Borella and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Borella and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) [2022] AATA 2489 (8 August 2022)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION 

File Number(s):2022/4204      

Re:Terry Borella  

APPLICANT

Tax Practitioners BoardAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member G Lazanas

Date:8 August 2022  

Place:Sydney

Pursuant to s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal decides:

1.    subject to (2), the decision under review is stayed pending final determination of the substantive matter or until further order of the Tribunal;

2.    the Applicant:

(a)  agrees to not take on any new clients;

(b)  undertakes to continue to negotiate with the Australian Taxation Office in good faith in relation to a settlement of his tax debt;

(c)   undertakes to update the Respondent in writing of the progress of the negotiations on a monthly basis on the first business day of each month; and

(d)  must inform his clients, on or before close of business on 22 August 2022, by way of letter in a form approved by the Respondent, of the administrative action taken by the Respondent and the proceedings currently on foot at the Tribunal.

3.    the stay order will lapse if the Applicant fails to comply with the requirements in (2).

...............................[SGD]...................................
Senior Member G Lazanas

  1. On 31 March 2022, the Respondent, the Tax Practitioners Board (Board) determined that the Applicant, Mr Borella, had breached certain sections of the Code of Professional Conduct in the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (TASA) and therefore ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirement that he is a fit and proper person for the purposes of the TASA. Consequently, the Board decided to terminate Mr Borella’s tax agent registration and preclude him from applying for registration for a period of two years.

  2. On 26 May 2022, Mr Borella applied to the Tribunal for a review and stay of those decisions. Broadly, s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act) allows the Tribunal to make an order that stays the operation or implementation of the decision under review.

  3. On 1 July 2022, the Tribunal ordered, consistent with the agreement reached between Mr Borella and the Board, that the reviewable decisions be stayed on an interim basis until the Tribunal hears and determines the stay application, subject to three conditions:

    (1)Mr Borella does not take on any new clients;

    (2)Mr Borella undertakes to continue to negotiate with the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) in good faith in relation to the settlement of his tax debt; and

    (3)Mr Borella undertakes to update the Board in writing of the progress of the negotiations on a monthly basis on the first business day of each month.

  4. On 22 July 2022, the Tribunal heard the stay application. Mr Borella’s legal representative submitted that the stay should continue on the three agreed conditions. The Board does not oppose a continued stay but only on the proviso that the stay is subject to a further condition that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Borella and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 2489
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Borella and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation)*, Mr Borella sought a stay of the Tax Practitioners Board's decision to terminate his tax agent registration and impose a two-year ban, pending his application for review. The dispute concerned whether a conditional stay should be granted, and specifically, whether a condition requiring Mr Borella to notify his clients of the Board's administrative action and the ongoing proceedings was appropriate.

The court was required to determine the factors relevant to granting a stay, including the prospects of Mr Borella's success on review, the consequences if a stay were not granted, and the public interest. It also had to consider the potential impact on the Board in carrying out its functions and whether the substantive application would be rendered nugatory. A key issue was the appropriateness of imposing a condition that Mr Borella inform his clients of the situation.

The court reasoned that Mr Borella bore the onus of establishing that a stay was warranted and that any conditions imposed were appropriate. Despite Mr Borella not filing evidence, the court considered submissions and documents. It noted Mr Borella's history of non-compliance with his personal taxation obligations and a previous agreement with the Board that he had breached. The court found that while a stay would not render the substantive review nugatory, the public interest in the integrity of the tax agent registration regime weighed in favour of imposing conditions. The court considered that Mr Borella's conduct, including repeated failures with his personal tax affairs and breaches of a formal agreement, raised concerns about his suitability as a tax agent.

