts Interpretation Act 1954
Criminal Code
, s 590AB, s 590AH
Criminal Law Amendment Act
1894, s 10
Criminal Law Amendment Act 1997
Criminal Law Amendment Act 2014
Criminal Law Amendment Bill 2014
Penalties and Sentences Act
1992, s 13A, s 13B, s 188

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (NT) (2009) 239 CLR 27, followed
CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd
(1997) 187 CLR 384, followed
Fractionated Cane Technology Ltd v O’Sullivan & Ors (unreported) Ambrose J, Supreme Court of Queensland, 17 September 1986, cited
Grey v The Queen (2001) 75 ALJR 1708, cited
J v L & A Services Pty Ltd (No 2) [1995] 2 Qd R 10, cited
K&S Lake City Freighters Pty Ltd v Gordon & Gotch Ltd (1985) 157 CLR 309, followed
Mallard v The Queen (2005) 224 CLR 125, followed
McDermott v The King (1948) 76 CLR 501, cited
Nguyen v The Queen (2020) 269 CLR 299, cited
Pollitt v The Queen (1992) 174 CLR 558, cited
Potter v Minahan (1908) 7 CLR 277, followed
R v A2; R v Magennis; R…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GJT v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 253
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant in GJT v Director of Public Prosecutions sought an order restraining the respondents from disclosing statements made by the applicant to police. The statements were made under s 13A of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, which provides for a reduction of sentence for an offender who cooperates with law enforcement agencies. The applicant was called as a witness in the prosecution of another person for murder, and the Crown intended to use the applicant's statements. The applicant argued that the statements should be protected from disclosure on the basis of confidentiality.

The court considered whether the statements were subject to a duty of confidentiality and whether the prosecutor was obliged not to disclose them. The court noted that ss 590AB and 590AH of the Criminal Code require disclosure of evidence when a defendant is called as a witness. However, the applicant relied on s 13A of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, which provides for the sealing of statements made under the section. The court concluded that there was no statutory exception to the disclosure obligations, and the relief sought by the applicant could not be given.

The court dismissed the application and ordered that the application, all material filed in the application, all written outlines of argument, and the transcript of the proceedings be sealed in an envelope marked, "Not to be opened except by order of the Court" and placed on the file. The envelope is not to be opened except by order of the Court. The court's decision highlights the tension between the duty of confidentiality under s 13A of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 and the statutory obligations to disclose evidence under the Criminal Code. The court ultimately found that the disclosure obligations took precedence over the duty of confidentiality in this case.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The application, all material filed in the application, all written outlines of argument and the transcript of the proceedings be sealed in an envelope marked, “Not to be opened except by order of the Court” and placed on the file.

3. The envelope is not to be opened except by order of the Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant seeks declaratory relief and orders restraining the respondents from dealing with written statements made by him.Background A prisoner, who I will call Smith, is on remand on a charge of murdering a person, who I will call Jones. The applicant was also held on remand for criminal charges. Both the applicant and Smith were held in the same correctional facility. The applicant has made two written statements to police. In those statements, he speaks of conversations he had in prison with Smith. According to the applicant, during those conversations, Smith made statements explaining his role in the murder of Jones. Jailhouse confessions, being oral statements by an accused who is in custody to another prisoner, are notoriously unreliable and a trial judge must be alert to the necessity to properly warn and direct a jury as to the dangers in acting upon such evidence.[1][1]Pollitt v The Queen (1992) 174 CLR 558. The Crown prosecutor handling the case for the Crown must decide what evidence is led and what is not. That decision is not reviewable.[2] The prosecution of Smith and others has not yet reached committal. However, the Crown prosecutor has decided that the applicant will be called as a witness in the case. Having regards to the contents of the applicant’s two statements, that decision is hardly surprising. The applicant supplies significant detail of the conversations and also identifies other prisoners who heard, or may have heard, the conversations or part of them. [2]R v Apostilides (1984) 154 CLR 563, Whitehorn v The Queen (1983) 152 CLR 657, Richardson v The Queen (1974) 131 CLR 116 at 119, followed in Nguyen v The Queen (2020) 269 CLR 299 at [33]-[35]. Nothing in the statements inculpate the applicant. They are not confessionary in nature. There is no suggestion that the applicant is involved in any way with the murder of Jones. It is not sought to lead the statements against the applicant.[3][3]Criminal Law Amendment Act 1894 and the principles in McDermott v The King (1948) 76 CLR 501 therefore have no application. There is no suggestion:1.that the statements were not voluntarily made by the applicant; or2.that they were otherwise made in circumstances which adversely affects their reliability.