MIGRATION – Mandatory visa cancellation – citizen of Armenia – Class BC Subclass 100 Partner Visa – failure to pass character test – Ministerial Direction No. 79 applied – decision under review affirmed
Direction No. 79 – Migration Act 1958 – Direction under section 499: Visa refusal and cancellation under s501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s501CA
REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member A. Nikolic AM CSC
27 June 2019
INTRODUCTION
The applicant, Mr Vardges Ghazaryan, seeks review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs, made under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”), not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of his Class BC Subclass 100 Partner Visa.
The hearing was held in Sydney from 13 to 14 June 2019. The applicant was represented by Mr John Fry OAM. The Minister was represented by Mr Jonathon Hutton from the Australian Government Solicitor.
Pursuant to s 500(6L) of the Act, the Tribunal must discharge its review function in respect of this application by 1 July 2019.
During the hearing the respondent expressed an intention to ask Mr Ghazaryan questions about alleged misconduct in prison and immigration detention. The Tribunal advised Mr Ghazaryan of his right to silence and against self-incrimination, and that the Tribunal would draw no negative inference should he exercise his rights.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The factual background to this application follows:
(a)Mr Ghazarayan was born in 1984 and is a citizen of Armenia.
(b)Mr Ghazaryan first arrived in Australia on 24 March 2002 with his parents.[1] He was 17 years old on arrival and is currently 35 years…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ghazaryan and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:
This case concerned an application by Mr. Ghazaryan, a citizen of Armenia, for review of the Minister's decision not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of his visa. Mr. Ghazaryan's visa was cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) following his conviction for possessing a firearm without a licence in August 2016, for which he received a sentence of three years and six months imprisonment. He applied for the cancellation to be revoked, but a delegate of the Minister refused to do so. Mr. Ghazaryan then sought review of this decision by the Tribunal.
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether there was "another reason" why the mandatory cancellation of Mr. Ghazaryan's visa should be revoked, pursuant to s 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Act. This required an evaluative process of considering all factors for and against revocation. The Tribunal also considered the object of the Migration Act, which is to regulate the presence of non-citizens in Australia in the national interest, and the High Court's interpretation of s 501(3A) as a legislative judgment that persons convicted and imprisoned should not remain in Australia.
The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the seriousness and pattern of Mr. Ghazaryan's criminal offending. It noted his convictions spanned a 13-year period, with escalating seriousness, including common assault, armed robbery with a pistol, and aggravated firearm possession. The Tribunal found that his offending occurred despite lenient court treatment and while he was subject to bonds. Furthermore, it noted his continued association with outlaw motorcycle gangs, which were relevant to his earlier offending. While acknowledging the interests of his daughter, niece, and nephew as factors weighing in favour of revocation, the Tribunal was ultimately unpersuaded that these, or his stated remorse and intention to reform, were sufficient to outweigh the significant risk to the Australian community posed by a repeat of his violent offending. The Tribunal also noted his failure to complete any rehabilitative programs during his periods of imprisonment.
The Tribunal concluded that the harm that would be caused by a repeat of Mr. Ghazaryan's violent offending constituted an unacceptable risk to the Australian community. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision not to revoke the visa cancellation.
Background
Background to the litigation
During the hearing the respondent expressed an intention to ask Mr Ghazaryan questions about alleged misconduct in prison and immigration detention. The Tribunal advised Mr Ghazaryan of his right to silence and against self-incrimination, and that the Tribunal would draw no negative inference should he exercise his rights.FACTUAL BACKGROUND The factual background to this application follows:(a)Mr Ghazarayan was born in 1984 and is a citizen of Armenia. (b)Mr Ghazaryan first arrived in Australia on 24 March 2002 with his parents.[1] He was 17 years old on arrival and is currently 35 years of age; (c)On 10 October 2017 Mr Ghazaryan’s visa was mandatorily cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Act,[2] following his convictions on 19 August 2016 of Aggravated offence – possess firearm without licence.