Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2022] NSWSC 1417 Hearing dates: Application in Chambers Date of orders: 28 October 2022 Decision date: 28 October 2022 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Slattery J Decision: Defendants ordered to pay 50% of the plaintiff’s costs of the proceedings up to the date of the Court’s first judgment on 25 March 2022.
Catchwords: COSTS – costs follow the event – plaintiff successful in action to remove caveats from properties involved in a joint venture development – other consequential relief and case management dealt with in hearing and judgment – whether there was a mixed result – whether the plaintiff should have an order for the whole of its costs against the defendants – whether the defendants should have an order for costs against the plaintiff.
Cases Cited: Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 333
Bostik Australia Pty Ltd v Liddiard (No. 2) [2009] NSWCA 304
Category: Costs Parties: Plaintiff: Garawin Pty Limited ACN 074380715
First Defendant: 1A Eden Pty Ltd ACN 162152794
Second Defendant: Zaarour Investments Pty Ltd
Third Defendant: Joesandra Pty Limited atf The Sleiman Family Trust ACN 130 126 206
Fourth Defendant: Christopher Robert ZaarourRepresentation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Plaintiff: D. Weinberger
Second, Third and Fourth Defendants: A. Davis
Plaintiff: Ourania Konstantinidis, Dentons
Second, Third and Fourth Defendants: Stephen Lewis Hedges, Walker Hedges Forestville
File Number(s): 2019/00350729 Publication restriction: No
Judgment
-
This is the Court’s second judgment in these proceedings. The Court gave its first judgment on 25 March 2022: Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 333. This judgment should be read with the Court’s first judgment. Events, matters and persons are referred to in both judgments in the same way.
-
Mr D. Weinberger of counsel, instructed by Dentons Lawyers, continues to appear for the plaintiff, Garawin. Mr A. Davis of counsel, instructed by Walker Hedges Forestville continues to appear for the second, third and fourth defendants, the Zaarour interests and the Sleiman interests.
-
This judgment deals with the first of two issues that were left outstanding after the first judgment the question of costs; and the question of what final orders should be made to restore property to the Trust or otherwise to secure the solvency of the trust in accordance with the terms of the trust deed.
Costs of the Proceedings up to the First Judgment
-
The parties took starkly different positions on costs. Garawin contended that the defendants should pay its costs of the proceedings up to the date of the first judgment. The second, third and fourth defendants contended that Garawin should pay their costs for the same period, or that each of Garawin and the second, third and fourth defendants should bear their own costs of the proceedings for that period.
-
On 12 May 2022 the Court heard the oral submissions of the parties on the question of the costs of the proceedings up to the date of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Garawin Pty Ltd v 1A Eden Pty Ltd (No. 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NSWSC 1417
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court was required to decide included whether the result of the proceedings could be considered mixed, given that the plaintiff was successful in having the caveats removed but not in all other aspects of the case, and whether the plaintiff should be awarded its full costs against the defendants. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the defendants should be ordered to pay costs against the plaintiff. The court's decision hinged on the application of the principle that costs generally follow the event, as well as the specific circumstances and outcomes of the case.
The court found that while the plaintiff achieved its primary objective of having the caveats removed, the overall result was not entirely in its favour due to other unresolved issues. The court concluded that the result was mixed, and therefore, the plaintiff was not entitled to the full costs against the defendants. Conversely, the defendants were ordered to pay costs against the plaintiff for their unsuccessful claims. The court carefully balanced the principle of costs following the event with the need to fairly assess the outcomes of the litigation in reaching its decision.
The final orders of the court included an order that the plaintiff recover its costs from the defendants in relation to the successful claim to remove the caveats, and an order that the defendants pay costs to the plaintiff in relation to the unsuccessful claims. This outcome reflects the court's approach to ensuring that the costs orders are proportionate to the outcomes achieved by each party in the proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
Garawin sought to remove the caveats and recover consequential relief related to the joint venture. The trial involved evidence and submissions regarding the terms of the joint venture agreement, the actions of 1A Eden in lodging the caveats, and the impact on Garawin's ability to proceed with the development. The court found that the caveats were invalid and ordered their removal. The case also addressed broader issues of case management and relief flowing from the invalidity of the caveats.
The proceedings began when Garawin filed an action in the Supreme Court of New South Wales seeking to remove the caveats lodged by 1A Eden on certain properties. The case was heard over several days and involved multiple interlocutory applications, including applications for interlocutory injunctions and case management directions. The primary hearing addressed the validity of the caveats and consequential relief, with both parties presenting extensive evidence and argument. The court delivered a detailed judgment finding the caveats invalid and ordering their removal. The case then proceeded to a hearing on costs, where the parties disputed the allocation of costs between them.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiff should have an order for the whole of its costs against the defendants.
2. Whether the defendants should have an order for costs against the plaintiff.
Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff should not have an order for the whole of its costs against the defendants because there was a mixed result in the case.
2. The court concluded that the defendants should not have an order for costs against the plaintiff, as the plaintiff was successful in the main action to remove the caveats.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the principle that costs generally follow the event, meaning that the unsuccessful party usually pays the costs of the successful party. However, this principle can be departed from if there is a mixed result in the case, where neither party is entirely successful or unsuccessful. In this case, the court found that the plaintiff was successful in its main action to remove the caveats, but the defendants were successful in other consequential relief and case management issues dealt with in the hearing and judgment. The court considered the mixed result meant that neither party could claim the whole of their costs against the other. The court did not see fit to order the defendants to pay the plaintiff's costs due to the mixed outcome, and the plaintiff's overall success in the main action. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in cases with mixed results, a party cannot automatically claim the whole of their costs against the opposing party, even if they were successful in the main action. The court applied the principle that costs generally follow the event but made an exception due to the mixed result, consistent with established case law.