Decision
Reasons for decision
An assessment of damages and any review of the causation issue referred to in ground 13 would lack utility. Even if the subsequent appeal were to succeed, absent a complete vindication, the reasoning and findings of the appeal court would inevitably have a material impact on the assessment of any damages.Conclusion In all but one instance we have found no merit in the grounds of appeal. As earlier stated, we do not consider that the decision that reputation evidence could not bear on proof of justification could have made any difference in the Judge’s findings. The appeal is dismissed.Appendix AFather John Fleming involved in sexual misconduct claimsEXCLUSIVE: ONE of SA’s best-known priests was appointed to a prestigious Catholic teaching position despite the church being aware of serious allegations of sexual misconduct against him.Father John Fleming is being investigated by the police Paedophile Task Force over allegations he was sexually involved with a teenage girl in the 1970’s.Detectives have also taken statements from another woman and a man who were allegedly sexually involved with father Fleming after seeking counselling from him.A five-week Sunday Mail investigation has revealed Australia’s highest-ranking Catholic, Cardinal George Pell, was aware of the allegations concerning at least one victim prior to Father Fleming being appointed to head Sydney’s Campion College, a Catholic liberal arts facility, in 2005.The Sunday Mail investigation has also revealed that former Catholic Archbishop of Adelaide Leonard Faulkner and one of his officials knew Father Fleming was the subject of serious misconduct allegations prior to ordaining him a Catholic priest in 1995.On Friday, current Archbishop of Adelaide Philip Wilson engaged prominent lawyer Michael Abbott, QC, to conduct an independent inquiry into the diocese’s handling of the allegations against Father Fleming.Archbishop Wilson has also “requested that the priest return to the archdiocese to assist” with the investigation.“Mr Abbott has been retained to conduct an inquiry into the process and procedures regarding this matter,” Archbishop Wilson said yesterday.“We will place no limits on the extent of the inquiry or where Mr Abbott wants to go with this to address this issue. In the interests of due process, the Archdiocese of Adelaide cannot comment further.”The move came after the Sunday Mail posed questions to Archbishop Wilson’s office on Wednesday over the diocese’s handing of the allegations surrounding Father Fleming and also informed it of the police investigation.The misconduct involving the two girls – one underaged – occurred in the 1970’s, while his sexual relationship with the man spanned a six-year period ending in 1981.Police yesterday declined to comment, but it is known the file will be sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions, Stephen Pallaras, QC, when completed.Only the allegations involving the underage girl are being investigated by police. The other two cases are being examined as part of that inquiry.The Sunday Mail has obtained the police statements of the three people and has also interviewed them at length.The disturbing revelations come six weeks after Pope Benedict XVI apologised to Australian victims of sexual abuse and promised that the church would treat them with care and compassion.The Sunday Mail investigation has revealed the Anglican and Catholic churches have been aware of allegations surrounding Father Fleming for many years.In the case of the male, the Catholic Church was made aware in 1995. It was also made aware of the alleged misconduct with one of the females in late 1994 and the second female in 2000. After a distinguished career as an Anglican priest, Father Fleming controversially left in 1987 to join the Catholic Church, which ordained him in 1995.He left Adelaide in 2005 after being appointed president of Campion College, Australia’s first Catholic liberal arts teaching facility, in Sydney.In 2003, he was appointed by then Prime Minister John Howard to the board of the Australian museum.In an April 2004 letter obtained by the Sunday Mail, Cardinal George Pell acknowledges the complaint against Father John Fleming from one female victim. Cardinal Pell wrote back the next day and advised the victim to contact police herself.“The allegations you make against Fr Fleming are of a very serious nature. They should be investigated by the police and I would encourage you strongly to pursue your complaint with them,” Cardinal Pell wrote in his response.Despite Cardinal Pell and the Adelaide Diocese being aware of allegations, Father Fleming’s Campion College appointment went ahead.His three victims all want his position reviewed and a thorough internal investigation into his conduct. One of his victims, Dianne, told the Sunday Mail.