GEJ & MA Geldard Pty Ltd v Mobbs (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

GEJ & MA Geldard Pty Ltd v Mobbs & Ors (No 2) [2011] QSC 33

PARTIES:

GEJ & MA GELDARD PTY LTD ACN 065 705 777
AS TRUSTEE FOR THE G & M GELDARD FAMILY TRUST
(plaintiff)

v

DONALD NOEL MOBBS and
JILL WINIFRED MOBBS

(first defendant)

and

SIMON DRURY

(second defendant)

and

MDH PTY LTD ACN 010 114 468

(third defendant)

and

DONALD ALEXANDER McDONALD

(fourth defendant)

and

BEN MAHER

(fifth defendant)

and

MEANDARRA AERIAL SPRAYING PTY LTD
ACN 087
259 283

(sixth defendant)

and

ROSS JAMES YORK TRADING AS ELITE AGRI‑SERVICES BN 19693941

(seventh defendant)

and

LACHLAN HILL
(eighth defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 2773 of 2007

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

11 March 2011

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27 August 2010; further submissions provided on 6, 10 September and 11, 12, 24 November 2010.

JUDGE:

Ann Lyons J

ORDER:

The claims for apportionment under the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld) are dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

NEGLIGENCE – APPORTIONMENT OF LIABILITY - where the court has found that the sixth and eighth defendants were negligent in spraying herbicides which caused damage to the plaintiff’s crops – where the proportion of liability as between the defendants is to be determined – where the apportionment of liability in relation to defendants with whom settlement had been effected is to be determined – whether an apportionable claim exists – whether any defendants are concurrent wrongdoers – whether the onus in determining the proportion of each defendants’ liability lies with the plaintiff or the defendants – whether apportionment can occur where other defendants were not parties at the trial hearing – whether the sixth and eighth defendants are each liable unaffected by the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld).

Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld), s 31, s 32B

Bonic v Fieldair [1999] NSWSC 636
Evans & Ors v Brannelly & Ors [2008] QDC 269
Nemeth v Prynew [2005] NSWSC 1296
PMB Australia Ltd v MMI General Insurance Ltd [2002] QCA 361

Purkess v Crittenden (1965) 114 CLR 164

Reinhold v New South Wales Lotteries Corporation (No 2) [2008] NSWSC 187
Ucak v Avante Developments Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC367
Watts v Rake (1960) 108 CLR 158

Yates v Mobile Marine Repairs Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 1463

COUNSEL:

K Howe for the plaintiff

G Newton SC and M Trim for the sixth and eighth defendants

SOLICITORS:

Woods Hatcher for the plaintiff

CLS Lawyers for the sixth and eighth defendants

ANN LYONS J:

History

  1. The first defendants (the Mobbs) are the owners of the cattle property “Sherwood”.  The second defendant (Simon Drury) was employed as the manager of that property.

  1. The third defendant (MDH Pty Ltd) is the owner of the cattle property “Wallumba”.  The fourth and fifth defendants (McDonald and Maher) were employed as managers and operators of that property.

  1. The seventh defendant (Ross York) has a business supplying agricultural products and supplied chemicals to those landowners to control wattle regrowth on their…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GEJ & MA Geldard Pty Ltd v Mobbs (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] QSC 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

GEJ & MA Geldard Pty Ltd sought damages against several defendants for negligence in spraying herbicides that damaged their crops. The case was heard in the Queensland District Court, where it was determined that the sixth and eighth defendants were negligent. The court was required to decide the proportion of liability between these two defendants, and how to apportion liability in relation to defendants with whom settlement had already been effected. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the sixth and eighth defendants were each liable unaffected by the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld).

The court considered various factors in making its decision, including the purpose of the legislation, the facts of the case, the practicalities of responsibility, the relative contributions of the defendants to the activity that caused the loss, and the responsibility of all parties involved. The court noted that blameworthiness and causative potency were also important factors to consider when apportioning liability. The court ultimately found that the sixth and eighth defendants were each liable for their share of the damages, and that the pre-trial settlements with other defendants did not affect the calculation of damages for the sixth and eighth defendants.

The court dismissed the claims for apportionment under the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld). The court found that the sixth and eighth defendants were each liable for their share of the damages, and that the pre-trial settlements with other defendants did not affect the calculation of damages for the sixth and eighth defendants. The court did not consider it necessary to apportion liability between the sixth and eighth defendants, as each was found to be equally responsible for the damage to the plaintiff’s crops.

Orders

Orders of the court

The claims for apportionment under the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld) are dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

That decision indicates therefore that the following factors should be taken into account:(i) The purpose of the legislation and the fundamental change in the law.(ii) That the Court must exercise a large discretionary judgment founded upon the facts proved in each particular case.(iii) A consideration of the actual practicalities of responsibility.(iv) A consideration of which of the concurrent wrongdoers were more actively engaged in the activity which caused the loss.(v) A consideration of which of the wrongdoers could have prevented the loss.(vi) The responsibility of all the parties, particularly those who had the duty or expertise to prevent the loss. In the 2008 New South Wales Supreme Court decision of Reinhold v New South Wales Lotteries Corporation (No 2)[2] Barrett J also discussed the process to be undertaken as well as the meaning of “just and equitable” as follows:[2][2008] NSWSC 187. The Reinhold decision therefore added blameworthiness and causative potency as two further factors which should be taken into account when determining responsibility of the respective parties. It is also clear that Reinhold indicated that factors which should not be taken into account included the financial strength of a party, the status of a party or whether there had been any indication of remorse. The making of an apportionment of the respective shares in the responsibility for the damage therefore involves a comparison of both culpability, ie of the degree of departure from the standard of care of the reasonable man, and the relative importance of the acts in causing the economic loss suffered by the plaintiff. It is the whole conduct of each negligent party in relation to the circumstances which must be subjected to comparative examination. Furthermore the significance of the various elements involved in such an examination will vary from case to case and if a party has profited from its actions which have caused the plaintiff’s loss and the other is or will be out of pocket, then that imbalance can be brought into account. As the cases indicate, a determination of what is ‘just and equitable’ will inevitably involve the court making an evaluation and coming to a discretionary conclusion about where the justice of the case lies. I have therefore been asked to determine the amount that reflects the proportion of the plaintiff’s loss of $467,187.45 that I consider is just and equitable, having regard to the extent of the sixth and eight defendant’s responsibility for the damage to the cotton crop. I will turn first to the question of what effect the pre trial settlement with the other defendants has on the present proceedings. The defendants having previously argued that the settlement figure should be taken into account in the calculation of the damages which the sixth and eight defendants should be ordered to pay. Section 32B of CLA provides as follows:- It is clear that s 32B only relates to a situation where a plaintiff has previously recovered judgment against a concurrent wrongdoer.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.