[3] He was sentenced to three years and six months imprisonment for this offence and, at the time of visa cancellation, was serving this sentence on a full time basis;(d)Mr Ghazaryan was invited to make representations to have the visa cancellation decision revoked, and did so on 27 October 2017 within the period and in the manner specified under the Act.[4] After considering his representations, a delegate of the Minister decided on 29 March 2019 not to revoke the cancellation of his visa;[5](e)By application dated 10 April 2019, Mr Ghazaryan applied to this Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision.[6] In Section 3 of the application headed ‘Why do you claim the decision is wrong,’ it states:[7]The harsh and protracted decision is wrong as the information we provided was not fully and properly taken into account. Family circumstances were obviously not adequaetly (sic) considered and the applicant’s physical, mental and emotional health continues to steadily deteriorate.[1] Exhibit R1, 56.[2] Ibid, 121-127.[3] Ibid, 30.[4] Ibid, 57-71.[5] Ibid, 5-21.[6] Ibid, 1-3.[7] Ibid, 2.STATUTORY FRAMEWORK Section 500(1)(ba) of the Act provides for applications to be made to the Tribunal if a delegate of the Minister decides under s 501CA(4) not to revoke the cancellation of a visa. The object of the statute of which s 501(3A) is a part is to regulate, in the national interest, the presence in Australia of non-citizens, and the removal or deportation from Australia of non-citizens whose continuing presence is not permitted by the Act (ss 4(1) and 4(4)). As the High Court stated in Falzon v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 262 CLR 333 at [45]:Section 501(3A) constitutes a legislative judgment that a class of persons identified by two features – offending and imprisonment – are not to remain in Australia. This is consistent with the object of the Migration Act, namely, to regulate the coming into and presence in Australia of non-citizens.(Footnote omitted). Section 501(3A) of the Act, read in conjunction with ss 501(6) and 501(7), obliges the Minister to cancel a person’s visa if the Minister is satisfied the person does not pass the character test and the person is serving a fulltime sentence of imprisonment.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
It follows that the discretion at s 501CA(4)(b)(i) of the Act to revoke the cancellation of Mr Ghazaryan’s visa on the basis that he passes the character test is not applicable. It therefore remains to be determined under s 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Act if there is ‘another reason’ why the mandatory cancellation should be revoked. This involves an evaluative process consistent with the reasoning of North ACJ in Gaspar v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2016) 153 ALD 338 at [38], which the Tribunal respectfully adopts:“The preferable conclusion is that s 501CA(4)(b)(ii) requires the Minister to examine the factors for and against revoking the cancellation. If satisfied, following an assessment and an evaluation of those factors, that the cancellation should be revoked, the Minister is obliged to act on that view. There is a single, not a two stage, process and the Minister does not have a residual discretion to refuse to revoke the cancellation if satisfied that it should be revoked …”EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL Mr Ghazaryan’s representative called the following witnesses at the hearing:(a)The applicant;(b)The applicant’s mother, Ms Seda Yegoryan;(c)The applicant’s sister, Ms Gayane Navasardyan; (d)Mr Sam Zakarian, a family friend; and(e)The applicant’s daughter, [name redacted]. G-documents numbering 165 pages[9] and a bundle of documents numbering 82 pages,[10] were taken into evidence. Other documents taken into evidence were letters from:[9] Exhibit R1.[10] Exhibit R2.(a)the applicant dated 27 April 2019;[11][11] Exhibit A1.(b)Gayane Navasardyan dated 22 April 2019;[12][12] Exhibit A2.(c)Seda Yegoryan dated 20 April 2019;[13][13] Exhibit A3.(d)Sam and Aza Zakarian dated 15 April 2019;[14] (e)John Fry dated 23 April 2019;[15] (f)Shoushan Navasardian dated 18 April 2019;[16] (g)Ziad Abboud dated 15 April 2019;[17](h)Art and Yana Nersisian dated 16 April 2019;[18](i)Goulnara Khederlarian dated 16 April 2019;[19](j)Nancy Khederlarian dated 16 April 2019;[20](k)Hasmik Grigoryan and Emil Besha dated 18 April 2019;[21](l)Vahram Simonyan dated 25 April 2019;[22] and(m)Abgar Avetisyan dated 18 April 2019.[23][14] Exhibit A4.[15] Exhibit A5.[16] Exhibit A6.[17] Exhibit A7.[18] Exhibit A8.[19] Exhibit A9.[20] Exhibit A10.[21] Exhibit A11.[22] Exhibit A12.[23] Exhibit A13.National Police Certificate and Sentencing Remarks Mr Ghazaryan’s National Police Certificate[24] discloses that his initial offences in 2006 (‘Resist officer in execution of duty;’ ‘Use offensive language in/near public place/school;’ and ‘Drive on road while licence suspended’) were dealt with by the courts through fines and bonds. His offending began to escalate in seriousness in his mid-20s, as evidenced by the following convictions:[24] Exhibit R1, 30-32.