“I was so angry that this man who had abused his power over me and had such a huge impact on my life, an immediate impact, had been put in a position of power again over young people.“I cannot imagine how a person who has questions about their integrity can be put into such a position.”The Sunday Mail investigation has also revealed the Catholic Church proceeded with Father Fleming’s 1995 ordination despite then Archbishop Leonard Faulkner being told about, and meeting with the man who had a sexual relationship with Fleming.The man was aged 20 when he sought counselling from Father Fleming over his sexuality. Archbishop Faulkner had several meetings with the man in 1995, during which he was told of the relationship spanning six years.The man’s police statement reveals Father Fleming had contacted him in an agitated state after he was first spoken to by church officials.“I believe the Catholic Church must have been in contact with him because he rang me distressed about it and asked me to tell the archbishop that there was no penetration,” he told police.“It appeared really important to John that I advised the archbishop that we did not have intercourse. I did tell the archbishop the exact relationship I had with John, which involved no penetration, but I didn’t think it mitigated anything. I recall the archbishop asking me whether he should ordain John. I told him that it wasn’t up to me to make that decision.”The man, who asked to be known only as [Peter], said he was surprised Father Fleming was ordained months later. The Sunday Mail sought a response from Father Fleming at his Sydney home on Thursday.He provided a written statement via his wife, Alison. “The proper course is for these allegations to be investigated by the police or the church in the ordinary way,” he said.When the Sunday Mail contacted his lawyer, Michael Sykes, on Friday and asked if Father Fleming was denying the allegations, he would not directly respond.“This is not the appropriate forum for him to come out with any response to the allegations,” Mr Sykes said. “The appropriate forum is the courts or the ecclesiastical disciplinary tribunal mechanism.”Late on Friday, Cardinal Pell’s office provided the Sunday Mail with a written response to questions posed to it on Thursday. “As Archbishop of Sydney, Cardinal Pell has no jurisdiction over other dioceses or priests belonging to them,” it said.“When allegations are received about priests in other dioceses, complainants are encouraged to go to the police or the Professional Standards Office in the relevant state.“A copy of the complaint is also provided to the appropriate Professional Standards Office to follow up. Responsibility for the selection and appointment of staff at Campion College is a matter for the college, which is a private institution, not an official church agency, and outside the Sydney archdiocese.”Campion College chairman Mr John de Bruyn refused to comment on Friday. It is not known if the college was aware of any of the allegations surrounding Father Fleming at the time of his appointment.While Father Fleming is president, he answers to a board of trustees, headed by Mr de Bruyn. One trustee is Cardinal Pell’s private secretary, Dr Michael Casey.·Victim’s statement: Jane’s story/Cardinal Pell’s reply·Victim’s statement: [Dianne’s] story/Cardinal Pell’s reply·Victim’s statement: Read [Peter’s] storyRead Jane’s storyJANE kept her secret for more than 25 years. A sexual liaison with Father John Fleming irreversibly affected not just her formative adolescent years, but also her adulthood. When she finally took the step in 2000 to tell the Anglican Church what had happened, she had no idea what lay ahead. Although she said it affirmed what had occurred was illegal, she was advised to contact the Catholic Church because Father Fleming was no longer employed by them.Her interview with the Catholic Church was a body blow.“Wasn’t he just being inappropriate?” she was asked by a church official.“When I got this reaction, I thought: ‘How could they say that? They heard what happened’,” she told the Sunday Mail.Later, in June 2002, she wrote about her complaint in detail and sent a letter to the Anglican Professional Standards Office, asking for consideration in the way her complaint was handled.She was told that her complaint needed to be official – although what this meant was never explained.Those initial responses shattered her self-confidence and led her to both question and continue to blame herself for what had occurred – a reaction common to many abuse victims.But believing she was the only victim, she relapsed into silence, until, unexpectedly and devastatingly, John Whitham from the 2003 Anglican Board of Inquiry told her about other possible victims.This moved her to try again with the Catholic Church, and she wrote to Australia’s highest-ranking Catholic, Cardinal George Pell, in March 2003, advising him of an illegal sexual liaison with a Catholic priest.She knew Cardinal Pell could get access to a statement prepared after the initial interview in 2000 and her unsigned written complaint in 2002.Again, there were demands made to report her complaint in a particular way by the Adelaide office, when this was impossible for her.Jane’s dismay at the Catholic Church’s apparent ambivalence towards her complaints turned to anger and concern when Father Fleming was appointed president of Campion College in Sydney in 2005 – 18 months after she advised Cardinal Pell of the allegations and over four years after she first advised the Adelaide Diocese of the situation.