Friend v Vacvator Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

Citation:

Friend v Vacvator Pty Ltd [2023] NSWPIC 224

APPLICANT: Andrew Friend
RESPONDENT: Vacvator Pty Ltd
Member: Karen Garner
DATE OF DECISION: 5 April 2023
date of amendment: 16 May 2023

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workers Compensation Act 1987; claim for weekly compensation pursuant to section 33; medical and related expenses of L5/S1 anterior interbody spacer surgery pursuant to section 60; lump sum compensation for permanent impairment pursuant to section 66; applicant had accepted injury to left hip which respondent alleged had resolved; whether the applicant sustained injury to his lumbar spine pursuant to sections 4(a), 9A and 4(b); Held – applicant sustained injury to his lumbar spine arising out of and in the course of his employment pursuant to section 4(a) and his employment was a substantial contributing factor pursuant to section 9A; applicant sustained injury to his lumbar spine in the nature of an aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation or deterioration of a disease process to which his employment was the main contributing factor pursuant to section 4(b)(ii); the proposed L5/S1 anterior interbody spacer surgery is reasonably necessary; the applicant was and remained totally incapacitated for work as a result of the injury to his left hip and lumbar spine from 13 April 2021 and continuing; the applicant’s condition has not stabilised and attained maximum medical improvement and accordingly it is not appropriate to refer the matter to a Medical Assessor for assessment of whole person impairment and determination of permanent impairment compensation pursuant to section 66; accordingly, the respondent is ordered to pay the costs of and incidental to L5/S1 anterior lumbar interbody fusion surgery in accordance with section 60; the respondent is ordered to pay the applicant weekly compensation in the amount of $1,401 per week from 14 April 2021 to date, and continuing, pursuant to section 37(1); the application for permanent impairment compensation pursuant to section 66 is dismissed.

determinations made:

The Commission determines:

  1. The applicant sustained injury to his lumbar spine on 8 September 2020 arising out of and in the course of his employment with the respondent pursuant to s 4(a) of the 1987 Act and his employment was a substantial contributing factor pursuant to s 9A(1) of the 1987 Act.

  2. The applicant sustained injury to his lumbar spine on 8 September 2020 in the nature of an aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation or deterioration of a disease process to which his employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor pursuant to s 4(b)(ii) of the 1987 Act.

  3. The treatment proposed by Dr Coughlan in a letter dated 1 March 2021, being L5/S1 anterior lumbar interbody fusion surgery, is reasonably necessary as a result of injury on 8 September 2020.

  4. The applicant was and remained totally incapacitated for work as a result of the injury to his left hip and lumbar spine from 13 April 2021 to 7 March 2023.

  5. The applicant’s condition has not stabilised and attained maximum medical improvement and accordingly it is not appropriate to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Friend v Vacvator Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 224
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Friend v Vacvator Pty Ltd, the applicant, Mr Friend, sought compensation from his employer, Vacvator Pty Ltd, under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the Act). The primary issues before the court were whether Mr Friend sustained an injury to his lumbar spine arising out of and in the course of his employment, whether his employment was a substantial contributing factor to the injury, and whether he was entitled to compensation for the injury, including weekly compensation and medical expenses. The dispute also included claims for permanent impairment compensation.

The legal issues before the court were to determine whether Mr Friend's lumbar spine injury arose out of and in the course of his employment, whether his employment was a substantial contributing factor to the injury, and whether the proposed L5/S1 anterior interbody spacer surgery was reasonably necessary. Additionally, the court had to decide if Mr Friend was totally incapacitated for work and if his condition had stabilised to allow for the assessment of whole person impairment.

The court held that Mr Friend sustained an injury to his lumbar spine on 8 September 2020, arising out of and in the course of his employment, and that his employment was a substantial contributing factor to the injury. The court also found that the proposed L5/S1 anterior interbody spacer surgery was reasonably necessary. Furthermore, the court determined that Mr Friend was and remained totally incapacitated for work from 13 April 2021 to 7 March 2023. However, the court found that Mr Friend’s condition had not stabilised and attained maximum medical improvement, and thus it was not appropriate to refer the matter to a Medical Assessor for the assessment of whole person impairment and determination of permanent impairment compensation at that time.