(a)8 October 2009: ‘Common assault’ of his former partner and the mother of his child, for which he was placed on a two-year bond and ordered ‘not to assault, molest, harass or otherwise interfere with [his former partner]…;’(b)8 June 2011: ‘Common assault;’[25] ‘Behave in offensive manner in / near public place / school;’ and Resist officer in execution of duty. Mr Ghazaryan received fines and was again discharged on a bond;[25] This was a ‘call up’ of the common assault conviction from October 2009, due to Mr Ghazaryan’s 2011 offending occurring within the previously-imposed two-year bond period.(c)18 January 2012: Convictions were recorded on 15 charges relating to dishonesty and driving matters, including making false or misleading statements, for which Mr Ghazaryan received fines and a warrant was issued for his arrest; (d)15 May 2013: ‘Robbery while armed with a dangerous weapon,’ for which Mr Ghazaryan was sentenced in the Parramatta District Court to four years imprisonment, with a non-parole period of two years. The circumstances of this offence were noted by the Supreme Court of South Australia, Court of Criminal Appeal, in R v Ghazaryan [2016] SASCFC 140 at [27]-[28]:[26] [26] Exhibit R1, 39-53.27. On 15 May 2013, in the Parramatta District Court, Mr Ghazaryan was convicted of robbery while armed with a dangerous weapon. This offence was committed on 8 September 2011, only three months or so after he had been released on a bond in June of that year … A copy of the sentencing remarks was before the Judge in this matter. The following matters emerged from those remarks:· Mr Ghazaryan’s co-offenders were … both members of the ‘Notorious outlaw motorcycle gang’. Mr Ghazaryan was an associate member of the gang at the time;· [one co-accused] was selling his Audi car. The victim took $11,000 in cash to a meeting to discuss the purchase. The $11,000 was intended to be a deposit;· the victim attended the meeting place with a companion. When they arrived, Mr Ghazaryan produced a black pistol from his pants, pointed it at the victim and demanded the money;· the victim gave Mr Ghazaryan the $11,000 in an envelope;· the two co-offenders were charged as accessories before the fact to the robbery. They were not present at the time of the robbery;· the robbery was committed at a time when Mr Ghazaryan was still subject to the two bonds from 2009 and 2011.28. … [Mr Ghazaryan] was regarded as the principal offender. Clearly, the robbery was treated as a serious crime. (e)19 August 2016: Aggravated offence – possess firearm without licence, for which Mr Ghazaryan was sentenced in the District Court of South Australia to three years and six months imprisonment, with a non-parole period of two years and three months. His Honour, Judge Paul Muscat, noted the following during sentencing:[27][27] Ibid, 33-38.… The car you were travelling in was travelling in convoy from Sydney to Adelaide with another car which contained associates of yours. They were all members of the Nomad Outlaw Motorcycle Gang.The police searched the car looking for drugs. Hidden behind the air conditioning panel in the centre console was a white bag and a semi-automatic pistol. The serial number on the pistol had been removed. The pistol had a magazine attached to it which contained five rounds of .32 calibre ammunition … Inside the white bag were nine further rounds of .32 calibre ammunition.Upon questioning by the police, you claimed that you did not know anything about the pistol or the ammunition which had been secreted behind the air conditioning panel …Despite your strong denials, your DNA was found on a swab taken from the pistol.On 3 June 2016, you pleaded guilty at your committal hearing. The prosecution accepted your plea on the basis that you owned the pistol, that you had hidden it in the compartment behind the air conditioning panel and that you knew that is where it remained throughout the journey from Sydney to Adelaide.…… the fact remains that you have committed an extremely serious firearm offence ... …… I consider your offence of being in possession of the loaded semi-automatic pistol to be a serious example of its kind. Not only is it objectively serious to have the carriage of, and in close proximity to yourself, a loaded semi-automatic pistol with extra ammunition but you have previously used a similar firearm to commit an armed robbery, thus revealing a disturbing propensity to possess illegal handguns. On 15 May 2013 you were sentenced by Judge Sides in the District Court of New South Wales in Parramatta for the crime of aggravated armed robbery which you committed on 9 September 2011. I pause to note that was only three months after you were placed on a 12 month good behaviour bond and fined for the crime of common assault.…Contrary to your submission to Judge Sides, you do not appear to have severed your ties with members of bikie gangs …In my view, your continued association and support of members of outlaw motorcycle gangs reflects adversely on your prospects of rehabilitation.