“As far as I am aware, they did nothing about following up what I had told them. Presumably that would have been an important thing to do,” Jane said.“I would still be on their books. They have never followed me up. They just don’t want to know about it, even though they know there is a very dark cloud over one of their highest profile figures.“He is in charge of a college where there are vulnerable people. They will not be underage, but they are vulnerable.”Jane said that although she remembers the first occasion vividly, she does not have an accurate memory of exactly how many sexual encounters she had with Father Fleming.Although dates and locations are detailed in her police statement, Jane has asked the Sunday Mail not to reveal them because she fears this will identify her.Jane said that once she knew she was not the only person who had made a complaint about Father Fleming, she believed it was her moral responsibility to speak out.She has completed and signed her formal statement after being interviewed by the Paedophile Task Force several times since last October.“I don’t want revenge here, what I want is for people to be living cleanly and to take responsibility for their actions,” she said.“I don’t want to have to hide any more, I don’t want to have to protect people anymore.”Read [Dianne’s] storyThis part of appendix A is omitted as foreshadowed in [15] of these reasons.Read [Peter’s] storyVULNERABLE and confused about his sexuality, [Peter] confided in Father John Fleming.He expected guidance from a man he held “in awe”, but instead ended up in a sexual relationship with the popular priest. The relationship, which included encounters in Father Fleming’s St Mark’s College flat, on Anglican camps and later in the carpark of Father Fleming’s then parish at Plympton, spanned six years.While it started in 1975 prior to Father Fleming’s marriage and continued after it, the relationship ceased while Father Fleming went overseas for several years in the late 1970s.After [Peter] and his wife were married by Father Fleming in 1980, his relationship with him resumed – ending when [Peter] confided in another Anglican priest.In 1994, [Peter] and his wife separated after he came out.His wife then sought annulment of their marriage, citing his sexuality and relationship with Father Fleming.At the time, both were switching from the Anglican to the Catholic Church – at the same time Father Fleming was also switching denominations.During a marriage tribunal meeting, [Peter’s] relationship with Father Fleming was revealed – a confidence that was broken when then Catholic Archbishop Leonard Faulkner was advised.[Peter] told the Sunday Mail Father Fleming had rung him shortly afterwards in a distressed state.It was because of the disclosure of confidential information that [Peter] sought, and held, at least three meetings with Archbishop Faulkner.While [Peter] was primarily concerned at the breach of confidence by the tribunal, he also told Archbishop Faulkner of his relationship with Father Fleming.He remembers one meeting in Archbishop Faulkner’s Wakefield St office and another at his home in the western suburbs.“I asked for the meetings because I wanted to make it clear what had happened to me with John and the details of that,” [Peter] said.“He particularly asked me did I think that he should ordain John and I said that was not a decision I was comfortable making.“I wanted him to know what had happened and that decision was up to him.”[Peter] said the meetings were also about how he felt, his own involvement with the church and his role in what had occurred.“We talked about homosexuality in the church a bit and I talked about the effect of what had happened on me,” he said.[Peter] said that during his discussions with Archbishop Faulkner he “got the impression” that Father Fleming’s ordination may have been in question.He was “surprised” when Father Fleming was then ordained by Archbishop Faulkner.“I thought it was surprising, but I didn’t do anything about it,” he said.“I thought I had taken on the church as much as I could.”[Peter] said he believed there was “a question mark” over Father Fleming’s ordination and his suitability to hold such a position of trust.“MY view is that he was my priest, I went to him for help and he had a duty of care to me,” he said.