[4][4]R v Falzon [1990] 2 Qd R 436, Rozenes & Anor v Beljajev & Ors [1995] 1 VR 533 and R v Healy [2016] QCA 334. Each of the applicant’s two statements begin with seven paragraphs in these terms:“1.I give this statement pursuant to an undertaking given under s.13A of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992.2.This statement is a proof of the evidence which I would be prepared to give in court in relation to this matter.3.I understand that this statement will be presented to the Judge who sentences me in relation to the charges that I am facing. I have given an undertaking that I will give evidence consistently with the content of this statement.4.I have agreed to give this evidence on the understanding that I will receive a lesser sentence for the offence for which I am being sentenced than I would without the benefit of that undertaking.5.I am aware that, should the evidence that I give differ materially from that contained in my statement or if I do not give evidence at all, I am liable to have the sentence I receive in consideration of my undertaking to give this evidence, re-opened.6.Should that be the case, then I am liable to have imposed upon me, a sentence which does not afford me the benefit of the cooperation I have undertaken to give law enforcement authorities.7.I understand that this statement has three purposes. 1. To provide a summary of the evidence that I am prepared to give in relation to these proceedings against others who were involved. 2. To give the Judge who sentences me the ability to assess the extent and degree of the cooperation I have given to law enforcement agencies. 3. To provide a basis for assessing whether my evidence conforms to my undertaking to cooperate.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further still, ss 590AB and 590AH(2)(e) place a legal obligation upon the prosecution to disclose the statements. The relief sought by the applicant, if given, would place the prosecution in breach of those statutory obligations. The relief therefore cannot be given in the absence of some statutory exception to the obligations of disclosure of which there are none.Conclusions The application should be dismissed. It is though in the public interest for the materials which were before me to remain confidential. I will make the appropriate orders. It is ordered that:1.The application is dismissed.2.The application, all material filed in the application, all written outlines of argument and the transcript of the proceedings be sealed in an envelope marked, “Not to be opened except by order of the Court” and placed on the file.3.The envelope is not to be opened except by order of the Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Sections 13A, 13B and 188 of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 provide as follows:“13A Cooperation with law enforcement authorities to be taken into account—undertaking to cooperate(1)This section applies for a sentence that is to be reduced by the sentencing court because the offender has undertaken to cooperate with law enforcement agencies in a proceeding about an offence, including a confiscation proceeding.(2)Before the sentencing proceeding starts, a party to the proceeding—(a) must advise the relevant officer—(i)that the offender has undertaken to cooperate with law enforcement agencies; and(ii)that written or oral submissions or evidence will be made or brought before the court relevant on that account to the reduction of sentence; and(b) may give to the relevant officer copies of any proposed written submissions mentioned in paragraph (a)(ii).(3)After the offender is invited to address the court—(a) the offender’s written undertaking to cooperate with law enforcement agencies must be handed up to the court; and(b) any party may hand up to the court written submissions relevant to the reduction of sentence.(4)The undertaking must be in an unsealed envelope addressed to the sentencing judge or magistrate.(5)If oral submissions are to be made to, or evidence is to be brought before, the court relevant to the reduction of sentence, the court must be closed for that purpose.(6)The penalty imposed on the offender must be stated in open court.(7)After the imposition of the penalty, the sentencing judge or magistrate must—(a) close the court; and(b) state in closed court—(i)that the sentence is being reduced under this section; and(ii)the sentence it would otherwise have imposed; and(c) cause the following to be sealed and placed on the court file with an order that it may be opened only by an order of the court, including on an application to reopen the sentencing proceedings under section 188(2)—(i)the written undertaking;(ii)a record of evidence or submissions made relevant to the reduction of sentence and the sentencing remarks made under paragraph (b). (8)The sentencing judge or magistrate may make an order prohibiting publication of all or part of the proceeding or the name and address of any witness on his or her own initiative or on application.(9)In deciding whether to make an order under subsection (8), the judge or magistrate may have regard to—(a) the safety of any person; and(b) the extent to which the detection of offences of a similar nature may be affected; and(c) the need to guarantee the confidentiality of information given by an informer.(10)A person who contravenes an order made under subsection (8) commits an offence.Maximum penalty—(a) for an order made by a judge—5 years imprisonment; or(b) for an order made by a magistrate—3 years imprisonment.(11)In this section—relevant officer means—(a) for a proceeding before the Supreme or District Court—the sentencing judge’s associate; or(b) for a proceeding before a Magistrates Court—the relevant clerk of the court.13BCooperation with law enforcement authorities to be taken into account—cooperation given(1)This section applies for a sentence if—(a) the sentence is to be reduced by the sentencing court because the offender has significantly cooperated with a law enforcement agency in its investigations about an offence or a confiscation proceeding; and(b) section 13A does not apply for the sentence. (2)For subsection (1), an offender has not significantly cooperated with a law enforcement agency in its investigations about an offence only because the offender has admitted guilt for the offence.