Fexco Merchant Services v Mainline Corporate Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

FEXCO Merchant Services & others v Mainline Corporate Holdings Limited [2011] APO 95

Patent Application:       763008.

Title:  Dynamic Currency Conversion For Card Payment Systems.

Patent Applicant:         Mainline Corporate Holdings Limited.

Opponents:1. FEXCO Merchant Services

2. National Westminster Bank PLC
3. Travelex Outsourcing Pty Ltd
4. Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited
5. First Currency Choice Pte Ltd

Delegate:  M. G. Kraefft

Decision Date:             22 November 2011

Hearing Date:              22 August 2011

Catchwords:                PATENTS – opposition to Section 104 amendment – redefinition within body of specification of identifier code portion of payment card number for determining cardholder’s currency – amendment refused under all available grounds of Section 102.

Representation: Applicant:  Ms Katrina Howard, senior counsel, instructed by Ms Rebekah Gay, solicitor, and by Mr Peter Treloar, patent attorney of Shelston IP, Sydney.

Opponent 1: Ms Connie Merlino, patent attorney, assisted by Mr Manuel Schmidt, trainee attorney, of F B Rice, Sydney.

Opponent 2: Mr Ben Fitzpatrick, of counsel, instructed by Mr Andrew Morton, patent attorney of Griffith Hack, Melbourne.

Opponent 3:  Mr Greg Noonan, assisted by Mr Carl Harrap, patent attorneys of Freehills, Sydney.

Opponent 4: Mr Ben Fitzpatrick, of counsel, instructed by Mr Duncan Longstaff, patent attorney, of Blake Dawson, Melbourne.

Opponent 5:  Mr Stephen Burley, senior counsel, instructed by Mr Roger Henning, special counsel, and by Ms Helen MacPherson, executive counsel, of Freehills, Sydney.

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:       763008.

Title:  Dynamic Currency Conversion For Card Payment Systems.

Patent Applicant:         Mainline Corporate Holdings Limited.

Decision Date:             22 November 2011

DECISION

The proposed amendments are not allowable under subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a) and 102(2)(b).

The amendments are refused.

REASONS FOR DECISION

BACKGROUND

  1. Mainline Corporate Holdings Limited (“Mainline”) filed patent application 763008 on 1 September 1999.  The application claims priority from an application made in Ireland on 12 July 1999.  The application was advertised accepted on 10 July 2003.  Subsequently the application was the subject of opposition proceedings before the Patent Office.  In a Patent Office decision (“the first decision”) dated 13 July 2007, the opponents were successful and Mainline was given an opportunity to propose suitable amendments to overcome the findings in that decision (Fexco Dynamic Currency Conversion Limited and others v Mainline Corporate Holdings Limited, [2007] APO 24). That decision is under appeal in the Federal Court.

  2. Mainline filed a statement of proposed amendments under Section 104 on 5 September 2007.  On 28 November 2008, a delegate of the Commissioner granted leave to amend as proposed by Mainline.  The proposed amendments were advertised on 18 December 2008.

  3. Five parties have filed notices of opposition to the allowance of the amendments.  They are (1) FEXCO Merchant Services (“FEXCO”), (2) National Westminster Bank PLC (“NatWest”), (3) Travelex Outsourcing Pty Ltd (“Travelex”), (4) Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (“ANZ”) and (5) First Currency Choice Pte Ltd (“FCC”).

  4. The Federal Court proceedings are stayed pending the outcome of the present opposition to the allowance of the amendments.

    SPECIFICATION

  5. The specification, as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fexco Merchant Services v Mainline Corporate Holdings Limite... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] APO 95
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Patent Office was the forum for a dispute between Mainline Corporate Holdings Limited, the applicant for a patent, and five opponents who were contesting the proposed amendments to the specification. The opponents were FEXCO Merchant Services, National Westminster Bank PLC, Travelex Outsourcing Pty Ltd, Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited, and First Currency Choice Pte Ltd. The core issue was whether the amendments to the patent specification, particularly those relating to the redefinition of the term "identifier code" within the context of determining a cardholder's currency, were allowable under the relevant sections of the Patents Act. The delegate, M. G. Kraefft, concluded that the amendments were not allowable under subsections 102(1), 102(2)(a), and 102(2)(b) of the Patents Act. The delegate found that the amendments extended the scope of the claimed invention beyond what was disclosed in the original specification, thus contravening subsection 102(1). Furthermore, the amendments broadened the scope of the claims, thereby contravening subsection 102(2)(a). Lastly, the amendments did not fully describe the invention and did not ensure clarity of the claims, contravening subsection 102(2)(b). The delegate refused the proposed amendments and ordered costs to follow the event, awarding costs against Mainline.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established