Gardner v ACT Heritage Council

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



GARDNER & ANOR v ACT HERITAGE COUNCIL & ORS
(Administrative Review) [2014] ACAT 4

Case Number            AT 13/64; AT 13/65

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW - – HERITAGE REGISTER – decision not to provisionally register as a place of heritage significance – requirement for reasonable grounds to be satisfied about heritage significance – relevant heritage significance criteria: important evidence of a “distinctive” form of design, and notable example of Garden City precinct – whether there was diminishing of intactness of the precinct’s Garden City design qualities – whether the precinct meets the criterion of being important evidence of a design  

Legislation:Heritage Act 2004, ss 3, 10, 13, 17, 18, 29, 32, 111 and 114

Subordinate

Legislation:Heritage (Decision about Provisional Registration of the Turner Housing Precinct, Turner) Notice 2013, Notifiable Instrument
NI 2013 – 337

Cases:150 Braddon Pty Ltd and ACT Heritage Council
[2013] ACAT 44

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Cummings v Lewis and Ors (1993) ATPR (Digest) 46-103

Pettersson and ACT Heritage Council and Commissioner for Social Housing [2010] ACAT 28

Taglietti and Ors & Act Heritage Council [2011] ACAT 14

Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Archdiocese of Canberra and Goulburn and the ACT Heritage Council and Ors [2013] ACAT 62

Texts/Papers:            Andrew Ward, Assessment of Garden City Planning Principles in the ACT, (Environment ACT, Heritage Unit) (September 2000) 

David Hay (Gen. Ed), Words and Phrases Legally Defined
(4th Ed, 2009)

John Sulman, An Introduction to the study of Town Planning in Australia, (National Trust of Australia (NSW)) (Facsimile edition, 2007)

Peter Dowling, Turner Streetscapes: A Heritage Assessment of
           Sections 46, 47, 48, 49 & 50, Turner ACT
, (National Trust of
           Australia (ACT), 2004)

National Archives of Australia, A Design History of Australia’s National Capital 2002

Tribunal:                  Ms E. Symons - Presidential Member
  Dr T. Foley - Senior Member

Date of Orders:  29 January 2014

Date of Reasons for Decision:         29 January 2014

ACT CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL                   AT 13/64

AT 13/65

RE: HENRY GARDNER

Applicant – AT 13/64

RE: NICOLA WATSON

Applicant – AT 13/65

AND: ACT HERITAGE COUNCIL

Respondent

AND: JUDY ANDERSON

Party Joined – AT 13/64

AND: HENAVINE PTY LTD

Party Joined - AT 13/64 &    AT 13/65

AND:RAMESH & RASHMI MALIK

Party Joined - AT 13/64 &

AT 13/65

TRIBUNAL:             Ms E. Symons - Presidential Member 

Dr T. Foley - Senior Member

DATE:29 January 2014

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

1.     The decision under review is confirmed.

………………………………..

Ms E. Symons - Presidential Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

Decision Under Review

  1. This is an application to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) for review of a decision[1] (‘the decision’) of the ACT Heritage Council (‘the Council’) made on 25 July 2013 pursuant to section 32 of the Heritage Act 2004 (‘the Act’) not to provisionally register the Turner Housing Precinct (‘the precinct’), Turner on the ACT Heritage Register…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gardner v ACT Heritage Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACAT 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gardner v ACT Heritage Council involved a dispute over the rejection of a provisional heritage listing for a precinct by the Heritage Council. The applicants and parties joined sought review of this decision, arguing that it contravened the spirit and intention of the Act, and that the Council's process was flawed. They also contended that the decision contained inaccuracies and directly contradicted the PLA report in various areas. The central legal issues for the court were whether the decision to reject provisional heritage listing was a reviewable decision, and if the applicants had standing to bring their applications. Additionally, the court needed to determine if the Council's decision was in accordance with the requirements of the Act, particularly whether the Council was satisfied on reasonable grounds that the place or object may have heritage significance.

The Tribunal found that the decision under review was a reviewable decision and that the applicants and parties joined had standing to bring their applications. The Tribunal held that the Council's decision to reject provisional heritage listing for the precinct was not flawed and was in accordance with the requirements of the Act. The Tribunal considered that the Council was satisfied on reasonable grounds that the place or object may have heritage significance and that the process followed by the Council was fair and lawful. The Tribunal also found that the Council's decision did not contain inaccuracies and did not directly contradict the PLA report in any material way.

