CKPN and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

CKPN and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 4397 (30 November 2022)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):2021/5061      

Re:CKPN

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member K. Parker (presiding)
Member T. Bubutievski

Date:30 November 2022

Date of written reasons:        30 November 2022

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal sets aside the Decision Under Review and remits this matter for reconsideration by the Respondent with a direction that on or before 14 December 2022, the Respondent facilitate the approval of a new statement of participant supports (SOPS) for the Applicant, CKPN, containing the following:

1.    a provision specifying that the reassessment date is to fall on the 12 month anniversary of the date of approval of a new SOPS for CKPN under this remittal;

2.    a provision specifying that all funding under the new SOPS for CKPN is to be “plan-managed”;

3.    the approval of funding for the following supports:

a.    the provision of support worker assistance to CKPN during school terms of 31.5 hours per week at the weekday daytime rate, and during periods that do not fall during school terms, of 15 hours per week at the weekday, daytime rate;

b.    48 hours of services or therapy to be provided by a paediatric psychiatrist and/or paediatric clinical psychologist including the time required to undertake appropriate assessments and to write progress reports;

c.     12 hours of psychological therapy and assessment by her treating registered psychologist, P1;

d.    27 hours of speech pathology, including the time required to undertake assessments and write progress reports;

e.    48 hours of occupational therapy including the time required to undertake assessments and write progress reports;

f.   20 hours of clinical leadership by an allied health professional as part of a multi-disciplinary team as determined by the members of CKPN’s treating team in accordance with CKPN’s needs; noting the recommendations that this team should be led by a Paediatrician or Occupational Therapist; and

g.    replication, on a pro basis, of all other existing supports in CKPN’s current SOPS except for the supports referred to in subparagraphs 3a. to f. above.

..............................[SGD]..........................................

Senior Member K. Parker and Member T. Bubutievski

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – review of decision relating to approval of Applicant’s statement of participant supports (SOPS) under his NDIS plan – child participant has severe gastro-oesophageal reflux disease (GORD), redundant length colon with poor gut motility, avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder, sensory processing issues, insomnia with underlying anxiety disorder, and chronic pain – request for additional funding for allied health interventions and support worker assistance – whether “reasonable and necessary supports” criteria under s 34(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (NDIS Act) are met – Tribunal satisfied that most, but not all, requested supports meet those criteria and should be included in Applicant’s SOPS – Decision Under Review set aside and remitted with direction to facilitate the approval of a new SOPS for the Applicant

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CKPN and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 4397
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between CKPN, a child participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme, and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The core of the disagreement concerned the approval of CKPN's Statement of Participant Supports (SOPS) under her NDIS plan, specifically regarding additional funding requested for allied health interventions and support worker assistance. CKPN has complex medical conditions including severe gastro-oesophageal reflux disease, a redundant length colon with poor gut motility, avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder, sensory processing issues, insomnia, anxiety, and chronic pain.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the requested supports met the criteria of "reasonable and necessary supports" as defined by section 34(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). This involved assessing the medical and clinical evidence presented regarding CKPN's various health issues and the proposed interventions. The Tribunal also considered the duration of the NDIS plan and the appropriate allocation of funding for different types of support.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal acknowledged the significant medical challenges faced by CKPN, as detailed by her treating paediatric gastroenterologist and other specialists. It found that most, but not all, of the requested supports met the "reasonable and necessary" criteria. Specifically, the Tribunal determined that while continued intensive treatment by a particular psychologist (P1) was not fully substantiated for ongoing funding due to limited evidence of efficacy, a limited period of 12 hours of P1's services would be funded to facilitate a structured handover to alternative supports. The Tribunal also noted the importance of a 12-month plan duration to support CKPN's transition to primary school and the development of her feeding strategies.

