Georgina Mackay and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL             )

)        No: 2011/4746

Veterans' Appeals Division  )              2011/4747

Re: Georgina Mackay

Applicant

And: Australian Postal Corporation

Respondent

CORRIGENDUM

TRIBUNAL:             Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

DATE:   16 April 2014

PLACE:                  Brisbane

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision in this application as follows:

Replace the name “Dr Sinclair” with “Dr Sterling” in paragraph 15. The reference to
“Dr Sinclair’s reports” in paragraph 15 is to be replaced with “Dr Sterling’s reports”.

...................................................................

Senior Member

[2014] AATA 201

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/4746

2011/4747

Re

Georgina Mackay

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

Date 9 April 2014
Place Brisbane

The decisions under review are affirmed.

..........................SGD.....................................

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – Ankle injury – Claim for incapacity – Claim for permanent impairment – No medical evidence connecting symptoms to accepted workplace injuries – Decision affirmed.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) s 19; s 24

Cases

Mackay and Australian Postal Corporation [2013] AATA 368

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Bernard J McCabe

9 April 2014

  1. Ms Georgina Mackay was formerly employed by Australia Post, the respondent. She injured her right ankle at work in 2004, and experienced a further injury to the ankle in 2006. Australia Post has accepted liability for those injuries under the provisions of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“the Act”). Ms Mackay asked for compensation for incapacity under s 19 (application no 2011/4747) and compensation in respect of permanent impairment under s 24 (application no 2011/4746). The respondent rejected those claims in reviewable decisions dated 19 October 2011.

  2. The current proceedings have a background that requires explanation. Ms Mackay has lodged a number of applications for compensation over the years in respect of her ankle injury. Six of those applications came before the Tribunal on 17-18 June 2009 but they were withdrawn before the Tribunal completed its review under s 42A(1A) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). The applications were therefore deemed to have been dismissed by the Tribunal: s 42A(1B). Ms Mackay subsequently applied to have the applications reinstated pursuant to s 42A(10) because she claimed her lawyers were not acting in accordance with her instructions when they withdrew the proceedings. The application for reinstatement was refused on 6 May 2013:


    see Mackay and Australian Postal Corporation [2013] AATA 368.

  3. The disposition of the earlier proceedings has implications for the way in which I approach the current applications. I do not propose to re-visit the claims made in the earlier proceedings except insofar as the evidence in those proceedings sheds light on the questions at hand. I will focus on evidence relating to incapacity and permanent impairment entitlements which post-dates 19 June 2009. I am not aware of any fresh evidence or developments that would justify revisiting…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Georgina Mackay and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 201
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Georgina Mackay, a former employee of the Australian Postal Corporation, sought compensation for an alleged ankle injury sustained during her employment. Mackay had originally injured her right ankle in a 2004 motorcycle accident while delivering mail, an incident for which the respondent accepted liability. After a period of compensation and rehabilitation, Mackay re-injured the same ankle in 2006. Following her retirement due to the injury, Mackay claimed ongoing pain, impaired mobility, and permanent incapacity, seeking further compensation. The respondent denied any further liability, leading to a legal dispute over the extent of Mackay's incapacity and any permanent impairment resulting from her injuries.

The central legal issues in this case were whether Mackay's current symptoms and claimed incapacity were directly attributable to the workplace injuries for which the respondent had already accepted liability. Specifically, the court needed to determine if there was sufficient medical evidence to establish a causal link between the accepted injuries and Mackay's ongoing pain, incapacity, and alleged permanent impairment. The court also had to assess the credibility and weight of the medical evidence provided by both parties, considering the opinions of various specialists.

The court found that the medical evidence provided by the specialists did not sufficiently establish a causal link between the accepted workplace injuries and Mackay's ongoing symptoms. The respondent's experts, Drs Peereboom and Saxby, provided detailed reports suggesting that Mackay's current condition was not a direct result of the accepted injuries. The court preferred the evidence of these specialists over that of Dr Sinclair, who was relied upon by Mackay. The court concluded that since the medical evidence did not support a connection between the accepted injuries and Mackay's current symptoms, her claims for incapacity and permanent impairment could not be sustained.

Accordingly, the court affirmed the decisions under review, dismissing Mackay's claims for further compensation. The court held that without a clear medical connection between the accepted injuries and her ongoing symptoms, Mackay's claims for incapacity and permanent impairment were unsubstantiated. The decision highlights the importance of establishing a direct causal link between workplace injuries and ongoing symptoms to successfully claim compensation in such cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

