FPB18 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

FPB18 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FedCFamC2G 859

File number(s): SYG 2976 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE PAPADOPOULOS
Date of judgment: 9 September 2024
Catchwords:

MIGRATION – Administrative Appeal Tribunal – protection visa  – Refugee Convention  – particular social group –  learning disability – well–founded fear of persecution not established – real risk of significant harm not established – no jurisdictional error

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – admissibility of new evidence – relevance – limited probative value – danger to mislead or confuse – ss 55 and 135 of Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – discretion to exclude – inadmissible evidence

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 55, 135

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36, 91R, 476(1)

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) Division 11.2

Cases cited:

Acting Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs v CWY20 (2021) 288 FCR 565; [2021] FCAFC 195
Applicant P119/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 230
Attorney-General (NSW) v Quin (1990) 170 CLR 1
FTZK v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 310 ALR 1; 88 ALJR 754; [2014] HCA 26
Hughes Aircraft Systems International v Airservices Australia (No 3) [1997] FCA 1537
La Trobe Capital & Mortgage Corp Ltd v Hay Property Consultants Pty Ltd (2011) 190 FCR 299; 273 ALR 774; [2011] FCAFC 4
LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs & Anor [2024] HCA 12; 98 ALJR 610
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA  (2019) 264 CLR 421;[2019] HCA 3
MZAPC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2021) 273 CLR 506
Perera v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 92 FCR 6; 58 ALD 231; [1999] FCA 507
Reading  v ABC [2003] NSWSC 716
Sadsad v NRMA Insurance Ltd [2014] NSWSC 1216; (2014) 67 MVR 601
SZHEW v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCA 783
SZRMQ vMinister for Immigration and Border Protection (2013) 219 FCR 212; [2013] FCAFC 142

SZYBR & Anor v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship & Anor [2007] HCA 26

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 71
Date of hearing: 28 August 2024
Place: Sydney
Applicants: First Applicant on behalf of all Applicants
Respondents: Mr T. Reilly of Counsel (instructed by Ms A. Wilford of Sparke Helmore Lawyers)

ORDERS

SYG 2976 of 2018

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FPB18

First Applicant

FPV18

Second Applicant

FPX18

Third Applicant

FPZ18

Fourth Applicant

FQA18

Fifth Applicant

FQB18

Sixth Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE PAPADOPOULOS

DATE OF ORDER:

9 SEPTEMBER 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The name of the first respondent be amended to ‘Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs’.

2.The application be dismissed.

3.The first, third and fourth applicants pay the first respondent’s costs and disbursements of, and incidental…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FPB18 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 859
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, South Korean nationals, sought judicial review of the Administrative Appeal Tribunal's (AAT) decision to refuse their protection visa application. The central issue was whether the Tribunal erred in its determination that the applicants did not qualify for a protection visa under the Refugee Convention due to a lack of evidence establishing a well-founded fear of persecution or a real risk of significant harm. The applicants argued that the Tribunal misapplied the law and misunderstood the particular social group claims of their daughter, who had a learning disability.

The court examined the evidence presented to the Tribunal, including the country information about South Korea's educational system for children with special needs, and the family's experiences in Australia. The Tribunal had considered the applicants' claims that their daughter would not receive appropriate educational support in South Korea and that she faced bullying and depression. However, the Tribunal found that the country information provided did not support the applicants' assertions and concluded that the applicants' claims did not meet the threshold for protection under the Refugee Convention. The court found no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal's decision.

Additionally, the court addressed the admissibility of new evidence submitted by the applicants. The court held that the new evidence had limited probative value and could potentially mislead or confuse the issues. Under sections 55 and 135 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), the court exercised its discretion to exclude the new evidence.