Ultimately, the court ordered that the reviewable decisions be stayed, but on four conditions. Three conditions were agreed upon by the parties, and the fourth was the "Client Notification Condition," requiring Mr Borella to notify his clients of the Board's actions and the proceedings. The court was not persuaded that a stay should be granted without this additional condition, citing reservations about Mr Borella's prospects of success and the need to protect the public interest in the integrity of the tax agent registration regime.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Borella, as the party seeking the stay, bears the burden of establishing that a stay is warranted and whether or not conditions should be imposed. THE FACTUAL BACKGROUND Mr Borella did not file any evidence in support of his stay application but relied on written and oral submissions by his legal representative at the hearing. His legal representative also referred me to certain documents contained in the T-Documents and to certain factual matters outlined in the Board’s written submissions. Mr Borella has been a registered tax agent under the TASA, and its equivalent, since 1995. Over the years, including in 2000, 2004, and in 2016, Mr Borella has had several interactions with the Board (as well as its predecessor agency) in relation to his tax agent registration owing to either his inability or unwillingness to comply with his personal taxation obligations. The information regarding Mr Borella’s interactions in 2000 and 2004 was vague because Mr Borella’s legal representative did not have all the background facts, and those matters predated the Board in its current form. However, it was common ground that the Board had on at least one occasion initiated disciplinary action against Mr Borella which found its way to the Tribunal. In 2020, that dispute was resolved by way of terms of settlement between the parties formalised by a Tribunal order dated 17 June 2020 under s 42C(1) of the AAT Act (42C Agreement).[1] The 42C Agreement required Mr Borella to comply with all his personal taxation obligations which included compliance with the terms of his current payment arrangements with the ATO in respect of outstanding income tax (IT) and integrated client account (ICA) liabilities until those liabilities are fully discharged. The 42C Agreement also required Mr Borella to complete a course in the TASA and the Code of Professional Conduct within three months of the 42C Agreement.[1] A redacted form of the 42C Agreement was included in the T-Documents at T5, pp 56-57. Mr Borella breached the 42C Agreement as he failed to comply with all his personal tax obligations including payment arrangements. He also failed to complete the course within the required timeframe. With respect to his tax payment arrangements, it transpired that on or about 16 January 2021, Mr Borella entered a payment arrangement with the ATO to repay his outstanding IT debt of approximately $76,000 and his outstanding ICA debt of approximately $230,000. On 7 April 2021, Mr Borella defaulted on the payment arrangement for his ICA debt and on 18 October 2021, he defaulted on his IT debt payment arrangement. Moreover, as of 31 March 2022, the date of the reviewable decisions, Mr Borella had failed to lodge three quarterly Business Activity Statements (BASs) by their respective due dates. These include the BASs for the quarterly periods ending 31 March 2021, 30 June 2021 and 30 September 2021. Furthermore, as of 21 July 2022 (the day before the stay hearing), Mr Borella had failed to lodge a further two BASs for the quarterly periods ending 31 December 2021 and 31 March 2022 by their respective due dates. Mr Borella also failed to lodge his IT return for the year ending 30 June 2021 by the due date and this was still outstanding as at the date of the stay hearing.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

If Mr Borella were to succeed in the substantive review, the review would not be rendered nugatory as Mr Borella could continue his tax agent business and, to the extent impacted by the conditions, notify his clients and rebuild his business even though there may have been some disruption. This consideration weighs in favour of the Tribunal granting a stay with conditions.CONCLUSION The consideration of the abovementioned factors weighs in favour of ordering the stay. In particular, the public interest considerations do not weigh significantly against making a stay order as there does not appear to be unacceptable risk to Mr Borella’s clients. I am also satisfied the stay would promote the effectiveness of the hearing, however, I consider it is appropriate that the reviewable decisions be stayed on conditions. As to the conditions, I am not persuaded that it is desirable to grant the stay without the additional Client Notification Condition. Based on the materials before the Tribunal, I have some reservations at to Mr Borella’s prospects of success. Additionally, the public interest in the integrity of the tax agent registration regime would also not be served by granting a stay that did not involve the Client Notification Condition. I find that it is appropriate that the reviewable decisions be stayed with four conditions, namely, the three agreed conditions and the fourth condition, the Client Notification Condition.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

These assertions were not supported by any probative evidence and are to be given little weight. In any event, the likely consequences of a conditional stay, including that Mr Borella’s clients may choose another tax agent, are due to Mr Borella’s own failures to adhere to the high standards of professionalism which the community is entitled to expect from a registered tax agent and which the Board is responsible for regulating. These matters weigh to some extent against the Tribunal granting a stay without the Client Notification Condition.Public interest considerations The Board argued that the Client Notification Condition is appropriate because there is a public interest in ensuring that Mr Borella’s existing clients are aware of the regulatory action so as to be given the opportunity to make an informed choice about whether they wish to remain clients. The Board argued that Mr Borella risked prejudicing his clients as his inability to manage his own tax affairs meant he had a fractious relationship with the ATO, thus potentially compromising his ability to deal with the ATO on behalf of his clients.[2] In this regard, the Board relied on the decision of Davies J in Su and Tax Agents’ Board of South Australia [1982] AATA 127 where it was held that a tax agent’s failure to comply with tax obligations may in turn reflect on their handling of their client’s taxation affairs and render them unsuitable as a tax agent.[2] T-Documents at T6, p 132. The Board also relied on M&A Corporate Accountants Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board [2021] AATA 4523 which concerned a tax agent’s application for a stay in similar circumstances of the tax agent being non-compliant with his personal tax lodgements and payments and where the Tribunal ordered a conditional stay which involved notifying the tax agent’s clients. Mr Borella denied that there is any such public interest requirement and argued that because there are no client complaints, he should be allowed to preserve and protect his reputation and his clients as he was a competent tax agent. He argued that it was premature to take action to notify his clients before the final decision on the reviewable decisions. Mr Borella’s arguments must be considered in the context of the regulatory regime for tax practitioners, which is set out in the TASA and administered by the Board. For an individual to be eligible to be a registered tax agent, the Board must be satisfied that the individual is a “fit and proper person”: s 20-5 of TASA. The Board must have regard to specified criteria to determine whether an individual is a fit and proper person, most importantly, “whether the individual is of good fame, integrity and character”: s 20-15 of TASA. Mr Borella’s conduct involved repeated failures with respect to his personal tax affairs. Those failures, both as to lodgements and payments, were exacerbated by Mr Borella’s failure to adhere to the 42C Agreement. That non-compliance of itself demonstrates that any conditional stay in the present case may afford insufficient protection to the public.