G J Brown & Co Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

G J Brown & Co Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board [2016] AATA 740 (23 September 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers

2015/6228

2016/2116

Re

GJ Brown and Co Pty Ltd and

Gregory Brown

APPLICANTS

And

Tax Practitioners Board

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member A C Cotter

Date 23 September 2016
Place Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.

.............................[Sgd]...........................................

Senior Member A C Cotter

Catchwords

TAX AGENTS –  renewal of registration – termination of registration – eligibility for registration -- whether individual applicant is a fit and proper person – good fame, integrity and character – where individual applicant is sole director of corporate applicant – compliance with taxation laws – where individual applicant lodged own income tax returns late – where individual applicant guilty of offences against taxation laws – where corporate applicant has either lodged late or not lodged income tax returns, FBT returns and BAS – where entities controlled by the individual applicant also lodged returns late or not at all – decisions under review affirmed

Legislation

Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth), ss 2-5, 20-5, 20-15, 20-25, 30-10, 40-5, Part 3
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), s 8C

Cases

Delis & Anor and Tax Practitioners Board [2015] ATC 10-408
Delis v Tax Practitioners’ Board [2016] FCA 570
Hughes and Vale Proprietary Limited  v New South Wales
(1955) 93 CLR 127
Stasos v Tax Agent’s Board
(1990) 21 ALD 437
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond
(1990) 170 CLR 321
Carbery and Associates Pty Ltd and Tax Agent’s Board of Queensland
[2001] AATA 107
Re Proh and Tax Agents’ Board of Victoria
(2010) 78 ATR 663
Re Phillip Same Accountants Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board
(2010) 79 ATR 292
Phillip Same Accountants Pty Ltd v Tax Practitioners Board [2011] FCA 36
Toohey and Tax Agents’ Board of Victoria
[2009] AATA 603
Re Adamec and Tax Agents’ Board of Victoria
(2005) 60 ATR 1243

Secondary Materials

Explanatory Paper TPB (EP) 01/2010: Code of Professional Conduct
Explanatory Paper TPB (EP) 02/2010: Fit and Proper Person

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A C Cotter

23 September 2016

INTRODUCTION

  1. In October 2015, the Tax Practitioners Board (“Board”) rejected the application of GJ Brown & Co Pty Ltd (“Company”) for renewal of its registration as a tax agent under the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (“Act”).[1] That was on the basis that the Board was not satisfied that Mr Gregory Brown, the Company’s sole director and himself a registered tax agent, was a fit and proper person.[2] As such, the Company did not meet the eligibility requirements for renewal of registration under the Act.

    [1] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 1, pages 9-13, letter from Board to Mr Brown dated 3 November 2015.

    [2] Ibid, page 9, [4].

  2. The following February, the Board decided to terminate Mr Brown’s own registration as a tax agent because he had ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirement that he be a fit and proper person.[3]

    [3] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read G J Brown & Co Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 740
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by G J Brown & Co Pty Ltd (the Company) and Mr G J Brown against decisions made by the Tax Practitioners Board (the Board). The dispute centred on the eligibility of Mr Brown, the sole director of the Company, and consequently the Company itself, for registration as a tax agent. The Board had determined that Mr Brown was not a fit and proper person to be registered, which in turn rendered the Company ineligible for registration.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Brown was a "fit and proper person" within the meaning of the relevant Act, and whether the Company was eligible for registration given Mr Brown's status. The Tribunal was required to consider the extensive history of non-compliance with taxation laws by both Mr Brown personally and by entities he controlled, including the Company and a Practice Trust. This non-compliance involved late lodgement of income tax returns and Business Activity Statements, as well as outstanding tax liabilities and director penalty liabilities.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal considered the meaning of "fit and proper person" as interpreted in previous case law, including decisions of the Tribunal and the Federal Court. The Tribunal noted that the expression requires a broad judgment, taking into account the conduct of the individual in the context of the activities they are engaged in and the ends to be served by those activities. The Tribunal found that Mr Brown's conduct, including significant and prolonged non-compliance with his own taxation obligations and those of entities he controlled, demonstrated a lack of good fame, integrity, and character. This extensive non-compliance, spanning many years and involving substantial tax liabilities, led the Tribunal to conclude that Mr Brown was not a fit and proper person.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decisions under review. It ordered that Mr Brown's registration as a tax agent be terminated pursuant to section 40-5(1)(b) of the Act. As a result of this finding, the Company was deemed ineligible for registration under section 20-5(3)(a) of the Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