In light of the above findings, the Tribunal confirmed the decision under review. The applicants' and parties joined's applications for review were dismissed, and no further orders were made. The Tribunal found that the Council's decision to reject provisional heritage listing for the precinct was lawful and that the applicants and parties joined did not have standing to bring their applications. The Tribunal held that the Council's decision was in accordance with the requirements of the Act and that the Council was satisfied on reasonable grounds that the place or object may have heritage significance.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Orders that:

1. The decision under review is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute regarding the rejection of a provisional Heritage Listing for a precinct by the ACT Heritage Council. The Applicants, along with Parties Joined, argue that the decision contravenes the spirit and intention of the Act and is not supported by sufficient evidence. They claim that the Council breached the timeframe for urgent applications, relied on irrelevant information, and rejected recommendations without sound evidence. The Applicants argue that the precinct has reasonable grounds for listing based on the 2012 nomination, the 2004 streetscapes document, and the 2013 PLA report. The Council's decision is also alleged to contain inaccurate assertions and contradict the PLA report in several areas. The Applicants further contend that the Council misrepresented the process by which it received submissions from residents and that the precinct is an excellent example of post-World War II planning and design.

The matter has been brought before the Tribunal as an application for review under sections 111 and 114 of the Act. The Applicants and Parties Joined have standing to bring their applications, as they are interested persons in accordance with section 13 of the Act. The Tribunal has reviewed the decision of the ACT Heritage Council to reject the provisional Heritage Listing for the precinct. The Applicants argue that the decision is contrary to the Act, based on insufficient evidence, and contains inaccuracies. The Tribunal has considered the evidence and submissions presented by the Applicants and the Council in making its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the decision to reject provisional Heritage Listing for the precinct contravene both the spirit and the intention of the Act?
2. Is the criterion for heritage significance constrained by the number of comparable precincts which are presently listed?
3. Have the Applicants satisfied the Tribunal on reasonable grounds that the precinct has heritage significance?
4. Was the process around the decision flawed because the Council breached the timeframe for urgent applications, relied on irrelevant information, and rejected the recommendations of their independent report without sound evidence or argument to the contrary?
5. Is there any information in the Tribunal documents to explain why the initially positive response to the PLA report and listing of the precinct changed in the lead up to the vote on 9 July 2013?
6. Does the decision contain a number of inaccurate assertions and/or directly contradict the PLA report in many areas?
7. Is the precinct important as evidence of a distinctive way of life, taste, tradition, religion, land use, custom, process design, or function that is no longer practised, is in danger of being lost, or is of exceptional interest?
8. Is the precinct a notable example of a kind of place or object and demonstrates the main characteristics of that kind?
9. Does the Council's statement about the number of responses it received opposing the nomination misrepresent the process undertaken by the Council?
10. Is a heritage precinct a museum, and do the Council's claims about certain qualities diminishing the value of the precinct misrepresent the potential for change in the precinct?
11. Do sections 47 to 50 Turner retain their integrity as an excellent late expression of Sulman Garden City planning and design, and is the precinct an aesthetically and culturally pleasing example of post-World War II planning in this city which is in imminent danger of being lost?

