Frost and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

Applicant:Ms Ashlee Jacqui Frost

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2024/8140

Tribunal:General Member A. E. Burke

Place:Melbourne

Date:31 December 2024

Decision:Pursuant to section 105 of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision. In substitution the Tribunal finds there is another reason under section 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to revoke the mandatory cancellation of Ms Frosts’ visa.

.............................[SGD]...........................................

General Member A. E. Burke

Catchwords

MIGRATION – mandatory cancellation of visa – New Zealand citizen – Class BS Subclass 801 Partner visa – failure to pass character test – serious offending – whether another reason mandatory cancellation should be revoked – Ministerial Direction No. 110 applied – ties to Australia and best interests of minor children considered – decision set aside

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Cases

Assistant Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Splendido [2019] FCAFC 132
FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185
Hughes v The Queen (2017) 263 CLR 338
Khalil and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2022] AATA 3563
LZGG and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2020] AATA
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559
Rano v Minister for Home Affairs, Minister for Cyber Security [2024] FCA 1003
Tanielu v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCA 673

Jagroop v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] 241 FCR 461

Secondary Materials

Jacek Debiec, ‘A sudden and lasting separation from a parent can permanently alter brain development’, The Conversation (online, 22 June 2018) <A sudden and lasting separation from a parent can permanently alter brain development>.

Caleb D. Lloyd, Nick Chadwick and Ralph C. Serin, ‘Associations between gambling, substance misuse and recidivism among Canadian offenders: a multifaceted exploration of poor impulse control traits and behaviours’ (2014) 14(2) International Gambling Studies, 279.

Rizeanu, Steliana, Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy and Clinical Applications, Chapter 9 Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for Gambling Addiction (InTech, 2018).
Direction No. 110 – Migration Act 1958 – Direction under section 499: Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA

Explanatory Memorandum, Administrative Review Tribunal Bill 2023 (Cth)

S.S. Merkouris et al, ‘Predictors of outcomes of psychological treatments for disordered gambling: A systematic review’ (2016) 48 Clinical Psychology Review, 7.

Julia Gillard, ‘National Apology for Forced Adoptions’ (Speech, Great Hall, Parliament House Canberra, 21 March 2013).

Statement of Reasons

  1. On 24 January 2024 a delegate of the Minister, administering the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Minister), cancelled Ms Frost’s Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) Visa under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. On 2 February 2024 Ms Frost provided a response to the decision requesting revocation of the decision to cancel her visa for other reasons:

    There is an extremely low…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Frost and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ARTA 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Frost v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved a New Zealand citizen, Ms Frost, who had her visa cancelled under section 501CA of the Migration Act due to her failure to pass the character test. The Tribunal had to decide whether the cancellation should be revoked, considering factors outlined in Ministerial Direction No. 110. Ms Frost's offending stemmed from a severe gambling addiction, which led to fraudulent activities, including using her employer's credit cards for personal gambling and selling travel credits. The Tribunal examined whether there was another reason to revoke the cancellation, taking into account the legal consequences, impediments if removed, and the impact on Australian business interests.

