Fitzgerald and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

Fitzgerald and        Inspector-General in Bankruptcy [2024] AATA 2731 (31 July 2024)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/3547

Re:Kevin Fitzgerald

APPLICANT

AndInspector-General in Bankruptcy

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member Lee Benjamin

Date:31 July 2024

Place:Brisbane

The Respondent's decision dated 30 April 2021 is affirmed.

.................................[SGD].......................................

Member Lee Benjamin

Catchwords

BANKRUPTCY – where Trustee objected to discharge of bankruptcy – where objection made out pursuant to subsection 149D(1)(f) of Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) – Applicant does not have reasonable excuse for failure to meet statutory obligations – decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)

Cases

Mallett and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy [2018] AATA 3739

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member Lee Benjamin

31 July 2024

WHAT IS THIS DECISION ABOUT?

  1. Mr Kevin Fitzgerald was declared bankrupt in 2018. In the ordinary course, he would have been discharged from his bankruptcy three years later. However, his trustee, Mr John Melluish (Trustee), objected to his discharge because Mr Fitzgerald failed to pay the Trustee an amount under an income contribution assessment (ICA). Mr Fitzgerald sought an Inspector-General in Bankruptcy (Respondent) review of the Trustee’s objection. The Respondent confirmed the objection. Mr Fitzgerald now seeks a Tribunal review of the Respondent’s decision. Mr Fitzgerald concedes that he did not object to the ICA or meet his obligations under the same. He contends that his liability under the ICA was not correct because he was unemployed, not receiving income and otherwise unable to pay anything to the Trustee. Despite Mr Fitzgerald’s contentions, the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to review the ICA’s correctness in this application. The key issue for the Tribunal is whether Mr Fitzgerald had a reasonable excuse for failing to pay an amount under the ICA. In my view, the answer to this question is, no.             

    WHAT HAPPENED?

  2. On 17 April 2018, a Sequestration Order was made against the Applicant’s estate in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on the petition of Deloitte Services Pty Ltd.[1]

    [1] Exhibit R1, p 4, para 14.

  3. On 18 April 2018, the Trustee sent Mr Fitzgerald a letter advising as to his obligations under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (the Act). [2]

    [2] Exhibit R1, p 5, para 17.

  4. On 12 July 2018, the Trustee issued a letter to Mr Fitzgerald directing him to provide the Trustee with details of his estimated income for the contribution assessment period 17 April 2018 to 16 April 2019 (CAP1). Mr Fitzgerald failed to provide the Trustee with the requested information.[3]

    [3] Exhibit R1, p 5, para 17.

  5. On 5 September 2018, the Trustee conducted an assessment of Mr Fitzgerald’s income for CAP1 and issued an income contribution assessment for CAP1 in the sum of $12,451.60. On the same day, the Trustee issued correspondence to Mr Fitzgerald, which enclosed a Notice of Income Contribution Assessment for CAP1. Mr Fitzgerald was advised that he could make a lump sum payment of his income contribution liability or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fitzgerald and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2731
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Fitzgerald to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) concerning a decision by the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy (the Respondent) to affirm a trustee's objection to Mr Fitzgerald's discharge from bankruptcy. The objection was made pursuant to subsection 149D(1)(f) of the *Bankruptcy Act 1966* (Cth), which relates to a bankrupt's failure to pay an amount they are liable to pay under section 139ZG of the Act, without a reasonable excuse.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether there was sufficient evidence to support the ground of objection under subsection 149D(1)(f) and, if so, whether Mr Fitzgerald had a reasonable excuse for failing to make the required payment under the income contribution assessment (ICA). The core of the dispute centred on Mr Fitzgerald's assertion that he had a reasonable excuse for not paying the assessed amount due to unemployment and a lack of income, despite the trustee's assessment.

Member Lee Benjamin found that Mr Fitzgerald conceded he did not make any payments under the ICA after a section 139ZI notice was issued. The Tribunal was satisfied that there was sufficient evidence to support the ground of objection, noting that Mr Fitzgerald did not provide satisfactory evidence or submissions to address this point. While Mr Fitzgerald contended he had a reasonable excuse due to unemployment and financial support from his wife, the Tribunal found this was not established. The Tribunal noted that Mr Fitzgerald did not seek a review of the merits of the trustee's ICA within the prescribed period and did not provide evidence of his income as required by section 139U of the Act.

