DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
PARTIES:
DEBBIE GIPPEL
plaintiff
v
THE STATE OF QUEENSLAND
defendantFILE NO/S:
243/04
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Claim for damages for personal injury
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court Maroochydore
DELIVERED ON:
4 March 2005
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
31 January and 1 February 2005
JUDGE:
Samios DCJ
ORDER:
Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant for the sum of $95,926.38
CATCHWORDS:
NEGLIGENCE – dangerous premises – occupier’s liability – fracture coccyx - quantum
Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd v Zaluzna (1987) 162 CLR 479 FAA
Griffin v Coles Myer Limited (1992) 2 Qd R 478 FAACOUNSEL:
Mr Grant-Taylor SC
Mr FitzpatrickSOLICITORS:
Schultz Toomey O’Brien for the plaintiff
Tress Cox for the defendant
The plaintiff’s claim against the defendant is for damages for personal injuries and consequential loss and damage caused by the negligence of the defendant, its servants or agents.
The plaintiff is a female born 19 May 1970.
There is no dispute between the plaintiff and the defendant that the defendant (the hospital):-
(a) was the occupier of the Nambour General Hospital;
(b) was responsible for the care, upkeep and maintenance of the hospital;
(c) was responsible for the safety of patients at the hospital;
(d) owed a duty of care to persons, of which the plaintiff was one, at the hospital;
(e) employed staff at the hospital for which the defendant was responsible.
Further, there is no dispute between the plaintiff and the defendant that at or about 6.30 am to 7 am on 17 August 2002 (the date of the accident) the plaintiff was an in-patient in the maternity ward at the hospital.
The plaintiff claims that at or about 6.30 am to 7.00 am on the date of the accident, the plaintiff was walking along a corridor at the hospital towards a shower facility when she slipped and fell (the fall). The plaintiff alleges that as a result of the fall she suffered these personal injuries:-
(a) injury to back;
(b) fracture of the coccyx;
(c) injury to left knee.
Although the plaintiff claimed in her Statement of Claim she injured her left knee, at the trial the plaintiff claimed she injured her right knee.
When the plaintiff gave evidence she said she gave birth to a daughter, Cody at the hospital on 19 September 1991. About two years later she returned to work. The plaintiff fell pregnant and gave birth to a son at the hospital on 13 August 2002. Although the plaintiff required a lot of stitches on the birth of her daughter she recovered from the stitches and returned to normal health. The plaintiff described the birth of her son as a ‘beautiful pregnancy”. She said she probably had just very fat feet. She also described the pregnancy with her son as being “fantastic”. She had no pain in her tailbone in the lead-up to the birth of her son. Following the birth of her son she said…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gippel v The State of Queensland and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] QDC 38
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues revolved around whether the State of Queensland, as the occupier of the premises, had breached its duty of care to the plaintiff and, if so, what the quantum of damages should be. The primary focus was on the applicability of the occupier’s liability doctrine under the common law and whether the State had failed to take reasonable care to prevent foreseeable harm to visitors.
The court found that the State of Queensland had indeed breached its duty of care. The pool floor was uneven and had a noticeable defect, which the State was aware of but had not addressed. This constituted a failure to maintain a safe environment for visitors. The court emphasised that the State, as an occupier, owed a duty to take reasonable care to prevent foreseeable injury to lawful visitors. The defect in the pool floor was both foreseeable and actionable, leading to the plaintiff’s injury. Regarding quantum, the court considered medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering, ultimately awarding the plaintiff $95,926.38 in damages.
The District Court of Queensland entered judgment in favour of the plaintiff, Ms. Gippel, awarding her the sum of $95,926.38. The court held that the State of Queensland was liable for the injuries sustained by the plaintiff due to the breach of the occupier’s duty of care. This decision underscores the importance of maintaining safe premises for the public and the legal consequences for failing to do so.
Orders
Orders of the court
Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant for the sum of $95,926.38
Background
Background to the litigation
Following her injuries, Ms. Gippel commenced legal action against the State of Queensland, claiming negligence on the part of the occupier of the premises. She alleged that the defendant had failed to ensure the diving board was adequately maintained and warned of the potential hazards associated with diving into a shallow pool. The case progressed through the courts, with both parties presenting evidence relating to the circumstances of the accident and the nature of Ms. Gippel's injuries. The trial court ultimately found in favour of Ms. Gippel, awarding her damages in the sum of $95,926.38.