The Tribunal concluded that the primary legal consequence of the visa cancellation was Ms Frost's removal from Australia and her inability to return. This outcome aligns with the purpose of the statutory framework, which seeks to exclude individuals who pose a risk to the Australian community. The Tribunal also considered Ms Frost's ties to Australia, particularly her two minor children, and the detrimental impact on their well-being if she were to be removed. The Tribunal noted that Ms Frost's gambling disorder and past traumatic experiences had significantly influenced her offending behaviour, and her imprisonment could exacerbate her mental health issues. Given these considerations, the Tribunal decided to set aside the decision to cancel Ms Frost's visa, allowing her to remain in Australia.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing of her application on 12 and 13 December 2024 Ms Frost was represented by Ruth Hamnett Counsel, and Ms Catherine Oppel, solicitor at Australian Government Solicitor, appeared for the Minister. The Minister lodged a set of paginated G-Documents, summons documents from Corrections Victoria, Queensland and Victoria Police. Ms Frost submitted numerous statements from family and friends, psychological reports and other documentation.BACKGROUND Ms Frost is a 37 year old New Zealand citizen who arrived in Australia at the age of 21. Ms Frost completed her secondary education in New Zealand growing up with her father after her parents separated when she was around six years of age. On 3 January 2008 Ms Frost, arrived in Australia on a 444 visa, she resided in Sydney until 2015 and worked predominately in administrative roles. Ms Frost worked in a call centre, in an administrative role at a gym and then as an executive assistant at True Solutions, CSL Behring from 2017 to 2019 and Target between November and December 2019. Ms Frost’s mother and new partner moved to Australia around 2010 and in 2012 Ms Frost’s father and new wife moved to Australia. Ms Frost commenced a relationship with her ex-partner in 2011, having known him from school, she relocated to Melbourne in 2015 to live with him and in 2020 they relocated to Mackay. In 2019 Ms Frost gave birth to her first daughter and her second daughter in 2021, both have resided in Australia since birth and are New Zealand citizens. Ms Frost’s offending commenced in 2018 and continued for some four years until she was remanded in Custody in 2022. In her witness statement, dated 29 November 2024 for these proceeding Ms Frost provided the following background to her offending:31.In Sydney, I was drinking three or four nights a week and going out every weekend. My gambling also started when I came to Australia as I had a friend who would do it. It started out as something we would do casually on the weekend and we would go to the pokies or to the races. We would do it on the weekends but not really throughout the week.…33. Peter was very nasty and would call me names constantly. He cheated on me twice as well. If I went out and wore a crop top he would ignore me for days. He physically abused me a few times. Once he grabbed me by the shirt and pushed me to the ground. On another occasion, I was lying in bed and he threw me around the room, took my phone and crushed it. On another occasion he grabbed my shirt and punched towards it. This happened when we were on the street and other people called the police. I didn’t tell them anything because I was worried for my kids and didn’t want them to see their dad getting arrested. There were no IVOs issued by either of us.34.My gambling started to pick up in 2015 when I moved to Melbourne and in around 2017 and 2018, it really escalated. My preferred app was SportsBet and I was gambling everyday. Peter didn’t know that I was gambling at all. Some of my family and friends knew I gambled casually but no one knew the extent of it.…38.My offending stemmed from my gambling addiction. I was gambling every day from around 2017 or 2018. My gambling of choice was through SportsBet and I would usually bet on horse and dog racing. I would occasionally place bets on rugby or basketball but it was mostly horses and dogs. I was working at CSL Behring at the time.39.On one occasion, a friend had given me $3000 to book accommodation for Christmas. I gambled the money away and needed to work out how I would book the group accommodation without the money. As part of my job, I would book accommodation as needed for my bosses. I put the Christmas accommodation booking on the work credit card and no one noticed. Gambling had taken such a strong hold that I kept doing it and no one noticed still.40.I would book accommodation on the work credit card and then cancel the booking. I would receive a travel credit. I saw on Gumtree that people were willing to buy these travel credits at a discounted rate. I would then on sell the travel credit and vouchers. I first sold them to a woman I met on Facebook Marketplace and she then told her friends. To get more money, I started selling the vouchers in advance of actually receiving the credit. For example, I would sell them to someone and then I would book the accommodation for them directly when they needed it.41.My intentions were to put the money back and I tried as much as I could when I was working at CSL Behring. All of the money that I took went into gambling. I lost over $800,000 through my SportsBet account. At the time, Peter and I were living with Peter’s parents. My only expenses were $100 towards board and the rest of my money went towards gambling. In my head I was going to put all the money back but it kept spiralling and I dug myself into a bigger hole.42.I fell pregnant in 2019 and had a very difficult first trimester and was very unwell. I did not tell anyone at work that I was pregnant as I had miscarried four times previously so didn’t want to tell anyone until I knew the baby was going to be ok. Because I was so unwell, I took a lot of time off work. They let me go while I was pregnant for underperformance which was realistically because I was not coming to work because I was sick.43.I continued gambling and continued selling travel vouchers even when I stopped working at CSL Behring. I started selling fake vouchers because I was so desperate to get more money to keep gambling. People started to notice when they tried to book things that their vouchers weren’t working. Another person noticed when they went to check in to their accommodation that I had booked for them and it hadn’t been paid for. I was making excuses that I couldn’t keep selling credits or booking holidays because I didn’t have the money to keep doing it because I was gambling it all. People who I had sold them to started asking for refunds and eventually went to the police.44.After this, I legitimately sold a jacket on Facebook Marketplace. The woman who bought it transferred me the money but said she couldn’t pick it up for a few days. I then decided to keep doing this but not posting the items that they had bought to keep gambling.45.Peter was working throughout this whole period and I was a stay at home mum to our daughter. There were issues with how I was spending the money he would give me for groceries and other things. He would give me say $200 to go grocery shopping for our family and I would buy $50 of food and spend the rest on gambling. Peter would come home and question me about why there wasn’t much food. I would make excuses like the girls were having a tantrum so couldn’t do the whole shop. I would then have to find the money to do the grocery shopping the next day because I had already spent it on gambling.46.I have nothing to show from my fraud and taking of the money. Every single cent went into gambling. I have no savings. I did not live a lavish lifestyle or spend money on clothes. I didn’t spend money on my daughter, every single cent went into gambling.47.When the police found out, I was arrested and bailed. I was then arrested for a few more of the same incidents and remanded. My criminal lawyer in Mackay negotiated with the police to try and avoid a prison sentence to avoid me having migration issues. I was sentenced to 18 months prison that was suspended for three years. This was for the Facebook Marketplace selling clothes and not sending them offending.48.When that case was finished in court, Victoria Police were there and they arrested me and extradited me to Victoria to face charges relating to the fraud for my employer and the fraud in selling the travel credits. I have been in Dame Phylis Frost Centre since this time. I was sentenced to three years and five months prison for my offending.LEGISLATION

