Freelancer International Pty Ltd and Australian Information Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

Freelancer International Pty Ltd and Australian Information Commissioner [2017] AATA 2426 (30 November 2017)

Division:FREEDOM OF INFORMATION DIVISION

File Number(s):       2016/0206

Re: Freelancer International Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

Australian Information Commissioner And  

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

Date:30 November 2017

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is set aside.  In substitution for that decision I make a determination that the 9 July 2013 complaint is substantiated.  I declare that Freelancer’s conduct in making the August 2012 disclosures constituted an interference with Mr Szczepanski’s privacy, and that Freelancer should not repeat or continue such conduct.  I declare that it would be inappropriate for any further action to be taken in the matter.

............................[sgd]............................................

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

Catchwords

PRIVACY - whether there was a breach of the National Privacy Principles – breach of National Privacy Principle 2.1 in August 2012 – no other breaches occurred – determination set aside

Legislation

Privacy Amendment (Enhancing Privacy Protection) Act 2012 (Cth)

Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act 1998 (NSW) ss 4, 8, 9, 18
Anti-Money Laundering and Counter Terrorism Financing Act 2006 (Cth) s 29
Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) ss 6, 6A, 6C, 13A, 16A, 16B, 36, 40, 41, 42, 43, 43A, 50, 51, 52, 55A, 61, 96, Sch 1, Sch 3, Sch 6

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 2A, 33(1), 33(1AA), 33(1AB)

Cases

Privacy Commissioner v Telstra Corporation Limited [2017] FCAFC 4

Telstra Corporation Limited and Privacy Commissioner [2015] AATA 991
Lobo and Department of Immigration and Citizenship (2011) 124 ALD 238
ZR v Department of Education and Training (GD) [2010] NSWADTAP 75
Twining v Curtis [2009] ACTSC 106
OA v New South Wales Department of Housing (No 2) [2006] NSWADT 94 
OA v New South Wales Department of Housing [2005] NSWADT 233
WL v La Trobe University [2005] VCAT 2592
Seven Network (Operations) Limited v Media Entertainment and Arts Alliance [2004] FCA 637
MT v Director General, NSW Department of Education & Training [2004] NSWADT 194
KD v Registrar NSW Medical Board [2004] NSWADT 5
Vice-Chancellor, Macquarie University v FM (GD) [2003] NSWADTAP 43
Bailey v Hinch [1989] VicRp 9; [1989] VR 78

Gale v New [1937] 4 All ER 645

Secondary Materials

Australian Law Reform Commission - Report No (2008)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

  1. Freelancer operates a website marketplace for service projects.  The services involved range from clerical and administrative functions through to highly skilled activities in the disciplines of computer science, information technology, engineering, accounting and law.   The website is accessible only to registered users, who are categorised as either project “employers” / “hirers” or “users” / “freelancers” / “(freelance) workers”.  Registered users include both organisations and individuals.  Freelancer claims that its registered users are located all over the world and number in the millions.

  2. Users register online at the freelancer.com website.  Prospective registrants must provide at least a name, email address and a unique “username”.  Registrants may also provide their geographical…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Freelancer International Pty Ltd and Australian Information... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2426
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Freelancer International Pty Ltd against a decision of the Australian Information Commissioner. The dispute arose from a complaint made by Mr Szczepanski regarding alleged breaches of the National Privacy Principles (NPPs) by Freelancer. The Senior Member of the Tribunal was required to determine whether Freelancer had breached the NPPs in its dealings with Mr Szczepanski.

The legal issues before the Tribunal included whether Freelancer's conduct constituted a breach of the National Privacy Principles, specifically NPP 2.1, and if so, what the appropriate outcome or remedy should be. The Tribunal also had to consider the causal link between any identified breach and any alleged harm or distress suffered by Mr Szczepanski.

The Tribunal found that Freelancer's User Agreement stipulated that the site was a market venue and that users negotiated fees and payments directly through the site's mechanisms. Freelancer reserved the right to suspend withdrawals if it suspected fraudulent activity. Mr Szczepanski had created multiple accounts using aliases and "dummy data," which contravened the User Agreement and triggered Freelancer's intervention. After investigations and Mr Szczepanski's compliance with identity verification, his accounts were reinstated. However, the Tribunal determined that only one breach, an August 2012 disclosure, had occurred and that this disclosure did not cause significant distress or loss to Mr Szczepanski, particularly given his adversarial stance towards Freelancer.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the Commissioner's decision. In substitution, it determined that Mr Szczepanski's complaint was substantiated, declaring that Freelancer's August 2012 disclosures constituted an interference with his privacy and that such conduct should not be repeated or continued. The Tribunal further declared that it would be inappropriate to take any further action in the matter.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a dispute between Freelancer International Pty Ltd and the Australian Information Commissioner regarding a breach of privacy under the National Privacy Principles. The facts commence with Mr Szczepanski's initial registration on the Freelancer website in November 2009. By January 2011, he had established or linked himself to at least three additional accounts, two of which he registered under different names using what he referred to as aliases and "dummy data." In early March 2011, Mr Szczepanski used one of these accounts to advertise for the purchase of a Paypal account. This activity, along with subsequent payments that appeared to be made from and to the same "dummy data" account, contravened the User Agreement and prompted Freelancer’s intervention.

