FRCT and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FRCT and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 1478 (24 June 2019)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:           2018/7502

Re:FRCT

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr L Bygrave, Member

Date:24 June 2019

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal decides that:

·the reviewable decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency on 22 November 2018 is set aside; and

·the matter is remitted to the National Disability Insurance Agency with the direction that the following will be funded as reasonable and necessary supports for FRCT in accordance with subsection 34(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth):

o18 hours of Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA) therapy per week paid on the basis of two hours senior 1:1 ABA therapy and four hours junior 1:2 ABA therapy per day x three times a week: amount of $70,200 to be used flexibly by FRCT over a period of 12 months; and

otwo hours of speech therapy per week: amount of $18,616 to be used flexibly by FRCT over a period of 12 months.

...........................[SGD].............................................

Dr L Bygrave, Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary support – where participant diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder requiring substantial support – early childhood intervention – ABA therapy – speech therapy – keyworker model – whether proposed supports are reasonable and necessary supports as defined in subsection 34(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ­– where ABA therapy represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support – where speech therapy represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support – where keyworker model not comparable support – best practice – where tension between parents’ preference that ABA therapy and speech therapy is provided in a clinical setting and best practice that prefers therapy to be provided in natural environments – decision set aside and remitted

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 26
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 3, 4, 31, 33, 34, 100, 209

CASES

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities done at New York on 13 December 2006 ([2008] ATS 12)
Early Childhood Intervention Australia, National Guidelines: Best Practice in Early Childhood Intervention (April 2016)
Larsson, E.V. Intensive Early Intervention Using Behaviour Therapy is No Longer Investigational (The Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention, 2008)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)
Planning Operational Guideline, National Disability Insurance Agency
Prior M. and Roberts, J. Early Intervention for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders: Guidelines for Good Practice (2012)
Prior M. et al. A Review of the Research to Identify the Most Effective Models of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FRCT and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 1478
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by FRCT, a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder, for funding for early childhood intervention supports. The dispute between FRCT and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) centred on whether proposed supports, specifically Applied Behavioural Analysis (ABA) therapy and speech therapy, constituted "reasonable and necessary supports" as defined by the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (Cth). The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered extensive evidence regarding FRCT's circumstances, the nature of early intervention for autism, and the differing therapeutic models proposed by FRCT's family and the NDIA.