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, the issue for consideration by the Tribunal is whether the cancellation of Ms Frost’s visa should be revoked, taking into account the relevant considerations in Ministerial Direction No 110 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA. In essence, the Tribunal must be satisfied there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked.EVIDENCEMs Frost’s Offending The following table has been derived from a national criminal history check relating to Ms Frost produced by the Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission on 16 October 2023: Ms Frost’s total effective sentence for her 1 September 2023 convicts was three years, five months and four days’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of one year and eight months fixed which included one sentence for 22 months imprisonment. In her sentencing remarks on 1 September 2023 Her Honour Judge Chambers described Ms Frost’s offending:5 Between 13 December 2017 and 4 September 2019, you were employed by CSL as an executive assistant working in Broadmeadows. In this role you provided administration and management support to six CSL executives. This included organising the travel arrangements for executives for which you were provided access to their company provided credit cards. You were only authorised to use the credit cards under instruction from the cardholders for work-related purchases.6 On 4 September 2019 your employment was terminated by CSL for poor performance.7 Soon after this, CSL identified suspicious transactions on a credit card of an executive who had previously been based in Broadmeadows but had left to work in Germany. The transactions were ongoing despite the fact that executive no longer worked at CSL. Following this CSL conducted a forensic audit of your work-issued laptop which disclosed more anomalous transactions CSL reported the matter to police on 26 November 2019.8 Your offending on this indictment relates to the 93 occasions between August 2018 and September 2019 that you made fraudulent transactions using the six company credit cards issued by CSL to its executives.9 In the majority of these transactions you would purchase flights or accommodation on the executive credit cards and later cancel these bookings. A credit would then be reimbursed to you. You would use this financial advantage by on-selling the credit at a discounted price.10 On other occasions you utilised merchant payment services such as PayPal or Stripe to credit money directly into your personal bank accounts. You did this by creating a PayPal account using the details of the actual CSL cardholders but registered to your own email address. In this way you avoided detection.11 The charges to which you have pleaded guilty relate to the 93 fraudulent transactions you made using the executive issued credit cards12 Between 27 December 2018 and 26 August 2019 you also attempted to obtain credits totalling $17,501.23 using four of the executive credit cards to purchase hotel accommodation, furniture and tickets to various events. However, these transactions were unsuccessful and as such the credit cards were never debited the full amounts. These attempted transactions are the subject of Charge 7, an attempt to obtain a financial advantage by deception.13 During the period of your employment with CSL you obtained a financial advantage in the sum of $392,030.39 in addition to your attempt to obtain a financial advantage totalling $17,501.23. The amount of all transactions, both successful and unsuccessful, totalled $409,531.62.14 While employed by CSL you paid back the sum of $111,300 by reversing some of the transactions. This occurred before your offending was detected by CSL.15 Accordingly, the actual loss suffered by CSL as a result of your offending was $280,730.39.16 The offending on the second indictment occurs after your employment with CSL was terminated and you moved to live in Queensland in June 2020. Between 11 June 2020 and 17 November 2020 you engaged in deceptive conduct in relation to eight separate victims, each of whom lived in Victoria, obtaining a benefit of $225,200.17 In each case you either purported to be an employee of Webjet or someone who knew an employee of Webjet who had been affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. You also held yourself out as a travel agent. Your offending involved making fraudulent representations to victims that you or other Webjet employees were suffering severe financial difficulties due to the COVID-19 lockdowns and were selling personal staff travel credits to fund yourself or others through the pandemic. You then offered to sell the travel credits at a significantly discounted rate than their asserted value.