Gardner v Northern Territory of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

Gardner v Northern Territory of Australia [2003] NTSC 113

PARTIES:KELVIN IAN GARDNER

v

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY EXERCISING TERRITORY JURISDICTION

FILE NO:SC 91 of 2001 (20107821)

DELIVERED:  25 November 2003

HEARING DATES:  10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17 and 19 November 2003

JUDGMENT OF:  RILEY J

CATCHWORDS:

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:A. Wrenn

Defendant:A.H. Silvester

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:T.S. Lee & Associates

Defendant:Solicitor for the Northern Territory

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  ril0330

Number of pages:  30

ril0330

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Gardner v Northern Territory of Australia [2003] NTSC 113
No. SC 91 of 2001 (20107821)

BETWEEN:

KELVIN IAN GARDNER

Plaintiff

AND:

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

Defendant

CORAM:    RILEY J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 25 November 2003)

  1. In 1995 the plaintiff, along with two of his brothers and his sister, was a joint tenant of land situated at Section 1746 Hundred of Cavenagh, Cox Peninsula Road, Berry Springs.  The land is in a relatively remote location and is surrounded by vacant land, including vacant Crown land to the north.

  2. In or about 1987 the plaintiff constructed a rudimentary dwelling on the land.  He claims that he holds the entire interest in the dwelling under a constructive trust from the joint owners.  He claims sole ownership of the contents of the dwelling.  On that basis he commenced these proceedings in his own name without joining his brothers or sister as parties.  An issue arises as to whether he can proceed in his own name in relation to damage to the land and fixtures.  The plaintiff was provided with the opportunity to join his joint owners either as plaintiffs or defendants but chose not to do so.

  3. There is no dispute that on 10 September 1995 a fire spread onto section 1746 and destroyed the dwelling and its contents, along with a shed and a bore.  It is the claim of the plaintiff that the fire escaped from the adjoining Crown land and that the defendant was negligent in failing to take adequate precautions to prevent the fire from spreading from the vacant Crown land onto section 1746.

  4. The plaintiff claims that the defendant was negligent in failing to take various steps to reduce the likelihood of this fire and other fires spreading from adjoining land onto section 1746.  In particular the plaintiff says that the defendant failed to implement and maintain firebreaks, reduce fuel build-up on the adjoining land, take action to reduce the spread of the fire and to monitor or extinguish the fire.

  5. The defendant admits that it owed a duty of care to the joint owners of section 1746 to take such precautions as were reasonable, in all the circumstances then prevailing, to restrain the fire on its land from escaping and causing damage.  The defendant denies that it was in breach of any duty as particularised by the plaintiff.

    The evidence of the Plaintiff

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gardner v Northern Territory of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NTSC 113
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Gardner v Northern Territory of Australia, the plaintiff sought damages for the destruction of his house and its contents by bushfire. The Northern Territory admitted to owing a duty of care to the plaintiff and the other joint owners of the property, but denied any breach of that duty. The plaintiff claimed that had the Territory not breached its duty by failing to establish firebreaks and maintain vegetation, the fire would not have reached his property. The Territory argued that the plaintiff's own failures to monitor the fire and remove flammable material contributed to the destruction of the property.

The court was required to determine whether the Territory breached its duty of care and whether that breach contributed to the destruction of the plaintiff's property. The court examined the evidence regarding the Territory's actions and the plaintiff's own conduct. The court concluded that while the Territory owed a duty of care, it had not breached that duty. The court found that the plaintiff's failure to adequately monitor the fire and remove fuel from around his house were the primary causes of the damage, not the Territory's failure to establish firebreaks or maintain vegetation.