Accordingly, the Tribunal was not satisfied that Mr Fitzgerald had established a reasonable excuse for his failure to make the payment. The Respondent's decision to confirm the trustee's objection to Mr Fitzgerald's discharge from bankruptcy was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There is no dispute between the parties,[42] and indeed Mr Fitzgerald readily concedes,[43] that Mr Fitzgerald did not make a payment under the ICA to the Trustee after the section 139ZI notice was duly issued.[42] Transcript, p 22, lines 27-28.[43] Transcript, p 10, lines 18-47.There was sufficient evidence to support the ground of objection (under subsection 149D(1)(f)) Subsection 149D(1) of the Act specifies the grounds of objection that may be set out in a notice of objection. As already mentioned, the relevant ground in the present application is subsection 149D(1)(f) - the bankrupt failed to pay to the Trustee an amount that the bankrupt was liable to pay under section 139ZG. On the materials before me, and in particular, the Respondent’s letters to Mr Fitzgerald dated 31 March 2021 and 30 April 2021 (see paragraphs 9 and 11/12 above, respectively), there is sufficient evidence to support the ground of objection.[44] I note that Mr Fitzgerald did not offer relevant evidence or responsive submissions to satisfactorily address this point.Mr Fitzgerald did not have a reasonable excuse for the conduct or failure that constituted the special ground under subsection 149D(1)(f) of the Act[44] Exhibit Tr1, p 56-58. Mr Fitzgerald contends that he had a reasonable excuse for not meeting his obligations under the ICA because he was not receiving any income, was unemployed[45] and financially supported by his wife[46] during the relevant period. He says that he was unable to obtain employment despite efforts to do so[47] (but there was no evidence before the Tribunal of the same).[48] Notwithstanding that Mr Fitzgerald concedes that he had the right to, but chose not to, seek a review of the merits of the Trustee’s ICA, he maintains his contention that he had a reasonable excuse:MR FITZGERALD: It just doesn’t make any sense to me on any grounds: legal, moral or whatever. But I did not, have not, received a steady income or any marginal income [since 2016] …And nowhere near $111,000 for that particular year or, in fact, for any year. So that’s my position, basically. I just don’t understand how this income assessment stands, I guess, legally. Surely, it’s based on fact, not fiction.…[I]f I understand what Mr Giacco is saying that … because I didn’t, in a sense, have a review on a timely manner of the income assessment, this income assessment should stand even though I can prove, I suppose, you know, in my view, I can prove that I didn’t receive anywhere near that income of $110,000, what I don’t - so there’s that - so that issue alone appals [sic] me in a sense that, somehow, I can be liable for income that the trustee knew I didn’t receive or was in receipt of, I just don’t understand how that stand (indistinct) stand, so to speak.[49] [45] Transcript, p 24, lines 38-40.[46] Transcript, p 15, lines 42-43.[47] Transcript, p 9, lines 6-8.[48] Transcript, p 9, lines 14-17.[49] Transcript, p 6, lines 25-27, 31-33; p 21, lines 26-34.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 30 April 2021, the Respondent made a decision (Respondent’s decision). In the same, the Respondent indicated that it had reviewed the Trustees’ objection with reference to subsections 149C(1), 149C(1A), 149N(1) and 149N(1A) of the Act. The Respondent noted that for an objection under subsection 149D(1)(f) of the Act to be confirmed, the following elements had to be satisfied, namely that:(a)Mr Fitzgerald was liable to pay an amount under section 139ZG of the Act (an assessed income contribution liability); and(b)Mr Fitzgerald had failed to pay the Trustee that amount by the due date.[12][12] Exhibit R1, p 7, para 22. The Respondent’s decision states that it made the following factual/evidential findings:(a)a valid contribution assessment had been issued by the Trustee to which the Applicant was liable to pay an amount under section 139ZG of the Act;(b)no payment of any amount towards the contribution assessment had been made by the Trustee’s requisite due date; and(c)there was sufficient evidence to support the ground of objection. [13][13] Exhibit R1, p 7, para 23. The Respondent’s decision indicates that, having satisfied itself that there was sufficient evidence to support the ground of objection under subsection 149D(1)(f) of the Act, the Respondent then considered whether Mr Fitzgerald had a reasonable excuse for the conduct or failure that constituted the special ground under subsection 149D(1)(f) of the Act (i.e., a reasonable excuse for not making a payment under the ICA). In reaching its position, the Respondent says they considered the matters offered by Mr Fitzgerald as a “reasonable excuse”, namely:(a)Mr Fitzgerald was unemployed in the years the subject of the period of the contribution assessment;(b)Mr Fitzgerald had received no income to make payment to the Trustee; and(c)Mr Fitzgerald had been supported financially entirely by his wife. [14][14] Exhibit R1, p 7, para 24. The Respondent’s decision states that it made the following findings on Mr Fitzgerald’s “reasonable excuse” grounds:·Mr Fitzgerald did not seek review of the merits of the Trustee’s assessment to the Respondent within the requisite 60 day period under the Act; ·Mr Fitzgerald did not provide evidence of his income and expected income during the subject period of the contribution assessment in accordance with his obligations under section 139U of the Act; and·accordingly, on the basis of the matters immediately above, the Respondent was not satisfied that Mr Fitzgerald had established a reasonable excuse for not making payment of the liability under the contribution assessment, which founded the ground of objection. Ultimately, the Respondent’s decision confirmed the Trustee’s objection to Mr Fitzgerald’s discharge from bankruptcy on the ground specified in subsection 149D(1)(f).[15][15] Exhibit R1, p 9, para 25-26. On 27 May 2021, Mr Fitzgerald made an application to the Tribunal[16] for review of the Respondent’s decision dated 30 April 2021 to confirm the Trustee’s objection to his discharge from bankruptcy under the ground specified in subsection 149D(1)(f) of the Act dated 5 January 2021.[17] Mr Fitzgerald states that the reasons for this application are as follows:Technically, I did not disclose particulars of income in the prescribed method. However, the Trustee was informed both verbally and via email that I had not had any regular, if any income, since 2015. The amount used for the [income contribution] assessment was erroneous. I was not, could not be an architect. I was as a bankrupt not able to practice as one. [18] [16] Exhibit Tr1, p 2.[17] Mr Fitzgerald applied to the Tribunal under subsection 149Q(a) of the Act and subsection 25(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (the AAT Act).[18] Exhibit Tr1, p 3.WHAT DOES THE LAW SAY?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.