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In making a decision under ss 501(1), 501(2) or 501CA(4) of the Act, the considerations below must also be taken into account, where relevant, in accordance with the following provisions. These considerations include (but are not limited to):·Legal consequences of the decision;·Extent of impediments if removed; and·Impact on Australian business interests.Legal consequences of the decision The Direction reminds decision-makers to be mindful that unlawful non-citizens are liable for removal from Australia as soon as reasonably practicable (see s 198 of the Act), noting that s 197C(1) of the Act provides that, for the purposes of s 198, it is irrelevant that Australia has non-refoulement obligations in respect of an unlawful non-citizen. SubmissionsMs Frost Counsel contented that if Ms Frost’s visa cancellation is not revoked she will be liable for removal from Australia as soon as reasonably practicable and would be unable to re-enter Australia where almost all of her immediate and extended family reside. Counsel submitted Ms Frost’s ability to see her children will be dependent on her ex-partner’s willingness and financial and practical ability to take the children to New Zealand to visit her. Counsel submitted Ms Frost’s evidence had been she did not know how or if Mr Frost would bring the children to visit her in New Zealand and her father’s evidence was he thought that it would be maximum once a year visit if at all. Counsel submitted both Ms Frost and her father gave evidence that she currently does not have meaningful communication with her children via zoom or phone because this is too difficult for them. Counsel submitted Ms Frost’s ability to communicate in a meaningful form or interact with her young children, particularly of pre-school age would be impossible if her visa was revoked. Counsel contended that telephone and video communication would not be a meaningful way to maintain a mother-daughter relationship. Counsel submitted there was a real question around whether or not Ms Frost would have any contact with her children again if her visa was cancelled. Counsel submitted whether Ms Frost’s ex-partner would bring the children to New Zealand or allow zoom calls given his previous conduct in saying that he would facilitate contact but not following through on his promises.Respondent Counsel contented this consideration should be given neutral weight by the Tribunal. Counsel accepted that a consequence of Ms Frost’s visa cancellation and its non-revocation is that it will be very difficult for her to return to Australia; and this is the intended legal consequence of the protective regime.Summary finding The Tribunal concurred with the parties that the legal consequence of Ms Frost’s visa cancellation would be her removal and inability to return to Australia, noting his Honour Judge Feutrill’s recent decision in Rano v Minister for Home Affairs, Minister for Cyber Security [2024] FCA 1003:Relevantly, the legal consequence of the Minister’s decision is that the applicant will be removed from Australia and cannot satisfy the special return criteria in cl 5001 of Sch 5 of the Regulations. In substance, that means that the applicant is ineligible for most classes of visa that would otherwise relate to him. That is not a matter of speculation. It is not necessary to wait for an application for a visa to be made to know that he cannot be granted a visa in any of the applicable classes. Therefore, the practical reality in human terms that flows from the legal consequences of the Minister’s decision is that the applicant will be removed from Australia and, thereafter, will be precluded from travelling to, entering and (or) remaining in Australia unless he is able to bring himself within the criteria of a visa class to which the special return criteria does not apply. In much the same way that a legal consequence may be characterised as ‘indefinite detention’, the legal consequence here may be characterised as removal and ‘indefinite exclusion’ from Australia. Moreover, in my view, not only is that a legal consequence it is manifestly a purpose of the applicable statutory framework and scheme that includes s 501(3).It is evident that a purpose of specifying that the special return criteria be satisfied for the various visa classes in Sch 2 is that persons who have had their visas cancelled under s 501(3) cannot satisfy the visa criteria and, therefore, cannot be granted visas in those classes and lawfully travel to, enter and (or) remain in Australia. It would plainly defeat a purpose of s 501(3) of the Act if persons who have had their visas cancelled on the grounds of national interest could, upon removal from Australia, immediately be granted a visa and return to Australia because all other criteria for the grant of that visa are satisfied.It follows that the applicant’s indefinite exclusion from travel to, entry and (or) remaining in Australia was a legal consequence of a decision to cancel his visa under s 501(3) of the Act. Accordingly, that was a consideration the Minister was bound to take into account.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Gina Cidoni, registered psychologist, in a sentencing report dated 9 August 2023 provided the following opinion of Ms Frost’s psychological functioning, the impact of this on her offending and potential imprisonment, treatment recommendations, prospects of rehabilitation, and risk of reoffending. In the report she opined:47. Psychological Testing…52. Her profile was valid, and there were no signs of exaggeration or faking good or bad on her profile.