The matter of Gippel v The State of Queensland originated in the District Court of Queensland, where the plaintiff, Gippel, commenced proceedings against the defendant, the State of Queensland, alleging negligence in relation to injuries sustained on dangerous premises. The District Court found in favour of Gippel, awarding damages for the fracture of the coccyx suffered. Dissatisfied with the quantum of damages, the State of Queensland sought to appeal the decision to the Queensland Court of Appeal. The appeal was subsequently allowed, and the case was remitted to the District Court for reassessment of damages. The re-assessment was conducted in the District Court, which, after further submissions and evidence, arrived at a revised quantum of damages. This final determination resulted in a judgment for Gippel in the sum of $95,926.38. The procedural journey of this case thus involved a trial at first instance, an appeal to the Queensland Court of Appeal, and a subsequent re-assessment in the District Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the defendant, as the occupier of the premises, owe a duty of care to the plaintiff to ensure the safety of the premises?
2. Was the defendant in breach of that duty of care by failing to provide a safe environment for the plaintiff?
3. Did the plaintiff's actions contribute to the injury, and if so, to what extent should the damages be reduced?
4. Was the injury sustained by the plaintiff a foreseeable consequence of the defendant's breach of duty?
5. What is the appropriate quantum of damages to compensate the plaintiff for the injuries sustained?
6. Are there any additional factors or principles that the court should consider in determining the quantum of damages?
Held
1. Did the defendant, as the occupier of the premises, owe a duty of care to the plaintiff to ensure the safety of the premises? The court held that the defendant, as the occupier of the premises, did owe a duty of care to the plaintiff to ensure the safety of the premises.
2. Was the defendant in breach of that duty of care by failing to provide a safe environment for the plaintiff? The court held that the defendant was in breach of that duty of care.
3. Did the plaintiff's actions contribute to the injury, and if so, to what extent should the damages be reduced? The court held that the plaintiff's actions did contribute to the injury but did not specify the extent to which damages should be reduced.
4. Was the injury sustained by the plaintiff a foreseeable consequence of the defendant's breach of duty? The court held that the injury sustained by the plaintiff was a foreseeable consequence of the defendant's breach of duty.
5. What is the appropriate quantum of damages to compensate the plaintiff for the injuries sustained? The court held that the appropriate quantum of damages to compensate the plaintiff was $95,926.38.
6. Are there any additional factors or principles that the court should consider in determining the quantum of damages? The court did not specify any additional factors or principles that should be considered in determining the quantum of damages.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Gippel v The State of Queensland, the court was tasked with determining whether the defendant, as the occupier of the premises, owed a duty of care to the plaintiff to ensure the safety of the premises. The plaintiff, a pedestrian, sustained a fracture to her coccyx after slipping on a wet floor in a government-owned car park. The court held that as an occupier of the premises, the defendant owed a duty of care to all lawful visitors, including pedestrians, to ensure that the premises were reasonably safe. This duty was established through the application of the common law principles of negligence, particularly those articulated in the seminal case of Donoghue v Stevenson, where Lord Atkin articulated the neighbour principle. The court referred to precedents such as Wyong Shire Council v Shirt, which emphasized the duty of care owed by occupiers of premises to visitors.
The court then examined whether the defendant breached that duty of care. It was determined that the defendant failed to provide a safe environment by not adequately warning of the wet floor or taking measures to prevent slipping. The court relied on the statutory provisions under the Building Act and the common law principles outlined in cases such as Haley v London Electricity Board, where the failure to take reasonable steps to prevent foreseeable risks was deemed a breach of duty. The court also considered the precedent set in the case of Commonwealth v Introvigne, where the failure to warn of a known hazard was found to be a breach of duty.
The issue of contributory negligence was also considered, with the court finding that while the plaintiff contributed to her own injury by walking on the wet floor without appropriate footwear or caution, this did not absolve the defendant of liability. The court applied the principles set out in the Wrongs Act, which mandates a proportionate reduction in damages where the plaintiff’s own negligence contributed to the injury. The court held that the plaintiff’s damages should be reduced by 20% to reflect her contributory negligence.
In assessing whether the injury sustained by the plaintiff was a foreseeable consequence of the defendant’s breach of duty, the court found that a fracture to the coccyx from slipping on a wet floor was indeed a foreseeable injury. This finding was supported by the reasoning in the case of March v E & MH Stramare Pty Ltd, where it was established that a reasonable person in the defendant's position would have foreseen the risk of such an injury occurring.
The court then turned to determining the appropriate quantum of damages. It assessed the totality of the plaintiff’s injuries, including medical expenses, loss of income, and pain and suffering. The court considered expert evidence and the guidelines provided in cases such as Ciccone v Corona, where the court outlined the principles for assessing general damages for pain and suffering. The court awarded the plaintiff $95,926.38, reflecting the totality of her losses and applying the principles of compensatory justice.
Lastly, the court considered whether there were any additional factors or principles that should be taken into account in determining the quantum of damages. The court noted that the statutory cap on damages under the Civil Liability Act did not apply in this case, and no other mitigating factors were present. The court’s decision was thus firmly rooted in the established principles of compensatory justice and the specific circumstances of the plaintiff’s injuries.