The court dismissed the application for judicial review, affirming the Tribunal's decision. The applicants' appeal was rejected, and no jurisdictional error was found in the Tribunal's determination. The refusal of the protection visa application was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants have applied to this Court for judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision pursuant to s 476(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act). To obtain assistance, the applicant must satisfy the Court that the Tribunal has fallen into jurisdictional error.BACKGROUND AND RELEVANT FACTS The background and relevant facts of this matter is largely derived from the Minister’s written submissions and, unless otherwise indicated, are not in dispute. The applicants last entered Australia on 27 June 2011 as holders of Subclass 976 Electronic Travel Authority (Visitor) (Class UD) visas. On 26 September 2011, the first applicant applied for a Subclass 428 Religious Worker (Class TE). The other applicants were included as dependents in that visa application. However, on 18 September 2012, he withdrew that visa application.[1][1] Court Book (CB) 229 to 230, 302. On 3 August 2012, the third applicant applied for a Subclass 572 Vocational Education and Training Sector (Class TU) visa. This application was refused by a delegate of the Minister on 14 September 2012. The applicants unsuccessfully sought merits and judicial review in relation to that decision, initially by the then Migration Review Tribunal and subsequently by the then Federal Circuit Court. On 6 November 2013, the third applicant made a request for Ministerial Intervention pursuant to s 351 of the Act and included the other applicants in her request. Her request was declined on 17 March 2014.[2][2] CB 302. On 10 April 2014 and 2 May 2014, the applicants sought to make two protection visa applications.[3] These were found to be invalid as they were made on the incorrect form and did not specify any claims for protection.[4] [3] CB 1 to 25; 33 to 57.[4] CB 30 to 32; 76 to 78.The protection visa application On 14 May 2014, the first applicant submitted a valid application for a protection visa, in which the second, third, fourth, fifth and sixth applicants were included as members of his family unit.[5] Claims for protection were advanced by, and on behalf of, the second applicant who is the daughter of the first and third applicants.[6] The second applicant was thirteen years old when this protection visa application was made. It is this visa application that the decision under review concerns.[5] CB 79 to 180.[6] CB 79 to 103; 122 to 134. On 7 July 2015, the first and third applicants attended a Departmental interview where they gave evidence on behalf of the second applicant in relation to her protection claims.[7] [7] CB 231 to 232. On 29 July 2015, the delegate refused to grant the second applicant a protection visa having found that she was not owed protection obligations as she was neither a refugee nor owed complementary protection. It followed that the other applicants were refused the grant of protection visas as they were not members of the family unit of a person to whom Australia owed protection obligations.[8][8] CB 223 to 238.The review application On 26 August 2015, the applicants sought review of the delegate’s decision with the Tribunal.[9] On 21 August 2018, the applicants lodged submissions and further evidence with the Tribunal,[10] claiming that they were owed protection under the Refugee Convention (Convention) because the second applicant was a member of the particular social group comprising students who have ‘dropped out of school [in Korea] due to being unable to adopt [sic] and adjust...to school in a proper manner’.[11][9] CB 239 to 247.[10] CB 282 to 287.[11] CB 283.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 135 of the Evidence Act relevantly provides:135 General discretion to exclude evidenceThe court may refuse to admit evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger that the evidence might:(a) be unfairly prejudicial to a party; or(b) be misleading or confusing; or(c) cause or result in undue waste of time.PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THIS COURTOriginating application The first applicant commenced the proceeding by way of an originating application filed on 24 October 2018 on the following two particularised grounds (reproduced without alteration): Ground 1: The Second Respondent failed to apply to a relevant consideration & law of the applicants’ country of origin in making the decision:Particulars(1)The Second Respondent misconstrued or misunderstood by failing to judge that the Second Applicant will be finishing school this year.