The Tribunal was required to determine several key issues. These included the appropriate number of therapy hours, the type of therapy supports to be funded, the cost-effectiveness of these supports, and the optimal environment for therapy delivery. A central tension arose between the parents' preference for therapy in a clinical setting and evidence suggesting that therapy delivered in natural environments aligns with best practice for early intervention in autism. The Tribunal also had to consider the application of the principles for assessing "reasonable and necessary supports" as outlined in relevant case law, particularly the distinction between "reasonable" and "necessary" and the requirement for probative evidence to satisfy these criteria.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal applied the principles established in *McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency*, which guides the assessment of "reasonable and necessary supports" under the NDIS Act. The Tribunal found that ABA therapy and speech therapy, when provided at specific hours and costs, represented value for money, with costs being reasonable relative to the achieved benefits and the cost of alternative supports. While acknowledging the tension regarding the therapy environment, the Tribunal ultimately determined that the proposed ABA and speech therapy met the criteria for reasonable and necessary supports.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's previous decision. The matter was remitted to the NDIA with a direction to fund 18 hours of ABA therapy per week, at a cost of $70,200 for 12 months, and two hours of speech therapy per week, at a cost of $18,616 for 12 months, to be used flexibly by FRCT.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence before the Tribunal in this matter is extensive. In order to clearly consider the circumstances of FRCT, research on early intervention for children diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder and therapy options for FRCT, I have set out the evidence before the Tribunal in the following format:·evidence about FRCT;·evidence about early intervention for children diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder;·evidence from FRCT’s ABA therapy provider;·evidence from FRCT’s speech therapy provider; and·evidence supporting the position of the NDIA.Evidence about FRCT The following information about FRCT is based on Ms “A”’s written statements dated 3 December 2018 and 7 April 2019, Ms “A”’s oral evidence to the Tribunal on 11 April 2019, Mr “A”’s written statement dated 30 November 2018, and medical and specialist reports. FRCT lives with his parents, Ms “A” and Mr “A”, his twin brother, WKZQ, and his younger sister in the outer south-west area of Sydney. FRCT and WKZQ were born premature at 34 weeks gestation in July 2015. Both children suffered from a condition known as benign enlargement of the subarachnoid space, which meant they were prone to brain bleeds. In October 2015, FRCT experienced his first seizure and, in December 2015, FRCT and WKZQ were admitted to Sydney Children’s Hospital for seven weeks where they underwent multiple brain surgeries and procedures to relieve pressure on their brains. During this period, FRCT and WKZQ began receiving therapy from occupational therapists, physiotherapists and speech therapists; they were monitored by the Brain Injury Rehab Team and referred to Allied Health at a local hospital. Following their release from hospital, FRCT and WKZQ were unable to attend childcare due to the risk that they could suffer from a further subdural bleed. The family was supported by a carer for 40 hours per week during the period from March 2016 to January 2017. This allowed Ms “A” to work part-time as well as assist FRCT and WKZQ with their rehabilitation and development. From January 2017 to June 2018, FRCT and WKZQ attended childcare. Ms “A” told the Tribunal that she began to have concerns about the behaviour of FRCT and WKZQ during 2017. She described FRCT pulling clumps of hair out of WKZQ’s head and drawing blood due to biting; and FRCT and WKZQ having lengthy tantrums and meltdowns, throwing food, exhibiting stimming behaviours such as repeatedly banging their heads against windows and spinning objects and themselves, watching shadows and constantly repeating words/phrases. She used “baby gates” to separate FRCT and WKZQ in the home. Ms “A” and Mr “A” sought an assessment of FRCT and WKZQ. On 13 February 2018, a specialist child assessment team comprising a pediatrician, occupational therapist, pediatric fellow and social worker reported that FRCT continued to develop in the low average range and:…has delayed communication, play and social skills. He uses his language to label objects, comment and to request. He has difficulty with attending to other people’s tasks and likes to do his own activities. He prefers to play on his own or with his twin brother rather than seeking out his peers. He displays features to confirm a diagnosis of Autism Spectrum Disorder requiring substantial support (Level 2).[9][9] Exhibit T-T16, page 441.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons set out above, I am satisfied that the following supports for FRCT meet the requirements of reasonable and necessary supports as defined in paragraphs 34(1)(a)–(e) of the NDIS Act:·18 hours of ABA therapy per week paid on the basis of two hours senior 1:1 ABA therapy and four hours junior 1:2 ABA therapy per day x three times per week: cost $70,200 for 12 months; and·two hours of speech therapy per week: cost $18,616 for 12 months.DECISION The Tribunal decides that:·the reviewable decision made by the NDIA on 22 November 2018 is set aside; and·the matter is remitted to the NDIA with the direction that the following will be funded as reasonable and necessary supports for FRCT in accordance with subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act:o18 hours of ABA therapy per week paid on the basis of two hours senior 1:1 ABA therapy and four hours junior 1:2 ABA therapy per day x three times a week: amount of $70,200 to be used flexibly by FRCT over a period of 12 months; andotwo hours of speech therapy per week: amount of $18,616 to be used flexibly by FRCT over a period of 12 months.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At the hearing, the Tribunal asked both Ms “G” and Ms “H” about the reasons underpinning the hours of supports recommended for FRCT as set out in paragraph 21 above. In brief, their evidence was that they looked at FRCT’s goals, considered what another family using the keyworker model was accessing under the NDIS, and recommended a program they believed was reasonable and necessary to assist FRCT’s family to transition from ABA therapy to the keyworker model.CONSIDERATION As set out at paragraphs 20 and 21, the Applicant and the NDIA have presented two alternate models of supports for FRCT. In brief, these models are: on one side, the Applicant seeking funding to support his participation in intensive ABA therapy and speech therapy over a period of 12 months; and, on the other side, the Agency proposing to fund therapy through a keyworker model at a less intensive and reducing rate over a period of 12 months. These alternate models of therapy highlight the following issues in dispute between the parties in terms of what supports are reasonable and necessary for the NDIS to fund pursuant to subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act: first, the number of hours of therapy for FRCT; second, the type of therapy supports; third, the cost of the proposed therapy supports; and fourth, the environment in which FRCT should participate in therapy. I now consider the supporting evidence for these models in relation to the provisions of subsection 34(1) of the NDIS Act. In my consideration below, I have regard to Mortimer J’s decision in McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency, which provides the following guidance to assess “reasonable and necessary supports” in the NDIS Act:Whether a support is “reasonable” requires a different assessment to whether a support is “necessary”. Again, it is not necessary in the context of this proceeding to be definitive about the nature and extent of the meaning of the phrase, or its components. It is enough to observe that using the concept of necessity would appear to tie one aspect of the CEO’s assessment to an evaluation of the kinds of factors set out in s 34(1)(a) and (b) and (d). The word “reasonable” would appear to be directed at factors such as those set out in s 34(1)(c) and (f). That is not to say the meaning of each word is exhausted by the factors set out in s 34(1): rather, it is to illustrate the different work that each concept does as an adjective in the phrase “reasonable and necessary supports”…In my opinion, the text and context of s 33(5)(c), read with s 34(1) indicates that the CEO (or the delegate or Tribunal) must either be satisfied that a support has the character of being a reasonable and necessary support, or that it does not. Once a support is identified and described…then the question for the CEO (or the delegate or Tribunal) is whether she or he is satisfied that support, as identified, is reasonable and necessary for that particular participant…That determination can only be made on the basis of probative evidence.Once a decision is made that the support…is reasonable and necessary, then subject to the other requirements in s 33(5) and s 34, the scheme requires and contemplates that support “will” be funded. In my opinion, that can only mean wholly or fully funded.The subject matter of the CEO’s approval in s 33(2)(b) is the reasonable and necessary supports that “will” be funded. The language is imperative, and in my opinion this is consistent with the applicant’s contention that the relevant gateway established by the legislative scheme is whether the support is “reasonable and necessary”, and once through that gateway, the scheme intends the support will be fully funded… [emphasis added][70]Will the support assist FRCT to pursue the goals, objectives and aspirations included in his statement of goals and aspirations – paragraph 34(1)(a)?[70] [2017] FCA 308 at [91], [93-95].