…54. Summary and Opinion55. The following are my conclusions regarding Ms Frost, based upon the above history, her self-report, psychometric testing, and evaluation findings.56. Cognitive Function:57. She is a 35-year-old woman where upon presentation, there appeared to be no obvious impairments and she did not report any risk factors suggestive of injury.58. Clinical and Personality Diagnoses:59. The clinical evaluation indicated she has the following clinical diagnoses in line with the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5):- Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (C-PTSD)- Gambling Disorder (severe) in early remission.-Alcohol Use Disorder (sustained remission in a controlled environment)60. Her diagnoses have profoundly affected her daily life, resulting in financial hardship, emotional turmoil, and relationship difficulties. These challenges are further compounded by her complex family history, characterised by sexual abuse as a child and young adult, and persistent domestic violence.61. Her experiences and psychological sequelae have likely interacted with her predisposition to gambling, intensifying her struggles. The complexity of her history of sexual abuse as a child and young adult, along with persistent domestic violence exposure, led to an increased reliance on alcohol and gambling as a coping mechanism. The emotional distress and financial hardship resulting from these traumatic experiences could have driven her towards these as a temporary escape or a way to regain control.62. Moreover, the compulsive aspects of personality may have further fuelled these behaviours, making them more severe and challenging to overcome. All these factors collectively shaped the development of her addictive disorders, including gambling.63. Mental State at the Time of the Alleged Offending:64. At the time of the alleged offence, her mental state was influenced by her gambling addiction and heavy drinking. In combination, these factors contributed to impaired decision-making and emotional regulation difficulties, leading to her engaging in financial deceptions. This situation aligns with the principles outlined in R v Verdins, where her mental impairment at the time of the offence impacted her ability to understand the wrongfulness of her actions or control her behaviour.…66. Reoffending Risk and Recommendations:67. Her risk of reoffending is influenced by a range of factors, including her gambling addiction, substance use, past traumatic experiences, and mental health challenges. These factors contribute to impulsive decision making and difficulties in managing emotions, increasing the likelihood of engaging in behaviours that may lead to reoffending.68. To mitigate these risks, it is important for her to undergo targeted therapeutic interventions that address her addictive behaviours, and mental health concerns, and provide coping strategies for emotional regulation.69. A comprehensive treatment plan should incorporate cognitive-behavioural therapy to target her addictions, trauma-focused therapy to address her past traumatic experiences, and counselling to enhance her overall emotional well-being.70. Additionally, support in developing healthier coping mechanisms, life skills, and relapse prevention strategies can play a pivotal role in reducing her risk of reoffending and fostering positive change.71. Impact of Imprisonment:72. Given her history of instability, including enduring mental health challenges, her current mental state is significantly impacting her. Traits such as impulsivity and difficulties with emotional regulation may lead to heightened vulnerability within the prison context. Her struggles with emotional regulation might contribute to mood swings and difficulty coping with the confined and potentially high-stress environment of prison.73. Although specialised mental health support is crucial for her well-being, she is likely too preoccupied with the immediate challenges of daily survival, coping with the overwhelming demands and maintaining herself day to day. Ensuring that she receives the necessary support will be vital in managing these challenges and promoting her overall mental health.74. Her separation from her children has created a deeply troubling situation. Her estranged husband's refusal to facilitate any form of contact in another state compounds the distress. This separation places her children at serious risk of profound and lasting disadvantage. The absence of maternal care during crucial formative years can hinder their emotional, psychological, and social development, potentially leading to anxiety, feelings of abandonment, and difficulties in forming healthy relationships. Her children's cognitive development and academic performance may also suffer.75. On Ms Frost's side, this separation is causing immense emotional anguish, guilt, and a sense of powerlessness. The connection she has with her children, coupled with her concern for their well-being, exacerbates her stress and depression. The loss of daily interactions and routines that come with caring for her children further isolates her.PRIMARY CONSIDERATIONSPrimary Consideration 1: Protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct (paragraph 8.1)