150 BRADDON PTY LTD & ACT HERITAGE COUNCIL (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

150 BRADDON PTY LTD & ACT HERITAGE COUNCIL (Administrative Review) [2013] ACAT 44

AT 13/18

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – Mural of heritage significance – whether the Mural is a heritage “place” or heritage “object”: distinction between a “place” and an “object” – provisional registration in heritage register – criteria of heritage significance: section 10 of the Heritage Act 2004 - definition section as aid to statutory interpretation

List of legislation:     ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT)

,


    

s 68

Heritage Act 2004 ss 3, 8, 10, 32, 40-42, 111, 114, 117 and 124
  Legislation Act 2001(ACT), ss 137

List of cases:             Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Kelly v R (2004) 205 ALR 274

Leon Fink Holdings Pty Ltd v Australian Film Commission (1979) 141 CLR 672

Tribunal:                  Ms E. Symons, Presidential Member (Presiding)
  Mr A Davey, Senior Member

Date of Orders:  5 July 2013  
Date of Reasons for Decision:         5 July 2013    

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AT 13/18

BETWEEN:

150 BRADDON PTY LTD

Applicant

AND:

ACT HERITAGE COUNCIL

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:            Ms E. Symons, Presidential Member (Presiding)

Mr A. Davey, Senior Member

DATE:5 July 2013

ORDER

  1. The decision of the ACT Heritage Council of 14 February 2013 that an entry to the heritage register be prepared for the place: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall, Braddon (part) Block 1 Section 8 Braddon, ACT is set aside and is substituted with a decision that an entry to the heritage register be prepared for the object: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall.

    ………………………………..

    Ms E. Symons – Presidential Member

    For and on behalf of the Tribunal

    REASONS FOR DECISION

Decision under review

  1. This is an application to review the decision of the ACT Heritage Council (‘the Council’) made on 14 February 2013, pursuant to section 40 of the Heritage Act 2004 (‘the Act’) to the effect that an entry to the Heritage Register be prepared for the place: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall (‘the Mural’), Braddon (part) Block 1 Section 8 Braddon, ACT. The Applicant is the registered proprietor of Block 1, Section 8 Braddon on which The Canberra Rex Hotel (‘the Rex Hotel’) is situated and where the Mural is located. The applicant applies to the Tribunal for a review of the Council’s decision, pursuant to section 114 of the Act.

Heritage registration

  1. The Mural was originally considered by the Council on 26 June 2008. The Minutes of Meeting 20 on 26 June 2008 (T 236) under the heading Nominations: Expansion Mural at Canberra Rex Hotel stated [1] “It was established that this mural is not public art. It is privately owned and integral to the building’s structure. It will be dealt with as an object.”

    [1] T 236

  2. On the ACT Government ACT Heritage Register Object List the Mural’s registration status was shown as ‘Provisionally Registered’ until June 2013.

  3. On 23 October 2012, the Council wrote to Mr Wayne Gregory at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 150 BRADDON PTY LTD & ACT HERITAGE COUNCIL (Administrative R... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ACAT 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter under review is an application to the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Tribunal) by the registered proprietor of Block 1, Section 8 Braddon, the site of The Canberra Rex Hotel, against the decision of the ACT Heritage Council (the Council) dated 14 February 2013. The dispute pertains to the classification of the 'Expansion' Mosaic Mural Wall (the Mural) as either a heritage "place" or a heritage "object". The applicant contends that the Mural should be classified as a heritage object rather than a heritage place, as it is privately owned, integral to the building's structure, and difficult to access. The Council had provisionally registered the Mural as a place of heritage significance, prompting the applicant to seek a review of this decision.

The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Mural should be classified as a heritage place or a heritage object under the Heritage Act 2004. The Tribunal had to determine whether the Mural, which was originally nominated for registration as an object, met the criteria for heritage significance as a place. The Tribunal also considered the definitions of "place" and "object" as provided in the Act, and the appropriate application of section 10 of the Act which outlines the criteria for heritage significance. The applicant argued that the Mural should be classified as an object due to its current location, which makes it difficult to access and view by the public. The Council's decision to classify the Mural as a place was contested on the grounds that it was originally intended to be registered as an object.

The Tribunal reviewed the Council's decision in light of the statutory definitions and the applicant's submissions. The Tribunal concluded that the Mural should indeed be classified as a heritage object, rather than a heritage place. The Tribunal noted that the Mural was originally nominated as an object, is privately owned, integral to the building's structure, and is currently located in a place that is difficult to access and view by the public. These factors align with the definition of a heritage object as provided in the Act. The Tribunal also considered the applicant's argument that the Mural should be classified as an object due to its current location and accessibility issues. Based on these considerations, the Tribunal set aside the Council's decision and substituted it with a decision that an entry to the heritage register be prepared for the object: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall.

