DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Ghane v QPS [2023] QDC 251
PARTIES:
GHANE, Moslen
(appellant)
v
QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE
(respondent)
FILE NO/S:
2257/23
DIVISION:
Appellate
PROCEEDING:
Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
Wynnum Magistrates Court
DELIVERED ON:
23 October 2023 (delivered ex tempore)
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane District Court
HEARING DATE:
23 October 2023
JUDGES:
Dearden DCJ
ORDER:
1. Vacate the sentences imposed on 24 July 2023, to this extent, in respect of:
(a) disqualified driving (20 October 2022) - the sentence of nine months’ imprisonment;
(b) driving a motor vehicle, tram, train or vessel whilst over middle-alcohol limit, learners/prob/provisional licence (on 20 October 2022) - six months’ imprisonment;
(c) disqualified driving (11 May 2023) - 12 months’ imprisonment.
2. Re-sentence as follows:
(d) disqualified driving (20 October 2022) - sentenced to eight months’ imprisonment, suspended after serving 91 days with an operational period of three years;
(e) driving a motor vehicle with the middle-alcohol limit (on 20 October 2022) - re-sentence 91 days’ imprisonment and three years’ probation (subject to the appellant’s consent);
(f) disqualified driving (on 11 May 2023) - 10 months’ imprisonment suspended after 91 days with an operational period of three years.
3. All other sentences imposed on 24 July 2023, affirmed.
4. All disqualification periods imposed in respect of all charges on 24 July 2023, affirmed.
5. All prison sentences to be served concurrently.
6. Declare the period of 91 days between 24 July 2023 and 22 October 2023 as time served in respect of all sentences.
CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – where the appellant appeals on the ground that the sentence was manifestly excessive – where the appellant was sentenced to 12 months imprisonment – where the appellant had previously been charged with disqualified driving - where the appellant was not an Australian citizen – where the appellant was facing deportation – whether the learned magistrate had sufficient regard to all of the effects of imposing a period of 12 months imprisonment
COUNSEL:
Appellant in person / S Josey as FOTC
E Zambas for the respondentSOLICITORS:
Appellant in person / Fuller & White Lawyers (FOTC) for the appellant
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent.
Introduction
The appellant, Moslen Ghane, seeks to appeal the sentences imposed in the Wynnum Magistrates Court on 24 July 2023 in respect of the following offences:
MAG-00194797/22(2):
Charge 1 - drive motor vehicle whilst of the middle-alcohol limit, but not over high-alcohol limit, on 20 October 2022;
Charge 2 - driving without a licence disqualified by a court, on 20 October 2022.
MAG-0008409/23(5):
Charge 1 - keeping a safe distance behind vehicles on 11 May 2023;
Charge 2 - fail to comply with duties of driver involved in a crash and give the driver’s required particulars to any other driver involved on 11 May 2023;
Charge 3 - driving without a licence disqualified by a court on 11 May 2023; and
Charge 4 - contravene direction required of a police officer on 11…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ghane v QPS and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] QDC 251
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the learned magistrate had sufficiently regarded all the effects of imposing a 12-month prison sentence. The appellant argued that the magistrate had not sufficiently weighed the total effect of the sentence, especially in light of Ghane’s visa cancellation and the prospect of deportation. The court also considered whether the magistrate had appropriately balanced the need for punishment and deterrence against the potential negative consequences of the sentence. The court noted the respondent's concession that the magistrate was mistakenly informed about a mandated eligibility date, but clarified that the need for actual imprisonment was not in dispute.
The court concluded that the learned magistrate had not sufficiently considered the overall effect of the sentence, particularly the potential for deportation and the impact on Ghane’s rehabilitation. The court found that the magistrate had not placed sufficient weight on the implications of a 12-month custodial sentence, which significantly increased the severity of the punishment. The court also found that the parole eligibility date set by the magistrate was effectively unattainable given Ghane’s visa status. The appeal was allowed, and the sentences were vacated and replaced with suspended sentences and probation.