Ultimately, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and remitted the matter with a direction to facilitate the approval of a new SOPS for CKPN. The approved supports included specific hours for support worker assistance, paediatric psychiatrist and/or clinical psychologist services, psychological therapy and assessment by P1, speech pathology, occupational therapy, and clinical leadership by an allied health professional. The Tribunal also made non-binding observations regarding the relationship between CKPN's parents and the NDIA, suggesting a potential benefit in changing CKPN's case manager to foster a fresh start.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal will start by outlining some of the medical and clinical background in relation to CKPN’s medical conditions, gastrointestinal dysfunction, feeding aversion, emotional regulation and mental health issues, pain and sleeping issues.Evidence by treating Paediatric Gastroenterologist – PGE1 The Tribunal had before it a letter from CKPN’s longstanding treating gastroenterologist, PGE1, dated 11 March 2021 (PGE1’s Letter),[37] and his expert report dated 14 January 2022 (PGE1’s Report).[38] In PGE1’s Letter he states that CKPN’s medical conditions included Chronic GORD, redundant length colon, cow’s milk/soy protein intolerance and feeding aversion. PGE1 states he has been treating CKPN since she was four months old. He refers to extensive investigations including an endoscopy which had confirmed chronic oesophageal reflux, bile reflux induced gastritis and (radiologically proven) redundant length colon. He confirms that these conditions have led to “severe feeding aversion, sleep disturbance and a degree of developmental delay”.[39][37] Refer T-Documents, Page 71.[38] Refer CKPN’s Tender Bundle, Pages 316 & 317.[39] Refer T-Documents, Page 71. In PGE1’s Letter he states that CKPN was being treated aggressively with “a long list of medications, dietetic input and specialised speech pathology input”. He explains that this treatment has been “to avoid invasive medical intervention including assisted nasogastric tube feeding or surgery”. PGE1 states that there had been “some improvement” but CKPN “still requires an intense degree of assistance”. The reason for this was stated to be “stooling issues due to her poor motility and a degree of anxiety”. PGE1 also states in this letter as follows:[40][CKPN] is likely to require further intensive psychology input from Clinical Psychologist [CP1]. [CP1] is also part of the chronic pain team Sydney Childrens Hospital which will prove helpful as we continue to manage [CKPN’s] pain. There are concerns about sensory processing problems particularly in relation to her reflux disease so occupational therapy will also be required in the near future.[40] Ibid. In PGE1’s Report he provides a summary of a conversation that he had with the independent psychiatrist, IP1, as part of this proceeding. In this report, he explained that all patients suffering GORD will experience bile reflux from the duodenum back into the stomach causing symptoms. He also refers to further reflux from the stomach into the oesophagus that causes discomfort, pain and feeding difficulties. PGE1 states in the report that gastro-oesophageal reflux involves a loose lower oesophageal sphincter, and it is “essentially lifelong”. He says it is “extremely difficult to set a prognosis for as it is about managing the disease via various strategies including lifestyle, dietary intake and medication along with Allied Health therapy”.[41][41] Refer CKPN’s Tender Bundle, Page 316. PGE1 states in this report that the redundant length colon causes increased symptoms in terms of abdominal pain and bloating. He states that it makes the management of constipation even more difficult. PGE1 referred to CKPN having different forms of pain including oesophageal discomfort, gastritis pain in the epigastric region and large bowel pain.[42][42] Ibid.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 19 July 2021, a “reviewer” made an internal review decision under s 100 of the NDIS Act, affirming the decision to approve the Sixth SOPS (Decision Under Review).[14] The reviewer considered that the requested supports did not meet the “reasonable and necessary” criteria under the NDIS Act.[15] The reviewer was also of the opinion that the statement of goals and aspirations contained in the plan were not a reviewable decision within the meaning of s 99 of the NDIS Act and therefore, were not part of the internal review under s 100 of the NDIS Act.[14] Refer T-Documents, T1M[15] Ibid.AAT application for review On 23 July 2021, the Parents signed and lodged an AAT Application for Review of Decision form (Application Form) with the Tribunal seeking that CKPN’s Fifth Plan be “reinstated”, to “continue her progress and gains in early intervention”.[16][16] Refer T-Documents, T1.Seventh NDIS Plan – October 2021 The CEO approved a further statement of participant supports (Seventh SOPS) resulting in the commencement on 26 October 2021 of a further NDIS plan for CKPN (Seventh NDIS Plan).