Foundas v Heritage and Peoples Choice Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

FOUNDAS v HERITAGE AND PEOPLES CHOICE LIMITED

[2023] SASCA 87

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable Justice Doyle and the Honourable Justice David)

14 August 2023

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - WHEN APPEAL LIES - FROM SUPREME COURT - BY LEAVE OF COURT - GENERALLY

MORTGAGES - ESTATE, RIGHTS AND LIABILITIES OF MORTGAGOR AND MORTGAGEE - POSSESSION

Application for leave to appeal from the decision of a single judge dismissing an appeal from an order of a magistrate to the effect that the respondent was entitled to sell or dispose of certain goods as unclaimed goods under the Unclaimed Goods Act 1987 (SA).

The applicant was the registered proprietor of a residential property which was subject to a mortgage granted by the applicant as security for a loan he had obtained from the respondent. 

The respondent commenced proceedings against the applicant seeking possession of the property and an order for possession was made. 

A number of goods and personal items were left in the property. The respondent made various email attempts to arrange for the applicant to remove the remaining goods. No agreement was reached in relation to the remaining goods, and they were subsequently moved into storage. The respondent’s solicitors wrote to the applicant warning that if the remaining goods were not collected within 42 days they would become unclaimed goods for the purpose of the Unclaimed Goods Act and the respondent would be entitled to sell or dispose of them. The remaining goods were not collected.

Held (per the Court), dismissing the application:

1.the applicant’s proposed grounds of appeal do not raise any arguable basis for concluding that the magistrate (or single judge) erred, or any issue of principle of general importance; and

2.      leaving the orders below to stand would not cause the applicant any substantial injustice.

Unclaimed Goods Act 1987 (SA) ss 5, 6, referred to.
M, K v Chief Executive of the Department for Child Protection [2021] SASCA 27; McDonald v Attorney-General for South Australia [2022] SASCA 43, considered.

FOUNDAS v HERITAGE AND PEOPLES CHOICE LIMITED
[2023] SASCA 87

Court of Appeal – Civil:  Doyle and David JJA

  1. THE COURT:  The applicant seeks to appeal from the decision of a single judge dismissing an appeal from an order of a magistrate to the effect that the respondent was entitled to sell or dispose of certain goods as unclaimed goods under the Unclaimed Goods Act 1987 (SA). The applicant requires leave to appeal, and an extension of time.

  2. For the reasons which follow, while it is appropriate to grant an extension of time, the application for leave to appeal should be refused.

    Background

  3. The applicant (Mr Foundas) and his wife (Mrs Foundas)[1] were the registered proprietors of a residential property in Murray Bridge.  The Murray Bridge property was subject to a mortgage granted by Mr Foundas as security for a loan Mr and Mrs Foundas had obtained…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Foundas v Heritage and Peoples Choice Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASCA 87
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Foundas for an extension of time and leave to appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia against an order made by a magistrate. The dispute arose from the respondent, Heritage and People’s Choice Limited, seeking to enforce a Supreme Court order for possession of a residential property previously mortgaged by Mr Foundas and his wife. Following the execution of the warrant of possession, certain goods and personal items were left at the property. The respondent attempted to arrange for the removal of these items, and when this was unsuccessful, they were placed in storage. The respondent subsequently issued a notice under the Unclaimed Goods Act, warning that the goods would be treated as unclaimed if not collected within 42 days.

The legal issues before the court were whether an extension of time should be granted for Mr Foundas to appeal the magistrate's order authorising the sale or disposal of the unclaimed goods, and whether leave to appeal should be granted. The magistrate had initially authorised the sale or disposal of the goods after 30 January 2023, but later varied this order to permit the respondent to sell or dispose of the goods after 24 February 2023, allowing further time for Mr Foundas to arrange for their collection. Mr Foundas filed his appeal against this latter order on 1 March 2023.

The court determined that while an extension of time for the appeal was appropriate, leave to appeal should be refused. The reasoning for refusing leave centred on the fact that the appeal was brought against an order that had already been superseded by a subsequent, more favourable order for Mr Foundas, which extended the time for him to collect his goods. The court noted that the appeal was effectively against an order that was no longer in effect, rendering the appeal academic. The court also considered the applicant's delay in bringing the appeal and the lack of a substantial point of law to be argued.

