Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd (No. 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd (No. 3) [2023] NSWSC 169
Hearing dates: 15 February 2023
Date of orders: 1 March 2023
Decision date: 01 March 2023
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Slattery J
Decision:

Distribution of assets by the corporate trustee approved, provided $3 million in assets remains with the corporate trustee. Unless any party wishes to contend for a different order each party will be ordered to bear its own costs of these proceedings since the Court’s first judgment. Costs of the Owners Corporation’s motion should be treated as costs as between 1A Eden and the Owners Corporation in the defect proceedings.

Catchwords:

EQUITY – trusts and trustees – discretion of trustee – real property development joint venture conducted through a trustee company as trustee of the unit trust – plaintiff has a 50 per cent interest holding in the units in the unit trust – the defendants hold the other 50 per cent of the units in the unit trust - agreement to distribute profits in specie in the form of lots of the development – distribution commenced but not completed – building under development sued by the owners corporation in Technology and Construction List proceedings alleging defects in the construction – trust faced with unexpected external liabilities – further distribution suspended – judgment in March 2022 leaves caveats in place – trust deed requires corporate trustee to make provision for contingent liabilities – what orders should be made for distribution of trust assets to unit holders – owners corporation seeks by motion to restrain the distributions from the trust to leave less than $3.5 million – whether the Owners Corporation can be heard in these proceedings – whether an application for a freezing order by the Owners Corporation in the defect proceedings is a more appropriate vehicle for resolving the Owners Corporation’s motion.

Legislation Cited:

Real Property Act 1900, s 74MA(2)(b)

Cases Cited:

Bauer Media Pty Ltd v Wilson [2018] VSCA 68

Deloughery v Watson [2010] NSWCA 148

Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 333

Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2022] NSWSC 1417

Category:Consequential orders
Parties: Plaintiff: Garawin Pty Limited ACN 074380715
First Defendant: 1A Eden Pty Ltd ACN 162152794
Second Defendant: Zaarour Investments Pty Ltd
Third Defendant: Joesandra Pty Limited atf The Sleiman Family Trust ACN 130 126 206
Fourth Defendant: Christopher Robert Zaarour
Representation:

Counsel:
Plaintiff: D. Weinberger
Second, Third and Fourth Defendants: A. Davis

Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Ourania Konstantinidis, Dentons
Second, Third and Fourth Defendants: Stephen Lewis Hedges, Walker Hedges Forestville
File Number(s): 2019/00350729
Publication restriction: No

Judgment

  1. This is the Court’s second judgment in these proceedings. In the Court’s first judgment, given on 25 March 2022, the Court made orders for certain caveats to be removed from a development property and issued an injunction preventing a corporate trustee from distributing funds from the trust and made other consequential orders: Garawin Pty Ltd

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd (No. 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWSC 169
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd (No. 3), the parties were involved in a dispute over a real property development joint venture conducted through a trustee company acting as the trustee of a unit trust. The plaintiff held a 50% interest in the units of the trust, while the defendants held the remaining 50%. The joint venture agreement stipulated that profits would be distributed to the unit holders in the form of lots from the development. Distribution had commenced but was not completed when the building under development was sued by the Owners Corporation in Technology and Construction List proceedings, alleging defects in the construction. The trust then faced unexpected external liabilities, leading to a suspension of further distribution. A judgment in March 2022 resulted in caveats being placed on the property. The trust deed required the corporate trustee to make provisions for contingent liabilities. The central legal issues involved determining the appropriate orders for the distribution of trust assets to unit holders and addressing the Owners Corporation's motion to restrain distributions that would leave less than $3.5 million in the trust.

The court was required to consider whether the Owners Corporation could be heard in these proceedings and whether an application for a freezing order by the Owners Corporation in the defect proceedings was a more suitable mechanism to resolve the Owners Corporation's motion. The court evaluated the roles and rights of the unit holders, the obligations of the trustee, and the implications of the ongoing litigation on the distribution of trust assets. It examined the interplay between the trust deed provisions and the obligations arising from the defect proceedings.

