Foster's Wine Estates Limited v Serafino Wines Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by FOSTER'S WINE ESTATES LIMITED to registration of trade mark application 1033609 (33) - SERAFINO MAGLIERI - filed in the name of SERAFINO WINES PTY LTD.

Delegate: Bianca Irgang
Representation: Opponent: Mr Ben Fitzpatrick of counsel, instructed by Allens Arthur Robinson
Applicant: Ms Phoebe Arcus of counsel, instructed by Johnson Winter & Slattery Lawyers
Decision: 2010 ATMO 81
s.52 opposition: sections 42, 44, 59, 60 and 62 pressed – s 44 ground of opposition established since trade marks are deceptively similar – no consent from the opponent to use a deceptively similar trade mark – no prior use – registration refused. Costs awarded against the applicant.

Background

  1. Serafino Wines Pty Ltd (‘the applicant’), filed application number 1033609 on 9 December 2004 in class 33 of the International Classification of Goods and Services (‘Nice’ classification). Current details of the application are set out below.

    Trade mark:  SERAFINO MAGLIERI

    Trade mark application:        1033609

    Filing Date:  9 December 2004

    Specification:  Class 33: Wines

    Endorsements:  Provisions of paragraph 44(3)(b) applied

  2. Foster's Wine Estates Limited (‘the opponent’) filed a Notice of Opposition (‘the Notice’) dated 25 August 2006 to registration of the application. Thereafter the parties served and filed evidence in accord with the provisions of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’).

  3. I heard the matter in Canberra as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks on 6 May 2010. The opponent was represented by Mr Ben Fitzpatrick of Counsel, instructed by Allens Arthur Robinson. The applicant was represented by Ms Phoebe Arcus of Counsel, instructed by Johnson Winter & Slattery Lawyers.

    Grounds of Opposition

  4. The Notice nominated most of the grounds of opposition under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’).  However, only those grounds under subsections 42(b), 44, 59, 60 and 62 were pursued at the hearing. As a formal matter, I note the remaining grounds listed in the Notice have not been established.

  5. The onus is upon the opponent to establish one or more of its grounds of opposition. Gyles J has referred to the standard of proof required in terms of a ‘balance of probabilities’.[1] His findings upon that issue, arrived at after a consideration of the relevant authorities, have been discussed with approval by Sundberg J in Chocolaterie Guylian NV v Registrar of Trade Marks[2].

    Evidence

  6. The evidence of the parties consists of the following declarations:

Declarant

Position

Date Made

Exhibits

Evidence in Support

Mathew Jordan O’Keefe[3]

Trade Mark Attorney employed by Foster's Wine Estates Limited

23 May 2008

MJO-1 to MJO-8

Sandra Elizabeth Forman[4]

Senior Associate of Allens Arthur Robinson Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys

23 May 2008

SEF-1 to SEF-7

[3] For ease of reference this statutory declaration will be called O’Keefe #1

[4] For ease of reference this statutory declaration will be called Forman #1

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Foster's Wine Estates Limited v Serafino Wines Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ATMO 81
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Foster's Wine Estates Limited (the opponent) sought to oppose the registration of a trade mark application by Serafino Wines Pty Ltd (the applicant). The dispute concerned the applicant's attempt to register the trade mark "STEVE MAGLIERI" for use on wine. Foster's Wine Estates argued that this proposed registration infringed upon its existing trade mark rights, particularly those incorporating the name "MAGLIERI," which it acquired through the purchase of Maglieri Wines. The matter was heard by Bianca Irgang, a Hearing Officer at the Trade Marks Hearings.

The primary legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether the applicant's proposed trade mark "STEVE MAGLIERI" was deceptively similar to the opponent's registered trade marks, specifically registrations 630850 (MAGLIERI WINES WHEN ONLY THE BEST WILL DO) and 739391 (MAGLIERI), for the purpose of wine sales. This involved an assessment of the grounds of opposition under section 44 of the relevant legislation, which deals with the registration of trade marks that are identical or deceptively similar to earlier trade marks.

