Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited v S.A. Corman

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited v S.A. Corman [2015] APO 74

Patent Application:                2007276203

Title:Milk ingredient enriched in polar lipids and uses thereof

Patent Applicant:                   S.A. Corman

Opponent:  Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited

Delegate:  R Subbarayan

Decision Date:  9 November 2015

Hearing Date:  20 August 2015, in Canberra

Catchwords:  PATENTS – section 59 – opposition to grant of patent – dairy ingredient enriched in phospholipids – whether the claimed invention is novel – whether the claimed invention is inventive – whether the claimed invention is fully described – whether the claimed invention is a manner of manufacture – none of the grounds made out – costs awarded

Representation:  Patent applicant:  Katrina Howard SC instructed by Shahnaz Irani of Spruson & Ferguson

Opponent:AJ Park

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2007276203

Title:Milk ingredient enriched in polar lipids and uses thereof

Patent Applicant:                   S.A. Corman

Date of Decision:                   9 November 2015

DECISION

None of the grounds of the opposition has been made out. The claimed invention is novel, inventive, fully described and a manner of manufacture.

The application is to proceed to grant subject to any appeal being filed within the relevant period.

I award costs according to schedule 8 against Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited.

REASONS FOR DECISION

BACKGROUND

  1. Patent application 2007276203 in the name of S.A.Corman (the applicant) was filed on 13 July 2007 as a PCT application (PCT/EP2007/057247) and claims an earlier priority date of 17 July 2006. It is titled “Milk ingredient enriched in polar lipids and uses thereof”. It was examined and advertised as accepted on 13 December 2012. The grant of the patent has been opposed under section 59 of the Patents Act by Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited (the opponent). The claims of the opposed application were amended after the filing of evidence in support and the claims that are the subject of this decision are those that were filed on 12 February 2014. The matter was heard on 20 August 2015 in Canberra. While the applicant appeared in person, the opponent appeared by way of written submissions.

    GROUNDS OF OPPOSITION

  2. The Statement of Grounds and Particulars lists the grounds of opposition as Novelty, Inventive Step, Manner of Manufacture, Sufficiency, Clarity, Fair Basis and Utility. However at the hearing, the opponent did not press the grounds of Clarity, Fair Basis and Utility.

    EVIDENCE

  3. The opponent's evidence in support comprises:

    • Statutory declaration of Christine Lennon Buchan executed 13 September 2013 (Buchan). Mrs Buchan is a legal assistant employed by AJ Park. She gives evidence about the publication of prior art documents.
    • Statutory declaration of David Scott Munro declared 8 October 2013 (Munro). Mr Munro is principal scientist at David Munro Consultants. He has extensive practical experience with dairy technology and dairy processing. He gives evidence about the opposed specification and the phospholipids levels in the cited prior art.
    • Statutory declaration of Philip Joseph Silvester declared 8 October 2013 (Silvester). Mr Silvester is a production assistant employed…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited v S.A. Corman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] APO 74
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited v S.A. Corman, the opposition was filed against the grant of a patent by Fonterra to S.A. Corman. The patent related to a dairy ingredient that had been enriched in phospholipids. The opposition raised various grounds, including that the claimed invention was not novel, not inventive, not fully described, and not a manner of manufacture. The case was heard by the Australian Patent Office, with the decision made by a Commissioner.

The central legal issues before the Commissioner were whether the claimed invention met the criteria for patentability under section 59 of the relevant legislation. Specifically, the Commissioner had to determine if the invention was novel, inventive, fully described, and constituted a manner of manufacture. The Commissioner carefully examined the prior art, the inventive step, the disclosure, and the nature of the invention to decide these issues.

After a thorough examination, the Commissioner found that none of the grounds of the opposition were substantiated. The claimed invention was determined to be novel, as it had not been previously disclosed in the prior art. It was also found to be inventive, as it represented a non-obvious improvement over existing technology. Furthermore, the invention was fully described in the patent application, meeting the requirements for disclosure. Lastly, the Commissioner concluded that the invention was indeed a manner of manufacture, fulfilling the statutory criteria for patentability. The Commissioner awarded costs according to schedule 8 against Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited, reflecting the outcome of the opposition.

The final order was that none of the grounds of opposition had been made out. The application for the patent would proceed to grant, subject to any appeal being filed within the relevant period. The Commissioner's decision was clear and decisive, affirming the patentability of the invention and the appropriateness of proceeding to grant the patent.

Orders

Orders of the court

None of the grounds of the opposition has been made out. The claimed invention is novel, inventive, fully described and a manner of manufacture.

The application is to proceed to grant subject to any appeal being filed within the relevant period.

I award costs according to schedule 8 against Fonterra Co-Operative Group Limited