Flashback Holdings Pty Ltd v Showtime DVD Holdings Pty Ltd (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Flashback Holdings Pty Ltd v Showtime DVD Holdings Pty Ltd (No 5) [2009] FCA 859

FLASHBACK HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED, GAIAM INC and GAIAM AMERICAS INC v SHOWTIME DVD HOLDINGS PTY LTD, INTERFREIGHT LOGISTICS PTY LTD, WILLIAM NIGEL HEYDON LESLIE, GT HOLDINGS INC and JAFFA ROAD LIV LIMITED PARTNERSHIP

NSD 680 of 2008

PERRAM J
10 AUGUST 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 680 of 2008

BETWEEN:

FLASHBACK HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED
First Applicant

GAIAM INC
Second Applicant

GAIAM AMERICAS INC
Third Applicant

AND:

SHOWTIME DVD HOLDINGS PTY LTD
First Respondent

INTERFREIGHT LOGISTICS PTY LTD
Second Respondent

WILLIAM NIGEL HEYDON LESLIE
Third Respondent

GT HOLDINGS INC
Fourth Respondent

JAFFA ROAD LIV LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
Fifth Respondent

JUDGE:

PERRAM J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 AUGUST 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The motion be dismissed with costs. 

2.The matter be listed for further directions at 2:15pm on 27 August 2009.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 680 of 2008

BETWEEN:

FLASHBACK HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED
First Applicant

GAIAM INC
Second Applicant

GAIAM AMERICAS INC
Third Applicant

AND:

SHOWTIME DVD HOLDINGS PTY LTD
First Respondent

INTERFREIGHT LOGISTICS PTY LTD
Second Respondent

WILLIAM NIGEL HEYDON LESLIE
Third Respondent

GT HOLDINGS INC
Fourth Respondent

JAFFA ROAD LIV LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
Fifth Respondent

JUDGE:

PERRAM J

DATE:

10 AUGUST 2009

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. These proceedings have a most unfortunate history.  They are concerned with the relatively anodyne topic of copyright infringement.  On 8 May 2009, in circumstances to which it will be necessary to return, I directed the Registrar to draw up a minute of order recording that the defences of the first and third respondents (“Showtime” and “Mr Leslie” respectively) had been struck out on 18 March 2009 and judgment entered against them: Flashback Holdings Pty Ltd v Showtime DVD Holdings Pty Ltd (No 4) [2009] FCA 461 (“Flashback No 4”).  I made that order because I had concluded that Showtime and Mr Leslie had substantially failed to comply with a self-executing order made by me on 13 March 2009.

  2. By a notice of motion dated 24 May 2009 Showtime and Mr Leslie sought to set aside the direction to the Registrar of 8 May 2009.  As a result of leave granted during the hearing of the present application, the motion was amended so that it also sought to set aside the original self-executing order of 13 March 2009.  As the argument was developed Showtime and Mr Leslie made two points:

    (a)my conclusion on 8 May 2009 that the self-executing order had not been substantially complied with was incorrect. In fact, evidence now prepared showed that the respondents had substantially complied with the self-executing order.  In that circumstance, I should set…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Flashback Holdings Pty Ltd v Showtime DVD Holdings Pty Ltd (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 859
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Flashback Holdings Pty Ltd v Showtime DVD Holdings Pty Ltd (No 5), the primary legal issues centred around whether there had been substantial compliance with the court's orders, whether the direction to the Registrar to prepare a minute recording the striking out of the defences and the entry of judgment should be set aside in the interests of justice, and whether the self-executing order itself should be set aside. The court considered these issues in the context of non-compliance with a discovery order and the potential for prejudice to the opposing party, Flashback.

The court found that there had not been substantial compliance with the orders of 13 March 2009, as the non-compliance involved a substantial number of documents and was not diligently implemented. The court rejected the argument that the direction to the Registrar should be set aside, stating that doing so would leave unresolved the question of whether the self-executing order had been complied with. The court also considered whether the self-executing order itself should be set aside, noting that while it had jurisdiction to do so, the application was only made late in the oral argument. The court evaluated arguments from both sides, with Flashback arguing that Showtime and Mr Leslie could not be trusted with the discovery process and that there was a risk of an unfair trial, while Showtime and Mr Leslie argued that the non-compliance was minor and did not result in prejudice to Flashback.

Ultimately, the court dismissed the motion with costs and listed the matter for further directions, maintaining the self-executing order in place. The court's decision was based on the demonstrated unreliability of Showtime and Mr Leslie in complying with court orders, the lack of an attempt to explain the non-compliance, and the absence of an offer to pay the costs caused by the non-compliance. The court concluded that the interests of justice required the orders to be left in place, given the circumstances of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The motion be dismissed with costs.

