Fleeting and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 1214

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No A2001/88

GENERAL AMINISTRATIVE DIVISION  )          
           Re      PETER MICHAEL FLEETING     
  Applicant
           And    AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION        
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mr M J Sassella, Senior Member Dr M D Miller AO, Member            

Date26 November 2002

PlaceCanberra

Decision      The tribunal affirms the decision under review.  The applicant is entitled to no costs associated with the application.   
  ..............................................
  Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
WORKERS' COMPENSATION – rotator cuff disease in left shoulder – whether disease aggravated by activities in employment – work as mail sorter – whether work as mail sorter aggravated rotator cuff disease – no injury found by Tribunal

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 4(1) ("ailment", "disease", "injury"), 14(1)

Casarotto v Australian Postal Corporation (1989) 86 ALR 399

REASONS FOR DECISION

26 November 2002 Mr M J Sassella, Senior ember Dr M D Miller AO, Member               

THE APPLICATION

  1. This is an application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal ("the tribunal") by Peter Michael Fleeting ("the applicant"), born 3 April1957 (T1).  The applicant seeks review of a decision of a delegate in the Australian Postal Corporation ("Australia Post", "the respondent") dated 8 January 2001 (T74) which affirmed a primary decision dated 9 November 2000 (T65).  The decision under review was the denial of any liability on the part of Australia Post for the degenerative condition affecting Mr Fleeting's left shoulder.
    THE HEARING

  2. The tribunal convened a hearing in this matter in Canberra.  Mr R Livingstone of counsel represented Mr Fleeting while Mr B Skinner of counsel represented Australia Post.  Oral evidence came from Mr Fleeting, Dr G Stubbs, orthopaedic surgeon and Dr J C Downes, orthopaedic consultant.  The following documents were entered into evidence and marked as exhibits as follows:

    Exhibit TD1 – Section 37 Statement and associated documents (exhibits T1 – T84) provided by the respondent.
    Exhibit A1 – Applicant's amended statement of facts and contentions, 17 May 2002.
    Exhibit A2 – Report by Dr R J Scott, occupational physician, 30 May 2002.
    Exhibit A3 – Report by Dr Stubbs, 13 July 2001.
    Exhibit A4 – Report by Dr Stubbs, 4 July 2001.
    Exhibit A5 – Article, Musculoskeletal Disorders and Workplace Factors, edited by B P Bernard, US Department of Health and Human Services, July 1997.
    Exhibit A6 – Report by Dr Stubbs, 2 October 2001.
    Exhibit A7 – Report by Dr Stubbs, 7 November 2001.
    Exhibit A8 – Report by Dr Stubbs, 9 January 2002.
    Exhibit A9 – Australia Post brochure, All In a Day's Work, photograph of "ULD".
    Exhibit A10 - Australia Post brochure, All In a Day's Work, photograph of "VSD".
    Exhibit R1 – Respondent's statement of facts and contentions, 11 October 2001.
    Exhibit R2 – Report by Dr Downes, 23 April 2001.
    Exhibit R3 – Report by Dr Downes, 5 July 2001.
    Exhibit R4 – Report by Dr Downes, 2 September 2002.
    Exhibit R5 – Report by Dr D S Elder, occupational physician, 31 May 2002.

LEGAL PRINCIPLES

  1. In order to qualify…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fleeting and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 1214
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Fleeting v Australian Postal Corporation, the applicant, Mr Fleeting, sought workers' compensation for a rotator cuff disease in his left shoulder, which he claimed was aggravated by his employment as a mail sorter. The dispute was heard by the tribunal, which ultimately found that Mr Fleeting had not sustained a compensable injury under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. The tribunal's decision was subsequently appealed to the court.

The legal issues before the court involved determining whether the work activities performed by Mr Fleeting as a mail sorter had aggravated his existing rotator cuff disease, thereby constituting a compensable injury under the Act. The court had to consider the evidence provided by the medical experts, Dr Stubbs and Dr Downes, and decide whether the repetitive and awkward movements required in Mr Fleeting's job had indeed contributed to his condition.