The final order of the Tribunal was that the decision of the ACT Heritage Council dated 14 February 2013, which required the preparation of an entry to the heritage register for the place: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall, Braddon (part) Block 1 Section 8 Braddon, ACT, is set aside. In its place, the Tribunal ordered that an entry to the heritage register be prepared for the object: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall. This decision reflects the Tribunal's finding that the Mural should be classified as a heritage object based on the provided criteria and the applicant's submissions.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision of the ACT Heritage Council of 14 February 2013 that an entry to the heritage register be prepared for the place: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall, Braddon (part) Block 1 Section 8 Braddon, ACT is set aside and is substituted with a decision that an entry to the heritage register be prepared for the object: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the 'Expansion' Mosaic Mural Wall, located in Braddon, ACT, on Block 1, Section 8, within the premises of The Canberra Rex Hotel. The Applicant, the registered proprietor of the property, seeks a review of the ACT Heritage Council's decision to provisionally register the Mural as a place of heritage significance on the ACT Heritage Register. The Mural was originally considered by the Council on 26 June 2008 and was initially classified as an object due to its private ownership and integral nature to the building's structure. The Council later provisionally registered the Mural as a place of heritage significance on 23 October 2012, inviting the Applicant to provide written comments on the registration by 21 November 2012. The Applicant responded to the Council on 17 December 2012, arguing that the Mural should be classified as an object due to its capability of being moved, its current hidden location, and its difficult accessibility to the public.

This case involves an application to review the decision of the ACT Heritage Council made on 14 February 2013, pursuant to section 40 of the Heritage Act 2004. The Applicant, the registered proprietor of the property, applies to the Tribunal for a review of the Council's decision, pursuant to section 114 of the Act. The Tribunal is tasked with reviewing the Council's decision to register the 'Expansion' Mosaic Mural Wall as a place of heritage significance on the ACT Heritage Register and determining whether it should be classified as an object instead. This case presents an opportunity for the Tribunal to clarify the distinction between a heritage "place" and a heritage "object" and to assess the criteria for heritage significance as outlined in section 10 of the Heritage Act 2004.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The decision of the ACT Heritage Council of 14 February 2013 that an entry to the heritage register be prepared for the place: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall, Braddon (part) Block 1 Section 8 Braddon, ACT is set aside and is substituted with a decision that an entry to the heritage register be prepared for the object: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall. ………………………………..Ms E. Symons – Presidential MemberFor and on behalf of the TribunalREASONS FOR DECISION This is an application to review the decision of the ACT Heritage Council (‘the Council’) made on 14 February 2013, pursuant to section 40 of the Heritage Act 2004 (‘the Act’) to the effect that an entry to the Heritage Register be prepared for the place: ‘Expansion’ Mosaic Mural Wall (‘the Mural’), Braddon (part) Block 1 Section 8 Braddon, ACT. The Applicant is the registered proprietor of Block 1, Section 8 Braddon on which The Canberra Rex Hotel (‘the Rex Hotel’) is situated and where the Mural is located. The applicant applies to the Tribunal for a review of the Council’s decision, pursuant to section 114 of the Act. The Mural was originally considered by the Council on 26 June 2008. The Minutes of Meeting 20 on 26 June 2008 (T 236) under the heading Nominations: Expansion Mural at Canberra Rex Hotel stated [1] “It was established that this mural is not public art. It is privately owned and integral to the building’s structure. It will be dealt with as an object.”[1] T 236 On the ACT Government ACT Heritage Register Object List the Mural’s registration status was shown as ‘Provisionally Registered’ until June 2013. On 23 October 2012, the Council wrote to Mr Wayne Gregory at the Rex Hotel informing him that in accordance with section 32 of the Act, the Council had provisionally registered the Mural as a place of heritage significance[2] on the ACT Heritage Register (‘the Register’).[3] The Council invited Mr Gregory to provide written comments on the provisional registration by 21 November 2012.[2] Notifiable Instrument NI 2012 - 545[3] Applicant’s Statement of Facts and Contentions, page 2 Mr Gregory and his solicitor, Mr Alfonso del Rio from Clayton Utz, met with Mr Duncan Marshall (Chair of the Council) and Ms Fiona Kane (ACT Heritage Unit Team Leader) on 3 December 2012 to discuss the provisional registration of the Mural as a ‘place’ as opposed to an ‘object’. On 17 December 2012, the Applicant’s solicitors provided the Council with a written submission in response to the provisional registration of the Mural as a ‘place’ of heritage significance. In the Conclusion of the Submissions (T122) the Applicant’s solicitors stated “As the mural was originally nominated for registration as an object….is capable of being moved, and is currently located in a place which results in it being hidden from public view and difficult to access, the mural should be classified as an object rather than a place. Our clients support the application to list the mural as an object of heritage significance.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the nature of the 'Expansion' Mosaic Mural Wall and its status in the context of heritage significance. Initially, the Mural was considered by the ACT Heritage Council as a privately owned object integral to the building's structure, not public art, and therefore initially classified as an object. However, the Council later provisionally registered the Mural as a place of heritage significance, a decision which the Applicant contested. The court considered whether this provisional registration was appropriate under the Act. The court found that the Mural, being privately owned, capable of being moved, and currently hidden from public view and difficult to access, aligns more closely with the definition of a heritage "object" rather than a "place." This conclusion is based on the distinction that a "place" typically refers to locations or areas of public significance, while an "object" pertains to movable or privately owned items with heritage value. The court further applied the criteria for heritage significance under section 10 of the Heritage Act 2004, determining that the Mural's historical, aesthetic, scientific, or social significance warranted its classification as a heritage object. The court also considered the appropriateness of using the definition section of the Heritage Act 2004 as an aid to statutory interpretation, finding it suitable for clarifying the distinction between a "place" and an "object" within the context of the Act. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the classification of heritage items as either "place" or "object" should be determined based on their characteristics and context, in line with the definitions and criteria provided in the Heritage Act 2004.