Georgina Mackay and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

[2013] AATA 368  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Numbers

2011/4746 & 2011/4747

Re

Georgina Mackay

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

Date 6 May 2013
Place Brisbane

The application to reinstate earlier proceedings is refused.

...........................[Sgd].............................................

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

CATCHWORDS

APPLICATION FOR REINSTATEMENT - dismissed in error - Matter withdrawn or adjourned - Understanding legal advice - Confidentiality order - Application to reinstate earlier proceedings refused

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ss 35, 42A

CASES

Goldie v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2002) 72 ALD 652

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

  1. Georgina Mackay was an applicant before the Tribunal in compensation proceedings brought against Australia Post. The hearing was conducted on 17 and 18 June 2009. I was the presiding member at that hearing; I was joined on the bench by Dr Maynard. The evidence called by the applicant – in particular the evidence led from her treating general practitioner – did not go well. At the end of that evidence, before an adjournment, I suggested to the applicant’s counsel that the evidence was of limited value. Ms Mackay was not in the hearing room to hear this exchange, but her brother was present.

  2. When the hearing resumed following the adjournment, counsel for the applicant said she had taken instructions from her client who wished to withdraw the proceedings. The proceedings were not withdrawn on the spot. Counsel asked for the matter to be adjourned so the withdrawal could be requested in writing. That occurred in due course.

  3. Ms Mackay now says the proceedings were withdrawn in error. She said she understood the proceedings were merely being adjourned. She wants to go on with her original claims. For that to occur, I would have to order that the proceedings be reinstated pursuant to s 42A(10) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act1975.

  4. I will come to the evidence and the findings of fact in a moment. I want to address s 42A(10) first. That sub-section says the Tribunal may reinstate a matter that was dismissed in error. At least two things flow from that proposition: firstly, I must be satisfied there is an error of the kind referred to in the section; and secondly, an error is a necessary but not sufficient condition for reinstatement. In other words, it is not enough for me to be satisfied there is an error. I must still be satisfied it is appropriate in all the circumstances to reinstate.

  5. The Full Court made clear in Goldie v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2002) 72 ALD 652 that the concept of error is to be interpreted widely. There remains an interesting question over whether the error must be a reasonable error, or whether it is enough in a case like this for the applicant to proceed on the basis of a misunderstanding that might have arisen notwithstanding the advice she received. I will have more to say about that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Georgina Mackay and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 368
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Georgina Mackay sought reinstatement of her application against the Australian Postal Corporation, which had been dismissed in error. The dispute centred around whether the proceedings could be reinstated under the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. The Federal Circuit Court was tasked with deciding whether to reinstate the application, considering whether the applicant had been given appropriate legal advice, and whether confidentiality orders should remain in place. The court had to determine if the error in dismissing the application warranted reinstatement, and if it was appropriate to reinstate the application under the circumstances, considering the strategic advice given to the applicant. Additionally, the court needed to decide if the confidentiality orders should be maintained, given that the proceedings had concluded and the allegations had been tested.

The court concluded that even if there was an error in dismissing the application, it was not appropriate to reinstate it due to the strategic advice the applicant had received. The court found that the advice to withdraw the application with a view to making fresh claims with better evidence was likely the right course of action. Given that fresh claims had already been lodged, it made more sense to allow the applicant to marshal her evidence for a new application. The court also considered the confidentiality orders, noting that while they were appropriate when first made, they were no longer necessary as the proceedings had concluded. The court decided that the orders should not remain in place, allowing the decision to be published subject to redactions to protect identifying details.

The application to reinstate the earlier proceedings was refused, and the confidentiality orders were lifted, with redactions to protect identifying details. This decision allows the applicant to proceed with fresh claims while ensuring that the confidentiality of the former lawyers, who were not parties to the proceedings, is respected to the extent necessary. The court’s decision ensures that the applicant can pursue her claims with the appropriate evidence, while also maintaining the principle of transparency in tribunal proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ultimately, I do not think it makes any difference to the outcome of this application. Even if there was such an error, I am still required to decide whether it would be appropriate in all the circumstances to reinstate the application. As it happens, the advice the applicant’s lawyers say she was given on the day of the hearing was probably the right advice. As I indicated on 18 June 2009, the case was unlikely to succeed to the extent it relied on the evidence of the treating general practitioner. A strategic withdrawal with a view to making fresh claims with better evidence was probably the best course of action in the circumstances. I note some fresh claims have since been lodged, and more have been foreshadowed. In all the circumstances, it does not make much sense to reinstate the earlier proceedings. It would be better for the applicant to martial her medical and other evidence for a fresh application which can be vetted in the ordinary way through the determination and reconsideration process. If she is dissatisfied with the outcomes of that process, she can come back to the Tribunal in due course. CONCLUSION The application to reinstate the earlier proceedings (namely files numbered 2007/4324, 2008/0389, 0974, 3437, 3881, and 4007) pursuant to s 42A(10) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act1975 is refused. CONFIDENTIALITY ORDERS I made orders under s 35 of the Act when the reinstatement proceedings were commenced. I believed it would not be appropriate to allow publication of serious allegations made about the applicant’s former lawyers before they could be tested in a hearing – particularly where the former lawyers were not a party to the proceedings and unable to respond before the obligation of confidentiality was waived and the hearing was held. But the hearing is over now. A decision has been made. Should the confidentiality orders remain in place? The applicant and respondent do not have strong views on this issue. The lawyers who appeared at the reinstatement hearing on behalf of Ms Mackay’s former representatives argued I should permanently suppress (a) the transcript of evidence taken at the reinstatement hearing and (b) the documents on the file in this matter. They suggested in the alternative that the decision should be edited so that identifying details be deleted when the decision was published. They argued there was no advantage in revealing the allegations but there was the potential for prejudice to the lawyers’ practices if the allegations became public knowledge. The Act anticipates the Tribunal will – as far as possible – do its job in public: s 35(1) and (3). There are certainly individual cases where it is appropriate to depart from this practice, but applications for confidentiality orders must be carefully scrutinised. I was satisfied an order was appropriate when I made it. The lawyers now have the benefit of a finding that I am satisfied they did not act improperly or induce the misunderstanding in the applicant about the effect of what transpired on 18 June 2009.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established