The court ordered the sentences imposed on 24 July 2023 to be vacated in respect of the disqualified driving charges and re-sentenced Ghane to suspended imprisonment and probation for each offence. The new sentences were designed to balance the need for punishment with the potential consequences of a custodial sentence. The court also affirmed all other sentences, disqualification periods, and ordered that the prison sentences be served concurrently. The court declared the period of 91 days between 24 July 2023 and 22 October 2023 as time served in respect of all sentences.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Vacate the sentences imposed on 24 July 2023, to this extent, in respect of:
(a) disqualified driving (20 October 2022) - the sentence of nine months’ imprisonment;
(b) driving a motor vehicle, tram, train or vessel whilst over middle-alcohol limit, learners/prob/provisional licence (on 20 October 2022) - six months’ imprisonment;
(c) disqualified driving (11 May 2023) - 12 months’ imprisonment.
2. Re-sentence as follows:
(d) disqualified driving (20 October 2022) - sentenced to eight months’ imprisonment, suspended after serving 91 days with an operational period of three years;
(e) driving a motor vehicle with the middle-alcohol limit (on 20 October 2022) - re-sentence 91 days’ imprisonment and three years’ probation (subject to the appellant’s consent);
(f) disqualified driving (on 11 May 2023) - 10 months’ imprisonment suspended after 91 days with an operational period of three years.
3. All other sentences imposed on 24 July 2023, affirmed.
4. All disqualification periods imposed in respect of all charges on 24 July 2023, affirmed.
5. All prison sentences to be served concurrently.
6. Declare the period of 91 days between 24 July 2023 and 22 October 2023 as time served in respect of all sentences.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The appellant’s counsel at the original sentence submitted for a suspended prison sentence and concurrent probation.Consideration Ms Josey, who has kindly appeared pro bono as a friend of the court for the appellant on this appeal, and provided at very short notice, helpful, written submissions, identifies the following matters on which it is submitted that the learned magistrate has (effectively) erred in his sentencing discretion by a failure to place sufficient weight on various matters. Without reproducing the full text of those submissions, Ms Josey submits that the learned magistrate did not place sufficient weight on the total effect of the head sentence, especially given the prospect of deportation if the appellant was sentenced to an actual term of imprisonment of 12 months or more; the learned magistrate did not place sufficient weight on the fact that the appellant’s rehabilitation will be significantly impaired if placed in immigration detention pending deportation; the learned magistrate did not place any weight on the root cause of the offending and the attempts to deal with the offending behaviour; the learned magistrate erroneously assumed an opioid addiction; the learned magistrate did not place sufficient weight on the total effect of the sentence imposed, making the overall effect far more serious than intended. The appellant notes that his visa was automatically cancelled on 28 August 2023, and his application for Australian citizenship lodged 3 June 2020 was refused on 5 October 2023, because he did not have a visa as a permanent resident of Australia. The learned magistrate did not take into consideration that on entering prison, the previous parole period would be added to the head sentence imposed due to the automatic cancellation of the six-month parole order imposed on 24 July 2022. The learned magistrate set a parole eligibility date of 25 September 2023, which is effectively unable to be met until a new visa is granted, which may take more than 12 months, and currently the full-time discharge date is 23 July 2024. The learned magistrate did not place sufficient weight on the benefit of additional supervision in the community and failed to set a head sentence below the automatic cancellation of a 12-month custodial sentence. The learned magistrate did not place sufficient weight on the restrictions the appellant faced in getting appropriate professional psychological support. The learned magistrate did not place any weight on the consequence of the appellant not being insured at the time of the accident and having to pay repair costs.[12] The respondent accepts that the learned magistrate was mistakenly informed that an eligibility date for the offending on 11 May 2023 was mandated, but it was later clarified during the hearing that the six-month parole order would have expired at the time of the commission of the second set of offences. The respondent notes that it was not in contest that a period of actual imprisonment was required.[12]Exhibit 3 – Outline of submission on behalf of the appellant, [3.5 - 3.9], [3.12 - 3.21].