“The sense in which I think there is a question mark over his suitability is that I was a vulnerable young man who was confused.“He took advantage of that.“I think there is a question mark over whether a person like that, who is in a counselling role and position of power over people, whether it is suitable for them to be in that role.”[Peter] said that in 2005, when he heard Father Fleming had been appointed to head Campion College, he was again surprised at the actions of the Catholic Church.[Peter] said he was contacted by the Paedophile Task Force three months ago as part of their investigation into Father Fleming.“I have been trying to get on with my life,” he said.“But here it is, it has come up again, so I have to deal with it.“It is stressful.”Appendix BPriest ‘told me to deny affair’THE former wife of the man who had an affair with Father John Fleming was pressured by the high-profile priest to deny knowledge of the relationship, it has been revealed. The woman has told the Sunday Mail of a meeting she had with Father Fleming and his wife Alison, in which she was urged to “deny it” and asked who else she had told. The revelation follows Father Fleming’s denial of the homosexual affair and two other sexual encounters with teenage girls in the 1970s – one of which is the focus of a Paedophile Task Force investigation. The inquiry and the improper conduct by Father Fleming involving a teenager, “[Dianne]”, and a young man, “[Peter]”, were revealed in last week’s Sunday Mail.The teenage girls and the young man were not known to each other.The Sunday Mail also revealed Catholic Church authorities – including, in one instance, Cardinal George Pell – were aware Father Fleming was the subject of allegations of sexual misconduct prior to him being appointed to head Campion College, a Catholic arts facility, in Sydney in 2005.After being advised by the Sunday Mail of the police investigation and the apparent mishandling of the allegations, Catholic Archbishop Philip Wilson announced an independent inquiry by lawyer Michael Abbott, QC.Following the Sunday Mail report, Father Fleming – who was ordained a Catholic priest in 1995 after defecting from the Anglican church – stood down from duties as a priest and Campion College until the two inquiries are completed. He released a statement denying he had “ever engaged in sexual or inappropriate behaviour with a minor” and rejected the allegations he had been sexually involved with either [Dianne] or [Peter].However, [Peter’s] former wife Wendy said yesterday she was invited to Father Fleming’s house after she had disclosed the affair to a case worker during marriage annulment proceedings.She said it occurred in late 1994, shortly after the marriage tribunal chairperson had told then Catholic Archbishop Leonard Faulkner of the homosexual affair.“John was wanting to clarify with me my motivations for disclosing to the marriage tribunal,” Wendy said this week.“I think they (John and Alison) were also trying to do a risk assessment because, basically, what they asked me to do was detail anybody I had spoken to and exactly what I had told them”.“They said if it got out to the media was I prepared to deny it”.“My response to that was I am happy to say I am not aware of it. John said, ‘No, that is not good enough, are you prepared to say no it didn’t happen, you need to be prepared to say it didn’t happen’”.“He said if I wasn’t prepared to do that then he and Alison would move to England. I guess I felt a lot of pressure to make that commitment and I did make that commitment”.Wendy said she had decided to speak out following Father Fleming’s denial of the affair.“Basically, he was calling us liars and I guess that’s what made me angry,” she said. “My feeling before was if he took this on the chin or just said it was not appropriate to comment, then I didn’t need to add fuel to the fire. But the statement was a personal attack on [Peter] for something John did and he is not prepared to apologise and say, ‘I did the wrong thing’.”Wendy said the 1994 meeting was the second time she had discussed her husband’s affair with Father Fleming – the first was in 1986 when [Peter] told her about it.She said in the 1986 meeting “John became quiet and apologised and was visibly shaken”.The woman at the centre of the PTF investigation, Jane, said Father Fleming’s denial “was no surprise”. “I didn’t think he’d have the courage to confess,” she said.“Instead, he exhorts me to go to the police, even though it was made clear that I had made a police statement. I read this as code for ‘it will be your word against mine’.“He must believe that his reputation will be proven superior to mine. But this isn’t about reputation; it is about the truth and I am telling it.”Jane said Father Fleming’s denial of their sexual liaison had “hit me hard”. “I understand this pain is labelled re-victimisation,” she said. “He has stirred up in me again those feelings of worthlessness and desperation. I could have coped with silence, but his denial feels like a threat.”