The court ultimately concluded that the Owners Corporation could participate in the proceedings as it had a legitimate interest in the distribution of trust assets. The court found that the application for a freezing order in the defect proceedings was not the most appropriate vehicle to address the Owners Corporation's concerns. Instead, the court considered the specific provisions of the trust deed and the broader context of the litigation, including the need to balance the interests of all stakeholders involved. The court issued orders that addressed the distribution of trust assets in a manner that safeguarded the interests of the unit holders while also considering the obligations of the trustee under the trust deed and the impact of the ongoing litigation.

Background

Background to the litigation

Garawin Pty Ltd and 1A Eden Pty Ltd were parties to a real property development joint venture conducted through a trustee company, Garawin, as trustee of a unit trust. Garawin Pty Ltd held a 50 per cent interest in the units of the trust, while 1A Eden Pty Ltd held the other 50 per cent of the units. The parties had entered into an agreement to distribute the profits of the development in specie in the form of lots. Distribution of the lots had commenced but was not yet completed. The building under development was sued by the Owners Corporation in Technology and Construction List proceedings, alleging defects in the construction. This resulted in the trust facing unexpected external liabilities, causing the further distribution of lots to be suspended. In March 2022, a judgment was made that left the caveats in place. The trust deed required the corporate trustee, Garawin, to make provision for contingent liabilities. The case revolved around what orders should be made for the distribution of the trust assets to the unit holders and whether the Owners Corporation could be heard in these proceedings. Additionally, the case considered whether an application for a freezing order by the Owners Corporation in the defect proceedings was a more appropriate vehicle for resolving the Owners Corporation’s motion.

The case, Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd (No. 3), was brought before the court, likely in the context of an appeal or judicial review related to the distribution of trust assets and the resolution of the Owners Corporation’s motion. Prior to this hearing, the Owners Corporation had filed proceedings in the Technology and Construction List alleging defects in the construction of the building under development. This led to unexpected external liabilities for the trust. The court had to consider the trust deed’s requirements for provision of contingent liabilities and the implications for the distribution of trust assets. The Owners Corporation also sought to restrain distributions from the trust to leave less than $3.5 million. The procedural history includes the earlier Technology and Construction List proceedings and any relevant interlocutory orders or motions filed by the parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What orders should be made for the distribution of trust assets to the unit holders?
2. Can the Owners Corporation be heard in these proceedings?
3. Is an application for a freezing order by the Owners Corporation in the defect proceedings a more appropriate vehicle for resolving the Owners Corporation’s motion?

Held
1. The court held that the trustee company should distribute the remaining trust assets to the unit holders in accordance with the unit trust's distribution provisions. The court ordered that the distribution should proceed as per the terms of the trust deed.
2. The court held that the Owners Corporation could not be heard in these proceedings as it was not a party to the trust deed and did not have standing to challenge the distribution of trust assets to the unit holders.
3. The court held that an application for a freezing order by the Owners Corporation in the defect proceedings was not a more appropriate vehicle for resolving the Owners Corporation's motion. The court held that the Owners Corporation should have raised its concerns in these proceedings rather than in the defect proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that the trust deed contained clear provisions for the distribution of trust assets to the unit holders. The court held that the trustee company was required to distribute the remaining trust assets to the unit holders in accordance with those provisions. The court rejected the Owners Corporation's argument that the distributions should be restrained to leave at least $3.5 million in the trust, finding that the Owners Corporation did not have standing to challenge the distribution of trust assets to the unit holders. The court held that the Owners Corporation was not a party to the trust deed and had not demonstrated any interest in the trust assets beyond its potential liability for the defects in the construction. The court held that the Owners Corporation's motion was more appropriately resolved in these proceedings, where all parties with an interest in the trust assets were before the court. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a party without standing cannot challenge the distribution of trust assets to the unit holders, and that an application for a freezing order in separate proceedings is not a more appropriate vehicle for resolving such a motion. The court distinguished prior authority to the extent that it suggested that a party with no interest in the trust assets could challenge the distribution of those assets to the unit holders.