The court ordered Vacvator Pty Ltd to pay the costs of and incidental to the proposed L5/S1 anterior interbody spacer surgery in accordance with section 60 of the Act. The court also ordered Vacvator Pty Ltd to pay Mr Friend weekly compensation in the amount of $1,401 per week from 14 April 2021 to 7 March 2023, and continuing, pursuant to section 37(1) of the Act. The application for permanent impairment compensation was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As noted at the conclusion of this Statement of Reasons, the original Certificate of Determination and Statement of Reasons has been amended. As noted above, the insurer’s letter dated 21 October 2022,[8] stated that it maintained a dispute pursuant to ss 33, 59 and 60 in respect of left hip injury and pursuant to ss 4, 9A, 33, 59 and 60 of the 1987 Act in respect of lower back injury. Whilst the insurer accepted that the applicant had an injury to his left hip, it stated that the effect of the injury has now ceased. In respect of the applicant’s back, it declined injury outright. The notice did not deal with the claim for permanent impairment compensation.[8] ARD, page 22. At the hearing, Mr Goodridge, counsel for the applicant, stated that the applicant does not press any claim for compensation in relation to the applicant’s right hip and accepts that there should be an award for the respondent in relation to the right hip. The parties agree that the following issues remain in dispute in relation to the applicant’s left hip and lumbar spine:(a) in relation to the lumbar spine:(i)whether the applicant sustained injury, arising out of or in the course of employment and his employment was a substantial contributing factor to the injury, pursuant to ss 4(a) and 9A of the 1987 Act, and(ii)whether the applicant contracted a disease or sustained aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation or deterioration of disease, arising out of or in the course of employment and his employment was the main contributing factor to the disease or the aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation or deterioration of disease, pursuant to ss 4(b)(i) and (b)(ii) of the 1987 Act;(b) in relation to the left hip and the lumbar spine:(i)whether the applicant has total or partial incapacity for work resulting from an injury and the extent and quantification of any entitlement to weekly compensation, pursuant to s 33 of the 1987 Act;(ii)whether medical or related treatment is reasonably necessary as a result of an injury, pursuant to ss 59 and 60 of the 1987 Act, and(iii)whether the applicant is entitled to permanent impairment compensation, pursuant to s 66 of the 1987 Act. The following documents were in evidence before the Commission and considered in making this determination: (a) ARD and attached documents, and(b) Reply and attached documents. No application for cross-examination was made and no oral evidence was given. The applicant gave evidence by way of a statement dated 21 October 2021. The applicant stated that, for almost his entire working life prior to the alleged injury, he engaged in fitting and welding work of a physical nature, he rarely ever took time off work for any reason and he never had a treating practitioner because he had no requirement to consult one. The applicant stated that he was injured on 8 September 2020, during the course of his employment with the respondent in the position of fitter mechanic. The mechanism of injury was that the applicant was going up an A-frame ladder without handles whilst carrying an item in his left hand which weighed approximately 8 to 12kg. The process by which the applicant ascended the ladder was that, as he continued to hold the item in his left hand, he reached his right hand up and grabbed the frame of the ladder, then stepped his feet up until both feet were on the same step, and then again reached his right hand further up the ladder to steady himself. As the applicant proceeded up the ladder, he was twisting with the weight of the item hanging down by his side in his left arm. The applicant felt an immediate sensation of a pulling in his left groin area together with a sharp shooting pain. The applicant was immediately concerned about the pain and shortly after that he got off the ladder. The applicant initially thought that he had just strained a muscle, however as he began to move around after he got off the ladder he noticed that, with movement, he had a sharp, shooting intermittent pain going around the outside of his left thigh. The sharp, shooting pain stopped if the applicant was not moving around however the pain on the inner side of his groin remained constant. The applicant disputes, as inaccurate, the history recorded by Associate Professor Miniter that he was simply ascending stairs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By notice dated 10 May 2023, the applicant opposed the respondent’s request for reconsideration. The applicant:(a) stated that the order should be that the respondent pay the costs of and incidental to the surgery proposed by Dr Coughlan set out at page 63 of the ARD;(b) agreed that the weekly compensation pursuant to s 37(1) of the 1987 Act is to be calculated on the basis of 80% of PIAWE of $1,401, as indexed, being $1,120.80 per week;(c) agreed that the Commission has no power to award any compensation pursuant to s 37(1) of the 1987 Act beyond 7 March 2023;(d) stated that the applicant has now made a claim for compensation pursuant to s 38 of the 1987 Act and requested that the matter be listed for conference for consideration of an entry of an award pursuant to s 38 of the 1987 Act;(e) agreed that there should be an award for the respondent in respect of the right hip. I note that the parties are effectively substantially in agreement as to errors which require to be corrected and I am satisfied that those errors do require correction. Having considered the parties submissions in relation to the request for reconsideration, I am satisfied that it is appropriate in the interests of justice to amend the Certificate of Determination and Statement of Reasons to correct errors and clarify the position, in a manner which is effectively substantially agreed between the parties. For convenience, the amendments have been identified by underlining. I do not consider that it is appropriate for me to relist the matter for further conference to deal with a claim for weekly compensation pursuant to s 38 of the 1987 Act as requested by the applicant nor for me to make any order in that regard. An application for weekly compensation pursuant to s 38 of the 1987 Act was not the subject of these proceedings. The applicant would be required to commence separate proceedings before the Commission in that regard if appropriate. On that basis, I determine that:(a) the applicant sustained injury to his lumbar spine on 8 September 2020 arising out of and in the course of his employment with the respondent pursuant to s 4(a) of the 1987 Act and his employment was a substantial contributing factor pursuant to s 9A(1) of the 1987 Act;(b) the applicant sustained injury to his lumbar spine on 8 September 2020 in the nature of an aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation or deterioration of a disease process to which his employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor pursuant to s 4(b)(ii) of the 1987 Act;(c) the treatment proposed by Dr Coughlan in a letter dated 1 March 2021, being L5/S1 anterior lumbar interbody fusion surgery, is reasonably necessary as a result of injury on 8 September 2020;(d) the applicant was and remained totally incapacitated for work as a result of the injury to his left hip and lumbar spine from 13 April 2021 to 7 March 2023, and(e) the applicant’s condition has not stabilised and attained maximum medical improvement and accordingly it is not appropriate to refer the matter to a medical assessor for assessment of whole person impairment and determination of permanent impairment compensation pursuant to s 66 of the 1987 Act at this time.