NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Fire Brigade Employees' Union v Fire and Rescue NSW [2014] NSWCATAD 113 Hearing dates: 3 June 2013 and on the papers Decision date: 05 August 2014 Jurisdiction: Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division Before: S Higgins, Principal Member Decision: File no 123306
1. The decision of the respondent in regard to the information in document 38,40, 60,79, 81 and the redacted information in document 84 is affirmed.
2. The decision of the respondent in regard to the information in document 50 is set aside and remitted for reconsideration by the respondent in accordance with these reasons for decision.
File no 133223
3. The decision of the respondent is affirmed.
Catchwords: Administrative review - government information - public access - conclusive overriding public interest against disclosure - Cabinet information
Administrative review - government information - public access - public interest test - whether public interest considerations against disclosure on balance outweigh the public interest considerations in favour of disclosure
Administrative review - government information - public access - prescribed public interest considerations against disclosure - reveal a deliberation in such a way as to prejudice a deliberative process of the agency - prejudice the effective exercise by agency of its functions - expose a person to an unfair advantage as a result of the premature disclosure of information concerning proposed action of the agencyLegislation Cited: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (as at 31 December 2013)
Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW)
Fire Brigades Act 1989
Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth)
Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009
Industrial Relations Act 1966 (NSW)Cases Cited: Attorney-General's Department v Cockcroft (1986) 10 FCR180
Commissioner of Police (NSW) v Camilleri [2012] NSWADTAP 19
Hurst v Wagga Wagga City Council [2011] NSWADT 307
McKinnon v Secretary, Department of Treasury [2006] HCA 45
McLennan v University of New England [2013] NSWADT 113
Re Waterford and Department of the Treasurey (No2) (1984) 5 ALD 588
Sobh v Victoria Police (1993) 1 VR 41
Van der Wall v University of Sydney [2008] NSWADT 213Category: Principal judgment Parties: Fire Brigade Employees' Union (applicant)
Fire and Rescue NSW (respondent)Representation: J Nolan (Applicant)
I Harvey (Respondent)
G Maniatis (Applicant)
Sparke Helmore Lawyers (Respondent)
File Number(s): 123306 and 133223 Publication restriction: N/A
reasons for decision
Introduction
The applicant, Fire Brigade Employees' Union of NSW v Fire and Rescue NSW, seeks review of two decisions of the respondent, Fire and Rescue NSW, made under the Government Information (Public access) Act 2009 (GIPA Act) in regard to two applications it had made for access to specified information held by the respondent.
The first application for access was made on 27 July 2012. The respondent's decision in regard to that application is the subject of file No 123306.
The second application for access was made on 23 April 2013. The respondent's decision in regard to that application is the subject of file No 133223.
In the first application the applicant sought…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fire Brigade Employees' Union v Fire and Rescue (NSW) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NSWCATAD 113
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The AAT examined the information contained within the documents and considered whether the public interest considerations against disclosure, specifically those concerning the revelation of deliberations in a way that could prejudice the agency's deliberative processes, applied. The Tribunal noted that for these considerations to apply, there must be a relevant connection between the information in dispute and the respondent's deliberative processes. The AAT found that the information in some documents reflected internal thinking regarding budgetary strategies and could reasonably be expected to prejudice ongoing deliberations about budgetary savings. However, it did not find that the information in other documents met this threshold. The redacted parts of the documents, particularly those that might reveal internal assessments about budgetary decisions, were deemed to potentially prejudice deliberative processes if disclosed.
Consequently, the AAT affirmed the respondent's decision to withhold certain documents, as the information within them could reasonably be expected to reveal deliberations in such a way as to prejudice the respondent's ongoing deliberative processes. The Tribunal set aside the decision regarding another document and remitted it for reconsideration, as it did not find sufficient evidence to support the withholding of information in that document. The AAT's decision underscored the importance of establishing a clear link between the information in dispute and the respondent's deliberative processes when applying the public interest considerations against disclosure under the GIPA Act.
The final orders of the AAT were to affirm the respondent's decision in regard to certain documents and to set aside and remit for reconsideration the decision concerning another document. Specifically, the AAT affirmed the withholding of information in documents 38, 40, 60, 79, 81, and the redacted information in document 84, while the decision regarding document 50 was set aside and remitted for reconsideration.
Orders
Orders of the court
File no 123306
1. The decision of the respondent in regard to the information in document 38,40, 60,79, 81 and the redacted information in document 84 is affirmed.
2. The decision of the respondent in regard to the information in document 50 is set aside and remitted for reconsideration by the respondent in accordance with these reasons for decision.
File no 133223
3. The decision of the respondent is affirmed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
For the public interest consideration against disclosure in cl 1(e) to apply, the respondent must establish that the information in issue could reasonably be expected to reveal a deliberation in such a way to prejudice a deliberative process of the respondent. That is a relevant connection must be established between the deliberation as contained in the information in dispute and the respondent's 'deliberative processes': see Van der Wall v University of Sydney [2008] NSWADT 213 at [36]. The meaning of the term 'deliberative process' was considered by the AAT, in Re Waterford and Department of the Treasury (No 2) (1984) 5 ALD 588 at [58] to [61], in the context in which it appeared in s 36 of the Commonwealth Freedom of Information Act 1982 (FOI Act (Cth)), as it applied at that time. Although cl 1(e) of the GIPA Act and s 36 of the FOI Act (Cth) (as it applied in 1984) are not the same, they both deal with the disclosure of information concerning the 'deliberative process' of government or an agency. Hence, the following comments of the AAT, in Re Waterford, remain instructive: I am satisfied that the information in document 3, 4, 38, 40, 60, 79, 81 and the redacted information in 84 falls within the description of being part of the respondent's 'internal thinking' about strategies to meet the labour expense caps, the Wages Policy and other budgetary matters for the financial year in question and future years. I am also satisfied that the Briefing in document 50, in part, contains information of that kind (see at the bottom of page 2 and the top of page 3). However, I am not satisfied that the remainder of the information in this document falls within this category. As is evident from the terms of the information in this document, the majority of the information appears to have been intended for public disclosure. In the absence of any evidence from the respondent, I assume this information was revealed in some form. Nevertheless, to the extent this document contains information that reflects the 'internal thinking' of the respondent in regard to labour cost reductions, my findings in regard to this information equally apply. On the basis of the evidence of Mr Husdell, Mr Summons and Mr Last and the nature of the information in dispute, I am satisfied that the information in documents 3, 4, 38, 40, 60, 79, 81 and 84 (i.e. the redacted information) if disclosed could reasonably be expected to reveal the deliberations of the respondent in such a way as to prejudice its ongoing deliberative process about budgetary savings. The redacted information in the schedule that is document 84 is perhaps a good example of this. As identified in the email to which the schedule was attached, the schedule is a 'decision assessment tool' for identifying which fire stations within the Metropolitan Commands might be ToL stations. The nature of the 'tool' has been disclosed as are the each of fire stations (i.e. the appliance) within the Metropolitan Commands together with the relevant the zone, response planning times, 1st Pump Coverage, ToL Conditions and Appliance Category of each fire station. What has been deleted are the comments made by the relevant officers about matters that may need to be considered in any assessment that is made. These comments are clearly part of the respondent's 'internal thinking' and a disclosure of this information, in my view could reasonably be expected to reveal the deliberations of the respondent in such a way as to prejudice its ongoing deliberative process about deciding which fire stations should be temporarily taken off line. The ToL arrangements being a budget savings strategy.