Part 3 of the Act contains the Code of Professional Conduct (“Code”).[9] The Board has developed explanatory papers on topics such as the Code,[10] and Fit and Proper Person considerations,[11] although they do not have the force of law and are intended to provide general guidance only.[9] See particularly s 30.10.[10] Exhibit 1, T Documents, ST 24, pages 270-333: Explanatory Paper TPB (EP) 01/2010: Code of Professional Conduct.[11] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 6, pages 41-70: Explanatory Paper TPB (EP) 02/2010: Fit and Proper Person.BACKGROUND The factual background to the Board’s decisions concerning the Company and Mr Brown is largely uncontentious, although Mr Brown took issue with some points and sought to explain others, or put them in context. Also, by the time of the hearing before me, Mr Brown had taken steps to address, or attempt to address, a number of issues that had been of concern to the Board in reaching its decisions. That background to the Board’s decisions is set out in some detail in its Statement of Issues, Facts and Contentions,[12] which I summarise briefly below, by reference to both the Company and Mr Brown. Later, I outline Mr Brown’s evidence and contentions, noting in particular where he disagrees or where he places a different emphasis or complexion on particular matters, and where he has taken steps to address the Board’s concerns. [12] Exhibit 2, Board’s Statement of Issues, Facts and Contentions dated 10 June 2016.The Company Between July 2011 and October 2015, the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation issued three separate statutory demands to the Company for substantial sums in respect of outstanding tax liabilities owed by it. Two of those demands resulted in the Deputy Commissioner commencing winding up proceedings, which ultimately did not proceed. The third statutory demand was allowed by the Deputy Commissioner to expire due to settlement negotiations.[13][13] Ibid, [9]-[16]. In April 2014, the Board found that the Company had breached s 30-10(2) of the Code, in that it had failed, as trustee of the GJ Brown Practice Trust (“Practice Trust”) through which the Company operated, to ensure that the Practice Trust lodged: its income tax returns for the 2003 to 2012 financial years by their respective due dates; and its Business Activity Statements (“BAS”) for the months ended May 2012 to August 2013, by their respective due dates. The Board gave the Company a written caution, advising that should it apply for renewal of registration as a tax agent, its compliance with its own tax obligations would be reviewed by the Board.[14][14] Ibid, [17]-[19]. When the Company applied for renewal of registration in July 2015, the question was asked whether there were matters that may affect its eligibility for registration, to which Mr Brown answered “yes”. Asked for details and an explanation as to why it should not be taken to adversely affect the Company’s eligibility for registration, Mr Brown responded: “Outstanding lodgements and pending conviction”.[15] [15] Ibid, [20]-[21]; Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 3, page 19, Tax Agent Renewal dated 28 July 2015.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As at 9 June 2016, Mr Brown, as sole director of the Company, had outstanding director penalty liabilities totalling $32,401.13.[27] His total outstanding personal tax liabilities were $44,059.79 (up from $39,440.53 in October 2015), comprising $10,160.20 in Running Balance Account deficit debt and $33,899.59 in income tax liabilities.[28] [27] Ibid, [35].[28] Ibid, [36]-[37].MR BROWN’S EVIDENCE Mr Brown gave evidence at the hearing. He outlined in detail the history of the matter, admitting that it was not something of which he was proud. He said his problems dated back to 2002, and that he has been “struggling since then to dig (himself) out of the issues”. Mr Brown was first registered as a tax agent in November 1979.[29] Early in his career, he had practised with others through jointly owned companies. He recognised that he had poor human resources practices and that he could not manage a large practice. Therefore, he decided to practise as a sole practitioner. [29] Exhibit 3, Applicants’ Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 11 July 2016, page 1. From 2001 to 2005, he operated his practice as an accountant and tax agent through the Company (which was registered as a tax agent in July 2000). The breakdown of the joint operations and his commencement as a sole practitioner placed significant strains on him and his family. That culminated in his marriage breaking down. He commenced a sustained period of counselling with a psychologist.[30][30] Ibid. In April 2005, he appeared in the Brisbane Magistrates Court and was found guilty of an offence of failing to comply with a notice to furnish a return for the 2002 financial year. He said that the Magistrate was fully aware that he was a tax agent, and did not record a conviction. He was placed on a bond with a surety for six months. Mr Brown believes that the light penalty was given in recognition of the other issues affecting him at the time. Nevertheless, he said that court appearance was a “wake up call” and served to pull him out of the depression from which he was then suffering. During the 2006 financial year, Mr Brown took steps to reduce the size of his practice. He effectively gave away over half of his practice to a colleague in Tasmania (from where he originally came) and, by agreement, ceased to act for many other clients.[31][31] Ibid. Notwithstanding that decision, he had substantial overheads disproportionate to the reduced size of his practice. He changed the emphasis of his practice to consulting, still primarily reliant on his skills as an accountant and tax agent but less reliant on compliance as the core function.