Decision
Reasons for decision
No additional considerations were advanced by the parties or identified by the Tribunal as relevant to the specific circumstances of Mr Ghazaryan’s application. CONCLUSION Mr Ghazaryan’s criminal offending is objectively very serious. Any repeat of his violent offences has the potential to inflict serious harm on members of the Australian community. His convictions and attendant sentences encompass a 13 year period, which is the vast majority of his time in Australia. His offending has increased in seriousness over time, despite lenient treatment by the courts. He has been convicted of assault against his former partner in 2009. Approximately three months after being placed on a 12-month good behaviour bond in 2011, he committed armed robbery with a pistol. His co-offenders were members of an OMCG. Despite submissions to the court about repudiating and severing his association with members of an OMCG, Mr Ghazaryan re-established associations with members of an OMCG after serving a lengthy prison sentence. In 2016 he was again found in possession of a pistol while in company with members of an OMCG, receiving a further sentence of imprisonment. The protective factors Mr Ghazaryan relied upon at his 2013 trial included the interests of his daughter, the medical needs of his father, the existence of strong family and community support, and a new personal relationship. The Tribunal is unpersuaded by Mr Ghazaryan’s latest submissions that similar protective factors justify a finding that ‘there is no likelihood’ he will reoffend. The Tribunal notes Mr Ghazaryan’s evidence that he has not completed any rehabilitative or self-development courses during lengthy periods of imprisonment since 2011. The Tribunal is unpersuaded by his submission that he will undertake such courses if released. The community’s perception of risk, given the specific circumstances of Mr Ghazaryan’s case, would be informed by the repeat nature of his violent offences – including while on conditional liberty, the increasing seriousness of his offending, his re-establishment of the same negative associations contextually relevant to his earlier offending, the previous insufficiency of protective factors he again relies upon to prevent his recidivism, and his failure to complete any rehabilitative programs while imprisoned. The harm that would be caused by a repeat of his violent offending is so serious that it constitutes an unacceptable risk to the Australian community. As a result of his criminal conduct and sentences of imprisonment, Mr Ghazaryan has absented himself from the life of his daughter for prolonged periods since September 2011. Her interests were insufficient to prevent him from committing numerous criminal offences in the decade after she was born. Others were subsequently required to undertake the primary parental role. In a similar vein, Mr Ghazaryan’s relationship with his ten-year-old nephew and six-year-old niece has been characterised by prolonged absences and infrequent contact. That said, the Tribunal accepts Mr Ghazaryan has a very close and supportive relationship with his immediate and extended family, including his daughter, niece and nephew. The interests of these children weigh in favour of revoking the cancellation of his visa.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Mr Ghazaryan’s appeal against the August 2016 sentence was dismissed by the Supreme Court of South Australia, Court of Criminal Appeal, on 21 December 2016. Chivell AJ concluded at [65]:The policy of the legislation, the fact that this was an aggravated offence and that Mr Ghazaryan is a serious firearms offender, the fact that Mr Ghazaryan had a relatively recent conviction for an offence of violence involving a handgun, and the Judge’s finding that Mr Ghazaryan was in possession of a loaded pistol for an illegal purpose, put his offending in the high range of seriousness. The finding that there were significant factors which told against Mr Ghazaryan’s prospects for rehabilitation was justified on the evidence.Conduct while imprisoned and in immigration detention The Tribunal notes in evidence Incident Reports compiled during Mr Ghazaryan’s imprisonment.[28] In an entry dated February 2017, it states that Mr Ghazaryan was ‘removed from Mobilong for the Security and Good Order of the prison.’ A December 2017 report describes Mr Ghazaryan’s purported involvement in a physical altercation with another prisoner after reportedly taking the other prisoner’s jumper from the shower room and putting it in his cell. Mr Ghazaryan was also noted in July 2018 to have ‘become abusive and aggressive towards officers.’ [28] Exhibit R2, 58, 73-75. The Tribunal notes a Client Incident Report (“CIR”) compiled during Mr Ghazaryan’s stay in immigration detention, which purportedly records his involvement in a number of incidents between 16 September 2018 and 6 February 2019.[29] These include alleged participation in the assault of a Sri Lankan detainee, damaging a bed in his room, displaying abusive/aggressive behaviour towards staff, a hunger strike, and suspected association with drug paraphernalia, which returned a positive reading for cocaine. Mr Ghazaryan was invited to comment on the CIR and in a letter dated 23 March 2019 denied the allegations contained in the report, with the exception of the assault matter, for which he admitted punching another detainee in self-defence.[30] During his oral evidence at the hearing, however, Mr Ghazaryan denied punching the other detainee. This matter is dealt with later in these reasons.[29] Exhibit R1, 111-118.[30] Ibid, 119.Mr Ghazaryan’s evidence Mr Ghazaryan’s submissions centre on the interests of his daughter, mother and sister. He misses close association with his family who have not been able to visit him for the last three years because his 2016 conviction was in a South Australian court and he served his sentence away from his home state of New South Wales. That geographical separation has continued after he was taken into immigration detention in August 2018. Mr Ghazaryan said he very much regrets the stress his actions have caused his family. He contextualises his offending as occurring because he kept ‘the company of wrong people,’ was ‘naïve…probably easily led,’ and failed to ‘pursue a good education.’[31] He refers to a previous lack of ‘confidence and self-esteem,’ but claims he now has renewed motivation for a ‘fresh start’ in life:Over the past two years I have been able to deeply reflect on my life and to appreciate even more the the many blessings I have received from my daughter and my other greatly loved family members. With their help and my own Love of God I am now resolved to make a new start in life from now on.…I have not completed any special courses whilst in prison to prepere me for my release. However as I have already mentioned I have firmily resolved to led a good and productive life upon my release with a strong support of my loving family and the sake of my daughter. And I shall be entering into courses to prepere me for my new life on the outside, including for my future work.[32](Errors in original).[31] Ibid, 68.[32] Ibid.