[17] The notional duration of the Seventh SOPS is six months. This plan incorporates the changes to the statement of goals and aspirations sought by Ms CKPN. This plan contains core funding of $37,559.38 (equivalent to $75,118.76 per annum), including for flexible support with daily activities within the home. It also contains capacity building funding for skills development by allied health therapeutic interventions. The total capacity building funding approved was $12,192.24 (equivalent to $24,384.48 per annum). The plan specified that the approved funding for core supports was to be “plan-managed”, the funding for improved daily living was to be “self-managed”, and the funding for support coordination was to be “NDIA-managed”. [17] Refer Exhibit R2. The Seventh SOPS and Seventh Plan was lodged at the time of the final hearing.Eighth NDIS Plan – July 2022 While this matter was reserved the Parents wrote to the Tribunal and the NDIA and explained that an offer of a placement had come up in the IFP, for which CKPN was seeking funding. In the Parents’ email of 20 July 2022, they requested that the Tribunal make a decision in relation to this support only and decide upon the other supports in dispute at a later stage.[18] The Tribunal wrote back to the parties to indicate that it did not consider that it had the power under the AAT Act to decide this matter in part and instead, that it was required under s 43(1) of the AAT Act to affirm, vary, or set aside the Decision Under Review. Given the urgency of this situation and the IFP being sought was an early intervention support, the Tribunal foreshadowed its expectation that it was likely to make a finding that this support was a “reasonable and necessary support” under s 34(1) of the NDIS Act. Once that indication had been provided to the parties, the NDIA of its own volitiion decided that it would approve a new SOPS for CKPN to include funding for the IFP, and sought a remittal. The Tribunal granted this request and remitted this proceeding under s 42D of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act). [18] The Parents, on behalf of CKPN, had sought funding for CKPN (with her Parents and one support worker), to attend a program in South Australia offered by Lively Eaters (Lively Eaters Program), whereas the NDIA considered that funding for CKPN to attend an alternative program offered by the Talbot Centre based in Sydney (Talbot Centre Program), where CKPN and her Parents live, was sufficient.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to the treatment by P1, the Tribunal acknowledges that the cessation of funding for CKPN to continue her treatment by P1 will cause an initial disruption to CKPN’s routine. However, given the limited evidence of efficacy, the Tribunal is of the view that the benefit to CKPN of continuing on that course has not been substantiated on the evidence. To mitigate against this disruption, the Tribunal considers it appropriate that CKPN be funded for 12 hours of services to be provided by P1 to enable CKPN to be transitioned to alternative set of supports as referred to in paragraph [365] that the Tribunal considers to be “reasonable and necessary” supports for CKPN. This will allow for a structured handover of CKPN’s psychological management from P1 to her new psychiatrist and or paediatric clinical psychologist. If the Parents want further ongoing sessions with P1, they are at liberty to seek a Mental Health Plan funded or subsidised by Medicare from CKPN’s general practitioner for additional sessions with P1 or to fund them privately.Notional duration of the plan The Tribunal notes that the parties agreed to a plan length of 12 months. Given CKPN’s considerable needs, the Tribunal was content for this plan duration. It will enable CKPN to have additional support during her transition to primary school, and will support the development of her feeding strategies taught at the Lively Eaters IFP to meet CKPN nutrition needs as she continued to mature.Non-binding Observation The Tribunal makes the following non-binding observations based on its consideration of the evidence before it. While it is not the role of the Tribunal to provide parties with advice, this application raises a number of complex issues about the relationship between the Parents and the NDIA. This has been a long, and acrimonious, process. There is potential for damage to the long-term relationship between the Parents and the NDIA, and a loss of trust. It would no doubt benefit CKPN if the parties could treat this Decision as something of a “clean slate”. To that end, the NDIA may wish to give careful consideration to changing CKPN’s case manager to allow fresh relationships to be built between the Parents and the NDIA. Ultimately, it is a matter for the NDIA. Both parties may wish to reconsider their approach to each other when CKPN’s plan next comes up for review or if they participate in any future review proceedings in this Tribunal. CONCLUSION The Tribunal concludes that each of the mandatory criteria in s 34 (1) of the NDIS Act are met and that the following supports are “reasonable and necessary supports” and should be included in CKPN’s SOPS over a period of 12 months:(a)the provision of support worker assistance to CKPN during school terms of 31.5 hours per week at the weekday daytime rate, and during periods that do not fall during school terms of 15 hours per week at the weekday, daytime rate;(b)48 hours of services or therapy to be provided by a paediatric psychiatrist and/or paediatric clinical psychologist including the time required to undertake appropriate assessments and to write progress reports;(c)12 hours of psychological therapy and assessment by P1;(d)27 hours of speech pathology, including the time required to undertake assessments and write progress reports;(e)48 hours of occupational therapy including the time required to undertake assessments and write progress reports;(f)20 hours of clinical leadership by an allied health professional as part of a multi-disciplinary team as determined by the members of CKPN’s treating team in accordance with CKPN’s needs; noting the recommendations that this team should be led by a Paediatrician or Occupational Therapist.