[32] [32] Ibid. From about 2004, Mr Brown had maintained his accounting records using the QuickBooks range of accounting software. At the end of the 2006 financial year, he dismissed his office bookkeeper who had been engaged to maintain ledger records for himself, the Company, the Practice Trust, and other entities. He took the step to dismiss her because the work had not been completed within the expected timeframe and because of the large number of errors in the data that had been processed. At some stage prior to her dismissal, the bookkeeper had password locked the files. She refused to divulge the passwords following her dismissal. Another employee thought that they could access the files, but was unable to do so, despite persistent attempts. After consultation with the QuickBooks help desk, it was arranged to copy the files and send them to QuickBooks, as CD copies, for the purpose of unlocking the files and resetting the passwords. QuickBooks charged $100.00 per file for that exercise, which was expected to be a routine process. However, the files were found to be corrupted when QuickBooks unlocked them. A second copy sent some months later was also found to be corrupted; it appears that the constant attempts to copy the files or unlock them had inadvertently corrupted them. After about eight months of attempts, QuickBooks finally advised that Mr Brown would have to start new files and re-enter the data. However, due to the lapse in time, all backup copies of files had been over-written and were no longer recoverable.[33] Some seven years of records were affected. [33] Ibid, page 2.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows from what I have said that I consider that Mr Brown’s registration should be terminated, pursuant to s 40-5(1)(b) of the Act.CONCLUSION For the reasons outlined above, I consider that Mr Brown is not a fit and proper person to be registered as a tax agent under the Act. As a consequence, the Company is not eligible for registration, by reason of s 20-5(3)(a) of the Act. In view of my findings that Mr Brown’s non-compliance had been extensive and over an extended period of time, I consider that his registration as a tax agent should be terminated under s 40-5(1)(b) of the Act. Accordingly, the decisions under review are affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In response to the Board’s submission as to lack of corroboration of aspects of his evidence, Mr Brown said that it would be difficult for him, at this stage, to go back and recover supporting information and material.CONSIDERATIONIs Mr Brown a “fit and proper person” within the meaning of the Act?What does the expression “fit and proper person” mean? Although s 20-15 of the Act sets out matters that the Board is to have regard to when deciding whether it is satisfied that an individual is “fit and proper”, that expression is not otherwise defined in the Act. It has, however, been the subject of much consideration by both this Tribunal and the courts in this and not dissimilar contexts. Indeed, the meaning of the expression in the context of the Act was recently the subject of detailed consideration by this Tribunal in Delis & Anor. v Tax Practitioners Board (“Delis”),[45] and then on appeal from that decision in the Federal Court.[46] In light of that recent and comprehensive consideration of the authorities by both the Tribunal and the Court, I do not propose embarking on a fresh exposition of the earlier case law. Rather, I propose to highlight a number of points from Tribunal’s and Court’s decisions which have particular relevance here.[45] [2015] ATC 10-408.[46] Delis v Tax Practitioners Board [2016] FCA 570. In considering the meaning of the expression in Delis, Senior Member Fice had reference to the decision of the High Court in Australia in Hughes and Vale Proprietary Limited v New South Wales,[47] in which it was said that the expression‘s purpose “is to give the widest scope for judgement and indeed for rejection”.[48] [47] (1955) 93 CLR 127. (See also Delis [2015] ATC 10-408, [86]).[48] Ibid, 156 (Dixon CJ, McTiernan and Webb JJ). Reliance was also placed on the observations of Toohey and Gaudron JJ in Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond :The expression “fit and proper person”, standing alone, carries no precise meaning. It takes its meaning from its context, from the activities in which the person is or will be engaged and the ends to be served by those activities. The concept of “fit and proper” cannot be entirely divorced from the conduct of a person who is or will be engaging in those activities. However, depending on the nature of the activities, the question may be whether improper conduct has occurred, whether it is likely to occur, whether it can be assumed that it will not occur, or whether the general community will have confidence that it will not occur.[49][49] (1990) 170 CLR 321,380. (See also Delis [2015] ATC 10-408, [85]). Senior Member Fice also referred to the obiter remarks of Hill J in Stasos v Tax Agents’ Board (“Stasos”),[50] to the effect that the legislature had conferred on registered tax agents a virtual monopoly in the preparation for reward of income tax returns and objections and in relation to the transactions of any business on behalf of a taxpayer in income tax matters for reward. The conferral of that “privilege”, as Hill J described it, “carries with it a consequent set of obligations and responsibilities”:A person is required, before being registered as a tax agent to demonstrate that he is a fit and proper person to prepare income tax returns and transact business on behalf of clients in tax matters and, inter alia, that as at the date of application he is of good fame, integrity and character…In addition to the tax agent dealing with his client, he will, almost invariably have dealings with officers of the Australian Taxation Office and perhaps the boards or tribunals to which I have already referred. Those dealings must be able to be carried on in an atmosphere of mutual trust… The commissioner and his officers must be able, also, to accept the word of a tax agent when acting for a taxpayer in negotiations, and a fortiori in matters proceeding in a Board, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal or indeed a court it is imperative that the honesty and integrity of the tax agent not be called into doubt. So it is that it is a requirement, not only of initial registration, but of remaining on the register that a tax agent be a fit and proper person to perform the duties of a tax agent and bear the responsibilities that come with those duties.[51][50] (1990) 21 ALD 437. (See also Delis [2015] ATC 10-408, [87]).[51] Ibid, 443-444 (Hill J).