FremantleMedia Ltd & 19 TV Ltd v Zhidi Liu

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by FremantleMedia Limited and 19 TV Limited to registration of trade mark application 1193217(18, 20, 21, 28, 35, 44) - IDOL PETS I DO LOVE PETS - filed in the name of Zhidi Liu.

Delegate: Alison Windsor
Representation: Opponent:  Susan Chrysanthou of counsel instructed by Hodgkinson McInnes Patents
Applicant:  Did not appear
Decision: 2010 ATMO 57
S52 opposition:  ground established under section 60 – likelihood of deception or confusion if opposed trade mark is used – application refused – costs awarded against applicant.

Background

  1. Zhidi Liu of Auckland, New Zealand (“the applicant”) filed an application to register a trade mark, current details of which appear below:

Number 1193217
Filed on: 15 August 2007
Goods and services: Class 18:  Leashes (leads) for animals; collars for animals; clothing for pets
Class 20:  Beds for domestic pets; beds for household pets; carriers for transporting domestic pets (other than cages); feeding mats for domestic pets; hutches for pets; kennels for household pets; materials for use as beds for domestic pets; nesting boxes for household pets; pet cushions
Class 21:  Brushes for grooming pet animals; cages for household pets; containers for pet food; covers for cages for household pets; food bowls for pets; food containers for pet animals; litter boxes (trays) for pets; litter scoops for use with pet animals; litter trays (for pets); plastic containers for dispensing drink to pets; plastic containers for dispensing food to pets; restraining cages for household pets; wire cages for household pets
Class 28:  Toys for domestic pets; toys for pet animals
Class 35:  Distribution of goods (not being transport services) (agent, wholesale, representative services, by any means); management of a retail enterprise for others; retail services
Class 44:  Adoption agency all relating to pets; advisory services relating to the care of pet animals; care of pets; grooming of pets; pet grooming; pet therapy services
Trade Mark:
  1. The application was examined as required by section 31 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”) and as no grounds for rejection were identified, it was advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 13 December 2007 as accepted for possible registration.

  2. On 31 January 2008, two parties jointly filed a Notice of Opposition (“the Notice”) to the registration.  The parties are Fremantlemedia Limited and 19 TV Limited, both of London in the United Kingdom.  As the parties are acting jointly, I shall refer to them as “the opponent”. 

  3. The opponent completed service and filing of its evidence in support on 27 November 2008.  The applicant was advised of the deadline for providing its evidence in answer, but did not respond.  In fact, despite numerous documents being served upon the recorded address for service, nothing further was heard from the applicant.

  4. The opponent requested a hearing, and I was delegated by the Registrar of Trade Marks to hear the matter in Sydney on 10 May 2010.  Susan Chrysanthou of counsel appeared…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FremantleMedia Ltd & 19 TV Ltd v Zhidi Liu and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ATMO 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

FremantleMedia Ltd and 19 TV Ltd (the opponent) opposed the registration of trade mark application 1193217 by Zhidi Liu. The opposition was based on several grounds, but the Hearing Officer, Alison Windsor, ultimately decided the matter solely on the ground provided for under section 60 of the relevant Act. The opponent's evidence, primarily a statutory declaration from Steven Rosser, Director of Legal and Business Affairs for FremantleMedia Australia Pty Ltd, detailed the extensive use and promotion of the "Australian Idol" television series and its associated trade marks since 2003. This included evidence of the global success of the "Pop Idol" format, its adoption in over 38 countries, and the opponent's registration of numerous "idol" trade marks worldwide.

The legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether the opponent had established a valid ground for opposing the registration of the applicant's trade mark. Specifically, the decision focused on the ground under section 60 of the Act, which concerns the use of trade marks in a way that is likely to deceive or cause confusion. The opponent argued that its extensive use of "Australian Idol" and other "idol" trade marks in relation to a popular television singing competition and associated merchandising had created a strong association in the public mind, and that the applicant's mark would likely cause confusion.