Freelancer investigated these activities and temporarily suspended both accounts. Mid-April 2011 saw Freelancer issuing "please explain" enquiries to registered users, including Mr Szczepanski. He provided a dishonest explanation in his response, maintaining the fiction of two separate individuals as registered users. After providing photographic evidence of his identity, Freelancer reinstated his November 2009 account. The other account was terminated in June 2011 due to non-response. In March 2012, Mr Szczepanski returned funds to another Freelancer user account from which he had received a payment, resulting in another temporary suspension of his account and a further "please explain" enquiry. He provided another false explanation and, following further communication, his account was reinstated on 28 or 29 March 2012. The critical event in question was the disclosure of Mr Szczepanski’s name in August 2012, which formed the basis of the privacy breach claim.

The case involving Freelancer International Pty Ltd and the Australian Information Commissioner came before the court following a complaint by Mr Szczepanski regarding a breach of the National Privacy Principles. The Privacy Commissioner investigated and found a breach, leading to a decision which Mr Szczepanski sought to have reviewed. This matter was brought to the court as an appeal against the Privacy Commissioner's determination, focusing on the procedural aspects of the decision-making process rather than the substantive privacy breach itself. The initial complaint was lodged on 9 July 2013, and after investigation, the Privacy Commissioner found that the complaint was substantiated, with a particular focus on the August 2012 disclosure by Freelancer. However, no other breaches were identified. Mr Szczepanski, who appeared unrepresented, challenged the decision on review grounds, arguing that the Privacy Commissioner's findings were flawed and that the damages assessment was speculative. The court was tasked with evaluating the procedural fairness and correctness of the Privacy Commissioner's decision, without delving into the specifics of the privacy breach or the damages claimed. Throughout the proceedings, various interlocutory applications and submissions were made to clarify the scope and impact of the Privacy Commissioner's findings, with the ultimate goal of ensuring that the review process was both fair and legally sound.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The attribution of causal significance to any particular breach is a matter of obvious difficulty, and it is perhaps understandable that Mr Szczepanski, as an unrepresented party was reluctant to embark upon such an exercise in advance of knowledge of the actual breach findings. Nevertheless, it would be quite wrong to undertake any damages assessment on the basis of some composite view of Freelancer’s conduct. There was, in my view, only one breach (the events I have described as the August 2012 disclosure. And that disclosure was, in my view, not one that the evidence shows was the cause of any significant distress, hurt or loss to Mr Szczepanski. On his own contemporaneous assertion, he had declared “war” on Freelancer and, as the narrative section of these reasons shows, he was an extremely enthusiastic, undisciplined combatant. In those circumstances I am left unsatisfied that the use of his name in the August 2012 disclosures occasioned any identifiable and significant hurt or distress. (I am rather inclined - for the reasons I have set out earlier - to the positive view that it did not). Consequently, in the particular circumstances of this matter I consider that, rather than embarking upon an essentially speculative exercise, the preferable course is to declare that it would be inappropriate to taken any further action in the matter.Conclusion The decision under review is set aside. In substitution for that decision I make a determination that the 9 July 2013 complaint is substantiated. I declare that Freelancer’s conduct in making the August 2012 disclosures constituted an interference with Mr Szczepanski’s privacy, and that Freelancer should not repeat or continue such conduct. I declare that it would be inappropriate for any further action to be taken in the matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Freelancer website stipulated that the site was merely a market venue and that the only contractual parties to a service project transaction were the respective “employers” / “hirers”, on the one hand, and “users” / “freelancers” / “freelance workers”, on the other. (This stipulation implicitly assumed that users could not purport to contract projects between their own accounts. Such a prohibition was made explicit in the March 2012 version of the User Agreement.) Another aspect of the User Agreement required users to negotiate all fees, and make and receive all project payments, “directly through the mechanisms available on the (web)site”. Those mechanisms permitted registered users to make and receive payments via Paypal and payment card accounts. Access to them was subject to various security verification procedures, related to Freelancer’s own contractual obligations to users, the security standards imposed by payment service providers, and statutory obligations under the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter Terrorism Financing Act 2006 (Cth). Freelancer reserved the right to suspend withdrawals from any user account where it suspected the source of the funds was fraudulent. Mr Szczepanski’s Freelancer registrations Mr Szczepanski first became a registered Freelancer user in November 2009. By January 2011 he had established, or linked himself with, at least three other Freelancer accounts. Two of those various other accounts he concededly registered in different names, by providing what he euphemistically called aliases and “dummy data”. In early March 2011, using one of these “dummy data” accounts, Mr Szczepanski advertised on the Freelancer website to purchase a Paypal account (i.e. an account in someone else’s name). In March and April 2011 he purported to make various payments to and from one of the “dummy data” accounts. But both the payment source and recipient accounts were in fact linked to Mr Szczepanski’s email address, and thus to his own Paypal account. Those two events (the advertising to acquire a false account and the apparently circular payments) were contrary to the User Agreement and triggered Freelancer’s intervention. Subsequent investigation resulted in the temporary suspension of both accounts, and Freelancer’s issue, in mid April 2011, of “please explain” enquiries to the registered users. Mr Szczepanski’s response to the enquiry directed to him (as the November 2009 account user) provided an explanation, which he concedes was dishonest, and maintained the fiction of two separate individuals as the registered users. Freelancer required Mr Szczepanski to provide specific photographic evidence of his own identity. After he complied, Freelancer re-instated his November 2009 account. (Mr Szczepanski did not respond to the “please explain” enquiry sent to the other “username”, and Freelancer terminated that account in June 2011.) In March 2012 Mr Szczepanski returned funds to another Freelancer user account from which he had received a payment. This activity resulted in Freelancer again temporarily suspending his account on 26 March 2012, and sending another “please explain” enquiry. Mr Szczepanski gave another false explanation in response to this enquiry and, after a series of further communications, Freelancer re-instated his account on 28 or 29 March 2012:- see paragraph 165 below.