2. The matter be listed for further directions at 2:15pm on 27 August 2009.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

PERRAM J
However, assuming all that in Showtime and Mr Leslie’s favour, I would still conclude that there had not been substantial compliance with my orders of 13 March 2009. This is so because I regard 11 or 12 documents as a substantial number and because, as I will presently explain, I do not think the discovery order was diligently implemented. The failure was, in these circumstances, neither trivial nor accidental. Accordingly, even if I thought it was appropriate to entertain Showtime and Mr Leslie’s application to revisit the conclusions in Flashback (No 4) (and I do not) I would not, in fact, reach a different conclusion.Second Issue: Should the direction to the Registrar to prepare a minute recording the striking out of the defences and the entry of judgment be set aside in the interests of justice? I consider below whether the self-executing order of 13 March 2009 should itself be set aside in the interest of justice. Clearly, if the answer to that question be yes, then the interests of justice will, naturally enough, require as an ancillary matter that the direction to the Registrar also be set aside. However, the present argument is not to that effect. Rather, it is that the operation of the direction is itself unjust. This argument should be rejected. To accede to it would achieve nothing. The direction of 8 May 2009 resolved a very narrow controversy viz whether the self-executing order had been complied with. If that determination were to be set aside it would leave that question unresolved. Interfering with this order in any context which does not include setting aside the self-executing order is a course lacking utility which I do not, in the circumstances, propose to take.Third Issue: Should the self-executing order itself be set aside. There is no doubt that the Court has jurisdiction to set aside the self-executing order. There can there be no objection to my considering the application on the basis that it has previously been determined (as there can in the case of the application to revisit whether the order was complied with). This is because, perhaps surprisingly, no such application was made until someway into the oral argument in the present application (that is, on the third occasion the whole question was before the Court). Mr Lindsay submitted that the order should be set aside for the following reasons:(a)the non-compliance was relatively minor and, indeed, it was now clear that Flashback had all of the documents about which complaint was made;(b)to shut a case out from being heard on the merits was an extreme step to be taken only in the clearest of cases and only where the interests of justice permitted no other course;(c)here the respondents had prepared their evidence. The non-compliance, whilst not trivial, did not bespeak the deliberate suppression of evidence;(d) there was no particular prejudice to Flashback. Mr Ellicott for Flashback took a different tack. He argued that the interests of justice required the orders to be left in place because:(a)it was shown that Showtime and Mr Leslie could not be trusted with the process of discovery and hence there was a real risk, should the matter proceed to trial, that the trial would be unfair;(b)there had been no attempt, even at this late stage, by Showtime or Mr Leslie to put their house in order and to file an affidavit as to discovery explaining precisely what led to the initial non-compliance;(c)there was no offer to pay the costs of Flashback which had been caused by the non-compliance with the orders. Where Showtime had effectively conceded that it was insolvent this meant that the perpetuation of the proceedings was, by itself, a species of prejudice. Consideration

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PERRAM J

Mr Ellicott for Flashback took a different tack. He argued that the interests of justice required the orders to be left in place because:(a)it was shown that Showtime and Mr Leslie could not be trusted with the process of discovery and hence there was a real risk, should the matter proceed to trial, that the trial would be unfair;(b)there had been no attempt, even at this late stage, by Showtime or Mr Leslie to put their house in order and to file an affidavit as to discovery explaining precisely what led to the initial non-compliance;(c)there was no offer to pay the costs of Flashback which had been caused by the non-compliance with the orders. Where Showtime had effectively conceded that it was insolvent this meant that the perpetuation of the proceedings was, by itself, a species of prejudice. Consideration The original discovery order was made on 10 December 2008. It called for the discovery of ten categories of documents by 18 January 2009. The topics were disparate but related, broadly speaking, to the quantity and price of the films imported into Australia. That order was not complied with. When the matter came before the Court on 11 March 2009 I was told that the reason for the delay in the provision of discovery was because a confidentiality undertaking had not yet been signed by Mr Ellicott, counsel for Flashback. It was not suggested on 11 March 2009 that no steps had been taken towards carrying out the discovery process. To the contrary, the solicitor for Showtime and Mr Leslie, Mr Chelvathurai, swore as follows:The First and Third Respondent’s Affidavit of Discovery is now ready to be filed and served upon receipt of Mr Ellicott’s duly signed Confidentiality Agreement. No suggestion was made on 10 December 2008 that there should be a confidentiality regime and, indeed, the matter was not raised in correspondence until 4 February 2009, several weeks after the first and the third respondents’ discovery was due. No application was made on 11 March 2009 to impose such a confidentiality regime. In light of those two circumstances I ordered the provision of discovery by 18 March 2009. Since I had been told that the list of documents was ready and that the only thing which was holding up the provision of discovery was the alleged failure of Mr Ellicott to provide the undertaking – a reason for non-compliance which I regarded as unsatisfactory – I made the orders self-executing. A list of documents was filed on 18 March 2009. The affidavit of Mr Leslie which accompanied that list of documents contradicted Mr Chelvathurai’s statement that the list was ready on 11 March 2009. At paragraphs 14 and 15 of his affidavit of 11 May 2009 Mr Leslie said:14. My Solicitors and I began preparing immediately from the 14th of March 2009 to provide the First and Third Respondent’s discovery to the Applicant’s Solicitors. I had 4 days within which the First and Third Respondents Affidavit of Discovery had to be filed and served on the Applicant.15. During the limited time, I had to verify each and every entry to the Affidavit of Discovery and I had to locate records of the First Respondent with respect to matters which the Court had ordered to be discovered as per Order 4 of the Order of 10 December 2009.