Fonterra Brands (Australia) Pty Ltd v Bega Cheese Ltd (Costs Ruling)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMERCIAL COURT

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LIST

S ECI 2017 00283

FONTERRA BRANDS (AUST) PTY LTD (ACN 095 181 669) First Plaintiff/First Defendant
by Counterclaim
BONLAND CHEESE TRADING PTY LTD (ACN 001 148 992) Second Plaintiff/Second Defendant
by Counterclaim
v
BEGA CHEESE LIMITED (ACN 008 358 503) Defendant/Plaintiff by Counterclaim

---

JUDGE:

McDonald J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

11 March 2021

DATE OF RULING:

16 March 2021

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Fonterra Brands (Australia) Pty Ltd v Bega Cheese Ltd (Costs Ruling)

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2021] VSC 117

---

COSTS — Plaintiffs’ claim and defendant’s counterclaim dismissed — No basis for departing from usual order that costs follow the event — Whether plaintiff should be liable for common costs not directly attributable to claim or counterclaim — Significant disparity in size of counterclaim justifies departure from usual order that liability for common costs falls in accordance with outcome of claim — Whether plaintiffs acted unreasonably in rejecting offer of settlement made on 38th day of hearing — Plaintiffs acted reasonably in rejecting offer — Supreme Court Act 1986 s 24(1); Civil Procedure Act 2010 s 9(1)(d).

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiffs/Defendants by Counterclaim Mr G Dalton QC with
Mr P Creighton-Selvay
Arnold Bloch Leibler
For the Defendant/Plaintiff by Counterclaim Ms X Teo Gilbert & Tobin

HIS HONOUR:

  1. On 25 February 2021 the Court published reasons for judgment in respect of the plaintiffs’ claim and the defendant’s counterclaim.  The Court dismissed the plaintiffs’ claim and the defendant’s counterclaim.  The parties were provided with an opportunity to file written submissions in respect of the costs of the proceeding.  Both parties filed submissions on 3 March 2021 and reply submissions on 9 March 2021.  On 11 March 2021 the parties made oral submissions in respect of the form of order they were seeking.  I have considered all of the submissions advanced by the parties, albeit I have not addressed in detail all of these submissions in this ruling.[1]

  1. The plaintiffs contend that the appropriate orders as to costs are:

(a)Subject to paragraphs (c), (d) and (e) below, the Plaintiffs are to pay the Defendant’s costs of and incidental to the Plaintiffs’ claim (including reserved costs).

(b)Subject to paragraph (e) below, the Defendant is to pay the Plaintiffs’ costs of and incidental to the Defendant’s counterclaim (including reserved costs).

(c)The Defendant is to pay the Plaintiffs’ costs of and incidental to proceeding S ECI 2019 00404 (including reserved costs).

(d)Subject to paragraph (e) below, the Defendant is to pay the Plaintiffs’ costs of and incidental to the matters pleaded in paragraphs 27 to 29 of the Fifth Further Amended Statement of Claim (including reserved costs).

(e)Neither party is entitled to recover common costs, which cannot be exclusively attributed to the claim or counterclaim.[2]

[2]Plaintiffs, ‘Fonterra’s Submissions on Costs’, 3 March 2021, [2]. 

  1. The plaintiffs submit that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fonterra Brands (Australia) Pty Ltd v Bega Cheese Ltd (Costs... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] VSC 117
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fonterra Brands (Australia) Pty Ltd brought a claim against Bega Cheese Ltd, which was met with a counterclaim by Bega Cheese Ltd. The parties' dispute was resolved by the Federal Court of Australia, which ultimately dismissed both the plaintiff’s claim and the defendant’s counterclaim. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate allocation of costs between the parties, considering whether the plaintiff should be held liable for common costs not directly attributable to their claim or the defendant’s counterclaim. A significant aspect of this consideration was the substantial disparity in the size of the counterclaim, which prompted a discussion on whether the usual order of costs should be altered. Additionally, the court evaluated whether the plaintiff had acted reasonably in rejecting a settlement offer made on the 38th day of the hearing.

The court examined the statutory provisions under the Supreme Court Act 1986 and the Civil Procedure Act 2010, specifically focusing on sections 24(1) and 9(1)(d) respectively. These sections provided the framework for determining the principles governing costs in litigation. The court concluded that there was no valid reason to diverge from the standard practice of costs following the event, meaning the losing party generally pays the costs of the winning party. However, given the substantial disparity in the size of the counterclaim, the court found it justified to adjust the liability for common costs. The court further determined that the plaintiff had acted reasonably in rejecting the settlement offer, as it was not in their best interest to accept terms that did not adequately address their claims.

In summary, the Federal Court of Australia dismissed both the plaintiff’s claim and the defendant’s counterclaim, finding no basis for deviating from the usual order that costs follow the event. However, the significant disparity in the size of the counterclaim justified a departure from the standard cost allocation. The court held that the plaintiff was not liable for common costs not directly attributable to their claim or the counterclaim. Additionally, the court found the plaintiff’s rejection of the settlement offer to be reasonable. As a result, the court ordered the defendant to pay the costs of the plaintiff.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established