Fifty Sixth Taljan P/L v Dattilo Holdings P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted
AT MELBOURNE
COMMERCIAL AND EQUITY DIVISION

No. 9450 of 2006

FIFTY SIXTH TALJAN PTY LTD Plaintiff
(ACN 007 129 017)
v
DATTILO HOLDINGS PTY LTD Defendant
(ACN 099 882 532)

---

JUDGE: WILLIAMS J
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 13 April 2007
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 28 June 2007
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: Fifty Sixth Taljan P/L v Dattilo Holdings P/L
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2007] VSC 226

---

Building Contract – Progress payment claim – Alleged negligence of builder in underquoting – Finance withdrawn – Alleged representations by builder to effect that it would rectify defendant’s financial difficulties – Alleged representation by builder that it would continue to build and forbear in relation to outstanding debt until defendant arranged finance – Right of set off under s 14 Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002.

Practice and Procedure – Summary judgment application – Whether real question to be tried.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff  Mr K C Oliver RND Lawyers
For the Defendant  Mr D Clough Ferdinand Zito & Associates

---

TABLE OF CONTENTS

The proceeding ...................................................................................................................................2
Material before the Court .................................................................................................................2

Facts.......................................................................................................................................................2

The BankWest decision ................................................................................................................3
The contract....................................................................................................................................3

The progress claim ........................................................................................................................5

The pleadings......................................................................................................................................7

Statement of claim.........................................................................................................................7
Defence and counterclaim............................................................................................................7

Amended defence and counterclaim .........................................................................................8

The Act .................................................................................................................................................9
Applicable principles ......................................................................................................................12

Submissions ......................................................................................................................................12

The plaintiff..................................................................................................................................12

The defendant ..............................................................................................................................15

Conclusions .......................................................................................................................................17

HER HONOUR:

The proceeding

  1. This is an appeal from the order of the Master dismissing the plaintiff’s application for summary judgment. The appeal proceeded as a re-hearing de novo under r 77.05(7) of the Supreme Court (General Procedure) Rules 2005 (“the Rules”).

    Material before the Court

  2. In accordance with r 77.05(7)(a), the parties rely upon affidavits used before the Master. The plaintiff relies upon affidavits from:

(a) Antonio Leonardo Coco, its director, sworn on 20 December 2006 and 14 February 2007, respectively; and
(b) Michael Cattenazzi, an information management co-ordinator, sworn on 20 December 2006.
  1. The defendant relies upon an affidavit sworn on 2 February 2007 by its director Antonio Gianluca Dattilo.

    Facts

  2. A number of matters of fact appear to be uncontentious. I will note where there is disagreement.

  3. The plaintiff carries on business as a builder. It traded at relevant times as “Apex Constructions”.

  4. In April 2004, the defendant obtained a building permit for the construction of seven warehouses/offices (“the building works”) on its land known as Lots 421 and 422 Randor Street, Campbellfield, Victoria (“the land”). The defendant sought quotations in relation to the building works from the plaintiff and others. The plaintiff provided a quotation of $1.08m and the defendant obtained others of $1.35m and $1.45m.

  5. On 5 October 2004, the plaintiff and the defendant first entered into a contract for the building works. The contract price was $1.08m plus GST. The defendant did not pursue the development. About a year later, Mr Dattilo of the defendant asked Mr Coco of the plaintiff whether the contract price stood. Mr Coco responded that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fifty Sixth Taljan P/L v Dattilo Holdings P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] VSC 226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute in Fifty Sixth Taljan P/L v Dattilo Holdings P/L involves a building contract and a claim for progress payments. The plaintiff, Fifty Sixth Taljan P/L, a construction company, brought proceedings against the defendant, Dattilo Holdings P/L, who engaged the plaintiff to construct a building. The plaintiff alleges that the defendant failed to make progress payments as required under the contract and that the defendant's financial difficulties were exacerbated by the plaintiff's negligence in underquoting the cost of the construction. The plaintiff further alleges that it made representations to the defendant to the effect that it would rectify the financial difficulties and continue to build and forbear in relation to the outstanding debt until the defendant arranged finance. The defendant filed a cross-claim seeking a set-off under s 14 of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002. The matter was before the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether there was a real question to be tried and whether the defendant's cross-claim for set-off was valid. The court had to determine if the defendant's allegations of negligence and misrepresentation by the plaintiff were sufficient to raise a real question to be tried. Additionally, the court had to examine the validity of the defendant's cross-claim for set-off under s 14 of the Security of Payment Act. The court had to consider whether the defendant's cross-claim was an abuse of process and whether the defendant had a genuine prospect of establishing a right to set-off.

In determining the issues, the court considered the evidence and submissions presented by both parties. The court found that the defendant's allegations of negligence and misrepresentation by the plaintiff were not sufficient to raise a real question to be tried. The court held that the defendant's cross-claim for set-off was an abuse of process and was not a genuine prospect of success. The court found that the defendant had not established a valid right to set-off under s 14 of the Security of Payment Act. The court dismissed the defendant's cross-claim and ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of the summary judgment application.

The court's final orders were that the defendant's cross-claim be dismissed and that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of the summary judgment application. The court held that the defendant's allegations of negligence and misrepresentation by the plaintiff were not sufficient to raise a real question to be tried. The court found that the defendant's cross-claim for set-off was an abuse of process and was not a genuine prospect of success. The court held that the defendant had not established a valid right to set-off under s 14 of the Security of Payment Act.