The Hearing Officer reasoned that the opponent had successfully demonstrated that its existing trade marks, particularly those incorporating the name "MAGLIERI," were well-established and had generated consistent sales revenue. The opponent's evidence, including statutory declarations and the Agreement for Purchase of Shares, established its ownership and control over the "MAGLIERI" brands. The Hearing Officer found that the opponent had met the onus of proof regarding the grounds of opposition under section 44. Consequently, the Hearing Officer refused to register the applicant's trade mark application. The Hearing Officer also ordered that the unsuccessful applicant, Serafino Wines Pty Ltd, pay the costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Maglieri has made considerable comment on the opponent’s failure to renegotiate for the use of STEVE MAGLIERI on its wine. Mr Maglieri has asserted that this failure after the expiration of the restraint clauses implies that the opponent gives permission for Mr Maglieri to use his name on wine. This argument is vehemently denied by the opponent. Opponent’s Evidence The opponent’s evidence consists of a number of statutory declarations and exhibits. In particular, the Agreement for Purchase of Shares between the opponent and Maglieri Wines (exhibit MJO-1 accompanying the statutory declaration of Matthew O’Keefe) is included in the evidence. The O’Keefe #1 declaration outlines the considerable reputation that Maglieri Wines had in its produce and the reasons why the opponent purchased Maglieri Wines. The O’Keefe #1 declaration states that by purchasing the shares in Maglieri Wines, the opponent obtained effective control over all of the assets of Maglieri Wines, including its brands. Mr O’Keefe states that the opponent owns a number of registered and common law trade marks which incorporate the word MAGLIERI. Most notably, the opponent is the owner of trade mark registrations 630850, 739391 and 784313. The details of these registrations are as follows:Trade mark: MAGLIERI WINES WHEN ONLY THE BEST WILL DOTrade mark registration: 630850Filing Date: 30 May 1994Specification: Class 33: Wines, spirits, liqueurs and all other goods in this classEndorsements: Registration gives no right to the exclusive use of the words WHEN ONLY THE BEST WILL DO. When the mark is used for items in the specification of goods other than WINES, the word WINES in the mark will be changed to accord with those items. The preceding endorsement(s) were recorded prior to commencement of the Trade Marks Act 1995.Trade mark: MAGLIERI Trade mark registration: 739391Filing Date: 18 July 1997Specification: Class 33: Wines, spirits, liqueurs and other alcoholic beverages in this class The O’Keefe #1 declaration states that the opponent had no intention of preventing Mr Maglieri from being referred to as a winemaker on any product produced by any business after the expiration of the restraint clause mentioned previously in paragraph 10 which was five years after the completion date of the contract of sale. Mr O’Keefe avers that after the restraint period finished on 25 August 2003, Mr Maglieri began using his name again as a winemaker and that the opponent was comfortable with this. Mr O’Keefe avers that the restraint clause 12.1(c)(ii)(A) in the Agreement for Purchase of Shares is a clause which specifically bans each vendor from ever using any trade mark which is substantially identical or deceptively similar to any of the trade marks owned or currently used by the business which had been sold to the opponent. Mr O’Keefe further asserts that such restraint clauses are standard features in large acquisitions of this kind. The O’Keefe #1 declaration and attached exhibits demonstrate that the opponent continued to sell wine under its MAGLIERI trade marks after the opponent became the owner of Maglieri Wines. Confidential Exhibit MJO-6 demonstrates that the sales revenue generated through the sales of wine under the MAGLIERI trade marks has been constant from 2004 through until 2007. Discussion

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 of the Act provides:DecisionUnless the proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established. I find that the opponent has met the onus upon it, in terms of the grounds of opposition under section 44 argued at the hearing. Accordingly, I refuse to register trade mark application 1033609. Costs It is usual for costs to follow the event, and I see no reason to depart from that principle here. I award costs, according to the official scale set out in Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995, against the unsuccessful trade mark applicant Serafino Wines Pty Ltd.Bianca IrgangHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings27 August 2010

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established