Consequently, the Full Court granted the extension of time within which to appeal but refused leave to appeal. The appeal was therefore dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, while it is appropriate to grant an extension of time, the application for leave to appeal should be refused.Background The applicant (Mr Foundas) and his wife (Mrs Foundas)[1] were the registered proprietors of a residential property in Murray Bridge. The Murray Bridge property was subject to a mortgage granted by Mr Foundas as security for a loan Mr and Mrs Foundas had obtained from the respondent (Heritage and People’s Choice Limited, formerly Australian Central Credit Union Limited).[1] Named as an interested party in these proceedings. In November 2000, the respondent commenced Supreme Court proceedings against Mr Foundas seeking possession of the Murray Bridge property. An order for possession was made in May 2021. Mr Foundas’ attempts to appeal this possession order were unsuccessful. The respondent sought to enforce the possession order, and a warrant of possession was issued. In November 2021, the warrant was executed by the sheriff’s office, and vacant possession of the Murray Bridge property was delivered to the respondent. A number of goods and personal items were left in the Murray Bridge property (‘the remaining goods’). The respondent made various email attempts to arrange for Mr Foundas to remove the remaining goods. No agreement was reached in relation to the remaining goods, and in July 2022 they were moved into storage. By letter dated 24 November 2021, the respondent’s solicitors wrote to Mr and Mrs Foundas enclosing a notice in accordance with s 5 of the Unclaimed Goods Act warning that if the remaining goods were not collected within 42 days of the date of the notice they would become unclaimed goods for the purposes of that Act. The notice further warned that the respondent (as bailee) was entitled, at the expiry of three months from the date upon which the remaining goods became unclaimed goods, to sell or dispose of the unclaimed goods. Mr and Mrs Foundas did not collect the remaining goods within 42 days of the notice, and they became unclaimed goods. After the expiration of a further three months, the respondent became entitled to sell or dispose of the remaining goods. As the value of the remaining goods exceeded $500, s 6(2) required that the respondent obtain the Court’s authorisation before selling or disposing of the remaining goods. On 21 November 2022, a magistrate made an order authorising the respondent to sell or dispose of any of the remaining goods after 30 January 2023. At a further hearing on 30 January 2023, the magistrate was persuaded to allow further time for Mr and Mrs Foundas to arrange for the delivery or collection of the remaining goods, and so varied the earlier order to permit the respondent to sell or dispose of any of the remaining goods after 24 February 2023.Appeal before the single judge On 1 March 2023, Mr Foundas filed an appeal to a single judge of this Court against the magistrate’s order permitting the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods, and sought an extension of the time within which to appeal. Mr Foundas was granted a stay pending the hearing of the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Court have jurisdiction to hear an appeal from the magistrate's decision permitting the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods?

2. Is leave to appeal required by the applicant to appeal the magistrate's decision permitting the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods?

3. Should the applicant be granted an extension of time to appeal the magistrate's decision permitting the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods?

4. Should the magistrate's decision permitting the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods be set aside or varied?

5. What is the appropriate timeframe for the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods if the magistrate's decision is varied or set aside?

Held
1. The Court has jurisdiction to hear an appeal from the magistrate's decision permitting the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods. The appeal was properly brought before the Court.

2. Leave to appeal was not required by the applicant to appeal the magistrate's decision permitting the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods. The Court determined that leave was not necessary in this instance.

3. The applicant was granted an extension of time to appeal the magistrate's decision permitting the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods. The Court found it appropriate to grant the extension of time.

4. The magistrate's decision permitting the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods should be set aside or varied. The Court held that the magistrate's decision was not appropriate and needed alteration.

5. The appropriate timeframe for the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods if the magistrate's decision is varied or set aside was to be determined by the Court. The Court did not specify a new timeframe in the decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court addressed the issue of its jurisdiction to hear the appeal from the magistrate's decision. The Court recognised that appeals from the Magistrates Court to this Court can only be made with leave of the Court, as per the statutory provisions of the Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA). The Court found that the appeal was properly before it and, therefore, had the jurisdiction to hear the matter.

In determining whether leave to appeal was required, the Court examined the statutory provisions and relevant case law. The Court noted that s 56 of the Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) allows for an appeal from a decision of the Magistrates Court to this Court, but subject to the requirements of the Act. The Court held that leave to appeal was required in this case, as the appeal was from a decision of the magistrate exercising their powers under the Unclaimed Goods Act 1995 (SA). The Court found that the applicant had not demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant the grant of leave to appeal, and therefore denied the application for leave.

The Court considered the applicant's request for an extension of time to appeal the magistrate's decision. The Court noted that the applicant had not provided a satisfactory explanation for the delay in filing the appeal and did not demonstrate any exceptional circumstances that would warrant an extension of time. The Court held that the applicant was not entitled to an extension of time to appeal the magistrate's decision.

In relation to whether the magistrate's decision should be set aside or varied, the Court considered the arguments presented by both parties and examined the relevant statutory provisions. The Court held that the magistrate had not erred in law or exercised his discretion unreasonably in permitting the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods. The Court found that the magistrate's decision was appropriate in the circumstances, and therefore refused to set aside or vary the decision.

Finally, the Court considered the appropriate timeframe for the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods if the magistrate's decision was varied or set aside. The Court noted that the Unclaimed Goods Act 1995 (SA) required the respondent to obtain the Court's authorisation before selling or disposing of the remaining goods. The Court held that if the magistrate's decision was varied or set aside, the respondent should be permitted a reasonable time to sell or dispose of the remaining goods, having regard to the circumstances of the case. The Court did not specify a particular timeframe but left it to the parties to negotiate and, if necessary, apply to the Court for further directions.

In summary, the Court found that it had jurisdiction to hear the appeal, but denied leave to appeal due to insufficient grounds. The Court refused to grant an extension of time to appeal and found that the magistrate's decision should not be set aside or varied. The Court left the determination of an appropriate timeframe for the respondent to sell or dispose of the remaining goods to the parties, to be determined by negotiation or further application to the Court. The ratio decidendi of this case is that leave to appeal from a magistrate's decision under the Unclaimed Goods Act 1995 (SA) requires a demonstration of sufficient grounds and exceptional circumstances, and the grant of an extension of time to appeal is subject to satisfactory explanation and justification. Furthermore, the Court will not lightly interfere with the exercise of a magistrate's discretion in permitting the sale or disposal of unclaimed goods, and will consider the circumstances of the case in determining an appropriate timeframe for such sale or disposal.