In its reasoning, the court examined the evidence presented by Dr Stubbs, who suggested that highly repetitive work with awkward shoulder postures could aggravate shoulder problems. However, Dr Stubbs had not observed Mr Fleeting at work and relied on his account of the job's demands. Dr Downes, on the other hand, believed that Mr Fleeting's rotator cuff issues were primarily degenerative and constitutional, not significantly influenced by his work activities. The court ultimately agreed with Dr Downes' assessment, finding that the work as a mail sorter did not materially contribute to Mr Fleeting's shoulder condition. Consequently, the tribunal's decision that Mr Fleeting had not sustained a compensable injury was affirmed.

The court's final orders confirmed the tribunal's decision, stating that Mr Fleeting had no left shoulder injury under the Act, and therefore, Australia Post had no obligation to pay compensation. Additionally, Mr Fleeting was not entitled to any costs associated with the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Dr Stubbs addressed the connection between repetitive work and shoulder problems. He repeated that degenerative changes are common in the community. Where a person engages in highly repetitive work with awkward shoulder posture and static shoulder loads the problem can be aggravated. Dr Stubbs had referred to ex A5 where it was written that:"There is evidence for a positive association between highly repetitive work and shoulder MSDs [ie musculoskeletal disorders]. Only three studies specifically addressed the health outcome of shoulder tendinitis and these studies involve combined exposure to repetition with awkward shoulder postures or static shoulder loads. The other six studies with significant positive associations dealt primarily symptoms. There is insufficient evidence for a positive association between force and shoulder MSDs based on currently available epidemiologic studies. There is evidence for a relationship between repeated or sustained shoulder postures with greater than 60 degrees affliction or abduction and shoulder MSDs. There is evidence for both shoulder tendinitis and non-specific shoulder pain. The evidence for specific shoulder postures is strongest where there is combined exposure to several physical factors like holding a tool while working overhead." Dr Stubbs agreed with reservations that, to make a connection between Mr Fleeting's work and his left shoulder musculoskeletal disorder he would need to see Mr Fleeting at work. He said that he had relied on Mr Fleeting's history. It would be preferable if he could see whether Mr Fleeting worked with awkward postures, how he did his work and how much of it was above shoulder height. He had assumed Mr Fleeting engaged in repetitive movements. He had assumed Mr Fleeting stood at the VSD and still had to sort to eye level and above. Mr Fleeting had not raised his OCR and FSM work with Dr Stubbs. Sorting had been presented by Mr Fleeting as the sole cause of his problems. Dr Stubbs considered that the pain Mr Fleeting had in his left shoulder in February 2000 came from sorting work. dr j c downes Dr Downes provided five reports, some in response to reports by Dr Stubbs – T61 (24 October 2000), T81 (15 March 2001), ex R2 (23 April 2001), ex R3 (5 July 2001) and ex R4 (2 September 2002). It is fair to say that he tended to the view that Mr Fleeting's left shoulder rotator cuff problems were degenerative and constitutional. He did not regard the movements required of Mr Fleeting in his work as involving sufficient above-shoulder activity for them to have contributed in any material way to the problem. In T61 Dr Downes offered an interesting excursus on rotator cuff disease. Rotator cuff muscles through a lifetime are subjected to considerable frictional movement. The rotator cuff causes problems in human beings significantly and frequently. He said that in younger people tearing of a relatively normal rotator cuff is quite common and so people such as Shane Warne, Pat Rafter and Greg Norman have required rotator cuff surgery.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The tribunal has found that Mr Fleeting has no left shoulder injury under the Act. Australia Post therefore has no obligation to pay compensation under the Act to Mr Fleeting. Mr Fleeting is entitled to no costs associated with this application.DECISION The tribunal affirms the decision under review. The applicant is entitled to no costs associated with the application.I certify that the 53 preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Mr M J Sassella, Senior Member and Dr M D Miller AO, Member. Signed: ..................................................................................... AssociateDates of hearing 5 and 6 September 2002 Date of decision 26 November 2002Counsel for the applicant Mr R LivingstoneSolicitor for the applicant Higgins SolicitorsCounsel for the respondent Mr B SkinnerSolicitor for the respondent Australian Government Solicitor

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established