| SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA COURT OF APPEAL | |
| S EAPCR 2024 0144 | |
| TIMOTHY FIELDEN | Applicant |
| v | |
| THE KING | Respondent |
| S EAPCR 2024 0145 | |
| MITCHELL KELLY | Applicant |
| v | |
| THE KING | Respondent |
---
| JUDGES: | PRIEST, TAYLOR and T FORREST JJA |
| WHERE HELD: | Melbourne |
| DATE OF HEARING: | 31 October 2024 |
| DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 26 November 2024 |
| MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2024] VSCA 284 |
| JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: | DPP v Kelly & Anor [2022] VCC 1060 (Judge Doyle) |
---
CRIMINAL LAW – Appeal – Conviction – Applicants convicted of rape and sexual assault – Applicants and complainant engaged in drug taking and consensual sexual activity – Activity filmed by Fielden in a series of eight videos – Complaint alleged to have become incapable of giving consent due to intoxication by commencement of video nine – Applicants alleged to have no reasonable belief in consent by commencement of video nine – Rape and sexual assault said to have occurred at specific times during video nine – Whether verdicts unreasonable or incapable of being supported by evidence – Application for leave to appeal against conviction granted – Appeal of Fielden allowed – Verdicts of acquittal entered – Appeal of Kelly allowed in part – Verdict of acquittal entered on rape charge.
Criminal Procedure Act 2009, s 276(1)(a).
M v The Queen (1994) 181 CLR 487; Pell v The Queen (2020) 268 CLR 123; Dansie v The Queen (2022) 274 CLR 651, followed.
CRIMINAL LAW – Appeal – Conviction – Whether comments of prosecutor in closing address caused trial to miscarry – Whether judge erred in failing to discharge the jury – Prosecutor made serious misstatements of the evidence and otherwise unfortunate remarks – No miscarriage of justice – Appeal refused.
CRIMINAL LAW – Appeal – Sentence – Kelly sentenced to six months’ imprisonment for sexual assault – Whether sentence manifestly excessive – Leave to appeal against sentence refused.
R v Boaza [1999] VSCA 126; DPP v Karazisis (2010) 31 VR 634, applied.
---
| Counsel | ||
| For the Applicant Fielden: | Mr J Lavery | |
| For the Applicant Kelly: | Mr G Chisholm with Ms E Byrt | |
| Respondent: | Mr B Kissane KC with Mr G Buchhorn | |
Solicitors | ||
| For the Applicant Fielden: | Stephen Peterson Lawyers | |
| For the Applicant Kelly: | Kurnai Legal Practice | |
| Respondent: | Ms A Hogan, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions | |
PRIEST JA
TAYLOR JA
T FORREST JA:
Introduction and overview
On 30 April 2024 each applicant was convicted by a jury of one charge of rape (charge 1) and one charge of sexual assault (charge 3).[1] On 15 July 2024 the applicants were sentenced as follows:
Applicant Fielden
[1]The jury were discharged without verdict with respect to two further charges of rape, being charges 2 and 4.
Charge on Indictment Offence Maximum Sentence Cumulation 1. Rape
(contrary to s 38(2) of the Crimes Act 1958)
25 years’ imprisonment 4 years’ and 2 months’ imprisonment Base Sentence 3. Sexual assault
(contrary to s 40 of the Crimes Act 1958)
10 years’ imprisonment 6 months’ imprisonment Nil Related Summary…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fielden v The King; Kelly v The King and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] VSCA 284
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the convictions were unreasonable or incapable of being supported by the evidence, and whether the trial had been miscarried due to the prosecutor's comments. The court also had to decide whether the sentence imposed on Kelly was manifestly excessive. The court considered the evidence presented in the videos, the prosecutor's comments, and the principles established in previous cases such as M v The Queen and Pell v The Queen.
The court found that the convictions were unreasonable and incapable of being supported by the evidence, as there was no clear indication that the complainant had become incapable of giving consent by the time the ninth video began. The court held that the applicants were entitled to an acquittal on the rape charges, but that Kelly's conviction for sexual assault could stand. The court found that the prosecutor's comments did not cause the trial to miscarry, and that the judge had not erred in failing to discharge the jury. The court also found that Kelly's sentence was not manifestly excessive, and refused leave to appeal against it.
The High Court granted Fielden leave to appeal against his conviction and entered verdicts of acquittal on all charges. The court allowed Kelly's appeal in part, entering a verdict of acquittal on the rape charge but upholding his conviction for sexual assault.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The relevant portions of the Summary of Prosecution were in the following terms:CHARGE 1 RAPE Kelly penile penetration of vagina – both Accused start to 27 seconds [video 9]19. During the first 30 seconds the complainant can be seen lying on her back on the mattress naked and with her head partly beyond the edge of the mattress. KELLY is depicted having penis-to-vagina sexual intercourse with her whilst FIELDEN films. (Charge 1).20. The Prosecution alleged FIELDEN to be involved in the commission of the offence by his presence, in filming the actions on the phone, and his words of encouragement/direction.21. At approximately 25 seconds FIELDEN is heard to say ‘fuck her cunt’ whilst KELLY is penetrating her vagina with his penis.22. At 27 seconds FIELDEN is heard to say ‘here we go mate’. 23. At 28 seconds KELLY says ‘oi’ and ‘is she alright?’.24. Other than a groaning noise being made between 0:06-0:13 the complainant does not respond or make any noises.25. From 0:30-0:49 one of the Accused can be heard saying ‘oi’ followed by a slapping sound. There is no audible response by the complainant. One of the Accused says ‘Is she alright’. FIELDEN asks ‘Are you alright or what?’ … ‘Hey. Are you ok?’. Another slapping sound is heard followed by one of the Accused stating ‘Do you want us to stop? … yes or no’ whilst filming close up to the complainant’s face. There is no audible verbal response by the complainant. Furthermore, between 0:38-0:40 there is no verbal or eye or motor response by the complainant. Her mouth is open and she appear [sic] to have laboured mouth breathing. Her eye lids are partially open and her eyes are fixed and not moving. CHARGE 3 RAPE – Kelly digital penetration of vagina at 1:37 [video 9 – alternative offence sexual assault]34. At 1:37 KELLY is observed within the video digitally penetrating the complainant’s vagina with his fingers. (Charge 3).35. At 1:42 one of the Accused stated ‘Here. You right’ as the complainant groans.26. The prosecution allege FIELDEN to be involved in the commission of the offence by his presence, in filming the actions on the phone, and his words of encouragement/direction throughout the first 1:42 of the video. The prosecutor opened charges 1 and 3 to the jury in accordance with the Summary of Prosecution Opening. The prosecutor also identified the relevance of video eight to the interpretation of the offences said to have occurred during video nine in the following manner:By the eighth video, which commences at 7.42 am, [LD] becomes so drug affected and fatigued that she is unable to answer the accused’s repeated requests for the PIN code to her mobile phone. In his closing address relevant to charge 1, the prosecutor addressed each of the elements of rape. The prosecutor said that the penetration occurred at ‘0 to 27 seconds’ in video nine and also referred to the still taken from ‘27 seconds’. The latter reference was an error. The still was taken from 21 seconds. It was not the only error the prosecutor made with respect to time. He twice said that the gap between the conclusion of video eight and the start of video nine was one minute and 18 seconds. It was not. The gap was 18 seconds.