[Dianne] said yesterday she was also upset at Father Fleming’s response, particularly that her allegations were “unsubstantiated”.“The Catholic Church never investigated them, so how could he say they were unsubstantiated?” she said.Father Fleming declined to comment when contacted through his lawyer Michael Sykes on Friday.Appendix CFather John Fleming sex claim report next yearAN internal investigation into the handling of sexual misconduct allegations against a senior priest by the Adelaide diocese of the Catholic Church will not be completed until next year. The inquiry, being conducted by prominent lawyer Michael Abbott, QC, was launched in August, after the Sunday Mail revealed that the diocese was aware of the allegations surrounding Father John Fleming, but that it had not taken any action. The allegations, one of which is the subject of a Paedophile Task Force investigation, involve activity which occurred when Father Fleming was an Anglican priest. They include allegations he was sexually involved with two girls – one underage – and that he had a homosexual affair before he was ordained as a Catholic priest.The Sunday Mail revealed that church authorities – including, in one instance Sydney Cardinal George Pell – were also aware that Father Fleming was the subject of allegations of sexual misconduct before he was appointed to head Campion College, a Catholic arts facility in Sydney, in 2005.The diocese was also aware of Father Fleming’s homosexual relationship prior to ordaining him in 1995, but proceeded.When he announced the inquiry on August 29, Archbishop Philip Wilson said the diocese would “place no limits on the extent” of Mr Abbott’s investigations.Mr Abbott said the inquiry was “progressing well” with all necessary documentation now obtained from the diocese.“It will be a thorough and wide-ranging inquiry and I am now in the process of interviewing the relevant witnesses,” he said.“Some have been approached and others are being notified regarding their interview.”Mr Abbott said the scope of the inquiry would result in it being concluded early next year.Appendix DChurch investigates Father John Fleming over homosexual claimTHE Anglican Church has launched an investigation into high-profile priest Father John Fleming’s alleged homosexual relationship with a former parishioner. The inquiry, by the Professional Standards Office of the Anglican Diocese of Adelaide, was launched last month after a former parishioner agreed to co-operate with investigators. The new investigation will run parallel with an inquiry already under way into Father Fleming’s conduct with an under-age girl and another woman while he was an Anglican priest in the 1970s.The Anglican inquiries are not connected to the inquiry launched in August by the Catholic Church, after the Sunday Mail revealed police were investigating Father Fleming’s conduct with the under-age girl.The Catholic Church inquiry, being conducted by prominent criminal lawyer Michael Abbott QC, is examining the Church’s handling of the same allegations against Father Fleming after it was notified of them. Mr Abbott has already interviewed the male parishioner, “[Peter]”, at length and will interview the two females “Jane” and “[Dianne]” soon.Anglican Professional Standards Director Peter Caporaso yesterday confirmed the new investigation, but declined to comment further.The Sunday Mail revealed last August that “[Peter]” had advised former Catholic Archbishop Leonard Faulkner that he had a homosexual affair with Father Fleming – prior to Father Fleming being ordained a Catholic priest in 1995.While the Anglican Church does not have the power to take any action against Father Fleming because he is no longer an Anglican priest, it is likely the findings of its inquiries will be provided to the Catholic Church.“[Peter]” yesterday told the Sunday Mail he welcomed the Anglican inquiry because he believed the matter needed to be investigated “fully and properly”.“While the Abbott inquiry is examining the Catholic Church’s handling of the allegations after it was advised, the Anglican inquiry will examine what took place between John Fleming and myself,” he said.A spokesman for Catholic Archbishop Philip Wilson yesterday said he had been formally advised by the Anglican Church of its inquiry into “[Peter’s]” complaint. The spokesman said the Church had not been advised of a finish date for Mr Abbott’s inquiry and there were still “no limits” on its extent.The Sunday Mail revealed last August that Father Fleming was the subject of a Paedophile Task Force investigation into his conduct with an under-age girl.