(2)In considering assessing the Second Applicant’s schooling, the Second Respondent erroneously took the view that the Second Applicant’s schooling is no longer relevant to the Applicants claims.Ground 2: The Second Respondent failed to explain correct laws of protection visa when a hearing was held.Particulars(1)In considering a definition of Article 1 of the Convention Article 1A(2), the Second Respondent narrowly limited a definition of persecution such as:· a threat to the person’s life or liberty;· significant physical harassment of the person. The application was accompanied by an affidavit of the first applicant, attached to which was a copy of the Tribunal’s decision record.Orders On 15 November 2018, a Registrar of this Court made various orders by consent including that:(a)Pursuant to Division 11.2 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), the first applicant is appointed as the litigation guardian of his children; the second, fifth and sixth applicants, who are minors.(b)The first respondent file one hard copy and an electronic copy of a bundle of relevant documents (‘the Court Book’) and serve a hard copy of the Court Book on the applicant by 13 December 2018.(c)The applicants have leave to file and serve any amended application giving complete particulars of each ground of review relied upon by 10 January 2019.(d)The applicants must file and serve any affidavit containing additional evidence to be relied upon, including any transcript of a Tribunal hearing, by 10 January 2019.(e)The Minister must file and serve any affidavit containing additional evidence to be relied upon, including any transcript of a Tribunal hearing, by 7 February 2019.(f)Other than the bundle of relevant documents, all evidence relied upon by the parties is to be presented by way of affidavit and any transcript of a Tribunal hearing must be verified by way of affidavit.(g)All documents in the proceeding must be filed at the Registry of this Court and served on the other parties.(h)The matter be stood over for hearing on a date and time to be advised. On 1 April 2019, the matter was docketed to another Judge of this Court who made further orders on 25 November 2019 including that:(a)The applicant has leave to file and serve any amended application giving complete particulars of each ground of review on or before 13 January 2020.(b)The applicant must file and serve any affidavit containing additional evidence to be relied upon, including any transcript of an interview or hearing, on or before 13 February 2020.(c)The Minister must file and serve any affidavit containing additional evidence to be relied upon in answer on or before 10 February 2020.(d)Other than the bundle of relevant documents, all evidence relied upon by the parties is to be presented by way of affidavit and any transcript of an interview or hearing must be verified by way of affidavit.(e)The applicant file and serve written submissions no longer than 10 pages and any list of authorities at least 14 days before the hearing.(f)The Minister file and serve written submissions no longer than 10 pages and any list of authorities at least 7 days before the hearing.(g)The matter be fixed for a final hearing at 2pm on 22 July 2020 before Judge Humphreys.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In an undated statement accompanying their review application to the Tribunal, it was further claimed that the applicants feared harm because of the second applicant’s political opinion. The second applicant could not live a normal life in South Korea because of her ‘unpopular ideas’ and neither could her family.[21] This claim was later withdrawn during the Tribunal hearing.[21] CB 247.Tribunal’s decision The Tribunal accepted the applicants were citizens of South Korea,[22] who formed part of the same family unit.[23] The Tribunal confirmed that it gave no regard to the second applicant’s claimed political opinions in circumstances where this claim had been withdrawn orally at hearing.[24][22] CB 305 [24] to [25].[23] CB 305 [26].[24] CB 305 [27]. The Tribunal recorded in its decision that during the hearing it had raised country information with the first applicant that was inconsistent with the claim that the second applicant’s needs could not be met by any school in South Korea. In particular, it identified that South Korean legislation provided for free education and support for children with diagnosed special needs and that there were schools in South Korea which also catered to those needs.[25] The Tribunal set out the first applicant’s response, namely, that country information did not match the ‘real situation’ in South Korea.[26] Regarding the availability of schools in South Korea for children with special needs, the Tribunal recorded the first applicant’s belief that those schools were only for children with ‘serious disabilities’ and that his daughter did not fall within that category.[27] [25] CB 306 to 307 [33]; [35].[26] CB 306 [34].[27] CB 306 [36]. The Tribunal also summarised the oral evidence of the third applicant at hearing, including, that she had tried to obtain a ‘disability grade’ for her daughter but had been unable to do so.[28] In any event, the third applicant thought her daughter’s condition had improved since being in Australia and believed that, if returned to South Korea, ‘it would be difficult for [her family] to get used to living there’.[29][28] CB 306 [37].