Finance Sector Union of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

[2016] FWCD 1492

DECISION

Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009
s.159—Alteration of other rules of organisation
Finance Sector Union of Australia
(R2015/235)
MR ENRIGHT MELBOURNE, 1 JUNE 2016
Alteration of other rules of organisation.

[1]        On 22 October 2015 the Finance Sector Union of Australia (the Union) lodged with

the Fair Work Commission (the Commission) a notice and declaration setting out particulars

of alterations to the rules of the Union.

[2]        The particulars set out alterations to rules 28, 29, 40, 44 and 47.

[3]        Current rule 28 outlines the National Executive’s powers and duties. The proposed

alterations authorise the National Executive to set up sub-committees and delegate its powers

(save the power to delegate) to those sub-committees. The alterations also insert two new sub

rules 28.6 and 28.7 which establish that the composition of the sub-committees are members

of the National Executive and confirm that any such sub-committees are responsible to, under

and subject to the control of the National Executive.

[4]        Current rule 29 deals with meetings of the National Executive. The alterations delete

rule 29 and insert in lieu a new rule which, among other things, directs that the National

Executive meet quarterly each year; and at other times as it determines. The proposed rule

also provides for certain periods of notice and sets out procedures for the conducting of

ballots and calling urgent meetings.

[5]        Current rule 40 deals with the office of the National Assistant Secretary. Alterations to

rule 40 include the insertion of new sub rules 40.5, 40.6, 40.7, 40.8 and 40.9. These new sub

rules, among other things, direct the National Assistant Secretary to comply with directions of

National Conference and Executive; and carry out other duties as assigned to him or her. Sub

rule 40.7 empowers the National Executive to temporarily appoint a person to the role when

the office is extraordinarily vacant. Sub rules 40.8 and 40.9 further provide that the appointed

officer shall have all the powers of the National Secretary or National Assistant Secretary as

the case may be and is entitled to nominate for the position at the next election.

[6]        Rule 44 deals with the removal of officers. The alterations amend sub rule 44.1, and

insert new sub rules 44.1A and 44.13. Proposed sub rules 44.1 and 44.1A distinguish between

charges for misappropriation, substantial breaches of rules, gross misbehaviour and neglect of

duty; and the removal from office when the officer is no longer eligible to hold that office.
[2016] FWCD 1492

Proposed sub rule 44.13 provides that an officer may be removed from the membership of the

Union where it has already been determined that an officer is to be removed from office and a

finding has been made that the officer is also of general bad character or has not complied

with the rules of the Union.

[7]        Rule 47 deals with Union elections. The alterations, among other things, delete current

sub rule 47.49.5 which allows elected officers who were removed from office to nominate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Finance Sector Union of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FWCD 1492
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Finance Sector Union of Australia (the Union) lodged with the Fair Work Commission (the Commission) a notice and declaration setting out particulars of alterations to the rules of the Union. The proposed alterations related to rules 28, 29, 40, 44 and 47. Objections were received from Mr Rodney Masson, Ms Fiona Jordan and Mr David Scanlon. The Union responded to the objections, and the objectors responded in turn. The Delegate of the General Manager considered the objections and the responses. The Delegate found that the proposed alterations did not impose upon members or applicants for membership conditions, obligations or restrictions that are oppressive, unreasonable or unjust within the meaning of s.142(1)(c) of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009. The Delegate also found that the alterations complied with the requirements of s.159(1) of the Act. The Delegate certified the proposed alterations.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 22 October 2015, the Finance Sector Union of Australia lodged notice and declaration with the Fair Work Commission setting out proposed alterations to the Union's rules. The proposed alterations related to rules 28, 29, 40, 44 and 47. Several members of the Union objected to the proposed alterations, arguing that they would undermine the democratic functioning of the Union, could be misused in oppressive ways, and lacked adequate consultation with members. The Union's lawyers responded to the objections, arguing that the proposed alterations were consistent with the Union's rules and within the powers of the National Conference. The Commission considered the objections and submissions from both sides. The Commission found that the proposed alterations did not impose oppressive, unreasonable or unjust conditions on members, did not contravene the objects of the Fair Work Act, and were made in accordance with the Union's rules. The Commission certified the proposed alterations under s.159 of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009.

The matter before the court is an application by the Finance Sector Union of Australia to have certain proposed rule alterations certified by the Fair Work Commission. The Finance Sector Union of Australia, represented by Hall Payne Lawyers, lodged a notice and declaration setting out particulars of alterations to its rules with the Fair Work Commission on 22 October 2015. Various members of the Union subsequently lodged objections to the proposed rule alterations. The Delegate of the General Manager subsequently received correspondence from the Fair Work Commission asking for additional information regarding the proposed alterations. After considering the submissions of the parties, the Delegate has decided to certify the proposed rule alterations as compliant with the relevant legislation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed alterations to Rule 28 of the Finance Sector Union of Australia's rules are necessary and/or oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust.
2. Whether the proposed delegation of powers to sub-committees under Rule 28 is undemocratic or contrary to the objects of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009.
3. Whether the proposed alterations to Rule 28 have been drafted with an improper purpose in mind.
4. Whether the proposed sub-committees under Rule 28 are subject to member scrutiny.
5. Whether the proposed alterations to Rule 29 are unnecessary, unwieldy, or undermine the powers of the National Secretary.
6. Whether the proposed alterations to Rule 40 are unnecessary, create tension, or dilute the powers of the National Secretary.
7. Whether the proposed alterations to Rule 44 are arbitrary or unjust in removing officers from membership.
8. Whether the proposed alterations to Rule 44 contravene principles of natural justice.
9. Whether the proposed alterations to Rule 44 result in oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust treatment of members.
10. Whether the proposed alterations to Rule 47 are an attack on the democratic processes of the organisation and member democracy.
11. Whether the proposed alterations were made in accordance with the rules of the organisation.

Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed alterations to Rule 28 are not unnecessary and do not impose upon members or applicants for membership conditions, obligations, or restrictions that are oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust. The court found that the content of the rules is primarily a matter for the members. (paras. [82] to [86], [87])
2. The court held that the proposed delegation of powers to sub-committees under Rule 28 is not undemocratic or contrary to the objects of the Act. The court found that delegation is a common practice and is consistent with the standards and objects outlined in the Act. (paras. [95] to [106])
3. The court rejected the argument that the proposed alterations to Rule 28 have been drafted with an improper purpose in mind. The court found insufficient evidence to support the conclusion that the proposed rules would be used in oppressive, unreasonable, and unjust ways. (paras. [117] to [120])
4. The court determined that the proposed sub-committees under Rule 28 are subject to member scrutiny. The court found that the sub-committees are responsible to, under, and subject to the control of the National Executive, and their decisions are subject to the same level of scrutiny as the National Executive. (paras. [127] to [129])
5. The court rejected the argument that the proposed alterations to Rule 29 are unnecessary, unwieldy, or undermine the powers of the National Secretary. The court found that the proposed alterations enhance the National Secretary's powers by allowing them to call for meetings on an urgent basis. (paras. [147] to [150])
6. The court held that the proposed alterations to Rule 40 are not unnecessary, create tension, or dilute the powers of the National Secretary. The court found that the proposed sub rule provides supplementary duties for the National Assistant Secretary and does not create tension or dilute the powers of the National Secretary. (paras. [159] to [165])
7. The court concluded that the proposed alterations to Rule 44 are not arbitrary or unjust in removing officers from membership. The court found that the proposed sub rule provides for a formal process and does not prohibit members from being given notice of the proposed allegations and being afforded the opportunity to defend themselves. (paras. [197] to [205])
8. The court determined that the proposed alterations to Rule 44 do not contravene principles of natural justice. The court found that the proposed sub rule does not expressly or by necessary implication exclude the application of natural justice. (paras. [196] to [198])
9. The court found that the proposed alterations to Rule 44 do not result in oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust treatment of members. The court found that the different treatment of members who are officers and who have been charged and found guilty of certain allegations does not contravene any of the standards or objects of the legislation. (paras. [212] to [214])
10. The court rejected the argument that the proposed alterations to Rule 47 are an attack on the democratic processes of the organisation and member democracy. The court found that the proposed alterations comply with the provisions of the Act and do not contravene any of the standards or objects of the legislation. (paras. [224] to [227])
11. The court held that the proposed alterations were made in accordance with the rules of the organisation. The court found that the actions declared to have been taken are consistent with the rule altering procedure set out in the rules of the Union. (paras. [242] to [246], [252])

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The decision addresses the proposed alterations to the rules of the Finance Sector Union of Australia (the Union) and whether these alterations should be certified under section 159 of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009. The Union's proposed rule changes were objected to by several members, who raised various concerns regarding the democratic functioning and control of the organisation. The court's reasoning can be distilled into the following key issues:

1. **Necessity and Democratic Control of Proposed Alterations to Rule 28**: The proposed alterations to Rule 28, which involve delegating powers to sub-committees, were challenged on the grounds of being unnecessary and undemocratic. The court rejected these objections, finding that the content of the rules, including the delegation of powers, is primarily a matter for the Union's members and that the proposed delegation is consistent with the Act's objects, including promoting efficient management and democratic control. The court found that the proposed sub-committees are subject to the same level of member scrutiny as the National Executive.

2. **Proper Purpose of Proposed Alterations**: The objectors argued that the proposed alterations were drafted with an improper purpose to circumvent the National Secretary's powers. The court found insufficient evidence to support this claim and concluded that the potential misuse of the rules was not a ground for disallowance, as relief for such misuse lies in the application of sections 164 and 164A of the Act.

3. **Certainty and Vagueness of Proposed Alterations to Rule 28**: The court rejected the argument that the proposed alterations were vague and uncertain, finding that the rule contemplates committees of different sizes and is limited by the number of members of the National Executive.

4. **Undue Influence on Rule 29**: The court found no evidence to support the claim that the proposed alterations to Rule 29, which concern meetings of the National Executive, would dilute the powers of the National Secretary or undermine the democratic functioning of the organisation.

5. **Duties of the National Assistant Secretary in Rule 40**: The court rejected objections to the proposed alterations to Rule 40, finding no inherent tension in the duties assigned to the National Assistant Secretary and no evidence that the proposed alterations would dilute the powers of the National Secretary.

6. **Removal of Officers in Rule 44**: The court found that the proposed alterations to Rule 44, concerning the removal of officers, did not contravene principles of natural justice and were not oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust. It held that the principles of natural justice must be implied into the procedure unless expressly excluded by the rules.

7. **Different Treatment of Members in Rule 44**: The court determined that the different obligations placed upon members who are officers and those who are not did not impose oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust conditions within the meaning of the Act.

8. **Elections in Rule 47**: The court rejected the objection that the proposed alterations to Rule 47, concerning elections, were an attack on the democratic processes of the organisation and member democracy, finding no evidence to support these claims.

9. **Compliance with Organisation's Rules**: The court found that the proposed alterations were made in accordance with the rules of the organisation, despite objections regarding the transparency of the rule-altering procedure.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the proposed rule alterations to the Union's rules are not oppressive, unreasonable, or unjust, and comply with the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 and other relevant legislation. The court's approach aligns with the principle that the content of the rules of a registered organisation is primarily a matter for its members, subject to the constraints and restrictions imposed by the Act. The decision also reinforces the importance of natural justice and democratic control in the functioning of registered organisations.