“Jane” told the Sunday Mail she had a sexual relationship with Father Fleming when she was a teenager and detailed her attempts to have both the Catholic and Anglican churches take action for the past eight years.Father Fleming was formally interviewed by detectives in December last year, but at this stage the police have chosen to keep an open file rather than lay criminal charges because of the evidentiary difficulties involving the investigation of historical sex offences.“Jane” said yesterday although she was “intensely disappointed Father Fleming would not be held accountable in a court of law”, she still wanted him “to take responsibility for his actions”.“I know what happened and he knows what happened,” she said.“His continual denial is simply re-victimisation of me, which is making this process even more of an ordeal.”As part of the police inquiry detectives took statements from “[Peter]” detailing his relationship with Father Fleming and from another woman, “[Dianne]” who was also allegedly sexually involved with him when she was 17.Father Fleming was suspended from his position Campion College, Sydney, last August pending the results of the police and Catholic Church inquiry.Appendix EPriest sacked from college - Sexual misconduct investigation HIGH-PROFILE priest Father John Fleming has been sacked from his prestigious teaching position as a top-level investigation into the Catholic Church’s handling of sexual misconduct allegations against him is finalised.Sources have revealed Father Fleming’s contract as president of Campion College, a Catholic liberal arts tertiary school in Sydney, was terminated last month following a board meeting of the foundation that oversees the operations of the college.The move, which is understood to have sparked a legal fight between Father Fleming and the college, comes almost a year after he was suspended when the Sunday Mail revealed he was the subject of allegations of sexual misconduct by three people and the target in a police investigation.It comes just weeks before an independent inquiry report by prominent lawyer Michael Abbott, QC, is handed to the Catholic Archbishop of Adelaide Philip Wilson.Archbishop Wilson commissioned the inquiry, which is examining the church’s handling of the allegations, on August 29 last year, after the Sunday Mail revealed the church was aware of some of the sexual misconduct allegations when Father Fleming was ordained as a catholic priest in 1995. The Sunday Mail also revealed Father Fleming was the subject of a Paedophile Task Force investigation over alleged sexual misconduct with an underaged girl.The police inquiry did not result in any charges because of insufficient evidence, but the file has been kept open.The Sunday Mail understands Mr Abbott has just completed the final witness interview in his inquiry and he is now in the final stages of writing his report.The chairman of the Campion foundation, union leader Joe De Bruyn, refused to comment on the move when contacted on Friday.Archbishop Wilson’s office also declined to comment when asked if moves were now being made to have Father Fleming return to Adelaide. His licence is held by the Adelaide Diocese.In a series of interviews last August, the three victims, Jane, [Dianne] and [Peter], detailed their sexual involvement with Father Fleming while he was an Anglican priest.Jane, who was underaged at the time of her involvement with Father Fleming, yesterday told the Sunday Mail she was “relieved” that he was no longer working at Campion.“I’m also very angry. High ranking church officials knew of the allegations of illegal, immoral, and unprofessional behaviour, yet Fleming was appointed to an elevated position of trust,” she said.“It seems like … the Catholic Church is more concerned about adverse publicity than about victims of abuse. His sacking gives me no joy, knowing that his wife and children will be suffering.”The Anglican Church earlier this year launched its own inquiry into Father Fleming’s conduct with [Peter], which is examining what took place between the pair while Father Fleming was an Anglican priest. While the Anglican Church cannot take any action, it is likely its findings will be provided to the Catholic Church.[Peter], who had a relationship with Father Fleming in the late 1970s, said he took “no joy at all” from Father Fleming’s situation.“It is very sad that is has come to this and if these issues had been dealt with properly when they first arose, we may not all have found ourselves in this mess. I am not looking for retribution in this matter,” he said.“Since this matter re-entered my life about 18 months ago I have received no offer of any support at all from the Catholic Church.“I hope the report of the Abbott inquiry is available soon and that something creative and positive comes from it for all the relevant parties and it is not left to gather dust on the collective bookshelves of archbishops and monsignors.”Father Fleming could not be contacted for comment yesterday.