[29] CB 308 [39]. The Tribunal accepted that the second applicant had a learning disability and had attended a public school in South Korea for one semester, where she was bullied by her classmates and was not supported by her teachers. It accepted that, as a result, she had been withdrawn from that school, homeschooled by her parents, and was subsequently diagnosed with, and treated for childhood depression. The Tribunal also accepted that the first applicant was in debt due to the cost of this treatment, and found that he decided to come to Australia to earn money to rectify that debt and to otherwise provide for his children.[30][30] CB 309 [45] to [47]. Turning to the applicants’ migration history, the Tribunal accepted that the first and third applicants had not wanted to apply for protection but did so because their children were happy in school in Australia, the second applicant was feeling better, and they were impressed with the second applicant’s teachers and school. The Tribunal also acknowledged the applicants’ desire to stay in Australia and accepted that they did not want to return to South Korea.[31] It did not, however, accept that the second applicant feared everyone in her age group in South Korea or that there was no one in South Korea who understood her.[32][31] CB 309 [48].[32] CB 309 [49].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The first applicant commenced the proceeding by way of an originating application filed on 24 October 2018 on the following two particularised grounds (reproduced without alteration): Ground 1: The Second Respondent failed to apply to a relevant consideration & law of the applicants’ country of origin in making the decision:Particulars(1)The Second Respondent misconstrued or misunderstood by failing to judge that the Second Applicant will be finishing school this year.(2)In considering assessing the Second Applicant’s schooling, the Second Respondent erroneously took the view that the Second Applicant’s schooling is no longer relevant to the Applicants claims.Ground 2: The Second Respondent failed to explain correct laws of protection visa when a hearing was held.Particulars(1)In considering a definition of Article 1 of the Convention Article 1A(2), the Second Respondent narrowly limited a definition of persecution such as:· a threat to the person’s life or liberty;· significant physical harassment of the person. The application was accompanied by an affidavit of the first applicant, attached to which was a copy of the Tribunal’s decision record.Orders On 15 November 2018, a Registrar of this Court made various orders by consent including that:(a)Pursuant to Division 11.2 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), the first applicant is appointed as the litigation guardian of his children; the second, fifth and sixth applicants, who are minors.(b)The first respondent file one hard copy and an electronic copy of a bundle of relevant documents (‘the Court Book’) and serve a hard copy of the Court Book on the applicant by 13 December 2018.(c)The applicants have leave to file and serve any amended application giving complete particulars of each ground of review relied upon by 10 January 2019.(d)The applicants must file and serve any affidavit containing additional evidence to be relied upon, including any transcript of a Tribunal hearing, by 10 January 2019.(e)The Minister must file and serve any affidavit containing additional evidence to be relied upon, including any transcript of a Tribunal hearing, by 7 February 2019.(f)Other than the bundle of relevant documents, all evidence relied upon by the parties is to be presented by way of affidavit and any transcript of a Tribunal hearing must be verified by way of affidavit.(g)All documents in the proceeding must be filed at the Registry of this Court and served on the other parties.(h)The matter be stood over for hearing on a date and time to be advised. On 1 April 2019, the matter was docketed to another Judge of this Court who made further orders on 25 November 2019 including that:(a)The applicant has leave to file and serve any amended application giving complete particulars of each ground of review on or before 13 January 2020.(b)The applicant must file and serve any affidavit containing additional evidence to be relied upon, including any transcript of an interview or hearing, on or before 13 February 2020.(c)The Minister must file and serve any affidavit containing additional evidence to be relied upon in answer on or before 10 February 2020.(d)Other than the bundle of relevant documents, all evidence relied upon by the parties is to be presented by way of affidavit and any transcript of an interview or hearing must be verified by way of affidavit.(e)The applicant file and serve written submissions no longer than 10 pages and any list of authorities at least 14 days before the hearing.(f)The Minister file and serve written submissions no longer than 10 pages and any list of authorities at least 7 days before the hearing.(g)The matter be fixed for a final hearing at 2pm on 22 July 2020 before Judge Humphreys.