The court reasoned that the Territory was not responsible for the plaintiff's omissions and dismissed the plaintiff's claim. The court also noted that the plaintiff's standing to sue was questionable, as he was one of four joint tenants of the property and there was no evidence of a severance of the joint tenancy. However, the court did not need to address this issue as it found in favour of the Territory on the merits of the case. The court ordered that the plaintiff's claim be dismissed and that the Territory recover its costs from the plaintiff.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The defendant admits that it owed a duty of care to the joint owners of section 1746 to take such precautions as were reasonable, in all the circumstances then prevailing, to restrain the fire on its land from escaping and causing damage. The defendant denies that it was in breach of any duty as particularised by the plaintiff.The evidence of the Plaintiff The evidence of the plaintiff was that section 1746 was, at the relevant time, owned by his brothers, his sister and himself. During 1987 he had built a house on the land and when the house was completed he lived in it with his wife and children. The plaintiff acknowledged through his counsel that the building was an illegal structure under the provisions of the Building Act and was unlawfully erected on the land. Each of his brothers and his sister has confirmed that, whilst they were joint owners of the relevant property, they made no contribution to the cost of building the house and now make no claim arising out of the destruction of the house on 10 September 1995. At that time the same members of the family also owned the adjacent land to the west, being section 1747, and the land at the south-west corner of section 1746, being section 1742. Each section was 320 acres in area. Mr Gardner gave evidence that he completed firebreaks around section 1746 each year, including the year of the fire. He said there were never any firebreaks on the adjoining Crown land. However in each year prior to 1995 the Berry Springs Volunteer Bushfire Brigade had attended and back-burnt into the Crown land from the firebreaks on his land. At the relevant time Mr Gardner was aware of a fire burning in the region of the Blackmore River. He said that on 9 September 1995 he was at a greyhound race meeting at Winnellie Park when he had a conversation withRoy Baxter who was, at that time, the Captain of the Berry Springs Volunteer Bushfire Brigade. Mr Gardner said that he asked Mr Baxter where the fire was and Mr Baxter told him “the fire is on the other side of the Blackmore River”. Mr Gardner assumed that meant the fire was on the eastern side of the Blackmore River and thus on the opposite side of the river to section 1746. On the day following his discussion with Mr Baxter, Mr Gardner was in a shed adjacent to some stables at section 1742. Following a comment by his son he looked to the north and saw that smoke appeared to be rising from an area near to section 1746. He drove to his house on section 1746, a distance of about 3 kilometres by road, and found that the surrounding land had been burnt and the house was ablaze. The house and its contents were completely destroyed. It was the plaintiff’s evidence that if he had been informed by Mr Baxter that the fire was actually on the western side of the Blackmore River he would have been fully prepared and on standby to meet the fire. He would have arranged with members of the Berry Springs Volunteer Bushfire Brigade to attend to assist in controlling the fire. He said that he had been “somewhat comforted” by the advice of Mr Baxter that the fire “is on the other side of the Blackmore River”. Notwithstanding those statements, it was not his evidence that he in any way slackened his vigilance because of that advice. He said that he was alert to the threat of bushfires during the dry season and that he maintained a watch for approaching fires by, inter alia, “checking the horizon regularly and being aware of wind and weather conditions”. In cross-examination he said he was alert to the presence of this particular fire and that he maintained a watch whilst he was working at section 1742. Included in his watch were visits to the house at section 1746 in order to monitor the fire. He said that he last visited section 1746 between 9 am and 10 am on 10 September 1995 “to see if the fire was anywhere near my house … the fire was nowhere near the house so I went back down the front of the stables”. At that time the fire was in the north. At one stage he said the fire was to the north-north-east (markings on exhibit D2) and at another that it came to section 1746 from north-north-west (markings on exhibit D18).

Decision

Reasons for decision

The extinguishment of the fire was not an available option, save by the method of burning back into the fire as it approached the boundary of section 1746. That did not occur because no-one was aware of the approach of the fire to section 1746. There was no failure on the part of the defendant or its servants or agents to monitor the fire.Conclusion Whilst it is clear that the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff, it has not been shown that any relevant breach of that duty occurred. The failure of the defendant to place firebreaks on the land adjacent to sections 1746 and 1747 and the failure of the defendant to reduce the available fuel on the Crown land to the north did not cause or contribute to the destruction of the house or other property. The defendant was entitled to rely upon the plaintiff to monitor the fire for his own protection and was entitled to expect him to seek the assistance of the Volunteer Bushfire Brigade when required. Had he done so, an appropriate back-burn could have been employed to protect the property. I find that was the general understanding within the relevant community and in particular it was the understanding between the plaintiff and Mr Baxter in relation to this fire. The plaintiff failed to adequately monitor the fire and he also failed to remove fuel from around his house. As a consequence of those failures the fire which entered onto section 1746 swept south and destroyed the house and its contents, along with the shed and the bore. The defendant is not responsible for those omissions. The plaintiff’s claim is dismissed.The Plaintiff The standing of the plaintiff to sue was an issue raised in the course of the proceedings. It is unnecessary for me to deal with this issue in light of the conclusions I have reached. In deference to the submissions presented, I should say something as to the matter. There is no dispute that the plaintiff has standing to bring the proceedings seeking damages in relation to the loss of the chattels destroyed in the fire. Those chattels belonged to him. However, there is a challenge to his standing in relation to the land and fixed improvements that were also the subject of a claim for damages. The plaintiff was one of four joint tenants in relation to section 1746. Joint tenants are jointly seised of the whole estate they take in land and no one of them has a distinct or separate title, interest or possession: Wright v Gibbons (1948-1949) 78 CLR 313 at 329. Because joint tenants have no separate distinct title, interest or possession in actions relating to their joint estate, one joint tenant cannot sue or be sued without joining the other or others: Commentaries on the Laws of England; William Blackstone (Vol II at 182). It was the contention of the plaintiff that, by virtue of his unilateral action in constructing the residence on the land, the joint tenancy had been severed and the land was held by himself and his brothers and sister as tenants in common. He was not able to identify the proportions of the holding of the individual tenants in common. There was no evidence on the part of the plaintiff of an intention to sever. There was no evidence of any agreement by the joint tenants to the action of the plaintiff in constructing the residence. There was no evidence on that matter at all.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established