The Hearing Officer found that the evidence presented by the opponent sufficiently supported the ground of opposition under section 60. The extensive use of the "Australian Idol" trade mark, its association with a well-known television format, and the global adoption of similar "idol" trade marks by the opponent and its related entities, demonstrated a significant level of public recognition and association. This evidence led the Hearing Officer to conclude that the applicant's proposed trade mark would likely lead to deception or confusion among consumers.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer ruled that the opponent had successfully established a ground of opposition. As a result, the trade mark application 1193217 was refused registration. The opponent was also awarded costs against the applicant, to be assessed according to the official scale.

Background

Background to the litigation

FremantleMedia Ltd and 19 TV Ltd (collectively referred to as the "Opponent") brought an action against Zhidi Liu, the Applicant, in opposition to the Applicant's trade mark application for the term "Idol" in relation to various goods and services. The Opponent is the Australian producer of the television series "Australian Idol," which was first aired in July 2003 and features a singing competition. This series was preceded by the British version, "Pop Idol," which used a similar format and logo, first aired in 2001 in the United Kingdom. Following the success of "Pop Idol," the "idol format" was adopted worldwide, with over 38 countries adopting the format and using variations of the word "idol" in their respective titles.

The Opponent asserts that it has applied for and obtained registration for many "idol" trade marks across various countries, with over 250 trade marks listed in different jurisdictions. The "Australian Idol" television series has been widely popular in Australia and other jurisdictions, with a significant proportion of the viewing public participating in each series. The Opponent also engages in a broad range of merchandising, licensing, and sponsorship activities related to the "idol" trade marks, which have been promoted on official websites and various independent websites since 2004. The Applicant's trade mark application for the term "Idol" in relation to various goods and services has been met with opposition by the Opponent, who claims that the proposed trade mark would cause confusion and dilution of the existing "Australian Idol" trade marks.

The matter of FremantleMedia Ltd & 19 TV Ltd v Zhidi Liu came before the court following an application by the respondents, FremantleMedia Ltd and 19 TV Ltd, to oppose the registration of trade mark application 1193217 by the applicant, Zhidi Liu. The opposition was grounded on section 60 of the relevant Act, asserting that the proposed trade mark would likely cause confusion with existing trade marks held by the respondents. This case was heard at the first instance, with no prior appellate or judicial review proceedings involved. The primary procedural step was the filing of the opposition by the respondents, supported by a statutory declaration from Steven Rosser, the Director of Legal and Business Affairs of FremantleMedia Australia Pty Ltd. The declaration provided detailed evidence of the respondents' use and registration of numerous "idol" trade marks, particularly in relation to the "Australian Idol" television series. Interlocutory applications or orders did not feature prominently in the procedural history of this case, which proceeded directly to the substantive hearing on the merits of the opposition.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The opponent’s evidence supports the ground of opposition under the provisions of section 60 of the Act, and that is the ground under which I will decide this matter. Evidence The evidence consists of the statutory declaration of Steven Rosser, who is the Director of Legal and Business Affairs of the FremantleMedia Australia Pty Ltd (formerly known as Grundy Television Pty Ltd). FremantleMedia Australia is described as “a related company to FremantleMedia Limited”.[3] It is the authorized user of a number of registrations for trade marks incorporating the words “Australian Idol”, many of which appear in the following logo form:[3] [3] References to the opponent can be taken as references to the Australian authorised user and vice versa unless otherwise specified. Mr Rosser says the opponent is the producer of the “Australian Idol” television series which is promoted by the AUSTRALIAN IDOL trade mark and features a singing competition. It was first aired in Australia in July 2003 and a competition has run every year since then. The “Australian Idol” contest was preceded by the British version of the contest known as “Pop Idol”. It used the following logo, and was first aired on television in 2001 in the United Kingdom: Following the success of the “Pop Idol” competition in the United Kingdom, a talent show contest utilizing a similar format was rolled out throughout the world. In most of the countries where the talent show was produced, a link with the original show was maintained by the use of trade marks (some being in logo form) incorporating the word IDOL or IDOLS. The talent shows were promoted by use of the blue and white get up similar to that which is shown in the “Australian Idol” trade marks mentioned previously. Many of the countries who utilize the format prefix the word “idol” with the nationality or name of the country, as is the case in Australia. When this is not appropriate, other versions such as “Music Idols” (Bulgaria) or “Super Idol” (Greece) have been used. There are other variations as well. However, most use the word “idol”. Mr Rosser says that talent contests utilizing the format have been widely adopted throughout the world and that the “idol format” has appeared in over 38 countries. The opponent has applied for and obtained registration in different countries for many “idol” trade marks: a list provided at Exhibit SR-6 to his declaration includes over 250 trade marks in a variety of countries. Extracts and copies of the certificates of registration for some of these trade marks have been provided at Exhibit SR-18. In Australia, Mr Rosser says, the contest is a popular piece of television viewing, with a high proportion of the viewing public watching each contest series. The same applies, he says, in jurisdictions other than Australia. Mr Rosser also provides examples of the range of merchandising, licensing and sponsorship of third party goods and activities with which the opponent is involved. This material covers a broad range of goods and services. He says that the “idol” trade marks have also been promoted on the internet at various official “Australian idol” websites from as early as 2004, as well as being widely featured on independent websites such as Wikipedia and some news sites.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having established one ground of opposition, the opponent is successful in this action. There is no requirement for me to consider any of the other grounds which were pursued at the hearing, and I do not intend to do so.Decision The opponent has established a ground of opposition. I refuse to register trade mark application 1193217.Costs The opponent has requested its costs, and is so entitled. I award costs against the applicant according to the official scale.Alison WindsorHearing OfficerTrade Marks and Designs Hearings10 July 2010

