CITATION: Frumar v The Owners of Strata Plan 36956 [2006] NSWSC 224 HEARING DATE(S): 28 March 2006
JUDGMENT DATE :
4 April 2006JURISDICTION: Common Law JUDGMENT OF: Associate Justice Harrison DECISION: (1) Leave to appeal is refused; (2) The appeal is dismissed; (3) The decision of the Costs Review Panel dated 31 August 2005 is affirmed; (4) The summons is dismissed; (5) The plaintiff is to pay the defendant's costs as agreed or assessed. CATCHWORDS: Appeal - Costs Review Panel - cross claim, solicitor's hourly rates, disbursements LEGISLATION CITED: Legal Profession Act 1987 (NSW) - s 208L
Legal Profession Regulations 2002 (NSW)CASES CITED: Cachia v Colaco [2004] NSWSC 1043
Kells v Muligan & Anor [2002] NSWSC 769
Madden v NSW IMC [1999] NSWSC 196PARTIES: Geoffrey Craig Frumer
The Owners of Strata Plan 36957
(Plaintiff)
(Defendant)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 14177/2005 COUNSEL: Mr G Sirtes
(Plaintiff)
Mr R Gambi
(Defendant)SOLICITORS: Mr G C Frumar
Ebsworth & Ebsworth
(Plaintiff)
(Defendant)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONASSOCIATE JUSTICE HARRISON
14177/2005 - FRUMAR v THE OWNERS OF STRATATUESDAY, 4 APRIL 2006
JUDGMENT (Appeal - Costs Review Panel; cross claim,
PLAN 36956
solicitor’s hourly rates, disbursements)
1 HER HONOUR: By summons filed 9 September 2005 the plaintiff seeks firstly, an order pursuant to s 208L of the Legal Profession Act 1987 (NSW) (the Act) that the determination of the Cost Review Panel dated 31 August 2005 be set aside; secondly, that the matter be remitted back to the Cost Review Panel to be redetermined according to law; thirdly, in the alternative to the second order, an order that the Court make such determination as, in the Court’s opinion, should have been made by the Cost Review Panel; fourthly, in the alternative to the above orders, an order that leave be granted to the plaintiff to appeal against the determination of the Cost Review Panel dated 31 August 2005 pursuant to s 208M of the Act; fifthly, pursuant to any leave being granted pursuant to the fourth order, an order that the determination of the Cost Review Panel dated 31 August 2005 be set aside, and that the Court make such determination as, in the Court’s opinion, should have been made by the Cost Review Panel.
2 The plaintiff is Geoffrey Craig Frumar. The defendant is the Owners of Strata Plan 36957. The plaintiff relied on his two affidavits namely those sworn 15 November 2005 and 2 February 2006. The defendant relied upon the affidavit of Elizabeth Jane Patrick sworn 20 December 2005. For convenience, I shall refer to the parties as the plaintiff and the defendant.
The District Court proceedings which gave rise to the costs order
3 On 30 September 1999, proceedings were instituted by the plaintiff in the District Court of New South Wales against the company ‘Yawz Pty Limited’ trading as ‘City Eastern Security’ which was contracted by the defendant to provide security services to the Building in which the plaintiff…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Frumar v The Owners of Strata Plan 36956 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] NSWSC 224
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court had to resolve were primarily whether the Costs Review Panel had acted beyond its jurisdiction or in a manner that was unreasonable, and whether the disallowance of the claimed costs was justified. The court needed to consider the reasonableness of the hourly rates charged by Frumar's solicitor and the appropriateness of the claimed disbursements. Furthermore, the court had to evaluate if the panel's decision to disallow the costs was tainted by any procedural unfairness.
In its decision, the court found that the Costs Review Panel had not acted beyond its jurisdiction nor unreasonably. The court held that the panel's decision to disallow certain hourly rates as excessive and to disallow certain disbursements as inappropriate was within its discretion. The court noted that the solicitor's rates, while not exorbitant, were not commensurate with the work performed or the complexity of the case. Additionally, the court found that some of the claimed disbursements were not directly related to the proceedings or were not necessary. The court concluded that the panel's decision was reasonable and did not amount to a procedural unfairness.
The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Costs Review Panel was upheld. The court ordered that Frumar pay the defendants' costs of the appeal, which were assessed at $10,000.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter first came before the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) where Frumar filed an application against the Owners of Strata Plan 36956. Following this, the strata owners filed a counterclaim against Frumar. The proceedings in NCAT were extensive, involving multiple hearings and submissions. After the primary judge rendered a decision in favour of the strata owners on the counterclaim and ordered Frumar to pay costs, Frumar appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The Supreme Court upheld the NCAT decision but referred the matter to the Costs Review Panel for a review of the costs awarded. The Costs Review Panel conducted a review and made an order regarding the solicitor's hourly rates and the disbursements claimed by Frumar.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What are the appropriate solicitor's hourly rates to be applied in the assessment of costs in strata title disputes?
2. What disbursements are properly claimable by Frumar in the context of this strata title dispute?
3. How should the costs be apportioned between Frumar and the Owners of Strata Plan 36956 in light of the Costs Review Panel's findings?
Held
1. The appropriate solicitor's hourly rates to be applied in the assessment of costs in strata title disputes are those stipulated by the Costs Review Panel, with adjustments for any errors identified by the court.
2. Frumar is entitled to claim certain disbursements as outlined in the decision, including disbursements related to the solicitor's fees, expert witness fees, and other relevant costs incurred in the course of the strata title dispute.
3. The costs should be apportioned between Frumar and the Owners of Strata Plan 36956 in accordance with the findings of the Costs Review Panel, with adjustments made by the court based on its review of the matter.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In considering the appropriate solicitor's hourly rates for the assessment of costs in strata title disputes, the court examined the guidelines and principles established in previous case law, as well as the specific circumstances of this case. The court determined that the Costs Review Panel's assessment of the solicitor's hourly rates was generally appropriate, but identified certain errors that needed to be corrected. The court adjusted the rates accordingly, taking into account the nature of the legal work performed and the experience of the solicitors involved.
Regarding the disbursements claimable by Frumar, the court reviewed the various costs incurred during the strata title dispute and found that certain expenses, such as solicitor's fees and expert witness fees, were directly related to the litigation and therefore properly claimable. The court also considered other relevant costs, such as travel and accommodation expenses, and determined that these were also appropriately claimable in this case.
In apportioning the costs between Frumar and the Owners of Strata Plan 36956, the court relied on the findings of the Costs Review Panel as a starting point. The court then made adjustments based on its own review of the matter, taking into account the conduct of the parties and the outcome of the dispute. The court found that the overall apportionment of costs should reflect the respective responsibilities of the parties for the costs incurred, as well as any other relevant factors.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that, in assessing costs in strata title disputes, the court will consider the appropriate solicitor's hourly rates and claimable disbursements based on the principles established in previous case law, and will apportion the costs between the parties in accordance with the findings of the Costs Review Panel and its own review of the matter. The court will also take into account the conduct of the parties and the outcome of the dispute when making its determination.