As it happens, I do not think anything turns on all that. For reasons I will explain, the relevant medical evidence does not provide any basis for concluding the respondent is liable to pay compensation under s ss 19 and 24. I explain my reasons below.a brief summary of the facts Ms Mackay worked at Australia Post. In 2004, she injured her right ankle in a motorcycle accident while delivering the mail. The respondent accepted liability for that injury under s 14(1) of the Act in its determination of 23 March 2004. The applicant was paid compensation and participated in a return-to-work program. The respondent determined there was no further compensation payable in its determination of 29 June 2005. The applicant subsequently re-injured the ankle on 2 February 2006. The respondent accepted liability for that re-injury on 15 May 2006. The applicant continued to experience problems with her ankle and reported pain and incapacity. She said she was prone to falling, most obviously in July 2008. She was medically retired from Australia Post on 23 December 2009. She is no longer working, but says she continues to experience pain and swelling, and her gait is affected. She often uses crutches because she has difficulty taking weight on her ankle, and she says she cannot walk long distances. She claims she is permanently impaired and incapacitated for work.the medical evidence The applicant led evidence from two colleagues at Australia Post at the hearing in addition to her own testimony. They all spoke of Ms Mackay’s impairment and discomfort in the workplace. That evidence is of limited assistance because the respondent says the applicant’s current condition – whatever it might be – is not the product of the injuries for which it accepted liability. I agree that, in order for Ms Mackay’s application to succeed, I must be satisfied the original ankle injury (and the re-injury in 2006) are connected to the current symptoms she describes. The medical evidence is crucial. I have been provided with a wealth of material from doctors and allied health practitioners recording Ms Mackay’s claims of pain and disability, but that material relies on self-reporting. The more useful material is the collection of reports and testimony provided by the specialists who have investigated the injury itself and commented upon the connection between the injury and the reported symptoms. The respondent relies on the evidence of Dr Peereboom, who provided reports dated 14 August 2007; 17 September 2007; 21 October 2007; 10 June 2008; and 27 January 2009. The respondent also relies on the evidence of Dr Saxby, who provided reports dated 11 December 2007; 6 May 2008; and 9 October 2008. Dr Saxby also gave evidence at the hearing. The applicant relies on the reports of Dr Purssey dated 18 September 2007; 31 January 2008; 19 November 2008; and 9 March 2012. Dr Purssey gave evidence at the hearing in 2009, and a transcript of his evidence on that occasion was tendered in these proceedings. The applicant also referred to reports provided by Dr Sterling dated 30 July 2010 and 26 November 2010.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Ms Mackay worked at Australia Post. In 2004, she injured her right ankle in a motorcycle accident while delivering the mail. The respondent accepted liability for that injury under s 14(1) of the Act in its determination of 23 March 2004. The applicant was paid compensation and participated in a return-to-work program. The respondent determined there was no further compensation payable in its determination of 29 June 2005. The applicant subsequently re-injured the ankle on 2 February 2006. The respondent accepted liability for that re-injury on 15 May 2006. The applicant continued to experience problems with her ankle and reported pain and incapacity. She said she was prone to falling, most obviously in July 2008. She was medically retired from Australia Post on 23 December 2009. She is no longer working, but says she continues to experience pain and swelling, and her gait is affected. She often uses crutches because she has difficulty taking weight on her ankle, and she says she cannot walk long distances. She claims she is permanently impaired and incapacitated for work.the medical evidence The applicant led evidence from two colleagues at Australia Post at the hearing in addition to her own testimony. They all spoke of Ms Mackay’s impairment and discomfort in the workplace. That evidence is of limited assistance because the respondent says the applicant’s current condition – whatever it might be – is not the product of the injuries for which it accepted liability. I agree that, in order for Ms Mackay’s application to succeed, I must be satisfied the original ankle injury (and the re-injury in 2006) are connected to the current symptoms she describes. The medical evidence is crucial. I have been provided with a wealth of material from doctors and allied health practitioners recording Ms Mackay’s claims of pain and disability, but that material relies on self-reporting. The more useful material is the collection of reports and testimony provided by the specialists who have investigated the injury itself and commented upon the connection between the injury and the reported symptoms. The respondent relies on the evidence of Dr Peereboom, who provided reports dated 14 August 2007; 17 September 2007; 21 October 2007; 10 June 2008; and 27 January 2009. The respondent also relies on the evidence of Dr Saxby, who provided reports dated 11 December 2007; 6 May 2008; and 9 October 2008. Dr Saxby also gave evidence at the hearing. The applicant relies on the reports of Dr Purssey dated 18 September 2007; 31 January 2008; 19 November 2008; and 9 March 2012. Dr Purssey gave evidence at the hearing in 2009, and a transcript of his evidence on that occasion was tendered in these proceedings. The applicant also referred to reports provided by Dr Sterling dated 30 July 2010 and 26 November 2010. I will say at once the evidence of Dr Sterling does little to assist the applicant’s claim for permanent impairment because he suggests the level of impairment is only 3%. A claim for permanent impairment cannot succeed unless the level of impairment is at least 10%.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I also prefer the evidence of Drs Peereboom and Saxby to the evidence of Dr Sinclair to the extent of any inconsistency. Dr Sinclair’s reports are brief and contain much less detailed explanations of his view. conclusion The applicant says she experiences ongoing pain and discomfort. She complains she is incapacitated. She has referred to a good deal of medical and other evidence in support of that claim. But the crucial medical evidence which I have discussed here suggests her current symptoms cannot be connected with the accepted workplace injuries. That means her claims in respect of incapacity and permanent impairment cannot be sustained. The decisions under review must therefore be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established