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began its analysis by determining whether the opponent had a registered trade mark that was identical or similar to the applicant's trade mark. The opponent, FremantleMedia Ltd, had registered the trade mark "AUSTRALIAN IDOL" for a range of goods and services. The court found that the opponent's trade mark was indeed registered and was highly distinctive, given the success and popularity of the "Australian Idol" television series. The applicant's trade mark application, however, sought to register "IDOL" for a different set of goods and services, which included a broader range of entertainment-related services. Despite the differences in the scope of goods and services, the court determined that the trade marks were similar due to the strong recognition and association of the word "Idol" with the "Australian Idol" brand.

Next, the court considered whether the opponent's trade mark had earlier priority. The opponent's trade mark was registered prior to the applicant's trade mark application, establishing that the opponent had earlier priority. This was a significant factor in the court's decision, as earlier priority generally strengthens the opponent's case in a trade mark opposition proceeding.

The court then examined whether the goods or services in respect of which the opponent's trade mark was registered were identical or similar to those in respect of which the applicant's trade mark was sought to be registered. While the goods and services in question were not identical, the court found them to be similar, particularly in the entertainment and television production sectors. This similarity increased the likelihood of confusion on the part of the public.

A crucial aspect of the court's decision was determining whether there was a likelihood of confusion on the part of the public, which includes the likelihood of association with the opponent's trade mark. The court found that there was a significant likelihood of confusion due to the strong association of the word "Idol" with the "Australian Idol" brand. The widespread use and recognition of the "idol" trade marks in over 38 countries further supported this finding. The applicant's attempt to register a similar trade mark for a broad range of entertainment-related services risked causing confusion among consumers and diluting the distinctiveness of the opponent's trade mark.

In considering whether the opponent had established a ground of opposition under section 60 of the Act, the court found that the opponent had indeed met the criteria. The opponent demonstrated that its trade mark was well-known and had a strong reputation, particularly in Australia and internationally. The applicant's trade mark application posed a threat to the reputation and distinctiveness of the opponent's trade mark, particularly in light of the similarity of the goods and services and the likelihood of confusion.

Finally, the court addressed the issue of costs, determining that the opponent was entitled to recover its costs from the applicant. The opponent had successfully established a ground of opposition, and under Australian trade mark law, the losing party in an opposition proceeding is generally required to pay the prevailing party's costs. The court awarded costs to the opponent in accordance with the official scale.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a well-known and distinctive trade mark, such as "AUSTRALIAN IDOL," can successfully oppose the registration of a similar trade mark for related goods and services, particularly where there is a likelihood of confusion on the part of the public. The earlier priority of the opponent's trade mark registration, combined with its strong reputation and association with the "idol" brand, played a significant role in the court's decision to refuse registration of the applicant's trade mark application.