(3)Before the sentencing proceeding starts, a party to the proceeding—(a) must advise the relevant officer—(i)that the offender has significantly cooperated with a law enforcement agency; and(ii)that written or oral submissions or evidence will be made or brought before the court relevant on that account to the reduction of sentence; and(b) may give the relevant officer copies of any proposed written submissions mentioned in paragraph (a)(ii).(4)After the offender is invited to address the court—(a) an affidavit, provided by a person representing the law enforcement agency, must be handed up to the court; and(b) any party may hand up to the court written submissions relevant to the reduction of sentence.(5)The affidavit must—(a) state the nature, extent and usefulness of the cooperation given to the law enforcement agency by the offender; and(b) be in an unsealed envelope addressed to the sentencing judge or magistrate.(6)If oral submissions are to be made to, or evidence is to be brought before, the court about the cooperation or the reduction of sentence, the court must be closed for that purpose.(7)The penalty imposed on the offender must be stated in open court. (8)After the imposition of the penalty, the sentencing judge or magistrate must cause the following to be sealed and placed on the court file with an order that it may be opened only by an order of the court—(a) the affidavit;(b) a record of evidence or submissions made relevant to the reduction of sentence;(c) a record of the sentencing remarks relevant to the reduction of sentence, as opposed to the sentence imposed.(9)The sentencing judge or magistrate may make an order prohibiting publication of all or part of the proceeding or the name and address of any witness on his or her own initiative or on application.(10)In deciding whether to make an order under subsection (9), the judge or magistrate may have regard to—(a) the safety of any person; and(b) the extent to which the detection of offences of a similar nature may be affected; and(c) the need to guarantee the confidentiality of information given by an informer.(11)A person who contravenes an order made under subsection (9) commits an offence.Maximum penalty—(a) for an order made by a judge—5 years imprisonment; or(b) for an order made by a magistrate—3 years imprisonment.(12)In this section—relevant officer means—(a) for a proceeding before the Supreme or District Court—the sentencing judge’s associate; or(b) for a proceeding before a Magistrates Court—the relevant clerk of the court. …188Court may reopen sentencing proceedings(1) If a court has in, or in connection with, a criminal proceeding, including a proceeding on appeal—(a)imposed a sentence that is not in accordance with the law; or(b)failed to impose a sentence that the court legally should have imposed; or (c)imposed a sentence decided on a clear factual error of substance; or(d)failed to fix a date for the offender to be released on parole as required under part 9, division 3;the court, whether or not differently constituted, may reopen the proceeding.(2) Also, if—(a)a court has in, or in connection with, a criminal proceeding reduced a sentence because the offender has undertaken in a written declaration to cooperate with law enforcement agencies in a proceeding about an offence, including a confiscation proceeding; and(b)the offender, without reasonable excuse, does not cooperate under the undertaking; the court, whether or not differently constituted, may reopen the proceeding.(3) If a court reopens a proceeding, it—(a)must give the parties an opportunity to be heard; and(b)may resentence the offender—(i)for a reopening under subsection (1)(a)—to a sentence in accordance with law; or(ii)for a reopening under subsection (1)(b)—to a sentence the court legally should have imposed; or(iii)for a reopening under subsection (1)(c)—to a sentence that takes into account the factual error; or(iv)for a reopening under subsection (2)—to a sentence under subsection (4); and(c)may amend any relevant conviction or order to the extent necessary to take into account the sentence imposed under paragraph (b).(4) On an application under subsection (2)— (a)if the court is satisfied that the offender has completely failed to cooperate, the court must resentence the offender having regard to the sentence that would otherwise have been imposed if an undertaking under section 13A had not been given; or(b)if the court is satisfied that the offender has partly failed to cooperate, the court may substitute for the reduced sentence the sentence it considers appropriate, not greater than the sentence that would have been imposed if the undertaking had not been given.(5) The court may reopen the proceeding—(a)on its own initiative at any time; or(b)for a reopening under subsection (1)—on the application of a party to the proceeding made within—(i)28 days after the day the sentence was imposed; or(ii)any further time the court may allow on application at any time; or(c)for a reopening under subsection (1)(d)—on the application of the chief executive (corrective services); or(d)for a reopening under subsection (2)—on the application of the prosecution made at any time, whether or not the appeal period under the Criminal Code, section 671(2) has expired.(6) Subject to subsection (7), this section does not affect any right of appeal.(7) For an appeal under any Act against a sentence imposed under subsection (3) or (4), the time within which the appeal must be made starts from the day the sentence is imposed under subsection (3) or (4).(8) This section applies to a sentence imposed, or required to be imposed, whether before or after the commencement of this section.”