Held
1. The Tribunal confirmed the decision under review.
2. The Tribunal held that the criterion for heritage significance is not constrained by the number of comparable precincts which are presently listed.
3. The Tribunal found that the Applicants did not satisfy the Tribunal on reasonable grounds that the precinct has heritage significance.
4. The Tribunal found that the process around the decision was not flawed because the Council did not breach the timeframe for urgent applications, the Council did not rely on irrelevant information, and the Council did not reject the recommendations of their independent report without sound evidence or argument to the contrary.
5. The Tribunal found that there is no information in the Tribunal documents to explain why the initially positive response to the PLA report and listing of the precinct changed in the lead up to the vote on 9 July 2013.
6. The Tribunal found that the decision contains a number of inaccurate assertions and/or directly contradicts the PLA report in many areas.
7. The Tribunal held that the precinct is not important as evidence of a distinctive way of life, taste, tradition, religion, land use, custom, process design, or function that is no longer practised, is in danger of being lost, or is of exceptional interest.
8. The Tribunal held that the precinct is not a notable example of a kind of place or object and does not demonstrate the main characteristics of that kind.
9. The Tribunal found that the Council's statement about the number of responses it received opposing the nomination does not misrepresent the process undertaken by the Council.
10. The Tribunal held that a heritage precinct is not a museum and that the Council's claims about certain qualities diminishing the value of the precinct do not misrepresent the potential for change in the precinct.
11. The Tribunal held that sections 47 to 50 Turner do not retain their integrity as an excellent late expression of Sulman Garden City planning and design and that the precinct is not an aesthetically and culturally pleasing example of post-World War II planning in this city which is in imminent danger of being lost.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 32 of the Act states: 32Decision about provisional registration(1)The council must decide whether to provisionally register each place or object nominated for provisional registration.(2)The council also may decide to provisionally register a place or object that has not been nominated for provisional registration.(3)The council may provisionally register a place or object only if satisfied, on reasonable grounds, that the place or object may have heritage significance. Sections 111 and 114 of the Act deal with reviewable decisions. The Tribunal is satisfied that the decision under review is a reviewable decision pursuant to Schedule 1, column 1, item 1 of the Act and that the Applicants and Parties Joined are interested persons in accordance with section 13 of the Act. They have standing to bring their applications. The Applicants and Judy Anderson contend[4] as follows:[4] Applicants’ and Parties Joined’s Statement of Facts and Contentions dated 4 October 2013, pages 7 to 17i.The decision to reject provisional Heritage Listing for the precinct contravenes both the spirit and the intention of the Act.ii.The criterion for heritage significance identified in section 10 of the Act is not constrained by the number of comparable precincts which are presently listed. iii.The Act states[5] that applicants seeking provisional registration must satisfy the Tribunal on reasonable grounds that the place or object may have heritage significance. There is more than enough evidence between the 2012 nomination, the 2004 streetscapes document[6] and the 2013 PLA report to argue that the precinct has reasonable grounds for listing. The term may has been considered in other Tribunal decisions. It is important to give full effect to the purpose and meaning of the Act by maintaining a distinction between provisional listing and registration (see Taglietti and Ors & Act Heritage Council [7](“Taglietti”).[5] Subsection 32(3) of the Act[6] The Dowling Report[7] [2011] ACAT 14-where it was held that provisional registration will affect the actions of future developers in that there will be a moratorium on new buildings until the registration has either been made or it is withdrawn.iv.The process around the decision was flawed because the Council:a) breached the time frame required for urgent applications[8];[8] Section 29 of the Actb) relied on irrelevant information – namely, the five unsolicited objections from other residents and the number of already approved Garden City precincts; andc) rejected the recommendations of their independent report with no sound factual evidence or argument to the contrary.v.There is no information in the Tribunal documents (‘T’ documents) to explain why the initially positive response to the PLA report and listing of the precinct changed in the lead up to the vote on 9 July 2013.vi.The decision contains a number of inaccurate assertions and/or directly contradicts the PLA report in many areas – Garden City planning principles, precinct size, hierarchy of roads, front fences, housing design, pocket parks, hedges, garages, verge crossings and integrity.vii.The precinct is important as evidence of a distinctive way of life, taste, tradition, religion, land use, custom, process design or function that is no longer practised, is in danger of being lost or is of exceptional interest (Section 10, criterion (c) of the Act).viii.The precinct is a notable example of a kind of place or object and demonstrates the main characteristics of that kind (Section 10, criterion (g) of the Act). ix.The statement by the Council that, in response to it advising residents of the precinct and the ACT Planning and Land Authority of the nomination, it received five responses all opposing the nomination and none in support misrepresents the process undertaken by the Council. The Council never formally requested submissions from residents. The Council omitted mentioning 28 residents’ signatures supporting the urgent nomination for heritage listing.x.A heritage precinct is not a museum. Many of the Council’s claims that certain qualities diminish the value of the precinct are very minor in nature and assume that no change can take place in a precinct since its construction in the 1950’s.xi.Sections 47 to 50 Turner retain their integrity as an excellent late expression of Sulman Garden City planning and design. Section 47 is unusually intact due to its protection from development by the moratorium. The precinct is an aesthetically and culturally pleasing example of post-World War II planning in this city which is in imminent danger of being lost.